HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tonyjwang

37 karma · joined July 29, 2011

tonyjwang@gmail.com
submissionscomments
tonyjwang··on Ask PG: Can you start a HN crowd-funding venture?
PG, would you still feel the same if there were limited disclosure/access requirements to crowd investors, so that the disclosure/reporting obligations were no different than if you were dealing with a limited number of accredited and/or sophisticated investors?
tonyjwang··on Ask HN: Is there a "Business for Hackers" book?
Venture Hacks. www.venturehacks.com
tonyjwang··on Ask HN: how do you deal with legal stuff when you are bootstraping?
I don't think tsegart is quite right on this one. Anytime you "express" words on a page, those words are copyrighted. Expressions are distinguished from more functional/factual considerations like labels, page numbers, math equations, etc.. So, my guess is that terms of service would likely be considered a copyrightable expression, just like software code, novels, and company manuals, because they are a manifestation of a lawyer's expression.

Assuming you copied Google or Facebook's terms of service without their permission, you would be in technical violation of their copyright. What they would sue for is less clear - unlike copying music, a textbook, or someone else's code, you're not really harming Google or Facebook's revenue through your copying like you would if you copied a competitor's design. In the extremely rare .00001% chance that Google's legal team decided to sue you, you're probably looking at a court-ordered takedown notice.

However, this discussion is largely academic. No one is probably going to sue you when you're bootstrapping and you can hire a real lawyer to change your ToS later. There's a good discussion of this on metafilter:

http://ask.metafilter.com/74055/Can-one-copyright-a-legal-ag...

Disclaimer: This is not legal advice, just my personal opinion. If you want to rely on someone's advice, hire a lawyer.

tonyjwang··on Ask HN: how do you deal with legal stuff when you are bootstraping?
For terms of use, another post mentioned modifying Wordpress's terms, which are under a Creative Commons license. For privacy policies, this area could be a little bit trickier if you have an open beta - if any of your users get pissed off that you did something with their data, and your privacy policy isn't up to snuff, you might be in for a world of hurt. With a closed beta or if you're not dealing with extremely sensitive information, I wouldn't worry as much.

Like I said before, a good startup lawyer in your local area is worth their weight in gold. For the basics, you can probably find a dozen lawyers who have worked in big firms who are working for themselves now advising startups like you, without having to spend what little cash you have. Some coworking spaces have lawyers too - and they're usually happy to help and often have structured office hours.

tonyjwang··on Ask HN: how do you deal with legal stuff when you are bootstraping?
To protect your company's domain, you can file a dispute with ICANN. I don't think it's necessary to register your trademark first, but having a registered trademark does help in the dispute proceedings. If you do need to register, hire a lawyer to do this.

If it were me, depending on the circumstances, I would probably wait to register a federal trademark until a Series A round, since you have other things to worry about before then.

Disclaimer: This is not a legal opinion, just a personal one.

tonyjwang··on Ask HN: how do you deal with legal stuff when you are bootstraping?
Again, not legal advice, but you can look at how ICANN resolves domain name disputes:

http://www.wipo.int/about-ip/en/studies/publications/domain_...

What factors guide the panelists' decisions?

-Whether the domain name is identical or confusingly similar to a trademark or service mark in which the complainant has rights. -Whether the respondent has any rights or legitimate interests in the domain name (for example, the legitimate offering of goods and services under the same name). -Whether the domain name was registered and is being used in bad faith.

So don't try to use a famous trademark to boost recognition or traffic to your site and don't try and squat on other people's domains. If you prefer to be cautious, you can search whether or not the domain name you have (and anything similar) is already a registered trademark.

tonyjwang··on Ask HN: how do you deal with legal stuff when you are bootstraping?
Unless you have a legal issue unique to your startup, you can always get general legal advice from mentors and advisors and the HN community - someone just asked about terms of service, for example. You're probably too small for anyone to care to sue you.

