HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tommy_mcclung

632 karma · joined March 9, 2009

submissionscomments
tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
Many PaaS offerings do some version of this, but we're targeting companies who aren't using PaaS. Specifically companies that are in AWS natively (other could providers coming soon). The reason for this is they are the ones who tend to need to build this from scratch and the market for companies in the cloud is... well... huge. They tend to want PaaS features but have to build it themselves. That's where we are headed. There is also a market for those that need to move off of PaaS due to complexity or technical needs that those PaaS offerings don't support. We think this is a sweet spot.

As for Docker, we choose that because it's kind of table stakes now. We didn't initially start here, we were thinking more inline with what you were saying initially about Glue between VCS and Terraform. But as we started engaging with users, it was clear that Docker, and more specifically docker-compose was the starting point because what we lacked was a good definition of the services people wanted to run and we didn't want to invent something new for this. We do see a place for Terraform in the near future in our offering.

We also had the good fortune of running into Ben Firshman (founder of Fig/docker-compose) recently and he told us what we're building is what they had envisioned in the early days building Fig. We just brought Ben on as an advisor to help us think through that vision and to also help us with our open source strategy. Because, as you mentioned, we believe that open source is going to play a critical role in how we evolve this business.

tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
Don't be sorry! I think we can all agree, picking a company name these days is a massive challenge for lots of reasons, you've pointed out one we didn't index on. We like it because it's a good name for what we're doing. I guess we just have to take on the challenge of becoming relevant and making our product awesome so we become relevant.

Thank you for the kind words about what we're building.

tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
We do not manage the setup of cloud native services just yet, but it's on our very near term roadmap. Seed data is something we're currently working on building now with a few of our early customers. We will tackle that first, then the cloud native services.
tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
Yeah, we're running in the customers cloud account so charging based on compute was a really awkward conversation when we had those initial conversations. (Different if we're hosting it). Charging based on the number of environments feels right to us and our customers because that's when they derive value. The number of containers is just a proxy for the amount of complexity we are orchestrating for them. I'm 100% certain we don't have pricing figured out and I really appreciate the discussion.
tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
I like this idea a lot. Thank you for suggesting it.
tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
Kompose is a really great tool in converting docker-compose to K8's yaml. But from there you are on your own. We've worked with a few companies that started down this path, realized how difficult K8's was and gave up. We handle everything in the K8's world so customers can just focus on their apps and simple environment definitions.
tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
Love seeing companies in this space. Thanks for posting.
tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
Yes, we have support for ephemeral environments, permanent staging environments and production environments. Release is currently running on Release in all three of those states. We've decided to focus on staging because that's where our customers are having issues today. Our longer term plan includes a lot of things in all three categories.
tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
I think the main difference is support for complex applications (lots of services) and running in your own AWS account. We actually have a few customers who have been using Heroku Review Apps and their application has outgrown Heroku and they were bummed they were going to lose that functionality and were now faced with having to build that themselves. For companies that are just starting out or just have simple apps we think our Free and Professional plans are somewhat competitive (albeit it a little more work for now) with Heroku but we don't have the growing out of it issue.
tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
We found the issue. When you have "Delete cookies and site data when Firefox is closed" set we weren't handling things correctly. Fixed and pushed. As an aside, we couldn't reproduce this locally and used an ephemeral environment to figure it out. Let me know if it works for you now.
tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
We've had a good amount of requests for it and we're adding it soon. We've been following our early customers, most have been Github. If you signup for the beta we'll let you know as soon as we add it.
tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
These are really good observations and probably points to us needing to add some clarity.

I think the thing we could explain better is we take the docker-compose and use that as a starting point to define how an application will run in Kubernetes. We aren't just running Docker when environments deploy, we're running applications in K8's. We've debated long and hard about how much K8's we expose to customers. We tend to think it's complex and if we can abstract the complexity so our customers don't have to worry about it, that would be better. Interested to know what people think about how much K8's we should expose.

The reason we choose to create a new YAML file was we needed a way to define environments. docker-compose does have some stanzas for environments but they were meant for Swarm and the older versions of compose didn't map well to K8's. This file is automatically generated and attached to an application so you don't have to write it by hand, just update pieces that apply to environments. There is definitely duplication with docker-compose in this file, we may end up migrating towards just using docker-compose with the Swarm environments definitions but we haven't seen anyone using those yet.

We're working on a few solutions to seed data and database cloning. It's a really big request and will be added very soon. We do have a few ways to do it now, but they are more one-off solutions than products at the moment. Same goes for testing. We've purposefully not tried to be a CI/CD replacement at the moment. Most of our customers are already using Jenkins or Circle so we decided to integrate for now. We are going to add simple test running soon.

tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
Thank you for pointing this out, you are right, that doesn't seem right. Fixing now.
tommy_mcclung··on Launch HN: Release (YC W20) – Staging environments made easy
We originally started with the CPU+memory concept but as we explained it to customers it was confusing. They kept asking why we cared about CPU/memory. We're trying to proxy application complexity and our thinking was containers was an easy way to approximate that. Great feedback, we'll keep iterating and thinking about it.
tommy_mcclung··on The new VirginAmerica.com
Would have been great, except for it suffers from the same problem the existing VA site suffers from. Almost every time I use the VA site, "something goes wrong". I just tried to book tickets for next week, got all the way to the end to pay, hit submit and "something went wrong". They just put a pretty front end on a broken booking system that breaks almost every time I use the site. The only thing I care about is that it works and the VA site consistently fails, this upgrade doesn't fix the core problem I've always had with it.
tommy_mcclung··on Sam Altman for President
Congrats Sam!! Woo!
tommy_mcclung··on CarWoo is shutting down
I'm going to work on writing this up. Lots of reasons and it deserves a detailed post-mortem.
tommy_mcclung··on New Car Pricing Data From Offers On CarWoo
Sure does. Thanks for the feedback!
tommy_mcclung··on New Car Pricing Data From Offers On CarWoo
Also, if anyone is interested we have an API into this data set. AOL Autos uses it here http://autos.aol.com/best-deal
tommy_mcclung··on New Car Pricing Data From Offers On CarWoo
Great idea.
tommy_mcclung··on New Car Pricing Data From Offers On CarWoo
There isn't really.
tommy_mcclung··on New Car Pricing Data From Offers On CarWoo
What we're doing is looking at the actual MSRP offered by dealers on vehicles in inventory inclusive of options. On Edmunds, KBB or any other pricing site what you're looking at is what you theoretically would pay if the vehicle you wanted existed in inventory and doesn't really represent true pricing at the moment. Their pricing isn't really representative of what happens when you go to a dealership and say I want this car, with these options. Many/most times that exact configuration of vehicle doesn't exist. (With a few exceptions... Honda's and Toyotas are different). Our AVG MSRP is really a view of the price with options included in dealer inventory and not just the MSRP as configured by the manufacturer. What people have told us is that they want to know how much it's actually going to cost me when I go to the dealership to buy a Mazda 5 (enter your favorite car here) . Our pricing reflects that almost perfectly.
tommy_mcclung··on New Car Pricing Data From Offers On CarWoo
Good question, looks broken. We will fix it.
tommy_mcclung··on New Car Pricing Data From Offers On CarWoo
Founder/CEO here. This data is from hundreds of thousands of offers made by dealers on CarWoo! This is likely one of the purest sources of new car pricing anywhere. Would love to answer any questions.
tommy_mcclung··on Buying a car on the Internet
carwoo.com
tommy_mcclung··on Car Dealers Wince at a Site to End Sales Haggling
One other thing I'd like to point out is the laws surrounding dealership advertising and brokering are extremely important to protect the consumer, therefor the scrutiny in the article. We agree with the laws and they do need to be in place. Here is why.

Dealership advertising laws require a vin/stock number and an expiration date to come along with all price offers. This protects the consumer from bait and switch problems which are rampant in this space. Without these protections dealers and vendors can simply make up prices to draw people into the store and when they show, switch them to something else.

I understand in depth the challenges involved in doing this right from a product standpoint and it would be orders of magnitude easier to provide a product that doesn't include a vin/stock number (a topic for another post). But the problem is consumer perception is wrong and misleading. If someone comes to my product and car buyers can get prices on a vehicle that may or may not exist (no vin/stock number) you are enabling bait and switch scenarios. On CarWoo! you will not have this problem, all offers have a VIN/Stock number and an expiration date.

