HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tmbsundar

914 karma · joined June 29, 2011

submissionscomments
tmbsundar··on On average, skipping college and investing tuition costs nets a higher return
Doesn't work in Medicine, Law and host of other fields which require hard core "physical assets" (tangible) things to teach for which includes dissecting stuff, attending patients, arguing cases etc.,

In coding all you need to learn is a PC and some connectivity. That;s all.

The only conclusion we can draw from your experience is that in coding/ software self-taught path can take you to places. But, cannot be generalised for all college going.

tmbsundar··on Ask HN: How do I switch from being a passive consumer to an active producer?
Thanks. If you have some information on my question above on the books on "personal kanban", can you help please?
tmbsundar··on Ask HN: How do I switch from being a passive consumer to an active producer?
Thanks. That helps.

Is there any place or book where I can read more about the "personal kanban" principles.

Basically, I don't want to overdo it either. Want to understand the principles before jumping in.

tmbsundar··on Ask HN: How do I switch from being a passive consumer to an active producer?
Would you mind explaining his you do this?

Any software you use? Modus operandi?

tmbsundar··on Blender 2.79: OpenCL on par with CUDA
Does freebsd support CUDA yet? I tried a year back and it didn't, due to limitations from NVIDIA side.

I like freebsd a lot, but for this reason had to switch back to debian/ kubuntu.

tmbsundar··on The relationship between social media use and well-being
> I get into 'someone is wrong on the internet' discussions, and for me, those are the 'addictive but not pleasant' aspects of social media.

This is exacerbated by not having the luxury of taking cues from facial expressions, body language, smiles and the context of the situation. Moreover, f2f discussions are mostly real time and synchronous vs the social media ones being asynchronous, allowing people to pick up days old thread and continue the discussions, thus there is no end at all if one decides to weave the topic further.

tmbsundar··on Practical Deep Learning for Coders
In same boat here. Early this year I put together a PC with GTX 750 TI 2GB.

What do you think of this? Will this work fine?

tmbsundar··on Venezuela Follows India’s Example and Voids Half of Its Cash
> NITI Aayog is a government mouthpiece and not any kind of credible source on this topic.

I don't think you can brush aside broadly like that. You may have your own reasons not to believe them. Can't say can't believe them. Have to wait and watch

> And I'm pretty sure GP said "everything" will be back to normal in 30 days, not just the cash crunch.

I admit my interpretation was different and may be wrong what OP said. Only he can confirm what he meant :-).

tmbsundar··on Venezuela Follows India’s Example and Voids Half of Its Cash
The "worst phase" that is, not "the effect". I think the OP meant the "cash crunch / unavailability of 500 INR notes/ ATMS running out of cash etc.,".

The effect may take at least a quarter to ease down.

[1] http://www.deccanchronicle.com/business/economy/161216/cash-...

tmbsundar··on Venezuela Follows India’s Example and Voids Half of Its Cash
Even in India, it's not "demonetization". Even though the word demonetization is used loosely, it is actually "remonetization" and "really a currency swap where you could have exchanged your old notes in a certain period and also you still have time to deposit all your old notes in all the banks till the end of the year.

-> Old notes which are now invalid: 500, 1000

-> New notes introduced: 500, 2000

There are plans for new 1000s to be reintroduced and new 100s etc., also to be introduced.

tmbsundar··on India's Misguided War on Cash
6% is only the official estimate based on IT department raids. In reality, this will be more.

Moreover, if you stub out this 6%, you will arrest leakage of that black money getting converted into land, gold, assets etc.,

See an interesting discussion here, (though this conversation concludes both parties not conceding their point:-):)

https://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/5cilgj/cash_has_only...

For a good argument in favor of the move, and for a theoretical perspective on this, even in a developed economy with less paper money %, please see Kenneth Rogoff's blog post and also his book - the "Curse of Cash" (I've not read his book though only his posts and tweets on this)

http://blog.press.princeton.edu/2016/11/17/kenneth-rogoff-in...

tmbsundar··on India's Misguided War on Cash
This article could have been a more researched. Currently the arguments seem to be more superficial than based on ground realities in India. The comparison with Nigeria also doesn't seem to be correct.

For a theoretical perspective on this, please see Kenneth Rogoff's theory on this in the "Curse of Cash"[1]

While there might have been implementation challenges, the Indian government did not a do a "cancellation" of the high denomination notes, as claimed in the article. It is at best a "currency swap" at a large scale. Whatever money is forced to come out from being stashed away or un-accounted for, will be replaced by new valid currency of 500/1000 Rs notes.

Agreed, a withdrawal or cancellation suddenly will undermine the currency. But, not in this case. On the other hand, even road side vegetable vendors and shops have started using online payment gateway machines in this period.

In the long-term, the shadow or parallel economy is going to be pushed and integrated with more mainstream and benefit everyone.

That's not the case now: an average middle class tax paying citizen cannot reliably invest in a real-estate (especially plots and independent houses) as half of the money is transacted in black. This is a vicious circle and pushes the prices of luxury goods, real estate etc., northwards.

[1] http://blog.press.princeton.edu/2016/11/17/kenneth-rogoff-in...

tmbsundar··on GNU Health
Does it run on Windows? The reason I am asking is that a practitioner or a hospital might be using Windows historically and may be wants to try this out rather than rebooting their infrastructure to Linux to try this?
tmbsundar··on React Native for Ubuntu
I have no experience with phonegap/Cordova. But to the first part of your question, please see my answer below/ or above. to another comment.
tmbsundar··on React Native for Ubuntu
To the extent I have used RN, I find the good parts to be: - Fast & iterative development

- If you are web developer, easy to switch to this (duh!)

- The "React" philosophy of "diffing" and pushing changes and having a virtual DOM

- Javascript - less boiler plate and easier to write (YMMV)

But, with RN you hit the limits in some spots:

- Handling navigation. The available navigator components are difficult to work with. The idioms are little sticky. I know they've started working on a new one

- With Android SDK, you have the full set of components available and hence more choices - components, Material themes etc.,

- Because of the above point, you are always ahead, unless you have bandwidth to write wrappers for new components/ changes

- Slightly noticeable lesser frame rates compared to native. I don;t think this is a deal-breaker though.

Overall, the RN team is doing a great job by bringing the well tested RN concept to the mobile world and making "reusable code" worth an attempt. The choice depends on one's requirements and technology choices available in the project etc.,

tmbsundar··on Why Wait? the Science Behind Procrastination
This article is right on many points. But, I think it does not do justice in characterizing the application of Temporal Motivation Theory (TMT), Expectancy Theory, Cumulative Prospect Theory to procrastination - by Steel and others at various points in time - as "Time management" in one broad stroke.

The behavioral economic school of thought clearly implies -explicitly and indirectly - the role of emotions and moods in procrastination.

Take for instance, in the TMT equation,[1][2] the concept of

- "Value": This is more of how much you see value in that activity, how interesting or engaging that is to "you", how pleasurable it is, How rewarding that activity is, etc., The selection of the activity is heavily influenced by what looks pleasurable and rewarding to you.

- "Impulsiveness": This is similar to the "Emotional regulation" or "self-control" in the psychologists' approach. If you are in a good and/or stable mood, chances are that, you would have more control over your Emotions and thus less distraction.

The "economic theory", apart from the "Temporal" aspect, also stresses on the "impulsive" and "pleasure" components in the equation.

Also, in the analysis, the analysts from the behavioral economic point of view also recommend "to break the activities into smaller chunks", "have conquerable smaller activities with local deadlines" etc., similar to the psychologists' approach.

I think that the psychologists' point of view is well taken, with the "mood control"/"emotional regulation" point being emphasized. But, at the same time, the behavioral economic point view is not only about "Time Management".

[1] http://lesswrong.com/lw/3w3/how_to_beat_procrastination/ [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temporal_motivation_theory

tmbsundar··on Open Source is losing, SaaS is leading, APIs will win…
Not quite.

If I want to start a project in, say R, I don't think I will start by searching "Open Source". I will search for "R". Here is the trend: https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=software%20as%20a%20...

So, this analysis is not accurate. Someone searching for "Open Source" might have been prevalent when the OSS movement was nascent. Now I think people will look for specific technologies rather than blanket terms.

tmbsundar··on Ask HN: What's your favorite online course?
> broad economical trends and projections

Any good Economics Text book will do: like Principles of Economics/ Principles of Microeconomics, Gregory Mankiw

You can also try, although, personally I have not taken these:

https://www.coursera.org/course/microecon

https://www.coursera.org/learn/principles-of-macroeconomics

> FT and all the stats that CNBC shows me

For Investment valuation and Corporate Finance Damodaran is one of the best sources:

http://people.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/

Visit his blog, read his books. He has online classes as well

Also you can try, (I've not taken this course): https://www.coursera.org/learn/financial-markets

For Value Investing, Benjamin Graham is a classic:

http://www.amazon.com/Intelligent-Investor-Definitive-Invest...

> For Technical Analysis and Futures Trading though, there are tonnes of books. May be you can start with these:

http://www.amazon.com/Technical-Analysis-Financial-Markets-C...

http://www.amazon.com/Options-Futures-Other-Derivatives-Edit...

And lastly,

> combine my CS background with Finance and do something interesting in it

https://www.coursera.org/learn/computational-investing

tmbsundar··on Ask HN: What's your favorite online course?
What do you mean by FT? "Financial Technology" or "Futures Trading"?
tmbsundar··on Ask HN: What's your favorite online course?
Try Steve Blank's How to Build a Startup. Link: https://www.udacity.com/course/how-to-build-a-startup--ep245
tmbsundar··on Ask HN: What's your favorite online course?
Learning from Data by Caltech Professor Yaser Abu-Mostafa : https://work.caltech.edu/telecourse.html. There was an edX version last year

MMDS: Mining Massive Datasets by Stanford professors Jure Leskovec, Anand Rajaraman,Jeff Ullman, Link: https://www.coursera.org/course/mmds

Neural Networks for Machine Learning: Geoffrey Hinton, Link: https://www.coursera.org/course/neuralnets

Artificial Intelligence for Robotics: Programming a Robotic Car, Sebastian Thrun Link: https://www.udacity.com/course/artificial-intelligence-for-r...

Intro to Artificial Intelligence, Peter Norvig & Sebastian Thrun. This was the one which started it all in 2011, joined a little late by Andrew Ng's ML course which has been mentioned already.

Intro to Artificial Intelligence link: https://www.udacity.com/course/intro-to-artificial-intellige...

tmbsundar··on If Lisp Is So Great (2003)
not Arc?
tmbsundar··on You should try FreeBSD (2014)
I have freebsd in one of my VMs and like it very much. One reason I am reluctant to move it as my primary OS is the lack of CUDA support (this might be an nvidia thing and not the fault of freebsd devs). But still it's seems to be a blocker.

Is there a way to make CUDA work in freebsd? Would be glad to know.

tmbsundar··on Why Software Outsourcing Doesn't Work Anymore
I've witnessed two occasions in succession where "outsourcing" failed right in India where an Indian start up "outsourced" to a firm just in the next street. The usual suspects listed in the article like "Cultural mismatch", "Lack of face to face communication", etc., were not the factors in this case.

Lack of clear requirements specifications, payments agreed to on-paper milestones vs. payments against actual working code, insistence / payment of advance money to the tune of 50% even before any actual deliverables (Some firms don;t even start work with that. Their logic is that - start ups go bust more than they succeed and they do not want to wait till you succeed to get their money.), lack of technology awareness from the founders (founders were non-technical in the web domain), etc.,

The factor of cost arbitrage did not play any role here.

These were the learning points: - They should have picked up a good firm based on known references rather than go with the cheap one based on a google search.

- Tie payments to working deliverables rather than abstract things like design sign off etc.,

- Track, monitor regularly

- Be aware of the technology you are outsourcing. If you are an enterprise IT consultant and you are going to outsource the web work. Be sure to read up on Php or whatever technology they use and ask/think through relevant questions/ improvements

Edit: Modified the list into bullet points.

tmbsundar··on Julia: A fresh approach to numerical computing
May be documentation will need some time to catch up vis-a-vis the likes of R, Python etc., Understandably since it is a new language this may probably remain so for quite some time? For e.g., when I was trying to find out how to generate "n" random numbers in a uniform distribution from a range of -x to +x. In R the code is as simple as runif(n,-x,x). In matlab, it is a little bit contrived by offsetting and multiplying with the interval etc., But in Julia, the details do not go beyond the standard random functions that do not let you do this and no pointers to documentation beyond. But finally I was lucky to find an entry in the mailing list where I figured out I needed to use the "Distributions" package using the "using" command. Even then , the results were delivered in multiple precision points -> 1.1234, 1.123456 etc.,

In R computing an outer product while passing a custom function is easy. Something like outer(x,y, some function of (x,y)) is pretty straight forward. Not sure how to achieve this in Julia.

Nevertheless, as the language grows and as more idioms are documented and widely used, lif will be simpler I guess.

tmbsundar··on Bill Gates's Favorite Business Book
Thomas Thurston in his TechCrunch article "Christensen Vs. Lepore: A Matter Of Fact":

http://techcrunch.com/2014/06/30/christensen-vs-lepore-a-mat...

tmbsundar··on How to Get Good at Chess, Fast
Arena and Lucas chess are good. I like Lucas for it's simplicity though. And it is fun for my kid to play with. It comes with a tutor option also.

http://lucaschess.pusku.com/

http://www.playwitharena.com/?Download

Edit: Not sure if all of these are Open source though. But they are free.

tmbsundar··on How to Get Good at Chess, Fast
Houdini is the best now. v 1.5 is free

http://www.cruxis.com/chess/houdini.htm

tmbsundar··on Someone stole my website
looking at the about page, seems like some Indian college kids cloned it for their festival
tmbsundar··on Mythbusting India's Mars Mission
This argument presumes that Schools, Factories are better investment of talent hours than Space (high quality aluminium, steel or electronics)

This is not always true. There are some areas of governance from a sovereign country's point of view which it cannot neglect and should develop indigenous capability. Areas like defense which is non-negotiable and other strategic areas like space.

A good government always tries to balance investment in different areas. If India stops investing in Defense and Space and keeps building only schools and toilets, that will be a lopsided, weak development to say the least.

Even in other non-strategic areas, societal development cannot be dictated to flow in a single direction.

Consider this for contrast:

India's top 3 high budget movies - 86 million USD [1]

Mukesh Ambani's house - 2 Billion USD [2]

India's education budget for 2013 - 11 Billion USD [3]

India's health care budget for 2013 - 6 Billion USD [4]

[1] http://www.therichest.com/luxury/most-expensive/top-10-most-...

[2] http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/international-bu...

[3] http://www.livemint.com/Politics/7EmPAMBANzkPDAPuyruQ1I/Chid...

[4] http://in.finance.yahoo.com/news/budget-2013-hikes-spending-...

Edit : alignment

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →