HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tomtomtom777

736 karma · joined November 19, 2014

submissionscomments
tomtomtom777··on So Much Blood
Agreed.

There is a good theory on why CEO's are paid more than they're worth called tournament theory.

A person in an upper layer of a hierarchical organization is paid for the value they provide PLUS an amount that incentivized anybody below them to reach that layer. If everybody is paid just for the value they provide, they wouldn't have a reason to try and reach higher layers and they would minimize work. After all, we cannot assume the value a person provides goes up in higher layers.

This additional pay bubbles up in larger organizations to exorbitant levels for CEO's.

tomtomtom777··on Suckless.org: software that sucks less
Suckless has a beautiful coding philosophy and I wish all software was written with this in mind, but surely a window manager and X-menu aren't really the best showcases? These aren't the types of programs where complexity is the biggest enemy.

I'm not claiming I could write these tools as simple as these, but surely the importance of these paradigms arise when actual complicated software is needed?

tomtomtom777··on DOGE puts $1 spending limit on government employee credit cards
From a profit maximization maybe.

But the government employs people. And in most of the civilized world, employing people comes with responsibilities over those people. For starters, the responsibility of not firing or changing terms that effects them on whim just for the sake of efficiency.

tomtomtom777··on Complex dynamics require complex solutions
I don't no which country you are from but in the western world, if you compare countries by their tax rates, countries with high taxes [1] tend to score quite well on quality-of-life comparisons.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_by_ta...

tomtomtom777··on JavaScript Temporal is coming
> It even solves the serialization issue of the difference between a "fixed-offset" timestamp (e.g. 2025-01-01T00:00+02:00) and one in a specific timezone (e.g. Europe/Paris).

Could you elaborate on that? What is the issue?

tomtomtom777··on TikTok says it is restoring service for U.S. users
That is incorrect in this case. The "censoring" was done by the legislative branch, congress.

The "uncensoring" is done by the executive branch.

tomtomtom777··on The history and use of /etc./glob in early Unixes
And when buffer overflows were (attempted to be) avoided by guestimating a large enough buffer size.
tomtomtom777··on Adversarial policies beat superhuman Go AIs (2023)
No. He did not abandon "World Chess". He is still an active player.

He chooses not to participate in the FIDE World Championship primarily because he doesn't like the format. He prefers a tournament format instead of a long 1-on-1 match against the running champion.

tomtomtom777··on Every V4 UUID
It helps, but only temporary. I wouldn't be surprised if all 6 digit PINs will be leaked within a few decades.
tomtomtom777··on Charset="WTF-8"
This assumes every resident is born and registered in said country which is a silly assumption. Surely, any service only catered only to "naturally born citizen" is discriminatory and illegal?
tomtomtom777··on Byoyomi Explained (1997)
Apart from the reasons you mentioned, the advantage of byo-yomi or Fisher time over the "add time after move 40" as often used in Chess, is that it doesn't create an artificial barrier.

What's so special about move 40? If you analyze chess games, you'll probably find that moves 40-45 are on average more accurate than moves 35-39 even it feels this number shouldn't be part of the game.

tomtomtom777··on New Mersenne Prime discovered (probably)
Isn't the fact that a certain number is a Mersenne prime interesting in itself? Surely it's a great addition to our knowledge of numbers?
tomtomtom777··on Bitcoin puzzle #66 was solved: 6.6 BTC (~$400k) withdrawn
A wallet address (where money is sent to) is the public key hashed. This money can than be spent with a transaction containing both the signature and the public key.

This is one of the reasons it is advised never to reuse an address. After using it once, your private key may still be private but your public key is exposed, reducing security.

tomtomtom777··on Insult Passphrase Generator
Nice except that it is an absolute no go to generate these on the server.

Why not port to JS and generate it on the client? Should be trivial.

Yould should not encourage people to trust you.

tomtomtom777··on 28-ton, 1.2-megawatt tidal kite is now exporting power to the grid
It is also a completely different scale. A 11M wind turbine has a 200m (!) rotor diameter. This thing is 12m.
tomtomtom777··on --libcurl
One could argue it's a half-baked quine.
tomtomtom777··on Metric Time
Exactly. The exact amount of sleep needed on average is almost certainly an irrational number. (Because almost every number is irrational)
tomtomtom777··on See this page fetch itself, byte by byte, over TLS
I don't think much is wasted on encryption. Most is wasted on backwards compatibility in the form of negotiating protocols, algorithm, extenstions, etc.

