HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tomtheelder

2,019 karma · joined July 26, 2016

submissionscomments
tomtheelder··on Why do so few people major in computer science? (2017)
This doesn’t track with my experience in industry whatsoever. In fact, those sorts of “low ethics” programmers are arguably the biggest hiring risk, and large amounts of effort and dollars are put into avoiding hiring them.
tomtheelder··on Amateurs obsess over tools, pros over mastery
I can’t really speak to the other brands, but the Epiphones under $500 start to, in my experience, suffer from pretty meaningful playability issues- and I’d argue that’s even more important of a problem for a beginner.

I’d definitely not recommend going below $500 if possible. That’s price as new, btw. Used guitar is a great option.

tomtheelder··on Harvard Discriminates Against Middle-Class Kids
This is absolute nonsense. Young people are overwhelmingly pro affirmative action, and none of this has damaged Harvard’s rep at all.

For STEM students it was just never as good a choice as schools with more developed eng schools.

tomtheelder··on Harvard Discriminates Against Middle-Class Kids
Implication here is that poor kids should need willpower, personal initiative, and self-discipline as teenagers, but that rich kids shouldn’t.
tomtheelder··on Harvard Discriminates Against Middle-Class Kids
My prep classes in high school were worth about 200 pts. _Massive_ difference when applying to elite schools.
tomtheelder··on Amateurs obsess over tools, pros over mastery
I think you’re basically fine with anything $500+ these days tbh. I say this as someone who owns multiple $1000+ guitars. You might get incredibly marginal gains in playability, sound, etc, at that price, but realistically my $500-$1k guitars are all completely capable instruments.
tomtheelder··on Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical bracing protocol [pdf]
My assumption was that the original comment was about professional athletes. For them any delay to returning is generally considered disastrous, and reconstruction success rates for them are near 100%, their recovery timelines are extremely quick, and doing PT all day isn’t really that different from what they normally do. Recovered performance is also incredibly good these days in most cases.

This conservative approach could become the default for most everyone else, but for professional athletes 90% success is not going to fly.

If the original comment was about casual athletes then none of this applies.

tomtheelder··on Healing of acute ACL tear on MRI following non-surgical bracing protocol [pdf]
I’d think for athletes a 10% chance of failure would make it a total non starter.
tomtheelder··on Threads, an Instagram app
Just tried, no ads anywhere. I wonder why.
tomtheelder··on Ask HN: Are people in tech inside an AI echo chamber?
> the average person is using it to genuinely provide value

I absolutely do not believe this to be the case. For starters the average person probably isn’t even aware, but the vast majority of folks I’ve seen use it have found it super interesting for like a week then dropped it because it wasn’t actually more helpful/better than the previously available tools.

tomtheelder··on Svelte 4
I assume they mean external dependencies when they say that. I'm not sure what the point of the statement would be if it included internal ones.
tomtheelder··on Migrating Netflix to GraphQL safely
Ok, but that’s true whether or not you use GQL.
tomtheelder··on Migrating Netflix to GraphQL safely
Honestly there’s a few good ways to do that. Schema directives, regular old permission system at the resolver level, etc.

I’m not a big fan of GraphQL, but I it’s not particularly difficult to secure.

tomtheelder··on US Patent Office proposes rule to make it much harder to kill bad patents
They did leave something extremely important out here that helps to explain the good faith argument. From the source:

> Petitions challenging under-resourced patent owner patents where the patentee has or is attempting to bring products to market;

So I’d say the good faith argument is that it’s designed to protect larger orgs from bullying actual inventors/startups by attempting to threaten the legitimacy of their patents. The bit about bringing products to market is supposed to exclude trolls. More from the source:

> Such limited resources may impact the perceived fairness of post-grant reviews. For example, some stakeholders in response to the RFC expressed concern that under-resourced inventors are unable to afford the costs involved in defending patents in post-grant review. Some stakeholders advocating for small businesses and individual inventors urged the Office to take into account the financial resources of a patent owner, and to limit reviews of patents owned by under-resourced entities who lack funding to defend challenges to their patents but who have sought to bring their inventions to market either themselves or through a licensee.

So yeah basically the argument is that defending themselves in this proceeds is too onerous for small entities.

So I think that’s the good faith argument. I’m skeptical, though I will happily admit that I don’t know much about the uses and abuses of the patent system.

tomtheelder··on Ask HN: Is it time to resurrect a Usenet clone?
You can still say whatever you want online. You just can't guarantee an audience, but that was _never_ the case.
tomtheelder··on NYC Bailing Out Hotels Paying Premium Rates for Budget Rooms to House Migrants
Federal law:

Under 18 USC 1201, a person is guilty of kidnapping who "unlawfully seizes, confines, inveigles, decoys, kidnaps, abducts, or carries away and holds for ransom or reward or otherwise any person."

