HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tjradcliffe

2,541 karma · joined June 17, 2014

Poet, physicist, engineer, author: http://www.tjradcliffe.com/?p=1422
submissionscomments
tjradcliffe··on Why Minds Are Not Like Computers (2009)
Since the brain is not just a Turing machine, it would be astonishing if it was limited to the capabilities of a Turning machine. The brain is capable of emulating a Turning machine, but that is just one of its capabilities.

The things a Turing machine lacks are interupts and I/O. If you hook sensors up to a Turing machine and make the tape change depending on the state of those sensors, you don't have a Turing machine any more, in the sense that it is no longer bound by any of Turing's computability theorems.

This insistence that the limits of the most limited model of computing (Turing machines) must be applicable to any machine that computes anything--including things that are not describe by any of the formal mathematical proofs on the limits of computability because they violate the most basic assumptions upon which those proofs depend--is one of the most curious aspects this debate.

So not even computers are just Turing machines, because they too have I/O. Turing's theorems are useful and important when considering certain practical questions of computability within the limited circumstances of a computation whose inputs are entirely specified at the start and which can't be interrupted by new information coming from the outside, but they just don't apply to cases where there are cells whose values aren't known until reality provides them via some sensor mechanism.

As such, it would be a little weird if we (and computers) can't compute things a Turing machine can't, given we have capabilities that a Turing machine doesn't have. There are even examples of such things. One due to Church (IIRC) that shows how we can solve certain instances of the halting problem that a Turing machine can't.

tjradcliffe··on Lies Employers Use to Get You to Work with Them
If employers really want people to work with them, they will pay them more. Everything else is meaningless and unenforcable. Cash on the barrel is the only thing that counts.

For job seekers, it's fair and reasonable to assume that any employer who makes promises against the future is lying, so for every promise you are made ("You'll eventually get to work on cool technology X!") you should increase your starting salary expectations, because you need to get a fair wage for being lied to.

tjradcliffe··on Why can't America have great trains?
False. China has high-speed trains that travel around 1000 km. China is also big. Really big. Also pretty poor. But it manages despite its ridiculous dictatorship to get a modicum of useful stuff done. Stuff that the US--uniquely in the democratic, developed, world--is unable to do.

For more information: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_China

So the claim that "trains don't scale well in the USA" is false. Trains scale just fine to thousands of kilometres. The distance from Bejing to Hong Kong, which has a rail line capable of more than 300 kph (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Rail_map_of_China.svg) is just shy of 2000 km as the crow flies, which is more than the distance from NYC to Chicago and a bit less than the distance from NYC to Dallas.

And pointing out that LA is more distant from NYC than that is utterly, completely and totally irrelevant. The distance from NYC to LA has absolutely nothing to do with the inability of Americans to build a high speed rail link between various Eastern and Southern cities, and there is zero plausibility to any claim that NYC and Chicago (or Dallas) aren't commerical hubs of comparable importance to the US as Bejing and Hong Kong are to China.

So we can put that false claim to bed now, and never muddy the discussion with it again.

The more plausible reason is the other one you cite, at least by implication: the American economic and political system, uniquely amongst developed democracies, is unable to muster sufficient collective resources in the form of public or private investment to enable creators to build a fairly straightforward rail network that would serve American economic needs.

The US is not "the most technologically advanced coutry in the world". It is two countries, one of which is technologically advanced, the other of which is backward in almost every respect (and kept that way by policies set by the first.)

Until Americans figure out how to deal with their unique social and political deficits and inabilities they will continue to suffer under stub-standard conditions in almost every respect. They will continue to die earlier, live with higher crime rates, lousy railways, and dramatically lower economic efficiency than that enjoyed by citizens of almost any other advanced nation.

Canada also sucks with respect to passenger rail, and we are generally far better than Americans at solving our collective problems, so there may be more to it than that, but clearly size alone is not the issue, or China wouldn't have the amazing high speed rail network it does.

tjradcliffe··on Liquid Breathing
The critical bit for many interesting practical applications is this:

    A significant problem, however, arises from the high 
    viscosity of the liquid and the corresponding reduction 
    in its ability to remove CO2.[3][20] All uses of liquid 
    breathing for diving must involve total liquid 
    ventilation (see above). Total liquid ventilation, 
    however, has difficulty moving enough liquid to carry 
    away CO2, because no matter how great the total pressure 
    is, the amount of partial CO2 gas pressure available to 
    dissolve CO2 into the breathing liquid can never be much 
    more than the pressure at which CO2 exists in the blood 
    (about 40 mm of mercury (Torr)).[20]
This has been a known issue since the 50's and shows no sign of going away. The paragraph is a bit muddled--it's the diffusion coefficient, not the viscosity, that is relevant--but the inability of oxygenated liquids to carry away CO2 has so far been the major impediment to doing any of the really cool things this technology has promised for so long.
tjradcliffe··on Gravity Kills Schrödinger's Cat
This is the relevant quote:

    "But from a deep, fundamental point of view, this is  
    nothing new," he says. A gravitational field is merely 
    another environment to interact with, so invoking it 
    does not explain whether quantum behaviour might lead to 
    classical reality if gravity’s influence were 
    mitigated—for example, by doing the experiment in 
    gravity-free space.
It's an interesting piece of work, but doesn't seem to add anything fundamental to the discussion of gravity and QM. It just shows how gravity can result in decoherence if different parts of the wavefunction experience different clock rates due to gravitational fields.
tjradcliffe··on Why Water Is Wet
These things are a bit of a fad where I live. There are two "float houses" within a few blocks of me. My girlfriend bought us a session in one last last year (she said she was "giving me nothing" for my birthday.)

You do feel the water, at least a bit. It might have been a little on the cold side, which didn't help the experience. I wasn't freezing to death or anything, but by the end was thinking, "Yeah, this could be half a degree warmer."

I didn't experience anything special. I meditate and whatnot and am pretty comfortable in the company of my own mind, so it was kind of like a long meditation session, though I never got in really deep. I was too busy watching myself for any novel reactions, I guess.

It lasted for an hour or ninety minutes and was pretty boring. My girlfriend reported a similar experience. YMMV, and you should try it and find out. It wasn't unpleasant, there just wasn't much there there (which is likely a commentary on the sterility of my mental environment or something.)

tjradcliffe··on Meta-analysis of heritability of human traits based on 50 years of twin studies [pdf]
This does not follow at all, because there is no evidence for any master mechanism that would correlate the group average of one trait with another. So simply because a group can be clustered by one trait there is no reason to expect they will differ from the population average in others.

For example, if you were to sort the population the length of their pinky finger, and then look at two groups of people, one the longest-pinky quintile and one the shortest, there is nothing in this study that would suggest those two groups would have different resting heart rates. This is true even though we can assume on the basis of this work that both pinky length and resting heart rate are about 50% heritable.

The only way they would be correlated would be if there was a single selection mechanism for both, and given that visible traits and non-visible traits tend to have completely different selection mechinisms you'd have to show positively and directly by experiment that such a common mechanism existed in any given case.

Ab initio there is simply no basis for the claim any random non-visible traits like resting heart rate will have different group averages for groups that are segregated from the general population by any random visible characteristics like pinky length.

tjradcliffe··on Diet that mimics fasting appears to slow aging
And what are the LD50's of those "toxins"? This is my first question to people who go on about "toxins" and "detox" and "cleansing".

I don't want an exact number, just a ballpark. Is it micrograms, milligrams or grams per kg body mass? Surely these people who know so very much about "toxins" must know the one fact that distinguishes the things we informally call toxic from the ones we don't.

It would be the hieght of intellectual dishonesty to claim something was "toxic" without having any knowledge of the LD50.

tjradcliffe··on Science, Now Under Scrutiny Itself
imh's explanation is good, but it's also worth considering a very common example of this. Consider two groups of people where one group engages in some activity and another does not. Measure a dozen things about those people. Then report only on the one that positively (or negatively) correlates with group membership as if it was the only thing you measured.

This generates an unrealistically high statistical significance (unrealististically low p-value) because the question should not be, "What are the odds these two things are correlated by chance" but "What are the odds that any of of these things is correlated by chance with this other thing?"

The significance of the result is far below the reported p-value from an analysis that assumes only one thing was investigated. You frequently see incorrect p-values of this kind even when the researchers acknowledge they tested for multiple things.

tjradcliffe··on My Position On The Disney Layoffs
Disney and the contracting firm are both corporations.

Corporations do not exist in free markets. They are a product of nothing but legislative intervention in the free market in the form of the Companies Act (the reformed version of the 1850's) and its descendents around the world. Without this interference in the marketplace, corporations in the modern sense cannot and did not exist.

