HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

totony

1,203 karma · joined May 24, 2014

submissionscomments
totony··on Bash functions are better than I thought
Since make does not sanitize input or handle error, I use it only for parallelism/dependency management and offload all build to shell scripts. I've found this to be way more maintainable.
totony··on Poor parents receiving universal payments increase spending on kids
Higher price on lower end housing, but that incentivises building more lower end housing (since higher end housing is more elastic and won't have as big of a markup).

EDIT: actually, thinking more about this I don't think lower end housing will see such an increase, since most people already have a home. You'll certainly see a rise in price of lower end housing, but it won't offset UBI, since I doubt people will just take ubi to put it into their housing

totony··on Poor parents receiving universal payments increase spending on kids
One of the direct consequences of UBI is inflation IMO. Of course things are going to be more expensive if we give everyone money. That doesn't mean poor people won't be better off. If your food costs 20% more but you have 200% the money, that's a good thing. UBI is like printing money, yes you have inflation, but the money is still useful.

Inflation won't eat the whole UBI (probably), because there's still supply and demande that other revenue generate. E.g. if I pay 20% of my income for food and UBI doesn't affect my income much, I won't be inclined to increase my spending on food by a big %.

totony··on Poor parents receiving universal payments increase spending on kids
>It's costly to hoard property and leave it unproductive

Not when property is a speculative/investment asset (and when you can leverage it to get credit).

totony··on Chicago creates one of the nation’s largest ‘guaranteed basic income’ programs
I highly doubt opposing giving people more freedom because you think society is in a bad shape (why? social media? I don't think this is as big an issue as you make it seem) is either morally right or useful. Clearly things could be better w/r to people's view of Internet, but that doesn't prevent doing other things to make other facets of life better.

Moreover, this fear of social unrest because of this new social media craze/new-woke extremism and closed-mindedness of other views is a middle-class thing. Poor people can't afford to waste their time arguing on social media/protesting/going deeper down the rabbit hole. Even if it were moral to oppose UBI on such grounds, I do not believe it is an actual issue that would get worse because of UBI.

EDIT: Or I guess it might, by making these people middle class/giving them too much time. I still think this is immoral and not grounds on which a democratic society should oppose policies.

totony··on Chicago creates one of the nation’s largest ‘guaranteed basic income’ programs
In other words, it's hard to control people who are not fighting to survive.

So let's keep them slaving away?

totony··on NPM package ‘ua-parser-JS’ with more than 7M weekly download is compromised
It's easier to trust 1 org than 1000 different developers.
totony··on Trump's new platform and the Affero General Public License of Mastodon
>If it's just because "but they claim to value free software", see my reply (which included ninja edits): free software != free speech.

I agree with you on this. The reason I believe they're somewhat related is that free software ensures users always have access to a software and can modify it if they disagree with the author. The spirit of that I think concedes that users should be allowed to use the software whoever they are/whatever they say/etc.

Now of course free software doesn't require you to provide them with the platform to run the software, but in spirit it definitely enables a discrimination-free permission to use it. EDIT: So having a platform deny access when it values such spirit is somewhat disagreeable.

totony··on Trump's new platform and the Affero General Public License of Mastodon
I think you're being disingenuous, I don't use my lawn to distribute other people's apps/signs, it's not its purpose, and I don't advertise it as such.

Also:

>FDroid is a small enough platform that they should be allowed to do whatever they want. But then it's OK to point out the perceived hypocrisy in having a free software platform that censors apps they disagree with.

totony··on Trump's new platform and the Affero General Public License of Mastodon
But my lawn is not a platform. And even then, FDroid is a small enough platform that they should be allowed to do whatever they want. But then it's OK to point out the perceived hypocrisy in having a free software platform that censors apps they disagree with.

Free software is not really about free speech, but usually both philosophies are held together since they are somewhat related.

totony··on Trump's new platform and the Affero General Public License of Mastodon
>Stealing is wrong. But what if you're stealing bread because that's the only way you can get food, and you're stealing it from Jeff Bezos who was just going to let it rot. Is that still wrong? Even if it has no value to Jeff B? Even if it means your death if you don't?

Which is a misunderstanding of what you really mean by "stealing is wrong."

In that example, Bezos doesn't care about the sandwish, so perhaps you mean "stealing is wrong if it deprives someone of something they cherish." Or maybe you hold your life above your morals, but then you have to recognize what you're doing is amoral.

totony··on Trump's new platform and the Affero General Public License of Mastodon
I don't doubt they have their own morals, but these same people say they hold free speech as moral. The whole point of free speech is to allow for speech you find reprehensible. If not, what's the point?
totony··on Trump's new platform and the Affero General Public License of Mastodon
>Most people are actually very much okay with "Thou shalt not kill"

I don't think that's true. Most people are very vengeful and do not hold that view.

>It turns out that things are frequently more complicated than absolutist rules allow for

imo "absolutist" is mostly used pejoratively. It's dissonance to believe both "People should be able to express themselves however they way" and "Racists should be ostracized." The logical consequence of the second is to disallow racists to speak. It might be OK according to your moral compass, but that's antithesis to free speech and more akin to "people should be able to express themselves if what they say is something I allow."

totony··on Trump's new platform and the Affero General Public License of Mastodon
>Out of interest, what's to stop them publishing some 'version' of the modified code, but actually running a different version on their servers?

The law

>Would that be easy to detect?

No

totony··on Trump's new platform and the Affero General Public License of Mastodon
>People have their limits. Most people aren’t absolutists, taking their philosophy to the extreme and utterly unable to make exceptions to their rules when egregious examples show up.

If your morals don't hold up when pushed to their limits, it's that you have a poor understanding of what your morals are. A lot of people like free software because it's hip, but when faced with the very reason free software exists they turn back on it very fast.

totony··on Uber and Lyft don't save money, time, or the planet
This is highly dependent on where you are. I had similar experience with ride sharing apps of drivers straight up scamming me driving around.

Uber are concentrated on where it's popular. Good luck finding one if you are in the suburbs, you'll get infinite cancelations and wait forever, where in my experience taxis will never cancel once confirmed and usually confirm wherever you are.

totony··on Decreasing service fees on subscriptions to 15%
>Google Play constitutes most of Android revenue.

Google also includes a few services apps use (eg google play services) which they could disable if an app isnt bought through google play. Their alternative might be to monetize their current services.

totony··on How can we break our addiction to contempt?
I don't think it's quite that. IMO from knowing some anti-vaxx it originates from a rebellion against power more-so than any actual belief in conspiracy. It seems to come from being fed up with being told what to do AND from distrust in authorities (arguably warranted). Conspiracy comes as a post-facto rationalization for some as far as I've seen.

I believe policies like vaccine mandate and the overzealous anti-anti-vax crew are paradoxically aggravating the issue. Making it a partisan issue also seems to force people on the defensive and harden their (potentially unfounded) beliefs, forcing them into the "other camp."

EDIT: My hypothesis on why it comes more from right-wing rather than left-wing people is exactly that right-wing is anti-government power (or more freedom of individuals, usually).

totony··on Tech salaries fall in Bay Area, New York City, rise in Austin, San Diego
Depends on how much salary appreciates elsewhere. It's quite significant compared to ny and texas (1.1% up + 0.3% down).

Salary is comparative by nature. If your worth increases less than someone similar, then it decreased.

totony··on [dead]
Not familiar with the whole controversy/don't care, but it's frightening to see people that should be the most respectful of others right to protest seem the least.
totony··on The day my script killed 10k phones in South America
Why? Looks good to me
totony··on Tesla officially launches its insurance using ‘real-time driving behavior’
Sex yes but weight no. Such a weird law.
totony··on Tesla officially launches its insurance using ‘real-time driving behavior’
Well, this seems slightly better to me. I'd rather be discriminated against based on what I'm doing than on what I am. I'd rather not have my life dictated by unaccountable analysts/AI but I don't think this particular news is worse than the status quo.

EDIT: Main thing that irks me about this is the invasion of privacy. Less data = good in my book and this is the complete opposite so I'd probably pay a premium not to use that.

totony··on Tesla officially launches its insurance using ‘real-time driving behavior’
Insurance already discriminates on age/car make based on shitty risk models, what's new
totony··on Plant-based meat deceleration signals niche future
I think there's a lot of variation in chicken taste so it's pretty hard to have a perfect replacement. Not sure why creates such a big range of taste
totony··on Nix-GUI: Make NixOS usable for non-technical users through settings / GUI
The thread raises some valid points on both sides, but the slock issue is secondary to the real issue. Adding misc patches:

- Makes different systems behave differently - this makes bugs harder to track and confuses users

- Moves the trust from the software developer to both the software developer and packagers (who may not have the same expertise that the developer has)

For ex. #1: When you use software like slock, you presumably trust slock to do its job well. If you don't trust him enough in his choice to add setuid, then why would you trust him enough to use the screen locker?

I understand adding patches that are strictly packaging related if upstream is uncooperative (mostly I guess because nix is small), but changing behavior is another ballgame.

totony··on Canadians can’t travel to Canada without a smartphone
>may be subject to fines or enforcement action

What does this mean? What's "enforcement action?"

totony··on Nix-GUI: Make NixOS usable for non-technical users through settings / GUI
Setuid has been replaced by capabilities, but nix faces the same struggles it has for setuid (only supports it through a wrapper, and that was after a "wontfix" according to the bug tracker).

More than that though, the mentality that you can just patch away critical features (like setuid) without telling the user is imo unhealthy for an OS.

totony··on Ontarians are getting digital ID this fall: All you need to know
Yikes, I would much rather have anonymous credit cards than having my identity validated through the government. Lots of talk about "decentralized technologies" to what seems to me like a centralized government-signed digital ID
totony··on Nix-GUI: Make NixOS usable for non-technical users through settings / GUI
Reproducibility is not the only issue they're facing. I think the mentality extends to more than just fixing linker issues, e.g. this https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/issues/9656

At the end of the day, I much prefer trusting upstream than having to trust packagers to do everything right.

← PreviousPage 7 of 30Next →