HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tomelders

3,861 karma · joined December 15, 2010

designer developer, based in london. www.tomelders.com
submissionscomments
tomelders··on MacBook Pro 13" Touch Bar 2018 Teardown
The T2 chip?
tomelders··on Goldman Sachs model to predict World Cup game results didn’t come close
While I agree that it's somewhat silly to try and predict a word cup winner like this (and I suspect it was just a bit of fun anyway), there is one other reason that could explain why all these attempts got it so wrong.

Cheating.

Before people start booing, let's not forget where this tournament is being held, and all the other nefarious things that country has been up to recently.

tomelders··on Red Flags Signaling That a Rebuild Will Fail
Their job isn’t to build the whole thing. Their job is to research and explore how new ideas and tools might be useful to your business.

It’s just R&D. It’s not an exotic idea.

tomelders··on Red Flags Signaling That a Rebuild Will Fail
I’ve carved a career out of rebuilds. I’m working on a rebuild right now. There’s a ton of companies out there who’ve done very well with their home grown antiquated systems from the late 90’s and early 00’s that are now facing stiff competition from young upstarts who had feature parity from day one and are knocking out new features at break neck pace because they’re leveraging the latest and greatest in tools, technology, and thinking.

I’ve always been a big believer in rebuilding your product from the ground up. I think it’s something you should always have going on in the background. Just a couple of devs whose job it is to try and rebuild your thing from scratch. Maybe you’ll never use the new version. But I think it’s a great way to better understand your product and make sure there’s no dark corners that no one dare touch because they don’t understand what it does, how it does it, or why it does it the way it does.

And I’ve always believed that if you don’t want to rebuild your app from scratch, then don’t worry, a competitor will do it for you.

So I agree with every point raised in this article. And I think it does a great job of articulating the issues that often go unspoken. But I’d like to add one more. And for me, this is the biggest issue for any company wanting to rebuild it’s product.

If your sales team has more clout than your designers and developers, then you’re fucked. And in the enterprise software world, this is the norm. An uncheked sales team that get’s whatever it wants has already killed your product and made it impossible to rebuild. Their demands are ad-hoc, nonsensical, and always urgent. So urgent that proper testing and documentation are not valid reasons to prevent a release. Their demands are driven by their sales targets, and the promises they make to clients are born out of ignorance of what what your product does, and how it does it.

This is not true of all companies. Many companies find a reasonable balance between the insatiable demands of a sales force and the weary cautiousness of their engineers. But if your company submits to every wish and whim of your sales team, and you attempt to rebuild your product, then you’re screwed.

tomelders··on Friendly web development tutorials for complete beginners
The best advice you can give to someone staring out from scratch is "Don't try to learn programming. It's boring, frustrating, and pointless. Instead, think of something you want to make, and learn how to make that. Start small though."
tomelders··on Show HN: Material Dashboard – Free Admin for Bootstrap 4, React, Angular, Vue.js
But there's not alternative to starting from first principles. Material UI and all other Ui libs are a premature optimisation that will paint you into a corner.
tomelders··on Show HN: Material Dashboard – Free Admin for Bootstrap 4, React, Angular, Vue.js
The alternative is to start with basic HTML UI. Almost no styling. And build from there.

Understandably, few people like that advice because it doesn't make life easier. It does make your product better though, which is really all that matters.

tomelders··on Show HN: Material Dashboard – Free Admin for Bootstrap 4, React, Angular, Vue.js
Design is hard and the value of it is difficult for most peolpe to quantify. So Material, and all other UI component libs, claim to offer an easy solution to a difficult, expensive, and seemlingly aestethic problem.

They don't. And when something like this has a connection to a company like Google, people simply don't question it.

tomelders··on Twitter ‘smytes’ customers
Site's that block users for not allowing cookies and tracking are essentially paywalled. Communities like HN should do their part to penalise sites that pull these kinds of tricks. If not us, then who?

So, anyone got a non-paywalled version of this?

tomelders··on Machine Learning: The High Interest Credit Card of Technical Debt (2014)
Piles of spaghetti code will give your customers what they want today, but rob them of the features they want tomorrow and make every future feature orders of magnitude more expensive to develop than they should be. That's the interest you pay on Tech Debt.

Much like regular debt, if you don't repay it, you go out of business and end up penniless.

tomelders··on Machine Learning: The High Interest Credit Card of Technical Debt (2014)
Two principles I live by (much to the annoyance of my bosses)

1. Don't fear the refactor. 2. If you don't want to rebuild your entire application from scratch, don't worry, a competitor will do it for you.

There's nothing wrong with creating something in increments. It's the fear of revisiting something that destroy's a code base.

tomelders··on Amazon shareholders demand it stop selling facial recognition to governments
Yeah but... that means the people who do take on this work will be the zealots who never doubt what they're doing. That's not to say that non-zealots should take on this work to keep the zealots out. I'm just saying that we're screwed so long as there are no laws prohibiting governments for doing this sort of stuff, because there will always be devs willing to use their powers for evil.
tomelders··on Caltech glassblower's retirement has scientists sighing (2016)
Agreed. GDPR is a good thing. I feel like the LA Times is just being difficult to make a point somehow.
tomelders··on The GDPR blog post
I had a recruiter call me up with what I suspect was a made up role. At the end of the call he casually dropped in the line "ok, well, is it ok if I get back in touch when something more suitable comes in?"