I think what went down would definitely qualify as inveigling.

tomtheelder··on MSI reveals first USB4 expansion card, delivering 100W through USB-C
I have a similar setup, and the use case is that it’s a single USB C swap for my entire workstation setup to go from my work laptop to my gaming PC. Just a convenience thing.
tomtheelder··on Lyft’s plan to take control of its maps and its future
In LA they seem to almost all use the Lyft navigation.
tomtheelder··on Dynamic Forms with LiveView Streams
The fallback to polling is generally a good solution. I think the sorts of problems that dev ran into are very much the exception, not the rule, given the kind of absurd environment they were working in. Also worth calling out that LiveView was _very_ new when that post was made.

The latency issue is a real one. Long polling can also help there, but realistically if a substantial portion of your user base is on poor connections you’re going to be much better off with a traditional server rendered web application than something like LiveView or a SPA.

I’m not sure what you mean about cross-platform. LiveView is for building web apps, so there’s only really one platform to speak of: the browser.

tomtheelder··on Rheinmetall pilot project for curb stone chargers for EVs
I live in a high EV density region and it’s already a complete non issue. We have a good number of providers around here, and they are all mostly extremely reliable. Most of the time when I go to charge it will be a bank of 6+ chargers. Occasionally one isn’t working, but that’s not much different from a gas pump being out of service. Worst case I can always drive down the street to another bank.

Like a lot of stuff with EVs, it’s just a question of demand reaching a certain level- which it will- before the services really hit their stride. It’s already happened in a good few places, and it will happen where you live in time.

tomtheelder··on Txti is shutting down
Liu Cixin certainly didn’t create the concept! It’s a long standing conjecture that he wrote a novel about and provided a new name for. Whoever “Yancy” is has done nothing wrong- certainly nothing more than Liu. They even attribute to Liu in the first sentence! No reason for outrage here.
tomtheelder··on Ask HN: Have any managers/team leads been asked to layoff staff b/c of AI?
I don’t think that’s right. He is pretty transparent about the layoffs being a cost cutting measure to try to increase profitability.
tomtheelder··on VanJS (Vanilla JavaScript): smallest reactive UI framework
You can just add a generic version tag function that takes a tag name as its first param to solve that issue. Lets you create your own generator functions with ease for tags that aren’t included by default. Don’t see any reason you can’t add a comment() function either.

If you use a template string like that then you lose a lot in terms of type checking/IDE tooling/etc unless you add a ton of complexity, which is antithetical to this library’s goals. I definitely think they went with the right option.

tomtheelder··on The brand new Thunderbird logo
Wow this is one of the best logo redesigns I’ve seen in a long time. Absolutely keeps the spirit and distinct identity of the old one, but looks a whole lot crisper and fresher. Huge props.
tomtheelder··on Simple exercise to eliminate gastroesophageal reflux (2022)
Do you drink coffee or some other caffeinated beverage? For me, caffeine is THE trigger for reflux. Secondary trigger is portion size. If I don't drink caffeine and I keep my meals relatively small I'm generally fine.
tomtheelder··on People who die by suicide want to stop suffering, not to stop living
I think your perspectives on things and your priorities can change as you get older in ways that are very difficult to imagine as a young person. I might once have agreed with this comment, but now I live a lot of that life and it’s fantastic and I’m happier than I’ve ever been.

Also parties that end at 9 are incredible. I fought this one hard for a _long_ time, but life is honestly just better when you go to bed earlier and wake up earlier. More daylight is a great thing.

tomtheelder··on The American Dream convinces people loneliness is normal
This felt like reading my own words. It has been and continues to be an enormous amount of effort to try to foster that sort of community, but truly nothing else I have invested into in my life- save my relationship with my partner- has been worth even a _fraction_ of what my community building efforts have been worth.
tomtheelder··on How to quit cars
Yeah I mean that’s totally fine. When I lived in Boston it was much more common to see people rent cars for that purpose, but either way it’s completely okay.

The infrastructure should support that sort of trip out of the city. It’s intra-city car use that’s a disaster, and our infrastructure should not support that.

tomtheelder··on Legend of Zelda game sells 10M copies in three days
Minecraft’s art direction is very cool and was, at the time, pretty unique. Arguably it was one of the most striking things about the game at the time, and definitely what got me interested back when it came out.
tomtheelder··on Pinball is booming in America
The dog bar thing is absolutely here to stay, and it's actually sort of crazy that it took this long. The one near us is more like a dog park that also happens to have a bar and a food truck and good wifi, but it's just such a big win as a dog owner. You get to hang out somewhere actually pleasant while your dog plays in a controlled space with folks watching and breaking up any major scuffles. For a reasonably well off- especially younger- dog owner it's kind of a no brainer.

I guess if dog ownership crashes that would be a problem, but I really don't see that happening any time soon.

← PreviousPage 5 of 19Next →