495 karma · joined February 4, 2021
email: Andrew [at] Leahey.org url: www.andrew.legal
General informational link: https://www.irs.gov/appeals/collection-due-process-cdp-faqs
Definitely get in touch with a tax attorney before you go further with the IRS, and watch what you say.
>Total proceeds - total cost basis = taxable income
Not taxable income but capital gains (unless you're talking about coins you mined, which is indeed ordinary income).
>I didn’t trust a mom and pop shop to properly account this this, especially since there were trades between different cryptocurrencies which makes the situation even more complicated.
It really doesn't make it much more complicated for taxes owed purposes. As far as the IRS is concerned, you can't "buy" anything with cryptocurrency. Its akin to a bartering of capital assets. So if you buy $10 worth of BTC and it appreciates and you use it to buy $100 worth of ETH and then you sell the ETH at $200 you have $190 of short or long term capital gains, depending on how long that all took. Cryptocurrency is property, not currency, for IRS purposes. Each of those transfers is a taxable event, but the tabulations is relatively straightforward and should be well within the grasp of a moderately with-the-times CPA.
As I mention above, get a tax attorney now if these values are anything you can't afford just straight up having to pay, plus fines, at the end of all this.
The first correspondence you received from the IRS is threatening a lien? That seems strange. I would expect they would have issued you an information audit first (basically: hey, can you give us more details on this?).
If we're talking big money, I'd say skip the accountant and go right for a tax attorney. Contact the federal bar.
Edit: I have heard good things about Moskowitz LLP: https://moskowitzllp.com/practice-areas/cryptocurrency-tax-a...
I'm not sure how enforceable the obligation to keep informed clause can really be, in and of itself. If you launch a competing business and violate the (I assume present) non-compete agreement clauses then sure. What remedies do the contracts provide for the breach? Termination? Can you provide sample language that we can take a look at?
As you suggest in the comments, I reckon this is mostly about keeping the employee contracts uniform. The lawyers don't "want" these clauses any more than you do; or, at the very least, they don't care one way or the other. Someone on the business side pushed it and they just went along.
I think our experience over the last year and a half has proven that, for many, it is not sufficient reason. Self-interest is a far stronger motivator.
As for the "licensed professional" dig, they're the only people who are going to represent you in front of the IRS when bad advice gets you in trouble. Do with that information what you will.
So FWIW, look out for ^ these guys too. Talk to your state or the federal bar taxation section.
Just as a heads up for other folks reading this, having a basis of $0 isn't the same as paying tax on the mined value at ordinary income rates (cap gains rate differs from ordinary income rates). Mined coins and bought coins are treated differently owing to how they're acquired.
Generally speaking, risk of audit and high fines and fees go up as the amounts you're dealing with go up. I don't know what kinds of values we're dealing with with 40-100 trades, so I'll just give you broad strokes. Having an accountant or a tax attorney review your numbers will, in almost all cases, cost you less than $1,000. If you're talking about $2,000 in income/gains, then obviously that's a non-starter and I'd just go the route you're considering (SaaS), having done good due diligence on the service as you seem to have. If, however, you're looking at $100k in OI or capital gains, I'd say a 1% investment to not owe all of your back taxes + potentially 100% or more in fines in 5-7 years when, potentially, you don't even have that money anymore.
As for your second question, I would just say there is no statute of limitations on undeclared income. The logic there is that you aren't incentivized to hide your income for 3 (or 7) years and then get off the hook, and it is difficult for the IRS or state taxing authorities to discover undeclared (as against under-declared) income -- i.e. how would they know about it? Thus, there is no amount of time that can pass such that you are truly free and clear.
You can file amended returns for ordinary income you failed to declare with Form 1040X: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1040x.pdf
The crypto lawyer folks are, by and large, claiming to be experts in a practice that is so new and so without firm guidance as to be practically the tax wild west. Right now we are in the metaphor stage, we're defining everything involved with cryptocurrency (from a tax perspective) with metaphors to other things: currency, stock, digital goods, etc. The cases that will be cited forever to define crypto for tax purposes are going to be litigated in the next few years, don't be one of them.
TLDR: Look for a tax attorney that knows the tech behind cryptocurrency well enough and doesn't make any promises or guarantees.
Edit: One additional point, merely competent attorneys won't be published in their field. If you're looking for an expert find someone who is contributing to the discussion in their area.
Form websites and tutorials are all well and good, and will probably work out for more people than they don't, but you super don't want to screw up your taxes. When the bill comes due, it'll be years down the line, and for an unrecognizable sum.
Your state bar can put you in touch with one. Avoid folks marketing themselves as something like "tHe CrYpTo LaWyER."
Definitely room for something like this in the space.
Tax and technology attorney looking for interesting projects to get involved in. Experience with contract drafting and review, deal structuring, tax planning and strategy and essentially anything at intersection of tax and tech.
Email in bio.
So does buying a 1992 Honda Civic from a guy give you the right to make more 1992 Honda Civics (not quite 1:1 with copyright, but you get the idea) -- no. Could Honda sell you a 1992 Honda Civic and also the right to make more 1992 Honda Civics? Sure.
They didn't permit a singular use of "they" until like 2017. Sometimes they get stuff wrong. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