If there would forever be only one encryption algorithm in use we we wouldn't need most of the stuff.

tomtomtom777··on Shell admits 1.5C climate goal means immediate end to fossil fuel growth
Because methods to reduce our wasteful consumption, reliance on continuous growth and on the evidently harmful burning of fossil fuel aren't "hard sacrifices".

They are progress. Necessary progress.

tomtomtom777··on GPT4 simulating a FTP server at ftp.disney.com
It is only the unimaginative who ever invents. The true artist is known by the use he makes of what he annexes.

- Oscar Wilde

tomtomtom777··on Wavelength
> this means that when new members are invited to a group, the existing members can automatically re-encrypt and securely send the recent message history — which is important for threaded chat, so that conversations aren’t broken.

This may be important for "threaded chat" but it's also a privacy killer. Everything you write might than be read by someone who later joins and wasn't the intended audience.

tomtomtom777··on Gptcommit: Never write a commit message again (with the help of GPT-3)
For me the point of this demo is that even a good commit message is often redundant information.

As programmers we learn that adding a comment like:

   // The limit is 16
to

    const SOME_LIMIT = 16
is bad because is redundant information that serves no purpose to the reader and can easily misalign in the future.

So what's a good commit message for changing this limit? Ideally we want to describe why we've changed it but this information isn't always available so even when we're avoiding redundant comments we often use redundant commit messages like "increased SOME_LIMIT" to make browsing through history easier for others.

As we do not need to provide this information (it is already in the code), it seems like a reasonable idea for an AI to help us provide it.

tomtomtom777··on The topologist’s world map (2020)
It seems correct to me.

The map shows the country "United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland" (UK) without separating its constituent countries. This is what most political world maps do.

Ireland does border by land to the UK, at the border of Northern Ireland. This is shown with the black line.

Also it borders to the UK and all of the world's ocean bordering countries which is shown through the surrounding blue.

tomtomtom777··on Show HN: uFuzzy.js – A tiny, efficient fuzzy search that doesn't suck
It is explained, but than why is it fuzzy? Isn't the fuzziness part exactly what's missing?
tomtomtom777··on Show HN: Get conversational practice in over 20 languages by talking to an AI
Such a tree mostly describes word similarity. But translating words is not what an AI (or more generally a computer) has problems with.

It's word ordering and idioms where AIs stand or fall. Things that show very little correlation in the evolution of language.

tomtomtom777··on Vim 9.0
Although I am currently tip-toeing on NeoVim, I still feel this is a horrible break-up.

Yes, Open Source simply allows you to branch whenever you're unhappy with the original but this comes at a cost for the community. The cost of having two diverging programs to deal with.

In this case, the motivation was simply insufficient. Some people wanted vimscript+lua instead of vimscript. They felt the code was too difficult. They wanted to develop on their own.

Not bad reasons in itself, but does it weigh against the tremendous cost for the community of the split? Isn't a split only justified in situation like OpenOffice/LibreOffice when there is no other choice? Couldn't they not convince Bram Moolenaar of proposed changes, and if not, doesn't this have a good reason.

I hate NeoVim for the reason they've split, even though I understand it might become even better than Vim in the long run. You need better reasons to fork and divide an ecosystem.

tomtomtom777··on DuckDuckGo Is Down
Same here. And when I got suspicious I stupidly searched for "is DuckDuckGo down".

No results.

tomtomtom777··on Things you don't need JavaScript for
So you would like a website to implement a checkbox to toggle dark mode, in case it doesn't implement dark mode correctly?

That doesn't make any sense.

tomtomtom777··on The harmful consequences of the robustness principle
It didn't survive because HTML5 came along with very well defined and strict parsing rules.

You don't need closing tags for a specification to be strict. As long as you define the parsing rules rigorously as HTML5 does, there is little benefit in XML compliance and there is in a well defined non-XML standard as it is mostly backwards compatible.

tomtomtom777··on The harmful consequences of the robustness principle
> That's... not an especially worthwhile goal for a competitor.

But it is. Because otherwise we're just embracing monopolies. We can't switch to X because it doesn't accept our input as well as the "main" implementation does.

You can only beat BIND, or Postfix or Excel if you at least understand what they understand.

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →