HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

topham

78 karma · joined April 19, 2026

submissionscomments
topham··on "We're not going to make rules that say you can't use tools for X"
A bug is a bug is a bug. But not everything reported is a bug.

I watched a significant portion of that video, it represents what I expect well. You can't bury your head in the sand because an AI reported a bug, it's, potentially, still an exploitable bug. They can however raise the standard. They can require that reporting a bug comes with a fix, even if they reject the fix provided, it gives them an opportunity to evaluate that the bug is real, that someone put some effort in resolving it for the community (even if an LLM provided the fix); it gives something to evaluate the can benefit rather than only being a determent to the community.

I've sent a half dozen patches over the year to projects, I've always provided my perceived fix for the issue, occasionally they've been implemented as-is, and sometimes they were replaced outright with an alternate solution. I never really cared about the solution, just that the issues was resolved.

The first was a commercial library that dealt with multiple modems (interrupts and daughter cards)on dos based machines. They took the fix and integrated it and provided me with an updated library. Not much of a thank you, but the library was fixed.

More recent ones was another commercial library, open source but proprietary, and they sat on it for 3 months waiting for me to fix it their way, before the accepted it as-is and released appropriately adjusted patch. (I'm not their employer or employee, their complaints were tedious undefined rules. I fixed the bug and had working code. I waited them out.)

Good responses, bad responses, none of them mattered, what did matter to me, and others, is the developers involved cared enough to eventually implement the right fix for their codebase. The bugs need to go. Set the ego aside and fix it.

topham··on AdFection: Targeted ads turned into a pipeline for zero-click mercenary spyware
Knew the country of origin before I read the article. Surprise!
topham··on "We're not going to make rules that say you can't use tools for X"
I'm substantially less worried about the Linux kernel than almost everything else.

Honestly, seeing people go from concern trolling to what I like to call _concern farming_ has been utterly disappointing.

_concern farming_ is when people build entire crops of concerns with no intent to do anything other than fertilize them.

topham··on Teaching a Door to Say No
Does the AI trigger the dtmf tone directly?

Yes -then no, you cannot trust it won't make that decision.

topham··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI assisted contributions
The community is relying on the obscure process flows they've learned and optimized for their own purpose; replacing QGIS will probably wipe out jobs.

Couldn't happen sooner.

topham··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI assisted contributions
Considering this application needs an entire overhaul on its UI it would simply be easier to start from scratch.
topham··on I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home Assistant dashboard
Except it's not a misconception.

Air temperature is only one contributing factor for comfort in a home. Surface temperatures take longer to achieve and the larger the gradient the longer it can take.

There are multiple factors to take into account, including the highest temperature the home gets to, that is dependant on location and weather patterns.

If you keep the temperature in the home to 28-30 degrees then later cooling to lower temperatures before bed time you can reduce costs and energy expenditures than if you let it rise to 34 degrees or more and only lowering it when you get home. Or, what you save in costs you expend in otherwise like poor sleep.

Lowering it advance, on a schedule makes more sense if you want surface temperatures to also be reduced.

The blanket disabling of air conditioning when not home is not the only solution, and often is sub-optimal.

topham··on I predict Apple will open their platforms within the next five years
I predict they won't.
topham··on I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home Assistant dashboard
"When everyone leaves, all the air conditioners switch off."

That's often substantially more inefficient than keeping it at the temperature desired, or adjusting the desired temperature to mitigate it somewhat.

topham··on How did Rosalind Franklin miss the helix in her iconic DNA image? She didn't
Perhaps one forgets how long it takes to write a patent.
topham··on A minimal kernel in Swift, running in QEMU
Those are references to "Hackers" the movie from 1995.
topham··on Tell HN: GitHub refuses to remove cracked copies of my software after a month
Wordpress does absolutely nothing to enforce this, so their position on the matter is irrelevant.

Commercial plugins are a thing, next.

topham··on Tell HN: GitHub refuses to remove cracked copies of my software after a month
If you think an AI can't reproduce this without it being a copy of the code you are sadly very very mistaken.

I've had an AI reproduce astronomical formula functions without difficulty in whatever programming language I want. Graphical algorithms aren't even a challenge.

Might be time to reconsider the business model entirely, because Pandora's box is already opened.

topham··on Vibecoding isn't as fun as writing code by hand
Should dig up my slashdot 5 digit uid to placate your concerns, or just decide your opinion in regards to me is irrelevant? (Because it is.)

My uid was < 32768.

topham··on OpenAI's Artist Rules Are Easier to Evade Than to Explain
Can an artist duplicate a style without violating rights?

Yes.

Then an AI duplicating style isn't inherently violating any rights either.

If you want to get them in the consumption of the content it gets murky quick. Have you every watched a pirated movie? Should you be convicted of that, or of sharing it?

Subsequently describing the movie to some else constitute sharing of it?

topham··on Vibecoding isn't as fun as writing code by hand
I've programmed for decades. Vibe coding is more fun than writing boilerplate just to kick off a small project these days.

The days of:

10 PRINT "Hello World!"; 20 GOTO 10

Are long gone.

topham··on Is it normal for a take-home to require booking real sales demos?
No. And this looks as scammy as you can get.
topham··on Borland Turbo Basic
I know their Turbo C 2 tools did.

Miss those days. When I got a 386 and could use the turbo debugger to hack games. Pretty sweet. Just run the code; interrupt it near where it was asking for a word or number or clicking a symbol, then tweak a flag and let the game continue.

So often the final fix was to nop out an instruction that set a flag and just let it fall through.

Then there was the DSI team in Vancouver who encrypted their boot code...

topham··on SWC stops accepting external PRs due to AI-generated content
AI doesn't give a flying fuck about your political opinion while they tear into your lack of security.
topham··on This Could legitimately end Stop Killing Games [video]
I didn't follow down the rabbit hole, but the premise seems on point and the hype isn't too severe.

Imagine that, using "think of the kids" as the scape goat to "totalitarian rule" seems to be the in thing these days.

topham··on Old hearts age backwards: transplanted organs adjust to host's biological age
"according to a study1. The findings, posted on the preprint server bioRxiv and not yet peer reviewed"

So, meaningless at this time.

topham··on UDP Broadcasting and the Brave New World of IPv6
I thought the article missed the mark and decided to experiment with IPv6 and update a Raspberry Pico project to use IPv6 multicast and also mDNS/DNS-SD.

In an afternoon I was able to get it working and running reliably. I'm not saying there aren't potential issues, either in my code, lwip (supported framework).

What I am saying is that ipv6 with ipv6 multicast instead of Broadcasting is approachable today. It's approachable on the desktop as well as microcontrollers for IoT uses.

Seriously, this was so easy to get working I'm thinking of expanding the usage of some IoT projects I've been languishing on.

topham··on Jehovah's Witnesses allow blood-derived products but keep ban on whole-blood
So somebody high up in the organization needed plasma or the like and instead of being ex-communicated they just changed the rules to solve the problem.
topham··on Chester Zoo Mistakenly Advertises 'Child Predator Tour'
"The Jeffrey Epstein edition"
topham··on Please Apple, free us from dopamine hell with cross-app Siri automations
Thanks for listening.

I named my social media folder anti-social for a reason.

Social media apps will always build to dark patterns; they are driven on engagement.

topham··on Please Apple, free us from dopamine hell with cross-app Siri automations
Can't take it seriously and read the article.

You have a statement to make and the your choice is making it's own statement about usability that is, frankly, off putting.

topham··on Large language models develop novel social biases through adaptive exploration
Creating bias in models is easy. Amplifying existing biases are easy too.

They aren't necessarily a sign of bias in the underlying model however. Many samples would be required for that.

topham··on Solving the Jane Street reverse engineering challenge
If learning is the point then obviously that was a missed opportunity.

If success was the intent, then it's a win.

While challenges are fun, sometimes the requirement is simply to achieve the end goal, with no other point than that.

If your job is to stop terrorists, and that includes hacking into a system and extracting their plans, the "fun" of it isn't the point, only the end goal it's important. Sometimes when we do things like this for fun we forget that someone else out there absolutely needs to achieve the result and doesn't care how it's achieved.

It's the part of penetration testing some people miss. (It's not generally a fun job, almost everyone I know that did it got out as soon as possible. They weren't solving problems, they just running audit scripts and generating reports.)

topham··on Late-life semaglutide slows ageing and extends lifespan in female mice
Ironically it takes away the reason people want to live. Their joy, fun, the spark of life disappears for many people.
topham··on I were 17, I'd learn how to build LLMs from scratch
Sure, you had to pick the browser I despise worse than Netscape 4.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →