HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tokipin

1,062 karma · joined September 21, 2007

submissionscomments
tokipin··on The Legend of Nintendo
> With Ultimate, Nintendo seems to have finally started thinking of Smash as primarily a competitive game.

I don't think Nintendo was ever against its competitiveness. They probably understand that if they focus on keeping the game fun, the rest will follow, regardless of whether the competitive scene accepts it or not. For an example of getting this backwards, of trying to make a game competitive first and worrying about the fun afterwards, look at the painful example of StarCraft II. Blizzard succeeded in making that game competitive, ok. But they failed at making it fun, and as a result its energy as an eSport, i.e. its playerbase and therefore viewerbase of casual and casual-competitive players, fell out from under it.

I do agree the things Nintendo is offering the competitive scene with Ultimate is awesome. I'm buying a Switch before the holiday season starts because it's probably going to get hard to get.

tokipin··on Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to the press
The cells and the packs are different things. The packs aren't just a bunch of cells glued together. See this[1] fun teardown discussion. Another company building battery packs would have different costs even if they were buying the same exact cells from Panasonic, and it's likely Tesla had a hand in designing the cells so I don't know if that's particularly possible.

The reason for the Gigafactory is to compress supply chains, but more importantly because there isn't enough global demand/supply for batteries to support the volumes Tesla wants. Without building their own factory, the global supply would be a constraining factor for Tesla's plans. The Gigafactory is a long-term bet that they will need that much supply in the future. This is not a problem that other carmakers have where they would want to "vertically integrate" oil refineries and gas stations, because availability of gasoline is not a problem.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpCrkO1x-Qo&t=29m30s

tokipin··on Tesla sues ex-employee for hacking, theft, and leaking to the press
Tesla isn't trying to become like GM, any more than Apple was trying to become like Nokia.

There's so many factors in play with the stock. Personally though, I think a lot the short sentiment is conservative ideological blindness of the anti-Obama, anti-environmentalism variety. Tesla has always been highly shorted, even when its market cap was smaller.

tokipin··on Elon Musk’s Boring Co. Wins Chicago Airport High-Speed Train Bid
The key is that this system can operate in 3D. You can have bundles of tunnels where you need higher throughput, and greater demand can just be met with more tunnels. The focus on small tunnels/cars as the core technology is part of this, since it makes it easier to reach "mass production" scales.
tokipin··on Thousands of AI researchers are boycotting the new Nature journal
Journal reviewing is oversold in my opinion. Just like Wikipedia became a better encyclopedia than traditional encyclopedias, I don't see why open-access approaches can't be at least as efficient at truth-seeking and consesus-building than traditional journals.
tokipin··on Tesla is holding a hackathon to fix two robot bottlenecks in Model 3 production
I think what you'll see with a lot of competing EVs is the same thing that happened with GM's Bolt. Decent enough car. But that's about it. The problem is that it's not enough to just make an EV. Wait until lower-priced variants of the Model 3 are being produced to see how outclassed the Bolt is, and wait until Jaguar and Audi's SUVs are out to see how they really compare. Chances are it won't be favorable for Jaguar or Audi, but I'm open to being surprised.

The first genuinely serious EV from another automaker in my opinion will be Porsche's Mission E, but take note of how well it can match the characteristics of a Model S, a family sedan, you can already buy today. Still, just the idea of an all-electric Porsche is badass.

> These may not all be sexy cars with ridiculous modes, but if they help save our planet, I'm all for it.

We're in agreement that any measure of EVing is good. Many of the challenges facing automakers are systemic, so they are in a tough spot even if they genuinely believe EVs are the future.

tokipin··on Tesla is holding a hackathon to fix two robot bottlenecks in Model 3 production
Aside from making it easier to get clicks, I think that's just the enthusiasm and the fact that Tesla is the only game in town right now. From what I've seen, when Electrek criticizes other automakers it's because they're not doing enough for electrification. There are many different reasons why automakers themselves are not eager for EVs, but that's what Electrek is judging them on. It's no surprise that Tesla is the standout.
tokipin··on To Understand the Future of Tesla, Look to the History of GM
This is a common misunderstanding in my opinion. People don't really care about the environment/climate change that much. People may think they do, but in practice the amount of people that would convert that sentiment to a purchase on a high-ticket item is probably a tiny niche, and not something you would build a business strategy around for something so capital intensive.

The point of Tesla is to force electrification simply by making cars that are better than gas cars, because then the broader market does most of the remaining work. Tesla has always known that the whole environmentalism thing is insufficient and unnecessary.

I think what throws people off is Tesla's stock price and brand. People who don't understand what can go into these assume it must be "hype and dreams," and they conclude that Tesla is popular because of marketing tricks.

tokipin··on Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla problems
The point is that that skilled engineer can manage and maintain robots across many factories. That's an aspect of Musk's "the machine that builds the machine" goal. It does have a high up front cost, but the long term advantage is real. Namely the ability to print factories, roughly speaking. Tesla is aiming for production volumes that are much higher than any current automaker.
tokipin··on Tesla Roadster
It uses 3 motors (2 in the back) and has a 200 kWh battery pack. The reason for such a large battery is so that they can draw more total current without overheating, theoretically twice as much as the Model S P100DL which only has two motors (1 in the back). Having more motors means you are spreading out the current/heat. The 600+ mile range is mostly a side effect of this engineering approach to performance.
tokipin··on Where will artificial general intelligence come from?
Well I don't know what consciousness is, so I couldn't answer that. But I think the opposite stance of consciousness being some kind of majestic oracle is silly. There is a reason why we perceive consciousness, even if it is just as a side effect of something else or a random fluke that is useless or an illusion for coordinating our limbs or whatever.

These types of discussions do get pretty wonky. When I say consciousness is selected for, I mean more whatever practical apparatus (if any) it is emergent from, not the perception of consciousness itself.

tokipin··on Where will artificial general intelligence come from?
> Artificial general intelligence won't be invented, it will emerge, just general intelligence did in the wild.

I think so as well, but for a specific reason: That people are not as "AGI" as we think, and that our general intelligence is the result of immense neuron-computing resources committed to satisfying a few simple drives. In other words, narrow AI with a lot of resources. Not to mention many specialized subcomponents.

And to the degree that consciousness is a selected trait, that means it has a purpose. I think the work on attention/focus in neural networks hints at that purpose.

tokipin··on Tesla Burns Through Record Cash to Bring the Model 3 to Market
Because Tesla is good at design, and Chevrolet is not.
tokipin··on Tesla Burns Through Record Cash to Bring the Model 3 to Market
> I think there's a huge risk for Tesla that most people don't factor in- that it's very possible that most car buyers simply don't want one.

This is a legit worry, but well-designed electric cars are better than gas cars by a large margin, without question. Ultimately this is the only requirement, and it's one of the reasons Tesla is so extreme in its design aspirations.

So this risk is not a risk at all in the case of Tesla. It is certainly a risk for other companies (see Chevy Bolt).

tokipin··on Big oil will die when it becomes cheaper to hail an electric self-driving car
Exactly. If you can throw 2 battery packs into the semi, it can be charged twice as fast as a Tesla car without doing anything else. The actual equation (miles/minute) has a few variables (mileage of semi, weight, charge curves), but the conclusion seems to be that it would charge really fast. I don't think they're going to bother with swapping.
tokipin··on Big oil will die when it becomes cheaper to hail an electric self-driving car
Charging I think is generally misunderstood. More room to work with (like in a truck) means you can either add more cells or have more space between cells, meaning you can pump more energy in (and out) within the thermal constraints. I suspect the Tesla semi will charge very fast for this kind of reason - much faster than Tesla's cars (not more slowly as people seem to expect).

If the semi is also made with "commodity" components like seems to be the idea (for instance using Model 3 motors[1]), then the cost of ownership equation becomes very appealing. This kind of modularity is yet another inherent advantage over ICE technology.

Also in this case I imagine multiple motors are more efficient than a single large motor for long-distance travel because of better thermal control for the motors themselves.

[1] https://electrek.co/2017/05/03/tesla-semi-model-3-electric-m...

tokipin··on Tesla Passes Ford by Market Value
The assumption is that Tesla is going to knock the market out of its steady state. You aren't going to predict any of those numbers because the space of possibilities is wildly broad for a roiling market. You may as well try to predict the weather a year from now. People instinctively know not to waste time on that.

Put differently, the long argument is a qualitative one, not a quantitative one. This doesn't make it any less intelligent, just harder for people to put into words. See an earlier comment I made[1] about the kind of thing that's meaningful but which is difficult to attach a number to.

And conversely, if you can predict something with numbers, that's a sign that it's stable and less risky, but then the price/ROI will reflect that safety.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13711871

tokipin··on Tesla to raise $1B
In my opinion that's like saying the "DVD buzz is wearing off" in comparison to VHS. :D But yes, if you don't believe electric cars are going to take over everything, the Gigafactory looks super risky, and regardless it's definitely an enormous investment to have on the books while it's not paying for itself.
tokipin··on Tesla to raise $1B
Packaging the cells is the hard/expensive part. Nevermind the battery management software. And the point of the Gigafactory is to compress the supply chains between raw materials and finished product. It's an all-in investment whose singular goal is to make battery packs cheaper. The only way other companies are going to match that efficiency is if 1) they make a similar investment or 2) Tesla/Panasonic screw up.
tokipin··on Tesla Says Model 3 on Track as Quarterly Loss Beats Estimates
The stock is fascinating to watch because of how binary the perception of the company is. After doing some sophisticated psychoanalysis™, the sharpest distinction I've found between the two opposing viewpoints is design. People who don't understand Tesla tend to be the same people who didn't (and still don't) understand the iPhone. For these people, the Model S is just another car, in the same way that the iPhone would have seemed like "just another cell phone". The idea that "just another car" is going to beat companies that are already making cars (and have been doing so since forever) doesn't make sense.

Related to this is people getting stuck on the idea of an "EV market", which I don't think was ever really a thing. Tesla has been competing in the same car market that every other car company competes in. The electric drivetrain may be a major factor in enabling a superior design, but most people don't care. I think many short sellers are attributing Tesla's sales to "EV buyers" rather than to "people that buy cars that are better than other cars". These are two very different beliefs about what's going on.

The financial arguments are (in my opinion) largely after-the-fact rationalizations.

tokipin··on Tesla Says Model 3 on Track as Quarterly Loss Beats Estimates
Its politicization during Obama's first term (Solyndra et al) threw it into the conservative news grinder, and for many people it's still spinning in that context. This is probably where the whole "Tesla is only alive because of government life support. And look at SpaceX just SIPHON cash straight outta NASA's coffers!" stuff comes from.
tokipin··on Tesla Says Model 3 on Track as Quarterly Loss Beats Estimates
exactly, people are reversing cause and effect here. first Tesla made desirable cars, then people started fanboying Musk. See this Google trends for Elon Musk searches:

https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=elon%20m...

Which only started picking up after the Model S was released and started getting great reviews.

The idea that Musk is a "master salesman" or whatever is pretty dumb if you watch any of his interviews. He's definitely good at business, but his fame has been fueled by his achievements alone.

tokipin··on Seven earth-sized planets discovered circling a star 39 light years from Earth
I'd be surprised if there isn't other microbe-like life in our own solar system. And the path from microbial to "complex" life is just a matter of whether the environment provides enough energy to support it (nearby sun + photosynthesis in our case). This is because cellular communities will always have certain niche advantages (homeostatis etc).

Complex life developed on Earth because it is advantageous in a physics/evolutionary sense, not because the universe accidentally slipped on a banana. Complex life is only an "accident" in that the search algorithm took a while to find the maxima. Otherwise it's just a matter of running the search long enough, and for that all you need is a star.

tokipin··on Employees are happier when led by people with deep expertise
obligatory Elon Musk SpaceX tour: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xahiWQQKw7Y
tokipin··on Alphabet’s Waymo Cuts Cost of Key Self-Driving Sensor by 90%
You're right quantity-wise, but then you have https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/812708946225963008 . I'd be surprised if Tesla EV's don't soon charge faster than it takes to fill up gas, within a couple years even. If EV's in general take off though, I think it's true that Tesla may have trouble keeping up with the larger market in terms of chargers.
tokipin··on Bram Moolenaar Discusses Developing Vim, How He Uses It, and Version 8
I'd argue Vim is actually the intuitive choice because its commands allow motion/editing across boundaries that make sense, without (in my opinion) awkward mouse/cursor motions. For example % at a function call will edit/select the whole call if the cursor is at the beginning of the function name.

Once you have the muscle memory, you use little thought on how to mechanically accomplish editing tasks, so the intent-to-accomplishment pathway is quite direct. In the end though this may not be the case for you, even if you earnestly dove into it.

I think the main difficulty with learning Vim is that its commands are like minimal "combinators" attached to arbitrary keys, and they take exploration/use to experientially bubble up these combinators to reach "comfort parity" with standard editors. In this way Vim is like the Lisp of editors.

About the ugliness, I agree. That's why I usually use a GUI version if I can. Plus it must be reiterated that Vim is more just a text editor, not an IDE like Visual Studio. If I could use VS+VsVim for everything, I would.

tokipin··on How Apple Alienated Mac Loyalists
For what it's worth, when I switched from Windows I was looking for a 17" macbook because I have a vision issue. I ended up buying a used 15" retina MBP and it's actually easier on my eyes than my 17" Windows laptop was. The retina makes a huge difference and the weight/form factor is very convenient.
tokipin··on How Apple Alienated Mac Loyalists
I think a lot of this depends on the individual. My natural preference is to use the touch screen. It's not about what's "better" in absolute terms, but what requires the least amount of thought/brain power for the person (my guess is that time is a major factor of the cost calculation - it's quicker to do what is natural). The cost of hand motions isn't significant by comparison.
tokipin··on Tesla Shock Means Global Gasoline Demand Has All but Peaked
Broadly maybe yes, but much of that infrastructure pays for itself because of the volume that goes through it. That includes processing plants as well as gas stations.

To take gas stations as an example, if 25% die off, that increases the everyday inconvenience of filling up gas, which may push X number of people to buy an EV over an ICE even considering the fuel cost. So then there will be even less volume, and more gas stations will close, so you will have a death spiral. Ironically it may become harder to fill up gas than to charge your EV.

Not saying this is what's going to happen, rather pointing out that the death of oil will be complex and it will be beautiful. :D

tokipin··on Tesla Shock Means Global Gasoline Demand Has All but Peaked
I think 150 million is a crazy underestimate. Since electric vehicles will be categorically better than gas vehicles, companies will be forced to produce them just from competition.
← PreviousPage 2 of 21Next →