But if you're raising money, having contracts signed, you really should work with a lawyer. Asking other startups in your area who they used is a good first step - you want to find a lawyer who specializes in working with early-stage companies, who can avoid some of the legal traps, many of which deal with tax issues associated with stock options and entity conversion. My personal opinion is that there's no good substitute for a good lawyer - using forms from LegalZoom just seems like a really bad idea.

I would also suggest getting a lawyer if your startup business model depends on a fine-tuned understanding of the law. For example, just the other day, a startup that was copying the structure and pagination of textbooks was sued by Pearson and other major textbook publishers. They're venture-backed, which probably means they consulted lawyers and understood the legal risks beforehand. Before spending tons of resources, I think you might want to know whether or not what you're doing is illegal, and whether you are prepared to deal with the legal risks.

Disclaimer: These statements are merely my personal opinions and do not constitute legal advice.

tonyjwang··on I have no idea what I'm doing
I assume, perhaps wrongly, that there are more efficient methods of becoming an entrepreneur than pure trial-and-error and plugging oneself into HackerNews, Quora, and irc channels, and reading books. People always ask, where do I begin? What's the most efficient way of doing X?

I'd love to see a mind map, or even a basic checklist, of all the skills you need in a typical startup and the different options for gaining that skill. Maybe I'm being too picky and demanding, but knowing what you know and what you don't know would be a nice efficient alternative to "I don't know what the heck I'm doing. Grit FTW!"

tonyjwang··on Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Under Approved Conn. Bill
Even if you have a legal right to do something (e.g. taking a picture or standing on a street corner), you don't necessarily have a right to sue the police officer for a wrongful arrest. Police officers and other government employees enjoy considerable immunity from their acts in the course of their job, unless they act with a particular type of intent; the level of intent (purpose, knowledge, or recklessness), I believe, depends on the state jurisdiction.

For Constitutional issues, I imagine it depends on whether you're suing the individual personally or the state agency, and lots of other things.

tonyjwang··on Ask HN: Do employers care whether my Computer Science degree is a B.A. or B.S?
I have a friend who got her BA in CS at Yale. She's now in law school and unable to apply for the patent bar because of it, which isn't a big deal since she'll be a patent litigator, but it is an odd wrinkle in the system.
tonyjwang··on Instagram
Elon Musk first made his money in Paypal and then funded SpaceX. I think Krieger and Systrom will have exciting world-changing projects in the pipeline too.

Oddly, I think the most influential path to curing cancer is making a lot of money, gaining lots of power, and having more control to allocate societal resources.

tonyjwang··on Ask HN: Bootstrap Alternatives?
That makes sense, thanks.
tonyjwang··on Ask HN: Bootstrap Alternatives?
Should I post this question as its own thread? I'm new to the HN community and haven't figured out all the norms around posting yet. Thanks.
tonyjwang··on Ask HN: Bootstrap Alternatives?
If I'm a non-technical person with minimal coding skills (C++, editing HTML/CSS, rudimentary knowledge of Ruby), should I invest time and effort to learn Bootstrap/Foundation? My goal is to develop a functional MVP that I can take to potential customers; I've validated the need for my product through individual sales but feel like I need to test a semi-functioning site to see if my idea can scale.

Would appreciate suggestions, alternatives.

tonyjwang··on Ask HN: How should we test if our idea is feasible and worth pursuing?
What kind of data would you need to validate/invalidate your idea?
tonyjwang··on Oracle v. Google judge to decide whether APIs are Copyrightable, not the jury
If settlement occurs before a judgment is passed down, then the court case doesn't bind future decisions.
tonyjwang··on Ask HN: What happens if I quit?
Just because you haven't signed a contract doesn't mean you are necessarily exempt from liability. It would depend on your state's law, whether there was an implied understanding that you would work until the project was completed, and various other factors.

Like read_wharf said, ask a lawyer about your rights and responsibilities. A good lawyer will also counsel you on what your best options are for resolving the situation.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2