HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tldrthelaw

495 karma · joined February 4, 2021

Attorney (tax and technology) and general geek

email: Andrew [at] Leahey.org url: www.andrew.legal

submissionscomments
tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: Can an American easily partner in an Indian startup?
Tax attorney here, so the hammer/nail analogy applies.

There are (almost certainly) tax implications, seek advice come tax day. Don't just go the TurboTax route. You'll either be leaving money on the table or setting yourself up for a costly problem a few years down the road.

tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: IRS Filing for C Corp?
Tax/tech attorney here (though not your attorney, not legal advice), so take my comment with a grain of salt.

Don't use a service. Get a tax attorney to review your particular situation and advise. It will be worth the higher cost upfront to get it right and not face issues down the road.

tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: Which book/essay changed your life?
"On Intelligence: How a New Understanding of the Brain will Lead to the Creation of Truly Intelligent Machines" - By the guy that started Palm. It is from 2004, and probably deeply flawed in a lot of ways, but I read it at the right time and it "clicked." I think about it often.
tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: Threated with legal action if I don't remove deep links to another site
I am a lawyer, but I am not your lawyer -- definitely get yourself a lawyer.

You almost certainly have broken the law, as best I can tell from your responses to comments below. You may have violated the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act and other state laws. More to the point, if you're asking whether something is or isn't illegal, you should recognize that you're really asking if you'll win in court. 1) No one can answer this question for you definitively in all but the most cut and dry cases and 2) do you really want to go to court over this?

Get a lawyer. Take the links down.

tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: A company wants to pay me to write open-source code
Happy to help - email me: Andrew [at] Leahey.org
tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: How do I find a lawyer for my software consulting business?
Echoing cj. I'd be happy to discuss and see if I can help: Andrew [at] Leahey.org
tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: What (side-)project are you working on?
I've been working in meatspace on a cabin my wife and I bought in the mountains. So far it has mostly been being handled by contractors, but I'm considering taking more of it over myself and maybe filming it or recording a podcast from there. Something creative.
tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: What is your current side-project?
Lawyer geek here, happy to weigh in if you need it. Looks interesting and will be following.
tldrthelaw··on Should I incorporate my app in order to charge users?
I am a lawyer, but I am not your lawyer and this isn't legal advice. Just advice to seek advice.

In short, the answer to your non-title question is "consult a lawyer." Incorporating (or forming an LLC) is not a silver bullet for insulating yourself from liability. At the risk of boring you with details, for the most part the law is logical and rational (please stop laughing, I'm serious). If you form an LLC but the LLC seems like it is just you (intermingling of funds, etc.) and you only formed it to avoid liability when your app goes haywire, it won't insulate you from liability.

tldr talk to a lawyer

tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: Serious question, why is short selling allowed?
I think we have to take the question and flip it, as the law (mostly) lays out what you can't do, rather than what you can. If I own X shares in company Y, why can't I enter in to a contract with you whereby you take my X shares and return them to me on date Z?

If I can do that, why can't you sell those shares and buy them back (presuming I'm okay with that)?

It is just sort of the default position, and stems more from our property rights than anything inherent in securities law.

tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: Room for a Lawyer at Your Company?
I have kind of a weird amalgam of niches, and I'm already 3 years removed from my last firm job -- just been doing contract work in the interim. I think, probably, if the door to private practice is to be closed it has been closed already for me.

My issue, to the extent I can identify it, is really that my niches and interests (within law) fit best at a level that I don't have the professional experience to warrant even an interview for.

Thanks for the tip, I'll keep my eyes peeled for PE and be weary.

tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: Room for a Lawyer at Your Company?
Very interested, how can I contact you?
tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: Room for a Lawyer at Your Company?
Interesting! That is pretty early on, but almost certainly the right move (though I am biased). Can I ask, where did you hire them from? What considerations did you make when choosing them? Just wondering what selection criteria non-law folks use for choosing law folks.

Thanks again, appreciate it. Good luck!

tldrthelaw··on Ask HN: Room for a Lawyer at Your Company?
Woof, I feel you. I have done the small business/bigger business calculation a million times as I obsessively scroll through LinkedIn and Indeed jobs. Your trajectory info is helpful, thank you.

Hang in there. Unless you're on the other end of this conference call ... in which case, hang up! :-)

← PreviousPage 5 of 5