It was conspicuous. I asked is he'd asked me that because of GDPR. He said yes. I said no.

tomelders··on Adobe to Acquire Magento
Makes a lot of sense. Adobe has some warped ideas about what makes something good.
tomelders··on Mandaeism
Wait but what? Why is a religon being posted to HN?
tomelders··on GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU
I don’t agree. All laws are up for interpretation. That’s why we have the judiciary. Law makers draft laws, courts decide where those laws fit into the wider body of law.

The kind of law making you’re implicitly advocating is tantamount to despotism. Drafting a law that outlaws islam might well be clear in it’s wording, but it needs to be tested against the law that allows freedom of religion, freedom from persecution, and a ton of other laws no doubt. The claritiy of language with which a ban on islam is articulated is all for nought if it’s contradicted by, and incompatible with other laws.

Although, GDPR has been explained very clearly. And we’ve been given a loooong time to digest, understand, implement, and question it. I don’t think any reasoable person can make a compelling case against GDPR. But unreasonable people can, and as we’re seeing, they will.

tomelders··on GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU
I suspect it's going to be a bit like IR35 in the UK. Menacing on first glance, but so broad in it's definition that any court is going to struggle to draw the hard conclusions for anything that isn't what the law was explicitly created to prevent.
tomelders··on Airbnb's new typeface
Hmmm, then one has to wonder, how did AirBnb become so successful while so many others have failed? It's a mystery that will tease our imaginations until the end of time no doubt. If only there were some clue, some window into their company and culture that could help us explain this puzzle?

But yeah, seriously, how hard can it be to make AirBnb? It's just a couple of tables in a database, a HTML form and a jQuery image gallery.

tomelders··on What’s the waiter doing with the computer screen? (2012)
Too many applications are really just crappy database UIs.

Software is meant to do things for you, but so many software developers think software is there to stop users messing up their database.

tomelders··on Facebook announces Clear History feature
too little too late.
tomelders··on Universal Basic Income Is Not Feasible
Well the current reality isn’t feasible, but we’re doing it anyway.

No one really knows wether UBI will be a succes or a failure. But then no one knows wether any policy will be a success or a failure, and there will always be supporters and fetractors on either side.

Ultimately though, all that really matters is that government takes action that it believes will make society better. That’s it’s purpose. And if government believes UBI would be a net good, it should do it.

tomelders··on Ask HN: What do Facebook employees think about their company?
> Corporations like Facebook are there to make profit within the rules defined by society

They seem to be having their cake and eating it. You hear the term "disruption" all the time from tech companies, and you'll hear tech leaders wax lyrical about their vision for society and how their work/product/service is shaping that.

Recent events have outed these people for what they are. Self serving profiteers who only care about how society can help them, and have little regard for how they can best serve society.

While shady corporate megalomaniacs are a problem, they are by no means unique. What leaves such a bad taste in my mouth however, is the way tech billionaires are so eager to project the idea that they're benevolent agents of progressive change, when really they're not and they're not even trying. They've been dining out for free on goodwill for too long. Now it's time to start paying the bill.

tomelders··on Redesigning Redux
Middleware. A UI events logger for example. Or finishing a network request may need to close some part of tge Ui and also trigger a reload somewhere else.
tomelders··on Redesigning Redux
As far as libraries generally go, Redux is tiny.

https://github.com/reactjs/redux/tree/master/src

The largest and most important part is CreateStore, but at 250 lines long (mainly comments), it's shockingly simple when you take a look at it.

tomelders··on Redesigning Redux
The strength of redux is that all your interactions with it are through functions. Redux today is far better than the Redux of yesteryear thanks to things like ReSelect, Thunks, Sagas, Higher Order Components etc. All these things augment Redux, and they can do so because of Redux's open embrace of the humble pure function.

Once you commit to a config based approach, you're basically closing the door to a future you can't imagine yet. I'm so tired of this short-sighted obsession with configuration some developers seem to have.

I think the author has a myopic vision for where Redux should go.

tomelders··on Understanding Dijkstra's Algorithm
Ah, ah ha. Hah. My bad.
tomelders··on Show HN: A simple React table library using CSS Grid Layout
React components that take configuration rather than allowing you to compose smaller components are generally a bad idea.
tomelders··on Understanding Dijkstra's Algorithm
I can highly reccomend the book “mazes for programmers” which introduces a lot of graph related alorithms in a clear, accessible way.

Dijkstra’s algorithm is on page 36 and explained in 8 paragrpahs.

https://media.pragprog.com/titles/jbmaze/first.pdf

tomelders··on Developing SaaS? Forget Scrum, Check Out Kanban and Similar Approaches
I'd argue that Kanban doesn't prevent you from having regular points in which to communicate. It's just that the work itself isn't bound by those points.

Having worked both scrum and kanban, I feel kanban is better for both large and small teams, so long as the team puts some thought into which items each person takes out of the backlog.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →