HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tom-_-

202 karma · joined April 3, 2014

submissionscomments
tom-_-··on Permanent suspension of @realDonaldTrump
The parent's link provides a fair summary of the report and is more detailed than the ABA statement, which is also fair, just less detailed.

The investigation was about two things; Trump's collusion with Russia AND the obstruction of justice.

The report finds no overt collusion between Trump and the Russians. It details promises of influence to the Ukranians and the Russians by sleazy power brokers like Paul Manafort and Felix Sater, and Trump's associates soliciting Russians and pretty much anyone for Hilary's deleted emails but again, no substantial evidence of direct collusion.

Whether there was obstruction of justice seems like a much more legitimate cause for outrage. https://www.lawfareblog.com/obstruction-justice-mueller-repo... details the numerous ways this was attempted, though full-disclosure Brookings is left-leaning centrist think tank.

The full report is here https://www.justice.gov/storage/report.pdf which you don't need to pass the bar to comprehend, though you do need a lot of free time. I've only read a few parts but it's further confirmed my belief that all politicians (right and left) are completely unscrupulous and must be in order win. "Democracy" is a vague, fungible concept that anyone vying for power will either disregard or interpret in their favor.

tom-_-··on Permanent suspension of @realDonaldTrump
It's probably more accurate to say that a some of the protesters were prepared to commit acts of violence towards those in the Capitol building, some had no interest in violence, and others had no explicit plans but were caught up by mob mentality.
tom-_-··on Permanent suspension of @realDonaldTrump
Not sure why this is being downvoted, "incitement" has a very narrow definition legally, see the Brandenburg test. Of course there are many other ways to incite a mob to violence that would avoid legal consequences, which i'm sure his advisors are aware of.
tom-_-··on Permanent suspension of @realDonaldTrump
This is a false assumption, the vast majority of Americans across the political spectrum have condemned the BLM riots and looting and largely find it unacceptable. Curious how you came to the conclusion that "everyone is okay" with it.
tom-_-··on China: The Disappearing Millionaires (2019) [video]
Yes, the "X is Evil and Evil do what Evil does" kind of reductive and anti-intellectual arguments here are disappointing.

I'll offer an alternative, although admittedly simplistic lens to understand the actions of the CCP:

To pull their population of 1.4 billion people out of poverty. To which political stability is essential.

tom-_-··on A group of Google workers have announced plans to unionize
What percentage of Alphabet employees work on profitable products? Since AWU has no contract with Alphabet, their only leverage is work stoppage but if those protesting aren't adding monetary value to the business, then wouldn't work stoppage be net-neutral or positive for Alphabet?
tom-_-··on An Engineer’s Guide to Stock Options (2013)
For the youngsters reading this thread, please understand there is a big difference in the expected return of early and late stage startups.

Early stage startups are often a crap shoot financially as others have pointed out, and contracts are structured so that unless you're a founding member, even a successful exit (after 10 years avg) probably won't net you FAANG money.

You will however probably have greater job satisfaction having more ownership over the product and will gain a much greater breadth of experience, which are the main reasons people leave FAANGs for startups (yes that is quite common).

Late stage startups (companies that are still primarily VC backed) but have a high likelihood of a successful exit have a financial risk-reward that is much closer to FAANG. The upside is that they are not so massive that your job will mean more than just ladder climbing and working on menial projects that have zero business impact.

You may find pre-ipo companies (Robinhood, Instacart, Coursera) hit that sweet spot of comp and job satisfaction.

Also if SPACs continue to get more popular, there's another option for the mid-stage startups.

tom-_-··on How Chase Sapphire retained customers
For each Sapphire Reserve card, Chase gets a $550 annual fee + 3.0% of every swipe.

Each cardholder gets $300 in travel credit + $120 in DoorDash credits and from 1% to 4.5% of every dollar spent refunded depending on how you spend your points. Plus purchase protection, Lyft Pink and a bunch of other travel benefits.

For the cardholder, it's easily break even if you spend ~$10k+/year on your credit card. For Chase, they only lose when users spend less than $10k and leave after the first year.

tom-_-··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
What process exists for fact-checking independent analysts? Most have zero accountability and have even less incentive to verify claims because 1) It takes time and money 2) Often does not serve their own political agendas and subscriber bases/income streams

Yes, placing our complete trust in a few major media outlets to accurately report the facts is naive. But believing that individuals with no independent fact checking department or an editor to enforce journalistic standards will somehow be less biased is even more naive.

tom-_-··on Biden wins White House, vowing new direction for divided U.S.
Because the polling majorly favored Biden and the results showed far more Trump votes than anticipated could rationally be interpreted to mean that mail-in ballots were flawed in a way that favored Trump.

I'm not claiming this is the case but providing an example of how subjective and spinnable any set of facts can be made.

tom-_-··on Poll: 62% of Americans Say They Have Political Views They’re Afraid to Share
Therein lies the subjectivity. One person interprets neo Nazis rallies as inciting genocide. Another interprets it as a bunch of harmless nuts on parade.
tom-_-··on Poll: 62% of Americans Say They Have Political Views They’re Afraid to Share
"Basic rights" is a subjective term and they're often in conflict with each other. Pro-choice vs pro-life being the classic example.

If you believe freedom of speech is a basic right, then you should also believe in protecting the right of bigots to spread diatribe.

tom-_-··on Abolish the Cash Bail System
The description of Prop 25 doesn't include any details about the risk assessment model. This is the only doc I've found that does.
tom-_-··on Abolish the Cash Bail System
Prop 25 upholds SB 10. This paper suggests improvements to SB10 based on potential biases in its design.
tom-_-··on Abolish the Cash Bail System
California Prop 25 on the ballot this election replaces cash bails with a risk assessment scoring system based on Senate Bill 10:

https://policylab.stanford.edu/media/improving-california-ba...

Note the flaws in its design that could replace the existing system with one that has potentially worse biases.

tom-_-··on One Guy Ruined Hacktoberfest 2020
Spam PRs are frustrating but this rant just reads as petty and vindictive.

The author claims that he doesn't "want to cancel or shame him personally", which just rings of false humility considering he named the article "How One Guy Ruined #Hacktoberfest2020" and then chose to expose his Youtube name repeatedly, something even other frustrated tweeters chose NOT to do.

Here's what CodeWithHarry did:

He created an example video of submitting a PR to an open source project that repeatedly reminded its viewers to make worthwhile contributions.

He then posted a lengthy response to again inform his viewers to NOT submit spammy PRs.

He's acting responsibly and in good faith.

Does this deserve lynching by the twitter mob?

Edit: Yes, the video appears to be mostly about showing kids how to get free swag with open source contributions without too much concern for whether these PRs are worthwhile. But the author of this post is absolutely trying to shame/cancel him personally.

tom-_-··on Seattle approves minimum wage for Uber and Lyft drivers
Therein lies the harsh business reality. Every product and service you use, somewhere along its production (including basic materials), distribution or marketing has workers earning poverty level wages. And many can only function as a business with low wage workers or automation.

Are these business worth having? If we hope to maintain our quality of life, I believe yes.

And because the choice for these workers is low wages or no wages, then answer is probably yes for them as well.

The only other option for higher wages would be for these businesses to be state-sponsored, which is at least worth consideration.

tom-_-··on Seattle approves minimum wage for Uber and Lyft drivers
This is where government policy meets business reality. The reality is, ridesharing is a low margin business. Have you seen Uber's earnings reports? It's questionable whether the business model can ever be sustainable.

So with higher wages, you're just accelerating Uber's drive into insolvency. Their only option is to cut workers and increase ride prices.

But you can only do the latter so much before you lose users to the point where Uber just becomes a private taxi service for the wealthy in which case you might as well not use a rideshare model and just hire professional chauffeurs.

tom-_-··on Vilified early over Covid-19 strategy, Sweden seems to have scourge controlled
No, it's quite obvious that lockdown would disproportionality impact middle and lower income families. Not to mention that implementing such a spite-based policy would require a massive conspiracy that crossed state boundaries and political ideology, and many of the policymakers themselves would be among the elite that were supposedly targeted.

To quote the op: "I think we’ve effectively lost our minds on covid."

tom-_-··on Nikola: How to Parlay an Ocean of Lies into a Partnership with GM
There are many would be con artists that have not gone further than counting cards at the local tribal casino. I would argue these men are equally unethical but success at this scale requires persistence, hard work and talent. In this case, the talent is lying convincingly.
tom-_-··on Palantir Moves Headquarters to Denver from Silicon Valley
It's true, locality of talent pool matters..but covid has shown the degree to which it matters is quickly diminishing as evidenced by the handful of companies declaring WFH forever, or re-considering their office leases.
tom-_-··on Palantir Moves Headquarters to Denver from Silicon Valley
Ignore the grandstanding, the two reasons why companies move out of a state/country:

1. Tax laws

2. Cheaper labor

Edit: 3. Be closer to the people that give them money

tom-_-··on U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjiang over forced labor
I'd also like to thank dang for upholding the values of evidence, logic, diversity and respect that distinguishes HN from the mob mentality, flame wars and general toxicity that is social media.
tom-_-··on U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjiang over forced labor
Is there substance in the comment that strikes you as misleading, an exaggeration or just untrue? If so, you should speak to that instead of not so subtly suggesting that the commenter is a Chinese misinformant, which is against HN guidelines and probably untrue.
tom-_-··on U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjiang over forced labor
Read the guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

"Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll look at the data."

You can believe what you want, obviously. But understand without evidence, your claims are baseless.

tom-_-··on U.S. to block cotton, tomato product imports from Xinjiang over forced labor
@phist_mcgee Here's my read of the same comment:

- The commenter is skeptical of the quality of Western media

- Commenter provides an anecdotal data point, which is by definition not reliable but provides some grounds for skepticism

- Human rights abuses have been and still are an issue in the United States. I would argue here that the comparison to China is facile at best but I understand the point being made.

You may have some strong counter arguments but starting off by accusing the commenter of being a "PLA" or "CCP" agent is undermining them.

tom-_-··on TikTok CEO Kevin Mayer to leave the company
It's easy to forget that China is still a developing nation (~$10k gdp/capita) and protectionist policy is designed to allow developing nations to strengthen domestic industries.

If "free access" were permitted, these Chinese companies would surely be absolutely crushed by their US counterparts and its citizens would forever be consumers of US goods while forever providing the cheap labor to produce them.

To build self-sustaining growth, a country must establish the positive feedback loop of consuming its own goods.

tom-_-··on Germany begins 3-year universal-basic-income trial
I believe what commenter is suggesting is that the notion of "fairness" provided by UBI is too simplistic and easily fails to uphold that principle under any amount of scrutiny.

By simply asking the question "Who will pay for UBI and who will receive it", the degree to which it's "fair", "just", or "equal" becomes obviously nebulous

tom-_-··on Pseudo-epidemics
I read it a little differently. The author steers clear of debating causes of symptoms and speculating how high or low FP% might be. He even doesn't quite come out and say Covid-19 is a "pseudo-epidemic" though one could easily infer that from the title + subheading.

The main points I read were:

- A FP cannot logically be determined using two non-ground truth tests (PCR)

- This means FP rate is unknown

- Even if the FP rate is low (~2%), it would mean perpetual epidemic given current testing targets

- Public health officials and policy makers don't understand the data and/or aren't incentivized to consider the cost of lockdowns

Though it was be nice to hear from mike_hearn himself.

tom-_-··on TikTok’s Chinese owner offers to forego stake to clinch U.S. deal – sources
I don't know of any but I also wouldn't be surprised if there were. The NBA and American movie production companies already censor in the US as concession to access the Chinese markets. Not arguing this is a good thing mind you, just that it may not be unprecedented.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →