HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tliltocatl

1,072 karma · joined June 23, 2024

submissionscomments
tliltocatl··on Turing Drawings (2012)
Past discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6693653

My personal find:

https://maximecb.github.io/Turing-Drawings/#4,4,0,3,2,1,3,1,...

While not as aesthetically pleasing as some, it displays a very complex behavior, with multiple spatial phases and Schlemiel the Painter's-style global synchronization. Might actually be worth a serious study.

Another one looks exactly like Conway's life, but than halts:https://maximecb.github.io/Turing-Drawings/#8,3,3,1,0,4,2,3,...

Here's a fork of the engine that allows you to see the transition diagram and control speeds: https://aesort.com/Turing-Drawings/#4,4,0,3,2,1,3,1,3,1,3,3,...

tliltocatl··on I beg you to follow Crocker's Rules, even if you will be rude to me
> There's a theory that a culture without taboos is past it's peak in some important way

That sound like yet another assertion that some people are so fond of and that I personally find totally baseless and irrelevant. You are simply proclaiming that a thing you like is good because it is good. So what? I don't like it and I want it gone. And I don't care that you think it is good unless you can come with some argument I can understand from my own set of values.

tliltocatl··on Ask HN: Why don't they make a big ol pipeline to bypass Hormuz?
Tens of billions USD worth of infra that will become obsolete before it is ready (TBM is slooow) as things sort itself out in one way or another. Either Iran run out of drones, USA steps back, or Israel and Gulf countries find someone to pay for a full scale ground operation. Not that that the last two would do any good for the humanity, but Hormuz would be the least of our problems for sure.
tliltocatl··on Standardizing source maps
> One of them is even Turing complete.

> figuring out where in memory or registers a given high level variable

Isn't the task itself Turing-hard? Or at least complex enough so that coming up with a non-Turing-complete solution would be impractical?

tliltocatl··on Uploading Pirated Books via BitTorrent Qualifies as Fair Use, Meta Argues
It wouldn't impact me at all. Without our hardware it is useless. And customers need certifications, support and availability guarantees. Customers aren't paying shit for code. They don't need code. They need solution to their problems. Of which my code is a very small (if critical) part of.

And yes, that's totally irrelevant. Because the mere fact that some people depend on some evil for their living doesn't justify its existence.

tliltocatl··on Modernizing swapping: virtual swap spaces
AFAIR it was quite efficient (basically free) on pre-VM PDP-11 where the kernel swapped the whole address space on a context switch. It only involved swapping to a new disk area.
tliltocatl··on Uploading Pirated Books via BitTorrent Qualifies as Fair Use, Meta Argues
I do. And I get paid because I write it fulfill to the customer's need that's not covered by an existing solution, not because some law prevents using what already exists.
tliltocatl··on Training students to prove they're not robots is pushing them to use more AI
Define "worse". I absolutely hated this formal essay style even before LLMs were a thing. All these "on the other side", "in conclusion" patterns with loads of generics of doesn't convey anything useful. And they make it really hard to tell if the writer is pretending to know anything or actually knows their shit but don't know how to write so that doesn't sound like an essay assignment. Good riddance.

On a side note: the fixed-pattern essay thing seems to be an American invention, or at least popularized by the American education system.

tliltocatl··on Modernizing swapping: virtual swap spaces
Yes, but at what cost? 99% of fork calls are immediately followed by exec(), but now every kernel object need to handle being forked. And a great deal of memory-management housekeeping is done only to be discarded afterward. And it doesn't work at all for AMP systems (which we will have to deal with, sooner or latter).

In 1970 it might have been the only way to provide a flexible API, but nowadays we have a great variety of extensible serialization formats better than "struct".

tliltocatl··on Uploading Pirated Books via BitTorrent Qualifies as Fair Use, Meta Argues
The only copyright reform I support is abolishing this abomination altogether.
tliltocatl··on Modernizing swapping: virtual swap spaces
fork() is a misfeature, as is SIGCHILD/wait and most of Unix process management. It worked fine on PDP-11 and that's it.

But Linux also overcommits mmap-anonymous/sbrk, while Windows leaves the decision to the user space, which is significantly slower.

tliltocatl··on Xous security focused open source on 22nm custom silicon
..which is a huge thing because AFAIK most Cortex-A SoCs on the market are full of undocumented peripherals. Cortex-Ms are usually sufficiently documented that you can bring them up from scratch. Once you want a MMU it's either "use our mainlined Linux drivers full of dark magic" (if you are very lucky - perfect if you want Linux, less so if you are developing your own OS), "use our Linux kernel full of binary blobs" (if you are less lucky) or, as a rule, "sign a NDA and don't even bother us if you aren't a billion-dollar corporation".

