3,057 karma · joined May 5, 2012
https://invisible.college/@toomim
https://braid.org
A reserve is something held by a political state. Bitcoin is exciting becauee it exists beyond politics and nation-states.
If this is news for you, go read the original bitcoin paper. Its title is "Bitcoin: a peer-to-peer electronic cash."
The solution is to make peer-review better, rather than remove it entirely. Imagine that you can choose a set of people who you trust on any particular topic, and rank them with how much you trust them. Then you, and those people, can all rank any paper (or in general any URL) you read, and each of you will have a feed of incoming papers (or URLs) on any topic computed by a function that you control, in your personal reader app, which crawls your network of trusted people, and the people they trust, and so on, and aggregates all rankings and reviews. After about 7 degrees of hops across that network, you'll cover most of the world.
The key new idea here is that peer review will no longer try to be a single, objective, determination of truth. Each person can have their own slightly different feed, computed by slightly different criteria, using slightly different sets of trust metrics of people over the community, all competing for other people's trust, by writing good reviews, and good papers, in order to gain reputation and influence within the distributed network.
This won't be a single app. Rather, it'll be a distributed use of the WWW. Anyone can host their ratings at any web URL, on any website, and subscribe to the ratings from anyone else, at any other URL, at any other website. We can make this all realtime using the web extensions defined by https://braid.org, so that you can have a continuously-updating feed.
In effect, we'll be building a distributed, subjective hacker news (or equivalently, a distributed subjective reddit). We don't need to fight over objectivity anymore. Instead, we'll all be entitled to our own view of the web, and be able to share our views with others. And we'll find that we are best off ourselves when we import the best views from the best people we know, and that way we will see the world through each other's eyes, and even be able to — with the flip of a dial — see the world through our enemies' eyes.
Please reach out if you are interested in building anything similar! I am toomim@gmail.com, and am coordinating a group to make this happen.
Did you realize that we're in a pandemic that's killing millions of people? We need to get R0 down in any way that we can. Masks aren't perfect. Vaccines aren't perfect. We need to use everything we've got.
Total cost: $20.
Consider that during the pandemic, the good N95 masks were not even available for any price, so people were wearing flimsy cotton things that only block 20% of particulates. Opening a window with a fan works far better if you do it right and uses materials we still had in supply.
I went further into the article, and found that every ... single ... example ... was about the political right.
> Seriously, what else were they supposed to do here?
Give examples of misinformation on the left.
If anyone's interested in putting this domain to better use, please reach out!
(1) If you lose trust in someone, you'll be less likely to try to find truth in their statements. Finding truth in someone's statements requires time and attention, and we'll invest that attention in people we trust.
(2) If you find falsehoods in their statements, you will lose trust in them.
Overall in Psychology, trust is a primary indicator of a relationship, marriage, partnership, or organization succeeding or falling apart. It's both a symptom and a cause of all other factors.
The idea that the earth travels around the sun was once a "fringe idea."
> he is so clearly using his tenure as a defense against the ... untestability, of his ideas.
The idea of the earth going around the sun was untestable until Tycho Brahe got enough data and Kepler put it together in a way that could more parsimoniously and accurate predict planetary motion.
In other words, the experience that you describe perfectly fits into his argument. You might want to read Kuhn's "The Structure of Scientific Revolutions" to get the full picture.
This animated gif makes it clear: https://invisible.college/reputation/declining-trust.gif
> The big advances all seem to come from big corporate labs
That's an interesting claim, and I'd encourage you to find some statistics to verify this hypothesis, because in my experience, that doesn't ring true.
From my subjective perspective, it seems that academic and industrial research labs innovate at roughly the same rate per-capita. I was a PhD student when Microsoft was dominant, hiring the best faculty from all top-4 CS schools (CMU, Berkeley, MIT, Stanford), and they certainly produced a lot of papers, and did seem to dominate conferences, but the actual innovation in computing came from Apple and startups, which did not have "research labs". Microsoft, including its giant industrial research lab, certainly was not the driver of innovation in computing!
And here are some numbers to back that up: Microsoft's R&D budget in 2011 was 10x the budget of the entire NSF -- for all sciences. Yet, Microsoft was clearly not producing more than 10x the scientific output of all NSF-funded academic science.
So it would help to have some statistics for the claim that industrial research innovates more than academic research. They certainly pay more, and often hire more people, but per-capita they don't seem any more productive or healthier than academics.
My envisioned solution is similar to yours, here. But rather than "privatize science", which I think most people will interpret as "move to industrial research", my rallying cry is a little more like "hey scientists, stop depending on public funding, let's find creative ways to get the science done."