Brokering laws (getting paid a referral fee from the dealer when someone you sent to the dealership sells a car) are also in place to protect the consumer. I had one of our ex-dealers that work for us explain this to me, because at first I didn't understand why this was a consumer protection issue. He used this example. It may be a bit out of date, but it illustrates the point. Let's say you're in a town with three or four car dealerships and the preacher in the town establishes a relationship with one of the dealers where the dealer will pay the preacher $500 for every customer the preacher sends their way that buys a car. On Sunday this preacher uses his influence to recommend people should buy from his favorite car dealer. The people in the congregation listen and when they go to buy a car, they go to the preacher's favorite dealer. The preacher gets paid, the dealer marks up the car $500 to pay the dealer and the consumer essentially paid $500 more than they had to. The brokering laws are in place so disclosure about the financial relationship between the buyer, the dealer and the broker are transparent.

Essentially you can get a better deal as a buyer without a broker and you should know upfront that's the case.

Hope this helps, it's taken me four years to understand all this stuff.

tommy_mcclung··on Car Dealers Wince at a Site to End Sales Haggling
I'll partially agree with you on this. Car buyers do only buy cars once every few years, but the amount of information available to a car buyer is incredible. You can know exactly what a dealer paid for the vehicle you're about to buy if you try. Dealer's are in somewhat of a vacuum from a data standpoint. Most of them have no insight into the buyer's shopping experience... meaning how many dealers are they talking to, were they on KBB/Edmunds, are they cross-shopping, etc... They may be better at haggling, but it's somewhat by necessity at this point to hold what little margin they can.

Consumers are armed with information and tools, dealers have a lot of challenges fighting this. Lots of people probably don't realize that at CarWoo! this is one of the issues we're helping dealers with when they use our product to engage with buyers. Only when both sides of the selling equation have an equal chance will the bad buying (icky) experiences go away.

tommy_mcclung··on Car Dealers Wince at a Site to End Sales Haggling
Thought I'd give my $.02 on this. I'm CEO of CarWoo! and we are right in the middle of disrupting the space and you guys are right it is extremely difficult, but it is possible. It's not so much of a disruption as it is an effort to level the playing field and bring an online buying experience to car buying.

It is possible to innovate here, you just have to do it the right way, within the laws that have been setup to protect the consumer and the dealer. It doesn't have to be a race to the bottom. What we see on CarWoo! are dealers offering market competitive prices and then competing with each other on things outside of the vehicle price. Things like professionalism and responsiveness become extremely important when all other things are equal (price and vehicle). Over half the consumers on CarWoo! buy from a dealer who didn't have the lowest price. A race to the bottom only exists if the only dimension visible to the consumer is price. On CarWoo! we emphasize the customer experience you're likely to get from the dealer which adds another dimension to the decision. Dealers love this, so do buyers.

The big issues in question are the brokering laws (getting paid a fee to refer someone who buys a car), privacy issues and dealership advertising laws (all vehicle offers must come with a vin and stock number). From day one at CarWoo! we have been keenly aware of these issues and worked within the rules to provide a highly valuable consumer experience, while working within the laws. It is absolutely harder to do it this way, but it can be done.

We don't believe haggling will ever go away, even if manufacturers move to a "single price" system like Scion. There is a distinct advantage for one dealer to break the rules and provide a lower price, so they will and the single price systems break down. We see Scion dealers discounting all the time, by the way. The only way to break out of this if you're a dealer is to be better at customer service and cater to your buyer's specific requests. Automation can not solve that problem, so selling cars will always have a dimension of personal touch and relationship.

What needs to be in place is a platform where buyers can shop multiple dealers online and dealers can work out the details of their car purchase before they show up at the store. This let's great dealers shine and helps them keep their margins in a highly competitive market. This is what CarWoo! provides and we've done it within the complex and ambiguos web of rules in this space. Innovation is possible here, and yes it is extremely hard. Harder than I ever imagined. But that's why it's such a huge opportunity.

tommy_mcclung··on Vidyard (YC S11) Is A YouTube For Businesses
We're using them as well. We like the ability to queue up videos in the player. Has helped conversions. We also found out that the average attention span was just about 20 seconds on a 90 second vid, so we cut it down to 15 seconds. Cool stuff.
tommy_mcclung··on Less is more when it comes to homepage design part II
Would love to answer any questions people have about Optimizely or the process we use to iterate on our theories.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →