924 karma · joined April 17, 2014
What I don't understand is what's supposed to be uniquely puzzling about strings. Maybe I'm under the influence of the submission, because the guy said he had an allergy for notation. But even after putting a floating point expression in analogy with some geometrical constructs, the whole thing could still be a model of alien gravity, because neither the expression nor the geometric figures carry any inherent meaning in themselves. The only reason why we know that it is in fact just a pure representation of how to approximate real numbers is because the post itself tells us so.
This isn't to say that visualizations aren't useful, of course.
But I sort of agree with the feeling, because it seems like it is that explanation which people fall back to in the absence of any other clue.
No really, they probably do. Archeologists have a love-hate relationship with laymen who hit upon artifacts. On one hand, a find is a find, and local communities can often point out likely archeological sites. On the other, these people might not handle artifacts properly, or fail to take notice of their context to the degree an archeologist might want, like taking notice of the depth at which it was.
Also, your crosswise comparison between an experienced candidate without a degree and an inexperienced candidate with a degree only tells me that you put more weight into experience than having a degree. It really doesn't tell me much about whether a degree is a good signal, but only that it's worse than experience. Now, if you had told me that you don't consider whether a candidate has a degree at all then I'd be able to infer that they are terrible signals and carry no information at all.
Which isn't to say that the issue is unsolvable. But it still needs solving. I don't think anyone has paid much attention to it.
As far as I know, people could get by with a high school degree in the 1970s: there was no significant wage difference between a high school graduate and a college graduate, and both faced similar rates of unemployment. Nowadays employers take for granted that candidates must have some form of qualification, even for positions that don't seem to require it. Has the quality of education fallen and the grades been inflated to such a point where degrees are no longer reliable signals of productivity?
But here's a "nice" graph (the graph is nice, but the trend is worrying): https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS11327662. Labor force participation for college educated workers fell by 3.9 percent points since 2009. This is rather massive compared with the actual unemployment.
I really wish the people at statistics offices would come up with some new measure of unemployment. Sometimes I feel a scalar doesn't cut it.
In the sense that our description of the world always seems to fall short of what it's trying describe? Or in the Gödelian sense of some theorems not being provable in finitely many steps in some particular language? Because as far as I know, the latter isn't really an issue.
I know particularly aggressive pedants made linguistic rules unfashionable, but most of the time they are merely suggestions of how to get the most of language e. g. how to avoid ambiguities and get your meaning across. Sure, they aren't rules in the sense of constraining every single possible manifestation of language. But no one ever thought that. Not even the pedants: instead they believed that they should constrain every possible manifestation, which implies that they believed they don't.
So yeah, I don't think it's a "puritan/evangelical" thing. It's more of a "anything but contemporary urban society" thing.
Which is what I don't understand. Because, as far as I know, firms should engage in product differentiation as long as it's possible.
This seems more like an issue of quality control.
For instance, someone might come to us asking for a text editor. In the absence of additional constraints (e.g. "it should be lightweight", "it should be extensible", "it should be WYSIWYG", etc), there's no unique solution. A unique solution only arises given some sufficient set of constraints. And the discussion will only degenerate into another vim vs Emacs pissing contest if there's any two people in it, one to defend each editor, who aren't keen enough to appreciate this.