HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tombone12

227 karma · joined May 22, 2016

submissionscomments
tombone12··on The Pentagon’s ‘Encyclopedia of Ethical Failure’
“They had properly listed the restaurant stop in their mission plan. Since the stop was properly listed, the soldiers had not violated any regulations, but they still received verbal counseling because their actions created an appearance of impropriety.”

I wonder if they where very loud in the restaurant? That they got clearance to stop the blackhawk is clearly the "violation" here, as long as they weren't to smug about it afterwards.

tombone12··on First test of rival to Einstein’s gravity kills off dark matter
people who just make up dark matter distributions are morons, obviously you use a model derived from the theory.
tombone12··on How to Get Your Company Execs Quoted as Thought Leaders
If you, like mr Schuman here, are a journalist I don't think it's your place to be providing media training, at least if you strive for a higher moral standing than the IRS officer working for PWC on the side coming up with tax evasion vehicles.
tombone12··on Zenefits ordered to stop offering free insurance software in Washington state
Offering something for free based solely on big capital sound like the definition of dumping, so anti-dumping laws is probably right.
tombone12··on Britons could pay a fee to retain EU membership
The argument from the parliament and the commission has always been that if the UK wants the single market it gets the other bits too, with freedom of movement being the biggest issue.

Obviously britons would still be able to get into the EU via some sort of visa system, and it's profoundly unclear if that is what Guy has suggested or exactly how many extra rights come with it. It is unlikely for instance that this EU fee would affect things like the ease moving between benefits systems because that would probably be handled by bilateral treaties.

tombone12··on Closing the Gap – The Formally Verified Optimizing Compiler CompCert [pdf]
Pff, amateur. The only safe way to read pdfs is by getting a bunch of smartphones by dumpster diving and then discarding them once you've read the pdf once.
tombone12··on Inside a Fake News Factory: ‘This Is All About Income’
I find it funny how globalism is leaking back into the US in unexpected ways; who would have thought twenty years ago that a Georgian citizen would take flak for derailing a US election by producing pulp news? It was always supposed to be the American eagle spreading its freedom to the world who gratefully welcomed it with praise, they weren't actually supposed to influence the US back!
tombone12··on Inside a Fake News Factory: ‘This Is All About Income’
> Censorship by private corporations and government is not the answer.

You yourself complain about lack of reporting about an issue, lack of truth, and then you go on to celebrate the spreading of lies? Fake news are basically just lies so opposing them is to spread truths, and to call efforts to spread truth "censorship" is 1984 logic.

Also, as I'm sure others will point out, FB and google already arbitrarily restrict content on their platforms so there is nothing "unprecedented" about it. There really isn't much of a case that filtering fake news is different banning from Simpsons clips or music remixes.

tombone12··on Inside a Fake News Factory: ‘This Is All About Income’
True enough, but the damage is more nebulous and potentially greater. Also, will bag of words work well for news?
tombone12··on I can’t just stand by and watch Mark Zuckerberg destroy the internet
We are always dying, and I doubt Facebook kills much faster than HN as most of the lethality comes from sitting still while reading. Of course, FB comes with extra stress for some, but I don't know how the cyber bullying on FB stacks up with the workplace rage from Excel.
tombone12··on EmDrive study officially published
> That's a non-sequitur. If there weren't several repeated experiments showing similar results it might be a reasonable caution. However, many of the best scientific discoveries arose in similar mis-comprehensions.

It's not a non-sequitur! It's firm evidence they don't understand what is going on and therefore aren't in a position to explain it. The fact that they have found a consistent effect does not mean they found anything interesting, a tiny wiggle very close to the detection range when you put a lot of power into it isn't by itself interesting unless you have a good basis to know it is. Which they DON'T.

tombone12··on EmDrive study officially published
Goddamit, I wanted to get to the comment about the superoptimizer, not this mass hallucination over crap sience :(
tombone12··on Learn X in Y minutes
Eh, I can't honestly tell if there has been more X's added since the last time it was posted and I don't feel like putting in the time into the wayback machine to find out.
tombone12··on GNU Octave
Why not just: v = np.array([2,3,1]).T

is there something wrong with numpys convenience method for transpose but not matlabs postfix unary convenience operator?

tombone12··on The Fact and Fiction of the NASA EmDrive Paper Leak
Part of the world has entered the post-truth age, the spirit of the times likes a good story better than the facts, and if you speak facts you'll be damned by them.

Just look at the article itself, doesn't actually say anything about the paper beyond confirming it's going to be publicated, the rest is just retelling the story up to now like there's much debate going on.

As far as I know, there are some extremely questionable measurements showing there is something there, theory to explain it that is for sure completely wrong, and now this paper that might be alright that is not totally ruling it out. And based of this people go "why must momentum be conserved???!"; It ain't pretty, but that's the world we live in.

tombone12··on Pornhub Bypasses Ad Blockers with WebSockets
While I'm sure there is some perverse way of defining "innovation" that can muster up enough factual basis to count as a half truth for some drunk in a gutter, I suggest you consider the less extreme position that technological development is driven by a multitude of factors and towards equally diverse goals.

First off, we can dispense both porn and video games as important technological drivers since both are realms of extremely narrow focus compared to the breadth of the military; neither can for instance be credited with driving development of automatic telephone exchanges.

The military has much more diverse needs, and could therefore plausibly drive "innovations in technology" over a large enough breadth of technologies to count. Still, the technology the military directly develops or pay for being developed is of a decidedly military nature, and as we all know the civilian sector of society is quite sizable and contains a multitude of technology unique to it, none of which are directly developed by the military.

Frankly, the fact that the Board of Longitude lead to portable timepieces does not mean the military can be credited with all advances in timekeeping henceforth.

tombone12··on Stealth Boat the U.S. Government Won't Buy or Let Be Sold Abroad
The government awards him both the patent and the intellectual property, the latter not being defined by the constitution.
tombone12··on How to Get Fired Using Switch Statements and Statement Expressions
I am reminded of the following story, reproduced here in its entirety

----

Thompson, Ritchie and Kernighan admit that Unix was a prank

=====================================

(This piece was found on Usenet. This is fiction, not reality. Always remember that this is not true. It's really a joke, right? -- Editor)

In an announcement that has stunned the computer industry, Ken Thompson, Dennis Ritchie and Brian Kernighan admitted that the Unix operating system and C programming language created by them is an elaborate prank kept alive for over 20 years. Speaking at the recent UnixWorld Software Development Forum, Thompson revealed the following:

"In 1969, AT&T had just terminated their work with the GE/Honeywell/AT&T Multics project. Brian and I had started work with an early release of Pascal from Professor Niklaus Wirth's ETH Labs in Switzerland and we were impressed with its elegant simplicity and power. Dennis had just finished reading 'Bored of the Rings', a National Lampoon parody of the Tolkien's 'Lord of the Rings' trilogy. As a lark, we decided to do parodies of the Multics environment and Pascal. Dennis and I were responsible for the operating environment. We looked at Multics and designed the new OS to be as complex and cryptic as possible to maximize casual users' frustration levels, calling it Unix as a parody of Multics, as well as other more risque! allusions. We sold the terse command language to novitiates by telling them that it saved them typing.

Then Dennis and Brian worked on a warped version of Pascal, called 'A'. 'A' looked a lot like Pascal, but elevated the notion of the direct memory address (which Wirth had banished) to the central concept of the "pointer" as an innocuous sounding name for a truly malevolent construct. Brian must be credited with the idea of having absolutely no standard I/O specification: this ensured that at least 50% of the typical commercial program would have to be re-coded when changing hardware platforms.

Brian was also responsible for pitching this lack of I/O as a feature: it allowed us to describe the language as "truly portable". When we found others were actually creating real programs with A, we removed compulsory type-checking on function arguments. Later, we added a notion we called "casting": this allowed the programmer to treat an integer as though it were a 50kb user-defined structure. When we found that some programmers were simply not using pointers, we eliminated the ability to pass structures to functions, enforcing their use in even the simplest applications. We sold this, and many other features, as enhancements to the efficiency of the language. In this way, our prank evolved into B, BCPL, and finally C.

We stopped when we got a clean compile on the following syntax: for(;P("\n"),R-;P("|"))for(e=C;e-;P("_"+(u++/8)%2))P("| "+(u/4)%2);

At one time, we joked about selling this to the Soviets to set their computer science progress back 20 or more years.

Unfortunately, AT&T and other US corporations actually began using Unix and C. We decided we'd better keep mum, assuming it was just a passing phase. In fact, it's taken US companies over 20 years to develop enough expertise to generate useful applications using this 1960's technological parody. We are impressed with the tenacity of the general Unix and C programmer. In fact, Brian, Dennis and I have never ourselves attempted to write a commercial application in this environment.

We feel really guilty about the chaos, confusion and truly awesome programming projects that have resulted from our silly prank so long ago."

Dennis Ritchie said: "What really tore it (just when ADA was catching on), was that Bjarne Stroustrup caught onto our joke. He extended it to further parody Smalltalk. Like us, he was caught by surprise when nobody laughed. So he added multiple inheritance, virtual base classes, and later ...templates. All to no avail. So we now have compilers that can compile 100,000 lines per second, but need to process header files for 25 minutes before they get to the meat of "Hello, World".

Major Unix and C vendors and customers, including AT&T, Microsoft, Hewlett-Packard, GTE, NCR, and DEC have refused comment at this time.

Borland International, a leading vendor of object-oriented tools, including the popular Turbo Pascal and Borland C++, stated they had suspected for Windows was originally written in C++. Philippe Kahn said: "After two and a half years programming, and massive programmer burn-outs, we re-coded the whole thing in Turbo Pascal in three months. I think it's fair to say that Turbo Pascal saved our bacon". Another Borland spokesman said that they would continue to enhance their Pascal products and halt further efforts to develop C/C++.

Professor Wirth of the ETH Institute and father of the Pascal, Modula 2, and Oberon structured languages, cryptically said "P.T. Barnum was right." He had no further comments.

tombone12··on Ask a Female Engineer: Employees with Kids and Relationships at Work
Dude, if your mother was discriminated based on her gender, and you share that gender, you know that her story of discrimination (in the workplace, say) likely applies to you. If you're a man, you know that scare story doesn't apply to you.
tombone12··on Ask a Female Engineer: Employees with Kids and Relationships at Work
This series isn't supportive of gender based discrimination, it simply acknowledges the physical fact that men and women exists as two separable groups, and then asks question to a small sample of the underrepresented group.

There are undeniable differences between women and men, and pretending that they don't exists, as you suggest, doesn't make them go away. It merely means that one of the groups will not have their specific requirements considered.

tombone12··on Ask a Female Engineer: Employees with Kids and Relationships at Work
A group in this context is a set of persons who share a property, in this case their gender.

As to the larger point you are trying to make, I'm sorry, you didn't manage to make one. It is true that any given person can be simultaneously in a privileged group and an underprivileged group (I'm both a man and a very short person), but this is a rather trivial observation much like saying that it can be both night and that at a particular place on Earth.

We get it, people have different possibilities in different contexts, what a remarkable observation! Now stop trying to restrict the possibilities women have to express their experiences, and dragging out a quote from Emerson about how he really dislikes the poor (which he can well do in the privacy of his own dead head or just generally away from me) does not count as discussion.

tombone12··on Elon Musk's finances
Buying an 8 year old car means buying a used car, no? In that case you are comparing the polluting factory to no factory at all.

Fleets of self driving cars are called public transport or taxis (depends on your preference), and have been around for a while. The environmental benefit of exchanging the bus driver with a more efficient steering method is probably offset by the idea that the inefficiencies of cars compared to buses for mass transit. Probably a net win for taxis though, but nothing revolutionary.

tombone12··on Iceland Is Drilling a 3-Mile Hole to Tap Magma Power
It's 50 MW per borehole, a power station typically generates power from a largish number of holes. A big geothermal plant on Iceland can have 30 boreholes, which with the new method could then produce 1.5 TW, 54 % of total capacity. Of course, how much is actually possible to take out at given size depends on the size of the magma system you are tapping and how fast it refills.
tombone12··on Iceland Is Drilling a 3-Mile Hole to Tap Magma Power
You know magma has a tendency to come out right? If you put trash down the hole, its burned remains just clog up the end and risk coming back out whenever the stopper is removed.
tombone12··on Iceland Is Drilling a 3-Mile Hole to Tap Magma Power
Yeah, Iceland doesn't really have a surplus if geologically stable land...
tombone12··on Wait continues for European Schiaparelli Mars lander
Well yeah, scattered out of the antenna line of sight by the martian atmosphere.
tombone12··on Ecuador acknowledges it has "temporarily restricted" Assange's communications
Yeah, she is transparently a boring establishment proxy, but so what? The US constitution is intended to preserve the establishments power, and you think its fine to celebrate that like a holy relic.

I don't get this overhyped aggression towards Hillary, her crime is basically to be a career politician. How can that be comparable to the idiot scumbag running for president?

tombone12··on Ecuador acknowledges it has "temporarily restricted" Assange's communications
Yes, Assange and wikileaks have built a strong mythos around themselves, in part based on true events.
tombone12··on Ecuador acknowledges it has "temporarily restricted" Assange's communications
Trump is not honest; telling obvious lies is not honesty, it is incompetent dishonesty.
tombone12··on Schaeuble Seeks Decision on EU Financial Transaction Tax in 2016
Wait, are you saying HFT are great and should be kept because their business model looks like its collapsing?
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →