HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

totony

1,203 karma · joined May 24, 2014

submissionscomments
totony··on The truckers shutting down Canada's capital
More importantly, why do you insist on labelling them as a problem? What do you propose be done once you do label them as "a problem"?
totony··on The truckers shutting down Canada's capital
(not parent)

>They're here to flex "ownership" of a national capital

Seeing how the government & media reacted at the start, I highly doubt a change.org petition would have had accomplished much. Having flashy show of support is way more impactful. This is the whole point of protests.

>This is a Facebook conspiracy theory convened to experience itself in person.

As I said in OP, reductionist views like this are very toxic and not how you approach disagreements in a democracy.

Attacking the character of some organizers (be it true or not) adds nothing to the discussion except divisiveness. Not only that, you seem to imply that their demands are invalid because of that, which is just a smear campaign to ignore the issues they (and the other protesters) raise.

totony··on The truckers shutting down Canada's capital
Unacceptable provincial legislations are federal matters. That has always been the case and is why the supreme court is federal.

So it makes sense to protest in ottawa when overreach is suspected (esp since this seems like a human rights matter and is federal jurisdiction).

Provinces in Canada have way less power than states in the US

totony··on The truckers shutting down Canada's capital
>But police say they are concerned about how the convoy has attracted extremist rhetoric

Blame the government for that. They need a scapegoat so hard for their failure to plan & react to the pandemic that they villainize groups like this and try to ostracize them (e.g. trudeau & al saying they are a fringe group - saying that since 90% of people are vaccinated they agree to the mandates, which is a false dichotomy. If you force someone to do something you can't say "well you did it so you agree it's necessary"). What did they expect would happen to those they voluntarily ostracize?

I've seen a lot of reasonable people that just didn't think the vaccine was worth it to them be pushed into very fringe views out of being cornered by the ruling class.

totony··on The case against masks at school
>Oh, and by the way: I have plenty of sympathy towards health care workers. I am dating a nurse. I have doctors, nurses, and paramedics as friends. I have extreme empathy towards them, and full seething burning anger towards the unvaccinated septuagenarians ruining our health care system. And the rest of our economy while they're at it.

Instead of blaming unvaxxed people, you should blame the government for not having more capacity and not planning on how to handle surge in demand for hospitals. We're lucky covid is so tame, this could have been a crazy disaster.

This rhetoric where we try to divide the population is insanely toxic when the fault should be placed on the ruling class for mishandling both the planning, the communication and the handling of the pandemic.

totony··on I read the federal government’s Zero-Trust Memo so you don’t have to
Laptops can have smart cards so there's no reason a phone couldn't
totony··on I read the federal government’s Zero-Trust Memo so you don’t have to
How do you do MFA without a password? I thought it was "what you know" "what you have" "what you are" etc?
totony··on Quitting Dgraph Labs
I think an issue with dgraph is their "open core" didn't include a lot of things you'd expect in a "core" DB (iirc backups, multi tenancy & acl). I'm not familiar with confluent & co. but imo for "open core" to succeed you need a product attractive enough to gain market share, and then you can have extra features for commercial use. But then why not just make it completely open source to gain even more market share and offer support contracts (eg redhat & co)?
totony··on Quitting Dgraph Labs
Yeah, that's a bad look for both dgraph and the new company imo. What guarantees the same thing ran by the same people won't have the same issues again?

Not only that, if the core team moves to the open source product to "rebuild" the same features, isn't that way too dangerous IP-wise?

This is also one of the reasons I didn't use dgraph: Open source core doesn't work. All the companies that were sold to now have nowhere to go for support.

totony··on Naomi Wu video demonetized on YouTube
Isn't it understandable that people want separate spaces for sexual and non sexual content?

I wouldn't jump the gun on allowing sexualization everywhere since it can have pretty bad effects on some people.

Now whether this is sexual or not is another matter.

totony··on Naomi Wu video demonetized on YouTube
How does she know whether the videos she references are demonitized? It's unclear to me if they are monitized since none of them seem to have midrolls.

But yeah, Youtube demonitization is pretty bad and arbitrary. Might be better if they had competition.

totony··on How to make your own SARS-CoV-2 variants
Is it better to restrict knowledge to an elite off the fear of a lower class bad actor having it easier? Seems like a very regressive view to me.
totony··on Spotify is removing Neil Young’s music after falling out over Joe Rogan
It is a way to dismiss someone. Doesn't make it unsubstantial. It's akin to saying "he just wants attention."
totony··on How to make your own SARS-CoV-2 variants
The good old knowledge = dangerous

Of course a lot of knowledge is dangerous (how to make xray, nuclear, etc ). Do we really want to filter it because of bad actors?

totony··on Solving Open Source Supply Chain Security for the PHP Ecosystem
How do you know a timestamped vouch is no more valid? Isn't that the point of revocation?
totony··on Solving Open Source Supply Chain Security for the PHP Ecosystem
In "What Happens if a Third Party is Compromised?" they mention you cannot revoke an attestation once it's committed. What happens if a security audit is conducted, concludes, but a vuln is found a few years down the line?

Security audits are not perfect. Is there a way to say "new information has come up, and this version is no longer secure?"

