HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tow21

488 karma · joined January 30, 2009

Founder/CEO, ArcticRex

Email: toby@arcticrex.com Twitter: @tow21

submissionscomments
tow21··on Why The UK Startup Scene Is Doomed
I'm not advocating using them long term, I'm advocating using them to get yourself off the ground. There's no setup cost, and integration is fairly trivial.

It almost doesn't matter whether you can get your money down from Paypal. It matters whether you can persuade people to hand over their credit card. Not much point worrying about anything else until you can prove that, and paypal is a very cheap & easy way to manage that.

tow21··on Why The UK Startup Scene Is Doomed
With all due respect and without being snarky, your steps are wrong. Try these ones:

1. Register a business (Ltd, LLC, etc)

2. Open a Business Bank Account

3. Implement Paypal to get yourself up and running,

4. Prove that there's a market for your product, people will pay for it, people will continue to pay for it, you don't have lots of chargebacks, you're capable of managing sensible customer relations, and generally are as small a risk as possible for any merchant account. As a bonus, this also validates your business plan before you invest too much time in irrelevant admin.

5. Go and talk to your bank. And every other bank out there. Shop around, shop around, shop around.

(As an aside, read David Mytton's blog: http://blog.boxedice.com/2009/05/20/taking-payments-online-m... )

6. Profit!

EDIT: fixed formatting

tow21··on Implementing New Cookie Law Drops Use by 90%
Thanks. After reading the ICO's guidance, so it seems. I was, in fact entirely wrong.

As someone elsethread pointed out, if this is taken seriously, people will just start browser fingerprinting. That at least means that the information is stored server-side rather than client-side, which the new directive seems particularly concerned about.

tow21··on Implementing New Cookie Law Drops Use by 90%
Someone correct me if I'm entirely wrong, but I thought the point of the law was to stop third-party cookies being used to track users.

That is, if you want to track your users - that's fine, use as many cookies as you like and don't ask anyone's permission. But it's your job to do the tracking, you can't outsource it to Google.

tow21··on Show HN: Requesting feedback on my side-project chatteranalytics.com
I think GoSquared (http://gosquared.com) have something of this flavour of interaction as well.
tow21··on Ask HN: Who's hiring in Europe?
(Co-founder butting in here!) Also, we're generally always interested in people into data visualization and the UX around it - come and chat to us <jobs@timetric.com> if that's your sort of thing!
tow21··on Tell me why I suck
Have you tried asking?

I've done this in the past with jobs for which I was not accepted. Some were happy to, some weren't, but where they did it was useful.

And as an employer now, I'm generally happy to share useful feedback. But I'll usually only bother if the candidate asks me. This is at least partly because - as RiderOfGiraffes alludes to, there are legal issues involved, and I have to think very hard about how I word a reply to make sure it stays within the bounds of relevant laws. And I'm happy to do that if the candidate asked after it - but not if they've expressed no interest.

(fwiw, this is in the UK)

tow21··on Introducing AWS Elastic Beanstalk
Presumably Jython would be pretty easy to get running, and you can run eg Django on Jython: http://docs.djangoproject.com/en/dev/howto/jython/
tow21··on Why services should offer marginal features (with apologies to 37signals)
API complexity - just as much as UI complexity - represents a host of different code paths in your software that you need to manage.

You need to make sure all these code paths work; and you need to make sure they don't interact in unexpected ways. You need to test not only the well-used paths (which your users will test for you - you'll find out quickly enough if commonly-used functions fail!) but also all of your less-commonly used paths, which will bit-rot if you're not on top of them all the time.

The art of good API design is entirely different, but just as hard, as good UI design. Bolting on a bunch of new features does not a good API make - you need to ensure that you add features sensibly, orthogonally, and matching your user's expectations.

Expanding your API also means you need to make sure you have a good understanding of the load profile of all your API calls, both individually and in combination.

In short, I think the OP is underestimating the complexity involved in designing and managing an API - just because the problems arising aren't the same as those in UI design doesn't mean they're not there.

tow21··on The Tax Haven That's Saving Google Billions
"Google's board and executives are legally obligated to maximize shareholder value. Shareholders can sue otherwise."

Common fallacy. No they're not, and no they can't. See, eg

http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1013744

tow21··on Ask HN: Help me understand online payment gateways
Actually, in the UK, banks are pretty much the only way of getting a merchant account, see:

http://www.businesslink.gov.uk/bdotg/action/detail?type=RESO...

(sorry for shitty URL)

The only non-bank merchant accounts you can get are Amex & Diner's Card, both of which only work for their own cards.

tow21··on Statistics Editor of FT joins London startup
Link to the original story:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/pda/2010/sep/22/timetric-fin...

tow21··on 'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator
"Be that as it may, can you see that it's legitimate for a musician to want to make, record, and sell music - not an associated industry of products?"

It's legitimate to want any sort of business model to work. But if it doesn't work, complaining that you wanted it to doesn't help.

tow21··on Google Apps (nearly) first class citizen now
And now I won't be able to use the same browser for both personal gmail & work gmail any more.

Unless I use multiple-sign-on, which comes with a whole host of caveats, including no offline gmail.

This will not make life easier.

tow21··on Ask HN:Mixcloud API - Peer Review
Haven't had a chance to have more than a very brief look so far; and I don't have any apps in mind just yet. But:

1) massive thumbs up for good use of HATEOS :-) Too many people miss it, and it makes writing clients much easier in my experience (also makes your job much easier in maintaining the API)

2) there's a couple of namespace conflicts which make me itch, but I don't know how important they are in practice. In particular:

http://api.mixcloud.com/spartacus/

http://api.mixcloud.com/popular/ http://api.mixcloud.com/new/ http://api.mixcloud.com/me/

at first glance, I would think that the latter URLS refer to users whose usernames are "popular", "new", and "me". If the endpoints look exactly the same, that's probably ok, but it's still a bit odd. If I'm writing an app which says "enter a username here", I have to remember that these are not valid usernames; and I can imagine similar sort of special-casing might have to be put in elsewhere.

3) I still hate OAuth - it's probably still the best of a bad bunch, though! Nice overview of how to use it in practice.

4) minor issue - for exceeding rate limits, I'd use a 403 code not a 503. 5xx limits boil down to "it's the server's fault". 4xx are "it's your fault" and in this case I think the semantics are more user error than server error.

tow21··on Element 114 on the brink of recognition
Not particularly Zeno's paradox-y, but yes.

You're trying to stick together big balls of protons and neutrons that wobble about under all the internal stresses and strains, which are stabilized by the surface tension of the nucleus. It's really very much like a drop of water, or even a bubble.

While small bubbles are fairly stable, because the surface tension largely overcomes any tendency to fall apart, large bubbles quickly break under the stress of other forces - there's a practical upper limit to the size of bubble you can make. The same thing is true, for the same reasons, with large nuclei.

tow21··on Google To Launch Amazon S3 Competitor ‘Google Storage’ At I/O
App Engine requires you to code your app in a particular way to work on their platform, and that way will (to a large extent) only work on App Engine.

This is true, but it does make for a very nice deployment story; and Ian Bicking's silver lining (http://cloudsilverlining.org/) is (I think) a very interesting attempt to tell that story in a more generic way.

tow21··on Still hatin' on git: now with added Actual Reasons
In other words, Git's abstraction is leaky

No, it means you're using the wrong abstraction.

As you change your codebase, files are modified. To the untrained eye, it looks like this a simple linear progression of history, and you just want to record savepoints as you go along. CVS lets you pretend this is the case.

Actually, that's not the case at all. What you actually want to record is the changes you're making, and the relations between them. In the vanishingly small edge case where you never have any collaborators, never any experimental code, you never need to backtrack, you never need to work on more than one portion of the code at a time - this is isomorphous.

The rest of the time, it's not. CVS & SVN try to stretch the first abstraction to take care of these differences, but fail.

git makes you face up to the fact that your abstractions are wrong.

tow21··on Why I went without hot water for a year
nitpick: melodiousness != malodourousness

I think I'd love to be surrounded by negligent melodiousness, it sounds delightful.

tow21··on If the TSA Were Running New York
I think there's probably an interesting overlap between security theatre and increased retail opportunity in airports. If I were a major airport retailer, I'd be lobbying hard for increased security screening - bored people forced to hang around in airports are likely to spend more.

See eg http://www.aerlines.nl/issue_40/40_Beundia_de_Barros.pdf

(and count me as another UK citizen who avoids flying as much as is reasonably possible these days.)

tow21··on Datasets and Data-driven Startups
"Why would you want to start a data-driven startup?"

In our case (http://timetric.com) - it was at least in part due to having spent several years beavering away trying to build products for the management of scientific data, before discovering that outside of science:

a) there's lots of other interesting data can benefit from better management

b) people will pay for it :-)

The article's a very good overview of lots of the issues we've faced in building a business around data.

tow21··on Really? Porn In The Workplace Is Now A Major Board-Level Concern For Business
People reading HN at work are unlikely to make their colleagues feel uncomfortable.

People looking at (image-based) porn at work are extremely likely to make at least some of their colleagues feel uncomfortable. That's not cool.

It doesn't really matter if you feel your colleagues ought or ought not to feel uncomfortable - some of them almost certainly will, and it's frankly antisocial behaviour to act in ways that will offend your colleagues, regardless of whether they "should" be offended.

The particular nature of the porn is irrelevant - whether objectifying, sexist of otherwise. (Except if it's text-only perhaps. That would get in people's face much less.)

(And all of the above would be equally true, for example, for image-heavy neo-fascist boards.)

tow21··on [dead]
Congratulations to Alexis et al!
tow21··on Ask HN: review our new thing!
Thanks - yes, this is an error. We'll fix it shortly!
tow21··on "Tough. Django produces XHTML."
Yes but - it's still true (for me at least), that XHTML is far easier to construct automatically. Mostly due to the tag-closing behaviour.

I don't spend all day writing HTML, so it's not at the forefront of my mind which tags are self-closing and which ones aren't. Is it "<br>" or "<br/>"? And really, why would I care? And ever more really, how much of that behaviour can I be bothered putting into automatically-produced output, rather than just simply putting the "/" everywhere?

If I cheat and serve up XHTML-like tags under a text/html mimetype, then nothing and nobody cares (as far as I can tell) except for the W3 validator.

tow21··on Lost Sleep Can't Be Made Up, Study Suggests
The other day, I was speaking to a doctor friend who's in the middle of sleep-deprived training, and she defended the practice.

She said that even as a senior doctor, you are going to have to pull insanely long shifts at times. Under those conditions, you're clearly not going to be working at your best. So you're going to have to develop good instincts; more importantly, you're going to have develop trust in your own instincts, that will allow you to operate effectively despite ridiculous levels of sleep deprivation.

And the only way to do that is to go through that in a semi-controlled environment in your training.

Says my friend the doctor anyway.

tow21··on Ask HN: What do you use for bookkeeping?
We use xero.com.

Your best solution might depend what tax jurisdiction you're in, though.

tow21··on Amazon Relational Database Service
The "march up the value chain" isn't about lock-in. It's about the fact there are a lot of business providing services between AWS and other services running on AWS (eg, by providing pre-packaged AMIs containing ready-to-run MySQL databases, and automatic management thereof) This is because in the early days of AWS, it offered you lots of moving parts to tweak, but you had to learn a lot to make best use of it. There was quite a lot of room in the market for paying people to take away some of the headaches in managing AWS yourself.

This is becoming less & less true as Amazon provide more services - if you're still in that space, then you ought to be looking worried.

tow21··on There Are More Slaves Today Than at Any Time in Human History
I really don't understand what you're arguing against here.

> Thus slavery in the United States is now illegal, severely increasing the costs and the risks of operating a human trafficking enterprise. That's all that we really can do.<

No, there's quite a lot more we can do. Foreign policy is all about influencing what goes on beyond your own borders.

> I see plenty of things wrong here. Is that $40K USD? Is that $40K USD in today's money or in the value of the dollar in 1850? What does it cost to make a living in Haiti? How far will $100 or $50 US go?

The word "equivalent" in the original article is clearly meant to convey that it's $40k in today's money. (as would even a tiny amount of knowledge of economic history, surely?)

I don't know how far $50 will go on the average Haitian salary, but surely part of his point is that in this case there is a population (visiting American tourists) for whom $50 is disposable income. It was never the case for historic US slavery that the price of a slave was anything less than an investment.

(And slave importation may not be the end goal. Maybe you just want a slave for two weeks while you enjoy your holiday. Is that less reprehensible?)

> Places like India have grown in population since the time of slavery in the United States. I would really like to see numbers based on % of population for these countries rather than raw numbers (and historical percentages for comparison, obviously)

Well, yes, comparative numbers would be interesting. (and I'm fairly sure nobody would be surprised to learn that there is less slavery per head of population than previously - but does that make it any less bad?)

I don't think human misery works on the calculus you're trying to apply. One million people in slavery are going to be fairly unhappy, whether they're embedded in a population of 50 million or 5 billion. If the number of people in slavery is increasing, that's bad, even if it's going down as a percentage.

> Do you really think that any US President is going to wipe out all slavery world-wide within a single term through only foreign policy decisions? Do you even believe that it's possible in the short-term without some sort of war/bloodshed?

Do you really think that's what he's asking for? Do you really think an appropriate alternative is just to shrug your shoulders, put it in historical context and do nothing?

Do you really think that if something can't be fixed immediately, or its fix isn't immediately obvious, we should just not bother thinking about it?

tow21··on Programming: Choosing the right name is everything
Not to detract from the actual point of the article, which is extremely good, but this gem popped out at me:

"Creating a root namespace named after your corporation will haunt you. Companies and brands get renamed, acquired [...] Oracle's Vending Machine division was once Sun Microsystems"

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →