HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

totony

1,203 karma · joined May 24, 2014

submissionscomments
totony··on AOC calls out Robinhood for blocking GameStop, suggests holding a hearing
How is she keeping him accountable by refusing to work with him? This seems wrong on 2 ways:

- It encourages others to do the same; someone doesn't agree with you on an important issue (pro life?) - just refuse to work with them. This furthers the divide in US politics and is (imo) an overall negative.

- It hurts her own cause by removing support she already has - is this what a representative is supposed to do?

totony··on Robinhood now has a 1-Star rating on the Google Play Store
The Parler ban was a response from service providers so that they are not blamed for what their users (Parler) do (controversial opinion).

The GME/etc ban is a response from Robinhood so that they are not blamed for what theirs users (retail inverstors) do (controversial trading activities/losing money).

totony··on AOC calls out Robinhood for blocking GameStop, suggests holding a hearing
Is this principled? It seems to me like going against your principles/ideals just to stick it to someone you (usually) disagree with.
totony··on AOC calls out Robinhood for blocking GameStop, suggests holding a hearing
It's unfortunate that the one time someone from the opposing party agrees with her she calls back on something they don't agree on (and refuses to work with them because of it).
totony··on Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against Robinhood
TD Canada has prevented some forms of orders (e.g. market buy), but not limit buy - I think this isn't so bad as their clients might expect the quoted price and get screwed at open because of volatility
totony··on Gab is now the 647th most popular website in the US, explosive 90 day growth
Yeah, Cloudflare has already shown that it does cancel customers (https://blog.cloudflare.com/why-we-terminated-daily-stormer/)
totony··on Stripe bans Trump campaign
>no loss of life

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violence_and_controversies_dur...

>most of the damage was on insured property

Government property is insured by taxpayers

>93% of the summer protests where peaceful

I'm not sure how to confirm/disprove that statement. I'd posit that most protestors at the capitol were peaceful, but I'm not sure how to confirm/deny that either.

>mob had gallows and chanted to kill the vice president

Where I live "ACAB" is a trendy chant used to devil-ify police

EDIT: Also, is this not the same thing? https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3217754/Black-Lives... - not sure how trustworthy this is

> molotov cocktails and hostage situation zip ties where found on the scene,

I have seen molotovs used at BLM protest

All this to say - it's not black and white; I also feel there clearly is some double standard going on here. I disagree with (what i think is) the premise of the capitol protests, but it does not strike me as that much worse than what people were supporting a few months ago.

totony··on U.S. to require negative Covid-19 tests for international air passengers
>I'm totally ok with covid19 positive Canadians being stuck an unable to return home until they test negative.

I am not; your home country should never deny you entry. You're telling a citizen he is not welcome in his own country, is that how you want to treat your citizens?

Quarantine is warranted but denying entry has a weird taste to me

totony··on Study: All non-violent criminals jailed on minor drug offence should be released
>We can't effectively rehabilitate when we have so many people in prison.

But the reason we have so many people in prison is that we have stupid laws that mark as jail-able offenses the stupidest stuff. Just take financial fraud, why must someone be jailed for that? Are they a menace if outside?

totony··on Apple has threatened to ban Parler from the App Store
Yes but the analogy does not hold, since Google is as close to a monopoly as you can get. If your technological overlord decides to "kick you out" and thus you get ostracized from society it is hyperbole to compare it to getting kicked out of an insignificant building.

>_everyone_

Businesses have incentives to reduce risks. It's not necessarily that they disagree with what they say, it's just that they made a calculated decision to not have them as consumers.

It's not because everyone decides not to have you as consumers that it is a good thing for society to let them not have you (same thing happened for gays, black people, etc. yet we decided to protect those from businesses).

totony··on Permanent suspension of @realDonaldTrump
>Is it? Would someone refusing to wear a mask, provably resulting in them asymptomatically infecting someone with COVID-19 be charged with negligent manslaughter?

It is not murder. There's a concept called "Negligent homicide," but even that is relatively well defined and requires intent to cause harm.

Don't want to get into the rabbit hole, and I am not in agreement with all the laws the US has, but the point is that "bad speech" is way harder to define than murder/homicide. Not only is it harder, it is arguably impossible to attain a good consensus on what it is.

PS: I don't agree with the premise that we should regulate speech, but if you were to want to do it it would most likely backfire or be counterproductive because of these reasons

totony··on Apple has threatened to ban Parler from the App Store
Comparing Google and Apple to the local pub is disingenuous. Google alone could buy all the pubs in the UK with its one-year revenue (or one-year profit, if my calculations are correct)
totony··on Apple has threatened to ban Parler from the App Store
I agree somewhat with OP. As an example, this happened in Canada: https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ndp-jagmeet-singh-rota-raci...