I also like to point out that money is often not the missing factor as much as community. This has always been true. Mendel discovered genetics by experimenting on beanstalks in his garden at his monastery. It cost him very little to do it, and he only stopped the research when his community told him to stop wasting time on beans and get back to the important accounting work that impacted the church's politics at the time.
You might think that maybe science was cheap in the past, but that today you need lots of money, to get the lab equipment, etc. However, science always has a cutting edge of cheaply evaluable questions. We recently hosted a DIY Synthetic Biologist (currently on the homepage of https://invisible.college) who showed the actual costs of his work, and his laboratory equipment was far, far, cheaper than the "cost" of his time. We can get far more science done with "amateur scientists" (remember that "ama" means love, and an amateur scientist is one doing science for love) by creating a scientific community outside the institutions for interested parties to work together, pool their brainpower and resources, and come up with great novel work.
And if anyone else agrees with me on this, please let me know so we can forces. I'm toomim@gmail.com, and am doing work on invisible.college.
To say that is to ignore all the progress we've made!
In the current system, the elites can literally print free money. But in PoS, all they can do is try to double-spend or censor transactions.
This is far less power for the elites to possess.
Furthermore, there's now a clear path to getting into position as an "elite" — you just need money. You don't need political connections. You don't need to be born into the right family. It doesn't matter what color your skin is. It doesn't matter what nation you are a citizen of. It's now just about money. And what you can do with that money is very boring, and gives you a very small reward.
1) Inflation rate
2) PoW function
3) Transaction cost after blocksize limit reached
The inflation rate determines the incentive given to miners. With less incentive, the energy use will go down. This comes at the cost of increasing the ease of a double-spend, but there is already far more than enough difficulty to double-spend at the current mining rates.
The PoW function determines the capital cost required to buy the miners themselves. If you increase the capital costs (e.g. with a memory-hard PoW function, or requiring less-efficient GPUs instead of more-efficient ASICs) then miners will be able to spend less of their costs on energy. This is one way in which Eth does well by the above metric, and is a valid way to reduce energy usage in PoW.
Of course, transitioning to proof-of-stake (as eth is doing) will eliminate the energy problem entirely.
Finally, some blockchains (e.g. BTC, ETH) have reached their capacity of transactions per second, and then users can add a fee to each transaction to incentivize mining pools to include them in a block. These fees do add incentive for miners to dump energy into their blocks. However, they are a much smaller portion of the incentive than you would expect.
The main point that you should understand is that a PoW blockchain's energy usage is not proportional to its transactions.
I'll say that a different way: the transactions themselves do not use any energy in mining.
I'll say this in a third way: it takes exactly the same amount of energy to mine an empty block as it does a 1GB block of transactions, as it does a 1,000,000,000 PB block.
In reality, transactions are all hashed together in a mining pool into a single numeric hash before miners ever see them. It doesn't matter how many transactions are included in the hash. The hashpower just has to find a magic number matching that hash.
On the other hand, the #1 factor that increases a blockchain's energy usage is its price per coin. The price of a coin is how much that coin is worth to be mined, which is the incentive for miners to dump energy into mining it. In steady state, miners will dump energy into mining a coin until the cost of energy = the value of the coins coming out.
This is why you can see Bitcoin SV at the top of the list -- it's worth the least of the Bitcoins.
And it's also misleading to compute the second factor -- transactions per second -- by counting the actual transactions on the blockchain, rather than looking at the transaction capacity. Because blockchains only cost something per transaction once they reach capacity. This is misleading with Bitcoin SV, for instance, because that coin artificially creates bogus transactions on its blockchain in order to make it look popular and demonstrate the vision of large blockchains. Bitcoin Cash, on the other hand, can handle a thousands of transactions per second (on testnet) but doesn't clog its live blockchain with them.
So, in sum, if you send a transaction on Bitcoin Cash, it will cost 0 kW of electricity, even though it says 31.3 Txs/MWh (which equates to 31.9kW/Tx) in this chart. This is because transactions do not cost anything in electricity. Electricity only goes to preventing double-spends. A better metric would be "energy use per double-spend that was prevented."
Source? How much are they asking for?
So it's not quite that the original founder felt pressure to create the token, but he did feel some pressure to make money, and eventually that led to a token.
The filtration constant for a well-sealed N95 can be 99.99%. The filtration constant for a thin cotton "face covering" can be 20%.
The point isn't that the model doesn't apply to poor masks -- it's that they have poor constants. We will do much better to include them in the model, and then mathematically predict how important it is to improve your filtration constant, than to say "those masks don't apply" and throw up our hands at quantifying the improvement that could be gained by better masks.
I'm very interested in getting GraphQL features into http and wasn't aware of these prior proposals. A quick web search didn't turn up anything for me on them either. Thank you!