The only reason this kind of situation can arise is because of the nature of corporate relationships, in which the actions of individuals are hidden behind the collective mask of corporate ownership. Otherwise, it would be, "Jane fired Fred from America and replaced him with Amir from India" and the locus of effect would be undeniable.

It follows from this that the lawmakers who intervened in the free market to create the corporate form of collective organization are--or ought to be--held responsible for the overall effect of corporate behaviour. The likely corrective action, as our Libertarian friends tell us, is further intervention in the free market in the form of regulation on this sort of behaviour.

tjradcliffe··on Capturing clean energy from evaporating water
"This is not the first time that evaporation energy has been captured, but it is the first time that it has been done a scale where objects could be moved."

Really? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drinking_bird

tjradcliffe··on Depression's Upside (2010)
> I think depression has a similar role.

Why? I can't see any basis for your belief other than "it just makes sense to me", which is the epistemology of bloodletting and witchburning.

Evolutionary just-so stories have been so thoroughly and repeatedly debunked that no one thinks they can be evidence for anything. They may be useful motivators for testable ideas, but that's all.

So where is your evidence, your clinical studies, your field observations? Anything. You've said that you believe clinical depression--a serious and even deadly disease--is caused by the brain trying to tell you there is something you need to change in your life, and given zero evidence for it. You've barely even motivated it.

Under those circumstances, one either has to assume bad faith, or an astonishing level of hubris and myopia. I'd say the person who responded to you was being rather generous, given what you've said is equivalent to, "It just makes sense to me that your cancer is just your body's way of saying that you need to change something important in your life, at least in the cases I've seen."

Anecdata ("the cases I've seen") is not evidence for anything, because we all know that humans are terrible observers and prone to confirmation bias and other problematic behaviours, so telling us "no really I saw this!" is not evidence of anything except what a naive observer believes, and again: that kind of thinking is what informed pre-scientific medicine for thousands of years, resulting in a vast amount of misery and very few effective treatments.

tjradcliffe··on The General Crisis of the 17th Century
Parker's book on the topic is a good one-volume cover of the history from a global perspective. The climate data are pretty clear on how weird things were, with no shortage of "most extreme ever" events from China to England:

http://www.amazon.com/Global-Crisis-Climate-Catastrophe-Seve...

Concepts--all concepts--are made things, and the edges we draw around them are the edges of our attention. People draw those edges in different places, or not at all, depending on their priors. As such, a certain type of person will argue that there wasn't "really" a "general criss" in the 17th century because the panoply of events aren't enough to trigger their edge-detectors, and they feel that their edge-detectors are arbiters of reality. Arguments of this nature are rarely productive. The events happened regardless of what you call them.

That the global climate underwent a statistically significant excursion in the 17th century is hard to argue against. That that excursion was also economically significant is likewise difficult to argue against. Unprecedented multi-year runs of poor harvests aren't really something that can be wished away with ideology. Finally, that the economic excursion helped drive political decision making should be relatively uncontroversial, unless one were to argue that politics happens in an economic vacuum.

Parker does a good job of emphasizing the contingency of outcomes. People made decisions for reasons that seemed good to them--often of the form "God loves my country, so if I do X, Y will necessarily and certainly happen!"--and results followed for unrelated reasons (often of the form, "Luck.")

He also argues that something like 1/3 of the human species died in the crisis, which is fairly astonishing, but given the death tolls for the places where we have data, not entirely unsupportable.

tjradcliffe··on Kongregate: the science behind the massive profits of F2P games
Other products don't aren't optimized by their creators to extract the maximum revenue from the 0.046% of their market that the creators have determined are vulnerable to remarkably effective psychological manipulation techiniques, and upon whom the creators are dependent for the majority of their revenue.

Next question?

And the next question really shouldn't be "Oh but aren't they really? Other products use advertising too!" If it is, please refer to the answer above, and add reading comprehension.

tjradcliffe··on How to implement a neural network: Part 1
Barely at all. Long Short-Term Memory network blocks, for example, are basically perceptrons with feedback controlled by two or three completely conventional non-linear nets running off the same inputs.

Deep learning networks are an assembly of existing connectionist parts, enabled by Moore's Law. There's nothing bad about this: the progress being made is real and substantial, but it's being made in ways that are true to Edison's prescribed ratio of inspiration and perspiration, although a lot of the perspiring is being done by machines.

The architectural tweaks, while small, are still very important. But the core learning algorithm is still backprop deployed over the new architectures.

tjradcliffe··on On Disliking Poetry
I'm much less dead, and have numerous other important differences, but I can see why you might see similarities.
tjradcliffe··on On Disliking Poetry
I said "Romantic twaddle", not "modernist experimentation". As indicated in what I wrote, I find a number of aspects of modernism interesting and worthwhile, for much the reasons you cite.

Also, I wrote about concrete experience and you've replied by talking about concrete language. Weird.

Good modern poetry has much to recommend it, but there is also a vast amount of unstructured garbage. Unfortunately anyone who complains about the latter is assumed to hate the former even if he explicilty states--as I did--that there is much value in it. For example, someone chimed in agreeing with me and then dissed Seamus Heaney. Err...

But the Romantic theory of poetry is twaddle, and it does represent a detour that has taken almost 200 years to recover from. We're slowly getting there.

The relative value of "rigid form" (I'm not sure why "rigid" is required... it certainly isn't a characteristic of any good formal poetry at any time) is something that non-technical people have trouble understanding (you see, I'm doing the same thing you did: assuming I know something about you, and then condescending to explain things to you on the basis of that baseless assumption... irritating, isn't it?) There is a proverb that every engineer knows: "Form is liberating."

We've actually got more in common in our views than you're apparently willing to acknowledge, and have instead chosen to project onto me some fairly weird ideas rather than engaging the words I've actually written. "O no! Someone is misunderstanding me on the 'Net!" is about as useful a call to action as "someone is wrong on the 'Net" but you're clearly not an idiot, so I couldn't help but be tempted to put things right. Now all I need to do is figure out how to buy you a virtual beer with bitcoin... this sort of argument is always much better with beer.

tjradcliffe··on On Disliking Poetry
This analysis of poetry is like declaring that the purpose of physics is to build perpetual motion machines and then saying we all dislike physics because it fails in this transcendent purpose.

The author trots out uncritically the entire corpus of Romantic twaddle, swathed in sufficient technical language that most poeple will feel too intimidated to challenge it. But twaddle it is.

The failure of poetry in the modern world is a result of the rejection of concrete experience as the foundational matter of poems. This has been accompanied by the abandonment of the physical rhythmicities of speech (including rhyme) as the basis of poetic structure.

There's nothing transcendent about good poetry. People are made out of meat, and we communicate by flapping peices of meat: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tScAyNaRdQ

Poetry reflects our meat-based lives, the physicality of our meat. When we abandon that, when we abandon concrete, sensual experience for floating abstraction, as the Romantics did, or for purely internal emotional states as modern confessional free verse does, we abandon the very thing that makes poetry possible and necessary: meat.

Poetry is speech, specifically speech where the rhythmical structure dominates the gramatical structure. The rhythmical structure can be strong and overt (rap, Kipling, etc) or subtle (even the best confessional free verse manages this at times, or the L A N G U A G E poets at their most surreal, although I don't have any use for their political programme.) The rhythmical structure of speech comes from the way we form sounds with meat, and nothing else.

Nor does poetry have to be about anything out of the ordinary, although it certainly can be. Poetry is, amongst other things, the literature of moments. It's a way to capture and communicate a fleeting experience. Consider:

    young girls in blue shorts  
    street corner in summer rain  
    light changes, they run  
Way more memorable and evocative than "I saw some girls wearing blue shorts on the corner waiting for the light to change and they ran when it did 'cause there was a hard summer rain falling."

Poetry makes the mind work in useful ways, focusing on structure and meaning and meat. We are physical beings capable of abstract appreciation of the world. Poetry exists at the intersection, grounded in one, guided by the other.

What's to dislike?

tjradcliffe··on New study looks at the connection between parental age and autism risk
Thanks for this. All you have to do is look at the "Deaf Culture" folks to see where attempts to normalize a disease state leads.

The lack of ability to hear is not a difference to be celebrated, and anyone who does celebrate it is a sad, pathetic individual spreading harm and--very often--hate.

It is possible to gracefully accept who we are and the things about us that can't yet be fixed, while at the same time striving to fix them.

Our diseases are not our identities.

