HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tomtheelder

2,019 karma · joined July 26, 2016

submissionscomments
tomtheelder··on Blizzard developers say return-to-office policy 'cost us some amazing people'
I mentioned my situation twice, because it was relevant to both comments. I worked at a tech company. We had an internal poll when decision making was made around this, and the breakdown was about 30% prefer full time in office, 40% wanted hybrid, and another 30% wanted full time remote. The high performers who left were mostly in sales and marketing, for what it's worth. Engineering suffered almost no attrition, but IMO (and I say this as an engineer) SWEs are much more fungible than sales people even if they are more expensive.

I think the discourse on forums like this one and Reddit, dominated by highly-online folks (especially engineers), has given folks a skewed perspective on the general population's preferences regarding office work. Most folks in my personal network do not work in tech. Among them the solid majority prefer a hybrid setup, with only a small portion preferring full-time remote or full-time in-office. But that leads to a very strong majority preferring that their organization have an active and vibrant office.

tomtheelder··on Blizzard developers say return-to-office policy 'cost us some amazing people'
> taking away benefits

It’s not that simple. For folks who prefer remote, remote is a benefit. For folks who prefer an in office work style, remote being an option is an “anti” benefit since it totally kills the value of in person work.

You’re going to lose top talent either way. The last org I worked at went remote and lost a bunch of high performers to places that were in office.

I ended up leaving for unrelated reasons. It seems like things ended up totally stabilizing and now they are in a happy state of remote culture, but it absolutely cost them along the way.

tomtheelder··on Blizzard developers say return-to-office policy 'cost us some amazing people'
The last org I worked at went remote during the pandemic, and lost a big chunk of top performers because of it. They went to companies with the sort of vibrant office that my org had prior to the pandemic.

It’s a lose-lose. And hybrid isn’t a solution at all; it’s a bad outcome for both sides.

Over time things are just going to settle into remote orgs and in person orgs, and all that’s happening now is that companies are deciding which side of the fence to come down on. Either choice hurts in the short term.

tomtheelder··on TP–7 Field Recorder
I got to fiddle around with one. I have probably average sized male fingers, and it really wasn't a problem at all. Tbh if there's one thing you can pretty reliably count on TE for it's spectacular minimalist design, but if there's a _second_ thing it's thoughtful ergonomics.
tomtheelder··on TP–7 Field Recorder
Their stuff is design art first and foremost. Usually they are also high quality, functional products as well, but someone would buy this if they think it’s beautiful, not for practical purposes.
tomtheelder··on The JavaScript ecosystem is delightfully weird
Is it a solo project? The time savings of typing is really a function of project size and number of collaborators. For a small, solo project it’s either neutral or a negative.
tomtheelder··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
There’s absolutely been value delivered, but at every turn it’s been vastly less than what was promised. I would be very surprised if generative AI doesn’t turn out to be the same: legitimately and seriously useful in certain use cases, but not as revolutionary as it’s being sold. I’m excited to see what comes of all this, but the hype is at an absolute fever pitch and I’m yet to see much past niche use cases and help along the periphery for more general tasks.

I mean even crypto has some actual, meaningful use cases, it’s just not replacing all currencies and fundamentally reshaping financial systems like a lot of folks thought it would.

tomtheelder··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
Crypto generated an insane amount of general public mindshare with zero marketing. I wouldn’t read too much into that as a signal. I do think the value prop is a lot more straightforward, but that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s not mostly hype.
tomtheelder··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
I think it’s extremely dangerous to predict the pattern of gains to continue.

Also I’m not actually convinced that there’s much value provided currently. I’ve yet to see a particularly compelling use case, and every time I go to try something that folks are hyping up (image generation, ChatGPT, copilot) I leave feeling like it’s all sizzle and no steak.

tomtheelder··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
Honestly I don’t think content generation is a limiting factor for a compelling meta verse. IMO the constraints are more to do with fidelity and the quality of the experience.

There are currently so many weaknesses and limitations with the medium of VR that it’s just not particularly appealing for folks to spend a lot of time using it, and I think that’s why you don’t have great content gen.

tomtheelder··on There's something off about LED bulbs
> As for the color reproduction issue... you do experience it, I imagine you haven't done color critical work under incandescent and then under LEDs?

High quality LEDs with a good CRI are vastly better for that sort of work. You don't want to be doing anything like that under 2700k incandescent light.

tomtheelder··on There's something off about LED bulbs
I put LEDs in about 10 years ago and have never replaced one. I used to have a big drawer full of incandescent ones because they would fail pretty regularly

I think there just might be more of a spectrum with LED bulbs, since they are more complicated than incandescent ones. The worst ones are much worse, but the best ones are far better.

tomtheelder··on There's something off about LED bulbs
US here. Light quality in my house went up noticeably when I switched to LEDs about a decade ago, probably due to having way more/better options for color temperature. Haven't had to replace a bulb since. I have zero clue what the author is talking about.
tomtheelder··on There's something off about LED bulbs
Yeah ~10 years of LED bulbs and I've never replaced one. I've moved multiple times and brought my bulbs with me. Used to have a drawer with a bunch of incandescent ones ready to go because it was a regular occurrence.
tomtheelder··on There's something off about LED bulbs
I had literally the exact opposite experience when swapping mine out. Both the incandescent and halogen replacements resulted in a _way_ better quality of lighting. And these were just like "first ones off the shelf" from the Home Depot or something- I'm not exactly sure it was maybe 10 years ago. But I vividly remember thinking how much better the lighting quality was, and I had far more options in terms of color temp, which was great.
tomtheelder··on There's something off about LED bulbs
Agree completely. I bought a bunch of LED bulbs maybe a decade ago to replace my incandescent ones. Lighting quality was immediately better, and I have never had to replace a single one. They have made multiple moves with me. Previously I was replacing bulbs maybe annually, or every 2 years.

I genuinely have no idea what people in this thread are talking about.

tomtheelder··on Amazon to lay off 9,000 more workers after earlier cuts
I actually agree totally. My experiences doing hiring and then subsequently working alongside folks for the past decade or so have led me to view FAANG experience on a resume as a moderate negative signal. It’s not at all that I don’t think the folks who work there aren’t smart or talented- they have just disproportionately been difficult in the interview process and had impossible salary demands while being not being stronger performers than their peers.
tomtheelder··on Black widows are losing to brown widows in the fight for attics and garages
It’s outright predation, which is a little different. The idea here is that the Brown Widows aren’t eating the Black Widows’ food sources, or otherwise infringing on their niche- they are just straight up eating them.

Like you wouldn’t describe us as “outcompeting” Bluefin Tuna, but we are doing our best to drive them to extinction by eating them.

tomtheelder··on Flux Keyboard
No worse than any other standard keyboard that the overwhelming majority of people use.
tomtheelder··on Flux Keyboard
I mean the layout is more or less a standard qwerty one. It's not any more condensed than any other keyboard, as far as I can tell. You can imagine why an ergonomic layout would make this particular product more difficult, as you'd either need multiple displays for a split board, or a much larger display to accommodate the larger keyboard surface of a more traditional ergonomic layout.

Also fwiw I don't think there's any real evidence to suggest that ergonomic keyboard layouts help with RSIs.

tomtheelder··on Zig as an alternative to writing unsafe Rust
My experience is that I see a LOT more complaints about these sorts of behaviors than I see the actual behavior. I think it's honestly just a meme that's gotten out of hand at this point. Speaking as someone who is not part of the Rust community and knows comparatively little about the language.
tomtheelder··on Maybe treating housing as an investment was a mistake
I couldn't possibly disagree more. _Nothing_ is less attractive than sprawl. Rural areas are beautiful. Dense cities are beautiful. The inbetweens are ugly.
tomtheelder··on Honestly, It's Probably the Phones
But isn't it possible that these things have different degrees of addictiveness and destructiveness?

Drugs would be the (almost too) obvious analogy. There are many that people develop addictions or dependencies on, but it's pretty clear that there are some that are far more addictive than others, and that not all of them have the same deleterious social and physical consequences.

Why wouldn't activities be the same here? It seems to me that social media might be "worse" than a lot of the others. It's perpetually available, painstakingly engineered to be as addictive as possible, and may (jury is very much out here, but there's some research to suggest this) have properties that make it damaging to the psyche above and beyond normal addiction.

Just like there seem to be drugs whose abuse potential is too high to rely on self-control and moderation, maybe there are activities for which the same is true.

tomtheelder··on Honestly, It's Probably the Phones
We are uniquely adaptable, but our ability to adapt does not necessarily imply that there are not ideal states. Not only that, there are clearly limits to our adaptability. We can be pushed to the point that we begin to break.

An awful lot of research exists to suggest that exposure to the outdoors has positive effects on mood and well being, and a veritable ocean to suggest that loneliness is toxic to both mental and physical health. It's not a simple appeal to nature- there is empirical data backing the claims that the original commenter made.

tomtheelder··on Honestly, It's Probably the Phones
I would propose a different hypothesis: that populations in urban areas might be more itinerant and much more likely to be removed from family structures.
tomtheelder··on Honestly, It's Probably the Phones
I think that one is pretty straightforward: homogeneity. I grew up in a much more rural area than I live in now, and you just don't get your perspectives and views challenged very much (unless you happen to be outside the norm, in which case your life can be extremely difficult).
tomtheelder··on You don't need a build step
I think what they are really saying is "What needs to happen to allow us to run server-side _style_, module-based JS run in the browser.

Basically the point being that the browser "version" of JS has a lot of limitations w.r.t dependency resolution and standard library usage, and that by either using a bundling tool or whatever is being proposed here you can avoid those. In that way you end up writing "server-side JS," basically NodeJS style JS, for the browser.

Major added benefit is that it allows you to use the same libraries/packages/whatever on both client and server. That's highly convenient.

tomtheelder··on To ease the housing crunch, more places end single-family zoning
I’m not convinced that’s true at all.
tomtheelder··on To ease the housing crunch, more places end single-family zoning
Mostly because it was boring and isolating. To be clear I didn’t dislike the yard! I disliked what living in an area of traditional SFHs (aka the suburbs) entailed.

My cousins growing up lived near the core of a small city and visiting them was like a breath of fresh air. So many fun activities nearby, things you could walk to, way more people to meet.

Where I grew up I was basically stuck on just my street unless I could convince my parents to drive me somewhere, and even when I had that there was nowhere interesting to go.

I guess when I was like <10 years old it didn’t really matter, but the older I got the worse it was. I’d never move back to a suburb personally, and I certainly wouldn’t raise kids there.

tomtheelder··on To ease the housing crunch, more places end single-family zoning
With all due respect that’s _your_ dream. I hated growing up in a house with a back yard and a driveway. I’m not sure I would have wanted to grow up in downtown Manhattan, but an apartment in a small city would have been infinitely better.
← PreviousPage 6 of 19Next →