(Started it as a minor edit, then decided to elaborate so moved it to a new comment).

tliltocatl··on Data has weight but only on SSDs
Trim might be an illusion, but block erase is very real, even through it's not exposed as a device command. What I'm trying to tell, writes are scrambled but erases (not trim which marks a logical block as collectable, but physical erase that makes a physical block writable) aren't as they happen over several megabytes at once with no way to control individual bits.
tliltocatl··on Xous security focused open source on 22nm custom silicon
Depends on your definition of general-purpose. It is much closer to RP2350 than to a Ryzen.

Edit: except it has a MMU…

tliltocatl··on Data has weight but only on SSDs
But SSD erasing must write a constant (either one or zero). So an erased ready-to-write SSD block will have consistently different energy than one written with a random scrambled pattern. Same for SMR HDDs - but not for CMR.
tliltocatl··on Data has weight but only on SSDs
I think the article is wrong in its core premise. While the electrons get added or removed from the floating gate, the total number of electrons in the SSD chip stays the same. Gates are capacitors, in order to add electrons to one capacitor plate, you have to remove an equal numbers of electrons from the other plate, i. e. from the transistor channel. The net charge of a SSD chip is always zero. Otherwise it would just go bang. <s>2.43×10^-15</s> [my bad 1] 2.67×10^15 electrons is about 300µC - that's a lot of charge to separate macroscopically.

Therefore the mass (weight is a different thing, through it is proportional to mass at a given constant gravity potential) of the data on a SSD isn't fundamentally different from a HDD - they both are caused by a change of internal energy without any change in the number of fermions. I'd expect data on SSD to have larger mass change because a charged capacitor always store more energy than a discharged one, while energy of magnetic domains is less directional and depends mostly on the state of neighbor domains - but I'm not sure about this part.

[1] Thanks stackghost.

tliltocatl··on Arm's Cortex X925: Reaching Desktop Performance
I'd really hope we do live with 4kb pages forever. Variable page size would make many remapping optimizations (i. e. continuous ring buffers) much harder to do, so we would need more abstraction layers, and more abstraction layers will eat away all the performance gains while also making everything more fragile and harder to understand. Hardware people really love those "performance hacks" that make live a more painful for the upper layers in exchange for a few 0.1%s of speed. You could also probably gain some speed by dropping byte access and saying the minimal addressable unit is now 32 bits. Please don't. If you need larger L1 cache - just increase associativity.
tliltocatl··on Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use due to age verification
You shouldn't apply that kind of thinking to global things. Because what you end up doing is nuking library on earth - there might be a casino somewhere near there. I see your concerns, but, ultimately, parent's carving for a comfortable illusion of control is less important than child's rights. And yes, I'll repeat it again, it's not child's best interest to have their surroundings controlled and censored.

And for reference, when I was talking about my personal experience, I wasn't talking about 80's. More like mid- to late- 00's Russia. The internet was already quite a cesspool at the time, the local IRL even more so. Just I wasn't interested. Once a teen is interested in getting into the edgy stuff there is no amount of regulation can stop them.

tliltocatl··on Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use due to age verification
The fear is that being below 18 doesn't mean you have no right to privacy. It's not implementation that's the problem. The whole idea is stupid.
tliltocatl··on Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use due to age verification
Because the kernel is the irreplaceable piece. None of what GNU did is: there are numerous implementations of coreutils and shells and at least one non-GNU production-quality compiler toolchain (clang-llvm), a few alternative libcs. And many distribution do actively use the non-GNU parts. But none of this is useful without the kernel that is compatible with computers people have. And the only usable kernel we have is Linux (while BSDs are out there too, they take a much different tightly-integrated approach to userspace).
tliltocatl··on Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use due to age verification
> There is no one to turn to and bully for compliance > These attempts at curbing the freedom to write and distribute software are pathetic and will fail.

You sweet summer child.

tliltocatl··on Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use due to age verification
Stop spreading disinformation. Linus and others did most of the work in the kernel. GNU project on the kernel side was architecture astronaut vaporware aka "Hurd". They were much more successful in userland (coreutils, gcc and the toolchain, gdb, Emacs, to name a few).
tliltocatl··on Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use due to age verification
For Linux it will be way more problematic because:

- A lot of of corporate contributions comes from SV.

- Linux Foundation is incorporated in CA.

- Linus himself is CA's resident AFAIR.

So there is zero chance of claiming no jurisdiction. The only hope is whoever is enforcing this batshit wouldn't go after what is essentially not an OS for the purpose of the bill, but rather an internal component (it would be like going after a vendor of bolts and nuts for noncompliance of a toaster).

tliltocatl··on Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use due to age verification
IANAL, but the whole thing feels quite problematic. Should we interpret the prohibition as a licensing condition "a resident using our IP is violating the contract" or as an informative note "we are not compliant and we are not ever going to be compliant so a resident using the IP is violating local laws"? I'd expect the intent to be the latter, but would it hold in front of a judge? If the notice is a licensing condition, the whole thing is problematic as hell:

- Does such prohibition has any legal force at all? Does it do anything to prevent responsibility according to the bill? Wouldn't just saying "CA/CO have zero jurisdiction over us, get screwed" be a saner choice (of course it would be better if the project wouldn't host on M$'s servers).

- The main project license is GPLv3. GPLv3 clearly has no provisions to introduce arbitrary prohibitions into the license without losing compatibility. But they still keep GPLv3 LICENSE.txt, which is problematic in itself - if LICENSE.txt says one thing and LEGAL-NOTICE.txt another, the conclusion might be that no license applies so no one may use the software at all!

- If they are reusing any GPL software that they don't hold copyright on, they might be or might not be in violation (would need a real lawyer to say if that's the case or not).

And on the actual matter of things, it's really sad to see California to be on the front line of this crap (this screams ageism). And, dear "adults", screw your parental authority so much. Whatever skills I've gained before the university I've done against an explicit parental prohibition. This is what I live off now. Screw you all.

tliltocatl··on I rendered 1,418 confusables over 230 fonts. Most aren't confusable to the eye
I used to read"Weird Al" as "AI" even before the LLM craze.
tliltocatl··on Raspberry Pi Pico 2 at 873.5MHz with 3.05V Core Abuse
> wifi integrated into the SoC

I really wish we would stop sticking wireless in every device. The spectrum is limited and the security concerns are just not worth it. And if you try to sell it, certifying will be RPITA even in US (rightfully so!). Just had to redesign a little Modbus RTU sensor prototype for mass production, noticed the old version used BT MCU. So I immediately imagined the certification nightmare - and the sensor is deployed underwater, it's not like BT will be useful anyway. Why? Quote "but how do we update firmware without a wireless connection"… How do you update firmware on a device with RS-485 out, a puzzle indeed. In all fairness, the person who did it was by no means a professional programmer and wasn't supposed to know. But conditioning beginners to wireless on everything - that's just evil. /rant

tliltocatl··on Raspberry Pi Pico 2 at 873.5MHz with 3.05V Core Abuse
LLM are memory-bandwidth bound so higher core frequency would not help much.
tliltocatl··on 15 years of FP64 segmentation, and why the Blackwell Ultra breaks the pattern
10% sounds implausibly high. Even on GPUs, most of area are various memories and interconnect.
tliltocatl··on Russia's economy has entered the death zone
> We started shit in Ukraine

No. Putin started shit in Ukraine after the locals got feed up with his dear friend's blatant corruption and he took it personally. America was never ever a factor there. The world doesn't spin around USA, even Americans may think so.

> Zelensky revolution

Lol, Zelensky didn't came into public light until a year or so after the revolution.

tliltocatl··on Russia's economy has entered the death zone
Aside from some factual errors, that's one way to look on things. Another one is that USSR's political top, however incompetent, released their personal fates are tied to their country, while the modern ones plan for a retirement elsewhere (or at least did so before SHTF in 2022).

> USSR: kicked their educated jews out (twice -- pogroms & doctors plot)

Sorry, that's not how it happen (source: my grandfather being a USSR Jew). Pogroms were before USSR (and were a huge factor in USSR becoming a thing) and before most Jews had access to upper education. The pre-WWII USSR was perhaps the most Jewish-friendly country in the world, or at least in Europe (however low of a bar it was at the time). After the purges and the war, with most of pre-revolution intellectual communists dead or worse and fresh-baked ex-peasant comrades now forming most of the bureaucracy, the pendulum came swinging back.

> kicked most of their educated gentiles out in 1917

Forced deportation was a few thousand cases, mostly humanitarians. Most of the educated gentiles left voluntary (showing their good judgement). And then emigration controls were put in place so the rest wouldn't leave - it's just 20's USSR weren't yet the totalitarian state it would latter become and had no machinery to prevent people from leaving.

> used up their remaining human capital as cannon fodder against hitler

Not like Stalin would not prefer to use cannon fodder elsewhere. It just wasn't an option at the time.

> Modern Russia is a gas station and strip mine with decent relations to the south and the east

That's what it was in the aughties. No more.

> Building up their defense sector

Russia already got damn nukes. That's the best defense against symmetric warfare the money can buy - and against asymmetric an inflated defense sector doesn't help much. Russia didn't built up defense sector because of any genuine or perceived threat, rather for the same reason USA does: it's a huge pork barrel.

> they don't get internationally looted again

Looted as in being sent food aid? (Well, truth to be told, this aid came with a heavy load of Mormon and Scientology cool-aid drinkers). The whole "90's looting" is tankies' legend. It was exactly the same kind of de-industrialization that happened in the West - except the social guards weren't in place and the state machine was totally collapsed. Which is certainly not a fault of any other nation.

> the right move for them, and an unfortunate reality for us.

The problem isn't "building up the defense sector". The problem is damn invading neighborhood country. Not only was it an asshole move, it was incredibly dumb because it leaves no good exit option. Even if the hostilities in Ukraine ends one way or another, the "new elite" aka bunch of goons with guns aren't going anywhere.

← PreviousPage 6 of 16Next →