Even with perfect security audits such a feature might be useful, e.g. when you conducted a security audit, but new SPECTRE-like attack vectors are found.

totony··on I got foiled by PHP's deceptive Frankenstein “dictionary or list” ARR (cont)
PHP developers differentiate between arrays and associative arrays. Although you can mix int and string keys, I've never seen anyone do so in actual code.
totony··on Abuse and Harassment on the Blockchain
How would you know if they worked? By their virtue they are used for privacy
totony··on Off the Grid
How difficult would using sonar be to protect against that?
totony··on SUSE announces Liberty Linux, new distro for those who miss the old CentOS
Long term release kernels are a maintenance nightmare, and have barely any difference in functionality. The maintenance burden of having 1 is already very huge, I don't see why they would add 1 more if what they have already works
totony··on New Year, New CEO
Let's say your net worth is ~100k. That's equivalent to a 2.5k donation. Investing 2.5k in a pet project is pretty common, and you don't find yourself in the streets for doing so.

I think people that say it's easy to lose 2b$ don't have a clear understanding of the amount of money that is. It's a crazy amount for one person.

totony··on New Year, New CEO
The average american makes ~2m in a lifetime, 1b$ is 500x that. "Losing" 1b$ is ludicrous unless you are actively looking to lose it (or don't care about it, like musk & al).

How do you lose what 500 people make in their lifetime?

totony··on Strengthening our efforts against the spread of non-consensual intimate images
>human oversight

Not at facebook, this will either be abused or useless

totony··on Open source package urllib3 raised $15,000 in 2021
Same thought here, but at the same time I believe the obsession with having an active OSS is partly to blame. Maintenance would be much lesser if we just stopped development when it's "good enough"
totony··on Tell HN: Canada Posts systems to be down for 6 hours of “unplanned maintenance”
Yeah that's terrible, even for canadian software engineering standards.
totony··on Tell HN: Canada Posts systems to be down for 6 hours of “unplanned maintenance”
Not only that, most gov projects have to outsource (that's why we have such big consulting firms like CGI and LGS). This make project costs skyrocket. All that because they can't offer good wages (or condition - working conditions are pretty much set in stone).
totony··on Coming to Agreement, a logic puzzle for Oxford admissions interviews
>But I have got a coin in my pocket, and from now on, I intend each round to flip the coin, sending the red message on heads and the blue message on tails. If you do likewise, then we are very likely in a few rounds to hit upon the same message, and then we shall win on the next round by following through, announcing the agreed-upon color.

What if the other person says "But I have got a coin in my pocket, and from now on, I intend each round to flip the coin, sending the green message on heads and the orange message on tails. If you do likewise, then we are very likely in a few rounds to hit upon the same message, and then we shall win on the next round by following through, announcing the agreed-upon color."

How do you choose the strategy? If both stick to theirs, then you have a deadlock

totony··on Systemd 250 Released
Well it's not a hypothetical solution, the script is probably about the same length as the timer config.

I used logger because it's better practice to log and for the logger to send email, you can send email using the mail command or msmtp. The timing was omitted because it is trivial and didnt serve to illustrate the point, just do backup && touch /var/lib/lastbackup && exit 0, with a if at the start of the script like if [ -x "$(find -mtime -1 /var/lib/lastbackup)" ]

The mid-backup shutdown is a property of the backup script, you'll have to consider that even using systemd.

Sadly there are not many distros without systemd. Everyone is strained in resources and Redhat is pumping money into the ecosystem, so it's really easy to take over most of it. Like I said I don't dislike systemd, I think it adds value, but it's just not the best solution since it does not integrate with others well.

EDIT:

>You don't like systemd, then do not use it and move on.

But this is the issue with systemd: you can't. Want gnome? needs dbus, which needs logind which is systemd. Need libvirt? also needs dbus. Need Y? Needs systemd-tmpfs, which packages the whole systemd as a dependency. Same thing for systemd-udev.

The interlock is so brutal most distros are forced to switch because they can't handle the dev burden.

totony··on Systemd 250 Released
Redhat made the scripting for you. I don't think it's that complicated of a script (although it would be easier with a retry command)

    sleep $random
    for i in 1 2 3 4; do
      backup && exit 0
      sleep 15m
    done
    logger "backup failed"
    exit 1

add script to @startup in crontab or whatever they use. You can use another wrapper that only execute it if the backup is newer than now-24h. Backup could even be remote and you could track it by touching a file in /var

Yes systemd might be slightly easier, but that's because they put a lot of money into systemd, not because systemd is a better architecture. It's nice that they open sourced it (although it does give them a competitive edge), but we can't act like what used to be there isn't as good.

Someone could have packaged utility wrapper scripts in much less time than it did to add those features to systemd, and these wrapper script would be more widely usable (by init scripts, cronjobs, etc)

totony··on Systemd 250 Released
Cron has all these features:

- single place control: crontab -e

- additional constraints: systemctl status && scirpt.sh

- randomize startup times: sleep ${RANDOM:0:MAX} && script.sh

The nice thing is that it integrates with the existing infrastructure (shell scripts). This means you don't have to add code to cron to add features.

I agree with the 10s of files in /etc/cron.daily, etc. But those are there for convenience (you can even remove them from /etc/crontab)

← PreviousPage 5 of 30Next →