HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

toomim

3,057 karma · joined May 5, 2012

Independent Scientist in Computer Science and Psychology

https://invisible.college/@toomim

https://braid.org

submissionscomments
toomim··on You might not need a CRDT
See https://raw.githubusercontent.com/braid-org/braid-spec/maste...

And for a more intuitive explanation, this might help: https://braid.org/demo/interact#a-merge-type-defines-how-to-...

toomim··on You might not need a CRDT
What happens if User B moves his cursor to position 0 at the same time that User A types at position 0?

Depending on the order that those events arrive, and how ordering is disambiguated, it's possible that different peers could see User B's cursor at different positions.

I believe that the system you're describing is akin to an OT system, but where the "operations" to transform are the "cursor move" actions that occur simultaneously with insertions and deletions. Most OT systems, on the other hand, are trying to transform inserts and deletes against one another.

Edit: Yes, in fact this is equivalent to OT if you replace every OT insert or delete with a tuple [move cursor, ins/del] in your system.

toomim··on You might not need a CRDT
This is close: https://decentpatterns.com/library/

...but my general belief is that UI patterns need to evolve as (1) specific UIs before they become (2) general patterns, and we simply don't have enough good solutions yet to make a pattern library out of them.

toomim··on You might not need a CRDT
Yes! We call this the "Merge Type" of data in the braid.org group.

Each datum as both a data type and a merge type. The programmer just needs to specify these two types, and then the programming runtime can choose which synchronization algorithm to use.

toomim··on Garage: An open-source distributed object storage service
Thanks! Where are you hosting the machines? Are they on a vps somewhere, or do you own the hardware?
toomim··on FTX’s collapse was a crime, not an accident
A publication that contradicts itself should be taken with a grain of salt.
toomim··on WebTorrent
Yes, and as feross says in a comment on this page: "WebTorrent is fully supported in nearly all the most popular torrent clients, including uTorrent."
toomim··on WikiLeaks is struggling to stay online as millions of documents disappear
But the same thing happens in sports.

In basketball, Dell Curry led to Seth Curry and Steph Curry, and the latter just broke the 3-point record. That's merit.

toomim··on What makes Git so hard to use?
Gitless is great, and to be fair is already mentioned in the article.
toomim··on Crsql – Multi-writer and CRDT support for SQLite
You can handle bank deposits with a counter CRDT.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conflict-free_replicated_data_...

toomim··on [dead]
By that logic the cold war wasn't a war.
toomim··on Make your DOM look like an eye that can focus on anything
Note that the pupil is almost always at the very edge of the eyeball. It's actually more realistic-looking to simulate the cursor being some number of inches above the screen, so that it more smoothly transitions from center to edge.

Here's an example: https://peeryview.org/about

toomim··on The currency of the new economy won't be money, but attention (1997)
In 2010, I was a PhD student inspired by Herb Simon, Goldhaber, and others, and decided to focus my dissertation on this topic: https://invisible.college/attention/dissertation.html

This was the first approach to measure the Economics of Attention, quantitatively. To do so, we define a new type of utility function, that can be measured with a new type of experiment that you can run via large-scale A/B tests, and lets you say things like "The new UI for Facebook is 6¢ per second worse than the old one!"

toomim··on A follow-up on our analysis of the anomalous restriction map of SARS-CoV-2
Can you please clarify your sentence?
toomim··on A follow-up on our analysis of the anomalous restriction map of SARS-CoV-2
> If you look at the paper objectively ... He may have the credentials but his social media activities

So did you read the paper and come up with a substantive scientific critique, or did you judge him on his social media activities and social opinions?

toomim··on The Internet needs the InterPlanetary File System
Those features are not what defines content addressing. Content addressing is defined as an address for a document that is a function of its content.

If your address is a function of a public key, then you're using "agent key addressing."

toomim··on Show HN: Minimal, no-JS web forum software
Oh my god, this looks so sane.
toomim··on The Internet needs the InterPlanetary File System
Because it's no-longer content addressing: if you are addressing your content by a name, to allow it to mutate, then you aren't addressing it by its content. You're addressing it by a name.

And not to beat a dead horse, but IPNS doesn't work very well. These days people tend to build their own naming systems using layers of IPLD hashes instead.

toomim··on The Internet needs the InterPlanetary File System
Then it's no longer content-addressing. It's now "public key plus a signed pointer referencing a name-that-has-yet-to-be-specified" addressing.

I think that's a fine road to go down for addressing data, but it's not content addressing.

toomim··on The Internet needs the InterPlanetary File System
And works great until your content changes, and then the address changes, and you end up wanting to have a way to name and address your content across the changes, and then you aren't using content addressing anymore.
toomim··on Mandated diversity statement drives Jonathan Haidt to quit academic society
That particular article's censorial bias is described in detail here: https://quillette.com/2022/07/18/cognitive-distortions/
toomim··on Mandated diversity statement drives Jonathan Haidt to quit academic society
That is the #9 most controversial article in wikipedia, historically: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/the-ten-most-contr...

It is heavily censored with wikipedia's left-leaning bias. Go read the talk page to see it in action.

toomim··on Ziti: Programmable network overlay and edge components for zero-trust networking
The similarity with tor is that you can connect to any other computer via its public key, which corresponds to a .onion address.

If your computer's public key is xx73u2, then I can access it at https://xx73u2.onion/and/whatever/path/i/want, and tor handles all the encryption. From this perspective, anonymity comes as a bonus.

toomim··on Ziti: Programmable network overlay and edge components for zero-trust networking
Is this an alternative to:

- ngrok

- ssh tunnel

- tor

- libp2p

?

toomim··on Ziti: Programmable network overlay and edge components for zero-trust networking
What does "zero-trust" mean?

I'd presume I want a network I can trust.

toomim··on Katara: Synthesizing CRDTs with Verified Lifting
I think so. Some of us in the braid.org group have been discussing how to add OS syscalls to do so.
toomim··on Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access' to voting equipment
When you don't understand them, that's how you know you're in a bubble. Try getting out and talking to them.
toomim··on The Steve Jobs Archive
That doesn't make it "insincere." It just means that the creators of this archive have different priorities than you.

I doubt that the people who hate Steve Jobs are willing to make something called "The Steve Jobs Archive", anyway.

toomim··on Show HN: Chitchatter – P2P chat app that is serverless, decentralized, ephemeral
Buuuuurn!
toomim··on Why use Paxos instead of Raft?
For some reason, people considering PAXOS/RAFT don't tend to consider CRDT/OT synchronization. I think this is a big oversight.

We should start considering CRDT/OT/VCS/Diffsync approaches to distributed systems as well. They present a very nice alternative approach: whereas PAXOS/RAFT implement a consistent "distributed state machine", a CRDT, OT, VCS, or Diffsync system implements consistent "distributed state", upon which one can build a machine as a function of the state.

This latter approach is actually simpler, IMO, because it encapsulates all the challenge of distributed consistency within a smaller subset of the problem — state synchronization. This makes it more generally re-usable. When you create a system, you can just use an off-the-shelf library & algorithm to synchronize your data over a network, and then write synchronous functions on top of that to represent the system you want, however you want, without having to understand PAXOS/RAFT.

← PreviousPage 12 of 34Next →