Deaf Culture and other similar movements start off by accepting the lie that collectivist bigots have imposed on them--that our diseases are our identities--and then simply declare that that identity is good. Accepting the identity that hostile collectivists want to impose on you is rarely a good thing. In the case of disease states it really does end in opposing any attempt to cure the disease, and if there's a purer kind of evil than that--cloaked in the brightly shining garb of rights and defense of the oppressed--I'm not sure what it is.

tjradcliffe··on How it feels to join an all-Haskell startup
> at this point

Which is a huge problem. Optimizing around the current fashion is generally a mistake.

As for the rest: the argument seems to come down to "there are no junior developers in Haskell, because if you don't understand the deep and dark abstractions you're really hardly better than a barbarian anyway."

This translates to: Haskell is doomed as a production language in the real world beyond a few niche/fetish applications, because "real" Haskell devs are always going to be scarce and expensive.

This was the selling point of Java back in the day: you could hire junior Java devs to do much the same things as senior C++ devs because the language was so much safer. I saw this in action. It was impressive. It was also around the time when the current fashion in Haskell was lazy evaluation, which I've seen modern Haskell fashionistas pronounce "not really so important after all".

Fashions change, and Haskell is a highly fashion-driven langauge, which means there will be a lot of unmaintainable Haskell code out there in five or ten years.

That's my prediction at least. Let's look at the issue again in a decade and see if I'm right or wrong!

tjradcliffe··on Fermented foods, neuroticism, and social anxiety: An interaction model
Everything about this study says it is not worth taking seriously. Why? Because...

1) The size of the effect is not reported. Without any indication of what the dose-response curve is other than it has a positive slope (at what significance level?) we know nothing about the relevance of this result to clinical practice.

For example, it is true that if you pay very careful attention to the sidewalk you will increase the amount of dropped money you find. It's not going to make anyone rich, though, any more than just any measurable effect is going to make one less anxious to a useful degree. There is zero indication of how big the effect is, other than it is measureable in a large population. The lack of indication of effect size suggests that it is really small.

2) Self-report via recollection is a lousy data collection technique. Was a food log app really too much trouble? So the raw data are incredibly noisy and may contain systematic errors that are related to the phenomenon under test.

3) They've subsetted the data by pulling out neuroticism, thereby dramatically reducing the significance of any result by an unknown amount (how many other characteristics did they investigate?)

This is the greatest sin. Any time you see a paper that says, "The effect was particularly large in sub-population X" the first question to ask it, "How many sub-populations did you look at?" The next question to ask is, "What is your calculated probability that any one of your sub-populations would have had such a large effect by chance?" These numbers should be reported in the abstract because people subset their data all the time and then analyze the subset that shows an effect as if it was the only one. This is either incompetence or dishonesty.

Statisical significance rolls off with astonishing speed as you subset the data, and if you don't have a formal discipline for subsetting as part of the experiment design that is fixed prior to analysis, any result on a subset is necessarily insignificant because you could have kept subsetting until you found a 'significant' result. If you don't have a formal discipline that says, "We will cut the data in these N ways and only these N ways" you are going fishing on an infinite ocean, where you will certainly catch the kind of fish you are looking for.

tjradcliffe··on What Is Code?
> The mere act of calling it programming is somehow a problem.

There are some words that carry with them unshedable connotations that people want to get away from so strongly that they will call themselves something else at the first possible instant. "Programmer" is one of them.

"Poet" is another. No one makes money from poetry because as soon as a poet makes money they are something else: a musician, a performer, a copy-writer, whatever.

Just don't call them a "poet", because "poets" are poor, sad people with no future, just as "programmers" are neckbearded nerdboys who smell bad, and no matter how many programmers (or poets) fail to live up to those stereotypes people will continue to impose them on reality come hell or high water.

tjradcliffe··on China’s Troubling Robot Revolution
Basic income schemes are getting seriously discussed in Canada right now (they were first mooted in the 1980's, to no effect, but have been lurking in the background since then). The concensus amongst economists is that they are very expensive if you provide a genuine living with a reasonably low phase-out (which is required to not have insanely progressive tax rates on the working poor.)

Still, these are practical problems that may turn out to be solveable, and the efficiencies that basic income schemes give are potentially large, as they would wipe out a lot of government workers whose sole job it to manage redundant arrays of independent welfare schemes.

Some badly formated discussion here: https://storify.com/bis_pilot/canadian-economists-on-basic-i...

tjradcliffe··on Google: 90% of our engineers use the software you wrote (Homebrew), but...
In my academic days I used to refer to say "physics-standing-up" is a different subject from "physics-sitting-down" and needs to be studied separately. Some years after I left academia I had the good fortune to get in contact with the person who introduced me to acting at a very young age and thank her for her contribution to my academic career. About 30% of my success was due to my comfort working in front of an audience--even a panel of examiners is "an audience"--and I had a huge advantage over my peers because of it.

One thing that I'd recommend to anyone seeking any kind of job is taking some improv courses--they are pretty common in major centers and even some smaller towns, and can really improve your ability to deal with this kind of nonsensical interview situation, which tests a bunch of skills that have nothing to do with your ability to actually do the job.

tjradcliffe··on Google: 90% of our engineers use the software you wrote (Homebrew), but...
And why don't they count the cost of good candidates who simply drop out of their hiring pool entirely, because they can't be arsed to bone up on the easily gamed idiotic hiring process?

I'd never even apply to Google based on the stories I've heard, and I'm sure there are plenty of others in the same position who are even better at what they do than I am. There are just so many stories out there of how crappy the hiring process is that everyone who's any good must have heard about it. Some significant fraction will have said, "Yep, not for me."

tjradcliffe··on Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis Yarvin)
I have very little idea what Yarvin's view on "gender roles" is but assume it's a traditional Anglo-European one that subjugates women to men, the same as virtually every culture everywhere has before the past hundred-odd years.

So this seems to suggest that you believe that "non-Muslim white males" have no cultural heritage whatsoever, which is... odd.

tjradcliffe··on Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis Yarvin)
Mostly put there by their fellow-revolutionaries.
tjradcliffe··on Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis Yarvin)
Thanks for the forthright reply!

I've been involved in political activism of one kind or other for decades, mostly in ways that are opposed to your ideals, so I'm not one tiny bit surprised to find a lefty who is opposed to free speech, nor am I unfamiliar with the "theoretical basis" for such abhorent positions.

I wanted to cast as broad a net as possible in my question, as I know how eclectic the left is: the two major Communist parties in my country spent most of their political capital fighting each other while the mainstream drifted gently, and rather too far, to the right.

Your myopia, anger and hatred are unfortunately true to the rightwingnutjob's caricature of anyone interested in building a just society, which makes the job of sane social reformers more difficult. Just so you know (yeah, I know, we're you're enemies too... and it's important to have a comprehensive enemies list, isn't it?)

And while on the one hand I can take heart in the knowledge that you'll never get close to achieving your goals, I'm also saddened that you will spread so much toxicity into your environment on your way to ultimate failure. The world needs more love, not more hate, or more fear.

tjradcliffe··on Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis Yarvin)
> I do in fact fear the "social justice" crowd and their ability to mess with people and their careers when they don't follow the party line

This is something I'd love see SJW's here react to. How do you feel about the fact that you have created a climate of fear amongst people who disagree with you?

Would you prefer convincing them of the correctness of your position, but willing to accept that at least by making them afraid you are helping further your cause?

Or are you concerned you've become the kind of discourse-stiffling monster you set out to defeat?

Or are you proud you've made the priviledged afraid?

Or something else entirely?

Because don't kid yourself: people are increasingly afraid to speak up on these issues because they are genuinely afraid of the consequences to their future employment prospects. Personally, I see that as a shameful situation, antithetical to any reasonable notion of a just society.

[Disclaimer: I've been accused at times of being an SJW, an MRA, a shill for Big Carbon, and quite a few other things besides.]

tjradcliffe··on Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis Yarvin)
The neoreactionaries aren't interested in the Enlightenment as a set of fundamental ideas, but as a time in history they find congenial: after the scientific revolution, before democratic, industrial capitalism steamrolled the aristocracy.

They are like an alternative version of the Society for Creative Anachronism, re-imagining the Enlightenment historical period in ways that leave out the things they find icky but that are in fact inevitable consequences of the times. For SCA that's reimagining the High Middle Ages without the plague. For neoreactionaries it's reimagining the Enlightenment without the end of slavery, or the rise of individualism and democracy.

For those of us who pursue Enlightenment ideals rather than Enlightenment historical accidents, they are an unfortunate bunch. SCA members would feel the same way about anyone who was serious about bringing back feudalism, or reducing society to "warriors, priests and peasants."

← PreviousPage 3 of 25Next →