Not the same thing, but this level of discourse is laughable.

totony··on ACLU Statement Opposing the 'Confronting the Threat of Domestic Terrorism Act' (2019)
>Appeasing the right has gone on for long enough

You should reflect on what that really means. You're segregating the population into 2 segments, which furthers the current problems the US is facing. Each side ostracizing the other.

totony··on Permanent suspension of @realDonaldTrump
Murder is quite easy to define, whereas bad speech/bad argument seems so much more nuanced. I don't think it's an hyperbole moreso than the logical consequence of such a thought.
totony··on Permanent suspension of @realDonaldTrump
But isn't there always a long tail that will cause chaos or take things in a bad way? Especially with the sheer size of Trump's audience.
totony··on Permanent suspension of @realDonaldTrump
The alternative, which is to prevent the spread of "bad arguments" is dystopian
totony··on Permanent suspension of @realDonaldTrump
As a data point, I haven't killed anyone because of trump tweets
totony··on Our Response to the Violence in Washington
The organized group known as "protestors"
totony··on Ten year study: No link between violent video games and aggressive behavior
There's a middle ground where mechanics are fun but not too easy; flight simulator is just too hard to be that fun in my experience.
totony··on Voat Is Shutting Down
This is a good point, but in my understanding of dignity was more of a physical "no slave" than a mental "respect." I'm having trouble finding a good definition of that.

Edit: i also understood the basic rights to be a property of the system rather than the actions of people; e.g. you should be free whatever people think of you; right to happiness whatever enemies you have, etc. If words can deprive you of dignity, then it seems as though the system is not giving you the feeling of safety in your rights that you should be expecting. This seems like a more logical application of the rights; since you cannot force respect out of others but can force the system to honor its promises.

totony··on Voat Is Shutting Down
If it becomes widespread; freedom of speech is irrelevent because the executive power bows down to populism.

I agree with words being able to elicit strong emotional response in people, but I disagree that this should serve as a basis for legislation. I do not think it is a strong enough basis to risk affecting the spread of ideas and discourse.

totony··on Voat Is Shutting Down
Words have the potential to affect action, that is their main purpose. But actions are not caused by words but influenced by them, which imo is a big difference
totony··on Voat Is Shutting Down
>You can either: believe people are inherently evil and will support genocide at the first opportunity; or people can be influenced by pointed words from a group intent on manipulating them.

It is also possible this was a prevailing thought, or that the environment was encouraging of such thoughts, in that nation at that time; that something caused division, and that the nazi used this as a way to assert power and spearhead their ideology.

To think people can just tell you to participate in a genocide and everyone will follow is not recognizing the agency of human beings. The WW2 was a dramatic period that had a lot of factors, but having restrictions on free speech is unlikely to be one that would or even did matter much.

Edit: plus, the restrictions on free speech are executed and decided by the oligarchy, and when the nazism was its most vicious it had little reason to restrict that kind of speech. The idea that free speech restriction help in preventing propaganda is wrong; it prevents only some subset of propaganda which does not further the elite, which imo is worse than not restricting it at all. And even then, free speech restrictions cannot stop the spread of ideas and prejudice, whatever they are.

totony··on Voat Is Shutting Down
Are you saying without free speech it wouldn't have happened?
totony··on Voat Is Shutting Down
>your argument at best is in bad faith

I disagree (although this was a question more than an argument)

>Constant dehumanization of people does not eventually lead to physical violence?

What it might lead to is irrelevant, the act of speech does not impede anything and a lot of things have the potential to lead to violence, yet legalizing it is arbitrary at best

totony··on Voat Is Shutting Down
>Remember the holocaust

I'd posit the words weren't the things affecting people, but whatever actions they took

totony··on Voat Is Shutting Down
>'free speech' supersedes other rights and should go unchecked at the expense of others

Curious about this, what right does anti-Semite/racism rhetoric removes from others? How can words affect your rights as a person?

totony··on Twitch bans words “simp” and “virgin”
>Because offending each other tends to make everyone angry and bitter.

Not necessarily, you can get funny banter or a viewer-streamer interaction where all is made in good fun. The issue people are having is that twitch poorly understands or support this kind of nuance.

totony··on Covid-19: Our approach to misleading vaccine information
That doesn't mean that it's a good thing; the mentality behind this is troubling.
← PreviousPage 14 of 30Next →