HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tominous

1,196 karma · joined February 11, 2016

submissionscomments
tominous··on Children who see clearly underwater
I think your friend isn't as lucky as you think. The eye/brain should automatically make the focus as sharp as possible so all that you can do consciously is make it worse.

Then again, if your vision isn't perfect there are tricks like placing pressure on the eyeball or squinting which can change the focus, but are probably not too healthy in the long term.

Best advice is to see an optometrist instead. Although, I have found that they aim to correct vision for 6 metres in red-green light. If you're reasonably young and myopic, ask for a slightly stronger minus power to get better blue vision at infinity (at the risk of more eye strain close up). The extra -0.25 makes a huge difference for me, really allows depth perception to "click" properly.

tominous··on Fighting cancer by putting tumor cells on a diet
One symptom of cancer, especially late-stage cancer, is cachexia: unintended weight loss. It is associated with a higher risk of death and lower quality of life. [1]

In addition, cancer treatments like surgery, chemotherapy and radiation affect the sense of taste, appetite and metabolism and make it difficult to get normal nutrition in the first place.

So you can see why clinical oncologists and patients might be wary of restrictive diets or fasting. In fact many offical guidelines suggest adding sugar, frying foods, eating more dairy, etc to boost nutritional intake.

Psychologically, even if a patient is overweight they may fear a drop in weight as a sign that the cancer is progressing. (An ex-colleague was very obese and lost 60kg before/after being diagnosed with kidney cancer).

A patient may also want to enjoy their remaining time. Food has a huge intrinsic pleasure and is very important socially.

I'm not saying this is an unworthy line of research but they will need good evidence or specific, easy interventions to convince people to change their diet. For example, drugs like metformin or rMETase may be easier than explicit restrictions.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cachexia

tominous··on MentalHealthError: an exception occurred
Oh absolutely. That's why I've tried to make that decision ahead of time and plan the details so that it's almost an automatic trigger, hopefully before all insight is lost.

It's hard because I'm a very independent, stubborn person who never takes anyone else's word for anything. I can't think of much worse than being locked up, forced drugs and being told what to think, like 1984. But losing touch with reality and effectively abandoning my family and friends would be worse.

EDIT: I'm not saying that drugs are a panacea, BUT.. I believe mental illness often has a chemical/biological origin, which over time accumulates into physical, psychological and social damage. I think appropriate low-dose treatment at an early stage has the potential to limit this damage while avoiding the worst side-effects of higher doses.

tominous··on MentalHealthError: an exception occurred
This story struck a nerve because (in hindsight) I saw the same thing happening to my brother when he was about 19. He was suddenly interested in astrology, reiki, "tachyon energy disks", epiphanies, angels and demons, the vibrations of the universe.

At the time I thought it was a phase. My mother was always talking (tongue-in-cheek?) about her "parking angel" and burning incense, so I thought he had just picked up that part of her personality.

Turns out he had (and still has, many years later) schizophrenia so he was genuinely using his considerable intelligence to try and make sense of what he saw, heard and felt, drawing on any "truth" he could find.

It really put me off religion and spirituality for a very long time. If these concepts weren't out there and accepted by so many people, maybe he would have been diagnosed and treated sooner and be in a better place today. I don't know.

These days I do think some amount of religion/spirituality is positive, and I think in total it makes the world a better place, but if I ever felt that kind of epiphany personally I know I would head straight to the nearest mental hospital.

tominous··on PostgreSQL Indexes: First principles
That's true but not particularly relevant to database performance. As I mentioned, random reads on an SSD do not suffer from a head seek penalty so it doesn't matter how the blocks are allocated. On the other hand with spinning disk there is a huge difference in throughput for large sequential vs small random reads.
tominous··on PostgreSQL Indexes: First principles
It's also tricky with a COW filesystem like ZFS in which the order of data on-disk may not match the logical order of the file. So your database may decide to dispatch a bunch of sequential 1MB reads to the filesystem, only for the filesystem to translate those large sequential reads into many small random 8kB reads. It depends on how fragmented the file is, so you can start off with great performance which degrades significantly over time.

Luckily SSDs have a much lower penalty for random reads compared to spinning disks, so in future this will be less of an issue.

In the meantime all you can do is use a different filesystem, hide the problem with cache, or manually defragment your data files from time to time.

tominous··on Cancer 'vaccine' that remembers and fights disease is developed by scientists
One way to approach an announcement like this is to wait until everything is wrapped up nicely in a neat paper.

Another approach is to investigate further using the tools available: look up the authors' past work on Google Scholar, check clinicaltrials.gov, look for third party opinions, even ask the authors directly. I'd argue that the scientists and journalists at the AAAS conference where this was presented are capable of this second approach, and so are many participants on HN.

tominous··on Cancer 'vaccine' that remembers and fights disease is developed by scientists
Thanks, I certainly have my eyes peeled for news about metastatic ACUP (or any related diagnoses) but as far as I'm aware there's no silver bullet anywhere yet.

Right now the strategy is to kick the can down the road until there is a solution: traditional chemo, then the blunt immunotherapy of ipilimumab + nivolumab/pembrolizumab.

Also (with oncologist's knowledge) adding in very speculative but reasonably safe extras like a COX-2 inhibitor, anti-histamine, and melatonin. (Certainly not the well-targeted approach I talk about in my other comment, unfortunately!)

tominous··on Cancer 'vaccine' that remembers and fights disease is developed by scientists
From a sociology point of view, yes you should distrust any signs of p-hacking or selective reporting, especially when there is a low effect size.

From a technology point of view, I think we are already well past "no one.. really knowing what is going on." Take the current study. Past researchers had identified the CD19 antigen found (often exclusively) on B cells, and others had found that autologous T-cells could persist in a patient for many years, potentially providing a durable response. The current researchers built on this knowledge to design and engineer T-cells that could wipe out a patient's B cells.

So it's a very planned, targeted approach, more akin to engineering than the old approach of testing thousands of random molecules as potential treatments. When the targeted approach works, and especially when it has a large and consistent effect on patients as in this case, then you can be very confident at an early stage.

This needs to be recognized and medical practice needs to change as a result. We're entering an era of incredibly detailed knowledge and precision tools for research and development. The pace of development will continue to increase and treatments will become more patient-specific as individual targets are identified.

You could consider the large, slow, blunt clinical trials as being like optimization for a particular treatment. When new drugs are rare or not well understood it makes sense to spend time to optimize their use. But when new drugs come frequently and are well targeted this premature optimization costs lives.

tominous··on Cancer 'vaccine' that remembers and fights disease is developed by scientists
I'm biased. My wife was diagnosed with metastatic cancer 6 months ago. With current standard treatments there is a 3-year survival rate of practically zero, so to me the most important thing is getting new effective treatments developed and brought into clinical practice as soon as possible.

I haven't seen the presentation about the study (a related news briefing is here [1]) so I don't know whether you're correct to say that the researchers haven't shared their methods and data. They seem quite happy to share technical details at the news briefing.

However, regardless of that, I still think it is a good thing if researchers talk about their findings at an early stage, especially if the findings are as dramatic and positive as these. If a treatment is available and you have patients out there dying with no other options, then it is just wrong to hide that away.

In my opinion we treat these things far too cautiously. It is not optimal for the individual and it is not optimal for society. By sharing /and/ opening up options like this to terminally ill patients we can (a) save individual lives and (b) speed up development and refinement of new treatments to benefit everyone.

The problem is that the incentives we have in place treat a cancer death as acceptable, while a treatment-related death is unacceptable for researchers, doctors and drug companies (unless they are shielded by layers of clinical-trial bureaucracy or years of standard practice). The result is that the course of treatment doesn't properly weigh the different sources of risk. Whether the goal is quality-adjusted life years for an individual patient or faster development of effective and safe treatments, the current system is way too conservative.

[1] http://www.eurekalert.org/aaasnewsroom/2016/webcast/?b=38

tominous··on What Little Babies See That We No Longer Can
I came here to make the same comment. Overlaying the images with crossed eyes, you can easily see that snails A and C share the most similar pixels. The mistake is in Figure 1 of the original paper and has been copied to the article.
← PreviousPage 6 of 6