HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tjr

9,258 karma · joined August 18, 2007

Using em dashes since the 1990s
submissionscomments
tjr··on The Timmy Trap
This seems reasonable. Much AI research has historically been about building computer systems to do things that otherwise require human intelligence to do. The question of "is the computer actually intelligent" has been more philosophical than practical, and many such practically useful computer systems have been developed, even before LLMs.

On the other hand, one early researcher said something to the effect of, Researchers in physics look at the universe and wonder how it all works. Researchers in biology look at living organisms and wonder how they can be alive. Researchers in artificial intelligence wonder how software can be made to wonder such things.

I feel like we are still way off from having a working solution there.

tjr··on The Timmy Trap
I might even think that a symbolic chess program is in some sense more intelligent than a modern LLM. It has a concrete model of the world it operates in along with representation what it can, cannot, and is trying to, do. When LLMs get the right answer, it seems more like... highly-optimized chance, rather than coming from any sort of factual knowledge.
tjr··on Are you willing to pay $100k a year per developer on AI?
Local and preferable Free. It seems odd that the majority of the software development world is gleefully becoming dependent upon proprietary tools running on someone else's machine.

https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/who-does-that-server-really-s...

tjr··on Kodak has no plans to cease, go out of business, or file for bankruptcy
I for one have been known to keep some cameras longer than some cars.
tjr··on The case for shorter .com domains
People seemed to prefer shorter domain names as far back as I can remember domain names. I always presumed that successful companies switched to a shorter name because they were better able to pay to acquire it from someone who had owned it since 1992 or whenever.
tjr··on Evaluating LLMs playing text adventures
I imagine that pitting LLMs against computer games is itself an enjoyable activity.

Generally speaking, people play games for fun, and I suspect that will continue. Even if an LLM can beat all humans at computer games, it doesn't matter. We will continue to enjoy playing them. Computers, pre-LLM, could already out-play humans in many cases.

Other activities mentioned -- writing, art, coding, etc. -- can indeed be fun, but they are also activities that people have been paid to do. It seems that there is incentive to create LLMs that can do an at least adequate job of these tasks for less money than humans are paid, so that that money is rerouted to LLM companies instead of human workers. I imagine humans will continue to write, create art, and even code, without any financial incentive, though probably less.

(I personally remain unpersuaded that LLMs will do away with paid creative work altogether, but there's clearly a lot of interest in trying to maximize what LLMs can do.)

tjr··on AI is impressive because we've failed at personal computing
Some ideas going back even further than that, like 1994:

https://philip.greenspun.com/research/shame-and-war-old

tjr··on After using ChatGPT, man swaps his salt for sodium bromide–and suffers psychosis
When the doctors tried their own searches in ChatGPT 3.5, they found that the AI did include bromide in its response, but it also indicated that context mattered and that bromide was not suitable for all uses. But the AI "did not provide a specific health warning, nor did it inquire about why we wanted to know, as we presume a medical professional would do," wrote the doctors.

Plus, LLMs are nondeterministic. Even if it did present a warning one time, it might not the next. Who knows?

tjr··on Cerebras Code
Even if it appears to do what you want, but you don't actually read and understand the code, how do you know it doesn't do something else also? Maybe something you don't want?
tjr··on Claude Code Is a Slot Machine
I am finding that I really like AI for tasks I don't want to do, and am annoyed by it for tasks I enjoy.

A non-programming example: I do some work in library music. I thoroughly enjoy writing and producing the music itself. I don't like writing descriptions of the music, and I'm not very skillful at making any needed artwork. I don't use AI for the music part, but use AI extensively for the text and artwork.

(I'm also not putting a human out of work here; before using AI for these tasks, I did them myself, poorly!)

tjr··on Stop Building AI Tools Backwards
If we were to reach a stage where humans don't write code any more, would there even be a need to have advances in programming languages? Maybe what we currently have would be good enough.

I don't know what future we're looking at. I work in aerospace, and being around more safety-critical software, I find it hard to fathom just giving up software development to non-deterministic AI tools. But who knows? I still foresee humans being involved, but in what capacity? Planning and testing, but not coding? Why? I've never really seen coding being the bottleneck in aerospace anyway; code is written more slowly here than in many other industries due to protocols, checks and balances. I can see AI-assisted programming being a potentially splendid idea, but I'm not sold on AI replacing humans. Some seem to be determined to get there, though.

tjr··on Stop Building AI Tools Backwards
I'm concerned about this also. Even just reading about AI coding, I can almost feel my programming skills start to atrophy.

If AI tools continue to improve, there will be less and less need for humans to write code. But -- perhaps depending on the application -- I think there will still be need to review code, and thus still need to understand how to write code, even if you aren't doing the writing yourself.

I imagine the only way we will retain these skills is be deliberately choosing to do so. Perhaps not unlike choosing to read books even if not required to do so, or choosing to exercise even if not required to do so.

tjr··on AI slows down open source developers. Peter Naur can teach us why
I have mostly worked in aerospace software, and find this rather horrifying. I suppose, if your tests are in fact good and comprehensive enough, there could be a logical argument for not needing to understand the code, but if we're talking people's safety in the hands of your software, I don't know if there is any number of tests I would accept in exchange for willingly giving up understanding of the code.
tjr··on AI slows down open source developers. Peter Naur can teach us why
That sounds like a navigation tool that I absolutely do not want! Occasionally I do enjoy meandering around, but usually fastest / shortest path would be preferred.

And I'm not sure about the other either. In my 20+ year career in aerospace software, the most memorable times were solving interesting problems, not days with no struggle just churning out code.

tjr··on Doom Didn't Kill the Amiga (2024)
I used my Amiga 3000 for a lot of video production and graphics work, along with some word processing / desktop publishing, and a bit of programming. And games! In my observation of other Amiga users at the time, this was typical.

Besides random individual users doing these sorts of things, Amigas were used in local broadcast television studios as video switchers and graphics layover systems, and even in more major media production outlets for video editing and 3D animation. They were seen as a more economical solution to more expensive hardware built specifically for television or graphics, but could pull of the work on a comparable level.

tjr··on Brian Wilson has died
Carol has said though that, for the most part, Brian did write the bass parts that she played.
tjr··on Parkinson's treatment closer as problematic protein imaged for first time
The linked article seems unrelated to the post headline.
tjr··on Canon EF and RF Lenses – All Autofocus Motors
My dog also developed an aversion to cameras, and I wondered if it was the USM focusing. That might have been what started it, but she still doesn't like any cameras at all, USM or not.
tjr··on [dead]
I would imagine it's more unusual for someone to have exactly one interest?
tjr··on Porting the GNAT Ada compiler to macOS/aarch64
Bring on the quadruple-precision floats!
tjr··on Ask HN: Why does US allow hard tech interview questions if it bans IQ tests?
It would be nice if there were some sort of standardized tests for skill competency. Like an employer could state, "we need someone who can handle C at level 5, JavaScript at level 3, and Fortran77 at level 9", and leave it to a third-party to test the candidate in a fair way.

Then the interviews would really be about cultural fit and project interest, not trying to prove if the candidate _actually_ knows C, JavaScript, and Fortran77 well enough.

\end{slightly-off-topic}

tjr··on AI means the end of internet search as we've known it
I was just trying to solve a configuration problem in Xcode today. I started with a web search, and found lots of proposes solutions, but nothing that worked for me. I asked ChatGPT, which regurgitated the same ideas I found on the web, plus a few more that also didn't work.

Finally I tried something undocumented on a hunch, and it kind of worked, and I shared my progress with a (human) colleague, who had the insight to take what I had done and finished a real solution.

Anecdotally, in mice, etc., etc.

tjr··on You Wouldn't Download an AI
I think it is fair to say that existing copyright law was not written to handle all of this. It was written for people who created works, and for other people who were using those works.

To substitute either party with a computer system and assume that the existing law still makes sense may be assuming too much.

tjr··on I am rich and have no idea what to do
https://philip.greenspun.com/materialism/early-retirement/

Ask a wage slave what he'd like to accomplish. Chances are the response will be something like "I'd start every day at the gym and work out for two hours until I was as buff as Brad Pitt. Then I'd practice the piano for three hours. I'd become fluent in Mandarin so that I could be prepared to understand the largest transformation of our time. I'd really learn how to handle a polo pony. I'd learn to fly a helicopter. I'd finish the screenplay that I've been writing and direct a production of it in HDTV."

Why hasn't he accomplished all of those things? "Because I'm chained to this desk 50 hours per week at this horrible [insurance|programming|government|administrative|whatever] job.

So he has no doubt that he would get all these things done if he didn't have to work? "Absolutely none. If I didn't have the job, I would be out there living the dream."

Suppose that the guy cashes in his investments and does retire. What do we find? He is waking up at 9:30 am, surfing the Web, sorting out the cable TV bill, watching DVDs, talking about going to the gym, eating Doritos, and maybe accomplishing one of his stated goals.

Retirement forces you to stop thinking that it is your job that holds you back. For most people the depressing truth is that they aren't that organized, disciplined, or motivated.

tjr··on Ask HN: Any good Black Friday deals on software?
If you're into music / sound production:

https://vi-control.net/community/threads/live-now-2024-editi...

tjr··on Raw milk recalled for containing bird flu virus, California reports
I have not gotten the impression that raw milk aficionados are in it for the money. What makes you think that?
tjr··on Raw milk recalled for containing bird flu virus, California reports
I had been largely oblivious to raw milk until just a few weeks ago when someone suggested I look into it.

From what I can tell, raw milk per se is not likely to be problematic, but problems can get injected if the cows and/or general milking operation are not handled well. Pasteurizing milk could plausibly be seen as a quick fix to not have to deal with such things well. On the other hand, who would I trust to actually handle raw milk with excellence?

Sounds to me like low-temperature pasteurization might be the best compromise? Kills off what is harmful, but supposedly retains more of the original nutrients?

tjr··on Show HN: I'm 17 and made a tool to help students study smarter
You might reconsider describing the free tier as being for "(soon to be) dropouts". It seems to come across as simultaneously insulting to potential users, and dismissive of your own product. (Is the free tier really that bad?)
tjr··on Ask HN: How Ray Bradbury's Advice on Writing Can Be Applied in Programming?
Frequent writing of programs along the lines of Knuth's might be a good approach:

https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/programs.html

These aren't shippable end-user applications, but implementations of algorithmic ideas, so something reasonably done even on a daily basis.

tjr··on 700k passengers delayed after remote work engineer password failed
Sounds like there were multiple levels of failure here. Curious that the headline seems to suggest "remote work" was the culprit.
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →