HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tomelders

3,861 karma · joined December 15, 2010

designer developer, based in london. www.tomelders.com
submissionscomments
tomelders··on NHS.UK frontend
Well NASA put a man on the Moon and America's economy boomed at the same time.

Also, your tax dollars are absolutely being handed over to private organisations in one way or another. Either through subsidies, tax breaks, welfare, economic initiatives, or direct investment.

tomelders··on Apple to pull some iPhones in Germany as Qualcomm extends global wins
Fijian dollars.
tomelders··on Apple to pull some iPhones in Germany as Qualcomm extends global wins
It would appear so... but in this case it will cost you about six hundred billion dollars if you're just trying your luck.

I suspect Qualcomm genuinely believe they have a case. But I wouldn't bet against Apple being genuinely innocent.

tomelders··on NHS.UK frontend
This project has obviously been carefully planned out, well defined ahead of time, and overseen with a militant eye for detail and style. That has lead to a neat, tidy, and immediately accessible code base that delivers what look like rock solid UI components.

Compare and contrast that to every private sector project I've worked on (for global household names none the less) and this sort of thoughtfulness and consideration simply is not compatible with the business objectives, and as such is the first thing to get the chop, leading to code bases that grow increasingly incoherent over time and deliver flakey solutions at best.

The next time anyone tries to sell me on the notion that the public sector can't do anything as well as the private sector, this is what I'll point them to. They wont understand what they're looking at of course, but that won't make them any less wrong.

tomelders··on A web-based mission control framework by NASA
Angular.
tomelders··on Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial complex”
I'd argue that the weaponisation of personal data and hyper targeted advertisements/disinformation are making all of those issues worse. It's what has created the current wave of climate change denying nazi sympathising maniacs to grow.
tomelders··on Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial complex”
Well done everyone. Never let the actual content of an article get in the way of some good old Apple bashing.

At the time of writing, I can only find one top level comment (by 'dvfjsdhgfv') that's making any attempt to discuss or expand upon the content of Cook's comments.

This is one of the most important issues facing mankind, and the ball is very much in our court. We all get plenty of opportunities to criticise our favourite tech companies and their practices, but if every single mention of them becomes an invitation to shoehorn in our gripes and complaints then this entire endeavour is just a massive waste of time.

tomelders··on Tim Cook makes blistering attack on the “data industrial complex”
Cook isn't arguing that companies should not be allowed to have access to data. He's arguing that there should be laws in place to prevent misuse and abuses of that data.

There's nothing inherently wrong with agreeing to give a company access to your data. But it's absolutely wrong that once you've handed your data over, that company can do whatever it wants with it, with no restrictions, as if they own it.

tomelders··on OOP Is Dead, Long Live OOP
Yep.
tomelders··on OOP Is Dead, Long Live OOP
The confusing thing about the name “Entity Component System” is that “System” is thing in ECS. It’s not a system of Entities and Components, it’s a pattern thay has three parts; Entities, Components, and Systems.
tomelders··on OOP Is Dead, Long Live OOP
Is FROOP a thing? Cos that’s what I’m doing it seems.
tomelders··on Evergreen: a React UI Framework built by Segment
Popover menus and drop-downs should disappear when the user scrolls the page.

Also, custom select inputs always ignore a big percentage of the functionality that native select inputs deliver.

tomelders··on Ask HN: What is your best advice for a junior software developer?
Write as little code as possible. But make sure that whatever code you do write is readable.
tomelders··on Microsoft intercepting Firefox, Chrome installation on Windows 10 Insider build
Only suckers trust Microsoft. That may be glib, but it's 100% true.
tomelders··on EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ and ‘upload filter’
Any country that legislates against free speech ans freedom of expression with such a brutal and blunt law such as this should be considered a failed experiment.
tomelders··on China now the most prolific contributor to physical sciences, engineering, math
It's always been this way to some degree. Every now and again a messiah comes along that illuminates and exposes a new way of thinking, and academia goes through a revolution. Then the weaker minds establish boundaries based on the teachings of their fearless leader, the leader dies, and academia settles back into it's natural state of dogmatic adherence to ideas it understands but can't expand upon.

There will be another Einstein. There will be another Darwin. And they will change everything. It is only a matter of time.

But I doubt they will come from China. While many a genius may be born in China, they may as well have been born on Mars because it is not a country that rewards exceptionalism and original thinking.

Also... I'm still trying to imagine what Dijon Ketchup would taste like.

tomelders··on EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ and ‘upload filter’
Hmmm. I'm not so sure. The EU parliament is usually pretty savvy on civil rights and freedom issues like this. I'm genuinely surprised that this law passed.

However, it's hard to fathom the EU parliament sometimes because it's such a broad and diverse bunch of people and interests forced into such a small political space.

If someone asked me to play devils advocate for this decision, I'd probably appeal to people's fear of foreign disinformation campaigns and the impact they're having on western democracies. I could probably cobble together a semi-compelling argument about how Twitter, Facebook, and Reddit, have inadvertently handed the enemies of the west the most powerful propaganda tool in all of human history, and those enemies are using it to great effect. Or how marketing companies have convinced millions of parents worldwide to not vaccinate their children through the internet. Or how organisations like Monsanto astroturf the web and misquote or misrepresent scientific reports or news articles to make it seem like Greenpeace promote and advocate using DDT.

I'd then go on to argue that information can and must be free to share, but nefarious misinformation should not be free from punishment nor protected by law. And so, the age of anonymous and unaccountable publishing platforms must come to an end. If they don't want to be held accountable for the content they publish, then that's fine. But that just means we restrict the type of content they're allowed to publish. After all, we have advertising standards that the press and broadcasters adhere to. We have rules around when and how "traditional" media can report on politics. So the Youtubes, Twitters, Reddits, and Facebooks of the world can either fall in line with those rules, or carry on as they are but simply refrain from anything that could be perceived as advertising or political reporting... which is pretty much everything except dick picks I think.

Now, I'm pretending to defend this law. Don't assume I believe any of what I just said. I actually think this law abhorrent. And while I do have concerns about the unrestrained power and influence of the web, I don't think this law is the answer to my concerns. But if I put my mind to selling this law to people who don't know as much about the web as I do, I think this kind of argument would be effective. On some people at least. And MEP's aren't technical people. They're political people. And I think it would be pretty easy to scare them into backing this law whilst appealing to their sense of justice, fairness, and honesty.

tomelders··on EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ and ‘upload filter’
As bonkers as this may seem, I suspect it will fall flat on it's face the second it's put before a court.

For example, someone defends their right to use the title or quote from an article from some other news gathering organisation. Someone will need to convince a judge that it's OK for The Sunday Times, or Der Spiegel to do that, but it's not OK for Reddit or Hacker News to do that.

And eventually, someone will need to convince a court that it's OK for Charlie Booker to broadcast a Cassetteboy video mash up on the UK's Channel 4, but it's not OK for Cassetteboy to upload that same video to youtube.

It is true that the CJEU doesn't hold case law and precedent in the same high regard as other courts, but neither does it ignore them. The ECJ and CJEU serves as a check on government in the same way the courts do in most other countries. I think it is unfortunate that the EU parliament has approved this law. But I struggle to see how it will stand up in court. That said, it will take a very brave person or organisation with deep pockets and a steel will to challenge this law.

However, if this law is upheld in court, then I think we can consider the EU a failed experiment. So abhorrent is this legislation that I, an ardent "Remaniac", would rather see the EU fail and take my chances with whatever comes next, than let the EU stifle free speech and the free flow of information and ideas in this way.

tomelders··on Stacking concrete blocks is a surprisingly efficient way to store energy
Cheers. I must be missing something, but once the hole is dug, it’s dug, and i’d have thought it was pretty low maintenance and more structuraly sound than a crane. So over time, would the costs of maintenance provide a benefit?
tomelders··on Stacking concrete blocks is a surprisingly efficient way to store energy
Honest question. Is there a reason to use a crane rarther than digging a hole? It seems all that needs to happen is for a weight to be lifted and then allowed to fall. If that was done below ground, that would cut out the weather issues and I feel like the structure itself would be a lot more robust.
tomelders··on The health-technology sector overlooks women and their bodies
Ok. I personally don't think that's a female activity, but I take your point that others might.

That said, I don't have any children of my own. As such, I only have a vague idea about the challenges involved. I am without a doubt, ignorant to the reality of child rearing.

Does that make me sexist?

tomelders··on The health-technology sector overlooks women and their bodies
> Sexism can also include paying less attention or being ignorant of stereotypically “female” activities.

What is a stereotypically female activity?

tomelders··on Imagvue: An image processing component for Vue.js
I wasn't saying "don't use Vue", I was saying there are good reasons to use a view layer library, and I used "VDOM" as a relevant example specifically because Vue implements one.

And two way data bindings are the best way to make a code base inscrutable. I'll put it another way. Wise developers avoid two way data bindings.

tomelders··on Imagvue: An image processing component for Vue.js
You don’t have to use Vue as a framework. You can opt just to use the view layer as a library.
tomelders··on Imagvue: An image processing component for Vue.js
No. It makes sense to use a library that implements a VDOM and efficient Dom Diffing because that's hard to implement yourself.

And there is no need for front end frameworks at all. They should be avoided entirely.

And two way data binding is for fools.

tomelders··on Imagvue: An image processing component for Vue.js
But what advantages does a Vue component offer over just doing the same thing with CSS? It's not going to be any more performant because it's not addressing a part of the rendering engine that Vue has any influence over. And you're not saving keystrokes because you've still got to instantiate the component and pass values to the props. All it does as far as I can tell is abstract away something that's trivial to do manually.
tomelders··on Imagvue: An image processing component for Vue.js
Yeah but why? It's just applying CSS. You set the props, it applies those props as CSS. Why not cut out the middle man and just apply the css directly? And why is lazy loading bundled in? What's that got to do with image processing?
tomelders··on Red Flags Signaling That a Rebuild Will Fail
Complete nonsense.
tomelders··on Red Flags Signaling That a Rebuild Will Fail
Well there's little else you can do when your app is a Java applet and your runtime has just vanished from the web. These things still exist, and people like me are rebuilding them.

I don't appreciate the snark in your comment.

tomelders··on Stripe Press
I couldn't disagree more. To wheel out a tired old phrase, design isn't how something looks, it's how it works.

The visual aesthetics of Stripe's output demonstrates great taste. But it's the way that taste complements the functionality, and how they are uncompromising about functionality and usability. I've worked on too many UI's where a detail in the design has compromised the usability, performance, or functionality of a UI all for the sake of aesthetics. I swear I might kill the next UXer that tries to argue that "responsive is out of scope" just because they can't be arsed to figure it out or change their designs to work responsively.

A lot of products and services look like Stripe now, or at least try to, but very few work as well as Stripe's output.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →