HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tpeo

924 karma · joined April 17, 2014

submissionscomments
tpeo··on Firm 'hides' university when recruits apply
Not Gresham's Law per se, as it is specific of money. But what you're describing is essentially a form of adverse selection (see Akerlof's "Market for Lemons"). If employers lower their wage offers below the reservation wage of graduates from prestigious schools, then they would leave the "undifferentiated" job market.

But there might be more to it. Graduates from better schools might still accept job offers if they could hope to get a raise once their true value is discovered.

tpeo··on The cure for procrastination? Forgive yourself
>I think the worst explanation for procrastination I've come across is that it's caused by not truly enjoying the activity that is being procrastinated upon.

I actually believe in this, though it's a somewhat far-fetched conjecture. There is some talk in psychology about "will power" being a scarce resource, though professionals are unsure why. But maybe human brains aren't made for keeping a thought for long. The need to procrastinate then would be like a homeostatic response from the brain saying "these neurons have been firing for too long, shut them off". But whereas diligent people leave for a cup of coffee and some fresh air, the procrastinator keeps the idea at the back of his head and goes check HN.

As for "forgiving youself", it could be something as little as acknowledging that I did indeed spend 40 minutes wikidiving by my own will, and not because of a little demon residing in my head. Low belief in free-will and self-efficacy spoil one's mood.

tpeo··on The yogic claim of voluntary control over the heart beat (1973)
>with the advance of information technology we should see more, not less, of these accomplishments recorded

This is an over sophisticated way to say "no evidence, no thing". I don't intend to defend the existence of big foot (which I think is a silly comparison), but if asked about it I'd rather make no claims about it.

The answer to whether it happened or not is moo.

tpeo··on Humans with Amplified Intelligence Could Be More Powerful Than AI
A "fallacy" would imply some hidden logical error or some loose thought, but this isn't the case: the idea that "great men are important" isn't by itself fallacious. The error lies in denying the contribution of "small men".

Furthermore, even if "small men" are important, why wouldn't they benefit by becoming greater? Instead of waiting on destiny to grant us another Leibniz or another von Neumann, maybe we could harness such powers directly from the source.

That, of course, if it works. Tampering with the brain is certainly one of those things that might have very unintended consequences. What neuronal adaptations wold arise from sticking a chip in someone's brain? For instance, the majority of savants have some sort mental impairment. What if by optimizing for specific skills one might perhaps find it difficult to learn new skills? Or maybe the contrary: optimizing for learning and generalist thinking might not increase computational intelligence, or even reduce it.

tpeo··on Capitalism is a paperclip maximizer
I disagree with much of what was written, but I find it hard to address what seems, to me, more like a long analogy than anything else.

"Capitalism" doesn't maximize "capital", in any sense. The word "capital" generally refers either: to some asset that might be used in production, such as a piece of machinery; or structures that might render services over a time, like buildings; or to some sum which might be used in buying either of these, through financial services.

Now, "capital" wouldn't be maximized by "capitalist" firms. Why should they? Firms produce additional capital units so long as they can be sold above production cost, but they won't produce indefinitely. They are concerned with their profits, not with the amount of product. They aren't even concerned with the products' value, so long as it is above production costs. Hence, there's no incentive to inflate the capital good prices, which would be necessary to maximize the amount of money "capital".

Also, an it really be said that capitalism is an adaptive intelligence system? That, I'm not knowledgeable enough to tell. On the other hand, human interaction is unstructured enough that it seems unlikely that there's any goal to such supposed intelligence, or that it has capital-maximization as it's goal. Rather, I see a collection of different goals, each corresponding to different agents, and some of which might even be contradictory. The noisy neighbor, the ambitious monopolist, or the NIMBY all seek to maximize their private benefit, but often beyond social benefits. Hence I find it hard, whenever markets fail through the presence of either externalities, imperfect competition, or adverse incentives, that it ought nonetheless be the work of some powerful demiurge.

Yet, in so far as it puts into words an anxiety that so many feel, I can't say much else beyond that I don't believe it. The author certainly proceeds by analogy when he likens "capitalism" to an artificial intelligence whose goals themselves mean nothing to humanity at large; and mentions alienating "monuments" to capital, as if to liken it to a 20th century pharaoh, or to cruel tyrant. But since so many feel this is really the case, I have nothing else to say (other than that it's a very vivid picture). I disagree, for instance, that the majority of goods are worthless, as they ought to have some value in order to be sold. Even Marx reckoned this much, and thinking otherwise seems like relying too much in the stupidity of others (which should never be trivially admitted). That would be the case if capital were built beyond all possible utility (say, like a bridge between London and NY). And I don't think it is necessary to make analogies to speak of wealth and income distribution issues, which are real problems in themselves, and which the majority of people are already acquainted with. Rather, I think that such analogies make problems much larger than they ought to be, by giving some monstrous character. Would be it be easier to tackle inequality by conceiving it as a result of an incredibly power artificial intelligence? I don't think so (even if the system is rotten, we'd be waiting on a constructive proof of one that isn't).

tpeo··on Death to Bullshit
I believe this submission vindicates, to some degree, the 'nostalgia' for pre-2012 internet that was so condemned in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9960730
tpeo··on What Is the One Fact Humanity Needs to Know?
There ain't no such a thing as talking people out of a free lunch. Or I don't think so, at least. Even the best of us fall for it.
tpeo··on The Dictionary of Obscure Sorrows
"Maturity".
tpeo··on Why Does Tap Water Go Stale Overnight?
Water from unbaked clay filters feels fresh due to evaporative cooling [0]. Some of the water seeps through the walls and slowly evaporates, cooling the recipient. The magnitude of this effect depends on air humidity. This is the same principle behind a Botijo [1].

I don't know where in the country you're from, but here the water and sanitation department said the water is okay to drink from the tap. Very few if any people do it anyway, as everyone is used to filtered water. Maybe water quality wasn't as good in the past, or as reliable (it still isn't).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evaporative_cooler

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Botijo

tpeo··on Google Is Working on a New Type of Algorithm Called “Thought Vectors”
There were many such attempts since Raymond Lull, and even Descartes toyed the notion for a while, but I'd more readily think of Leibniz's Characteristica Universalis, whose intent was to outright reduce language processing to calculation.
tpeo··on Why Calorie Counts Are All Wrong
This article takes up a common position that calories are "wrong" because, due to our bodies' complex natures, such an arbitrary measure ignores a lot of what is going on. And yet, every time this view is expounded, someone comes up to calories' defense, saying that they are a reliable measure of nutritional energy. So which one is right?

While it is true that calories don't measure the nutritional energy absorbed in any single meal, that would be a trivial proposition. Calories are a statistic, that is, an estimate of an unknown but posited number, and partial representation of an underlying distribution. Saying that calories are "wrong" in this sense would be merely stating that they are possibly wrong. And they would be wrong, if the underlying processes are somehow consistently correlated with each other, which would produce inconsistent and biased estimates of caloric content.

Yet, I don't have any reason to believe that the probability that I buy some potato cultivar today is correlated with the composition of my gut flora three weeks in the future, much less that it would be consistently so. On the contrary, the factors supposedly affecting my nutrition according to biologists are so many, and so diverse, that I might as well appeal to the central limit theorem, in which case calories would be just as a good measure as we can have. If today some potato gives me 166 kcal, and tomorrow 158, and further on 163... I don't see what's the issue. The likelihood of a critical event, such as starvation, due to misreporting of calories or due to some feature of my constitution seems so low that I would only very likely trigger it if I ate nothing but one type of food, in the same quantities, for a long period of time.

Furthermore I will never understand those who prefer no measures to at least one rough measure. No things are created perfect, but only made better. I wonder would have happened it occurred to Eratosthenes that his measure would have been too rough, too imprecise, or too vague for his mind. If all ancient mathematicians were bothered that no "real" triangles were to be found anywhere, mathematics wouldn't have happened at all. By such strict understanding of measure and precision, of course measures fail. They couldn't possibly live up to it. An other example is personality theory, which is said to have been nearly abandoned at it's inception because some psychologists thought of it entirely in terms of archetypes, rather than a general description of probable behavior.

And lastly, if calories have been adequately defended here, then I'll also add that ogling at them in order to find what is wrong with nutrition theory seems completely wrong. We already know about calories, and they are a measure of what we know. Rather than looking at them, we should be looking at the measure of our ignorance, which is the error term. If some calories consistently fail to account for some observations, then it's because no one has looked inside the black box enough to figure out what is going on.

In short, it's a sensational headline. The only people who perhaps should be worrying if calories are "wrong" in the sense of not being accurate to the tenth decimal are Soylent-ers.

tpeo··on Why do ten Chicken McNuggets cost the same as twenty?
Rather, it becomes "revealed preference theory".
tpeo··on Isaac Asimov: The Relativity of Wrong (1989)
Do astronomers perform experiments?

This is the example used in methodological discussions of economics. I don't know if astronomers do actually perform experiments on some limited scale, but it seems that classicaly they relied on "luck" to test predictions e. g. testing general relativity through observations of eclipses. In social sciences, there is a somewhat similar thing called "natural experiment", which is the main test for the validity of predictions. In both cases, the researcher takes a more passive role in testing his predictions.

This can be dauting to researchers, but overall it's for the best. There are indeed experiments in economics, specially in game theory. But the majority of possible experiments would cross the boundary of what is morally acceptable, and well into morally abhorrent e. g. randomly restricting a sample's access to education to estimate it's effects on wages.

tpeo··on China rates its own citizens – including online behaviour
I know this isn't a particularly constructive comment, or even a constructive comment at all, but reality really blows my mind sometimes.
tpeo··on “I paid $25 for an Invisible Boyfriend, and I think I might be in love”
'I could see someone go through the 100 SMS very quickly in a "conversation" where the imaginary person has to answer a bunch of short texts like "yes", "and you", etc.'

Reminds me of the Argument Clinic sketch.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQFKtI6gn9Y#t=79

tpeo··on Things I still can't do in November 2014
There's no guarantee that individual banks will have enough deposits to cover their liabilities, so they first have to wait until the end of the day in order to clear all transactions made and fix any possible deposit shortfalls by operating on the overnight market getting short-term loans, either from the FED or from other banks.

http://www.investopedia.com/terms/o/overnightrate.asp

I'm not saying this is the reason why you can't instantly transfer money around, as there could possibly be a better implementation of such a system that allows consumers to do that. I'm just saying what I know.

tpeo··on On the phenomenon of bullshit jobs
Graeber makes no distinction between "useful" as in: a) creator of exchange value to it's maker; b) creator of utility to it's holder; b) psychologically "meaningful" to the worker. And while the core of the article deals with the latter, by not making this distinction he dangerously suggests the two former.

As much I'd like to believe that managers are stupid, they're not crazy to hand out free money. If an employee generated no additional income to it's employer, there would be no reason to hire him in the first place. Similarly, if the holder of a good derived no enjoyment from it, it would be of no value at all to him.

It's hard to believe, for instance, that a "corporate lawyer's" work has no social value. The job of lawyers isn't even to win legal battles, but to avoid them in the first place. The job of a corporate lawyer is to ensure corporations are compliant with all the paperwork necessary to their operation. For sufficiently large corporations, they're a necessary condition for it's functioning.

For me, the only reason why his argument might seem personally intuitive is because the majority of things in capitalism are of no use at all to any given particular person, even if all of them are "useful" in some way. Paparazzi, dog-washers and all-night pizza deliverymen are useless for all but the people who demand their services. It's not hard to see why consumers would have little interest in contract law if they deal so little with it, and when they do, their job of understanding it has already been cushioned by a specialist.

I see little point in coffee shops. Nonetheless, people flock to places with well-developed service economies that offer such things (e.g. New York, San Francisco) along with dog-washers. Perhaps because they know they'll cater to their bullshit tastes too.

tpeo··on From the World of Design Trends: “Flat Design” Is Dying
I think the graphic design aspect of contemporary UIs isn't as big of a problem as their overall design philosophy. Developers seem to have conflated "minimalism" with "slashing features and hoping no one notices", while suddenly hiding stuff behind clunky menus is hip.
tpeo··on A Leader Struggles to Sell Software Meant to Aid Sales
In microeconomics, there's the concept of a "marginal consumer". When a demand curve is formed, it's so by mapping all the consumers' reserve prices (i.e. the maximum they're willing to pay for a product) on the y-axis and the quantities demanded on the x-axis (so the first guy is willing to pay $100 for 1 unit, the next one $98 for 1 unit, etc). The marginal consumer is the guy whose reserve price is exactly the the market price of whatever good we're talking about. So whenever the price of that good goes up, he stops buying it.

Now, if reserve prices correlate to the urgency and magnitude of consumer needs, the majority of consumers would be the guys who buy on a whim (if the demand curve is steep enough). They don't buy it because they want to, but rather because they need to.

tl;dr deong is right

P.S. If this still seems counterintuitive, consider that a customer asking too many questions doesn't necessarily signal he's interested in it. On the contraty, it could be that the more clueless he is, the more likely he is to ask questions as he didn't do any research in the first place. Example/anedoctal "evidence": Whenever I bought computer parts, for instance, it was mostly a silent trade, because I've picked them all beforehand. The only things I asked about were those I didn't bother to research.

tpeo··on A Buddhist monk confronts Japan’s suicide culture (2013)
If the first step to suicide were ideation, which is usually the result of prolonged psychological isolation, then wartime simply can't provide the proper enviroment for it.

During a war everyone huddles together trying to survive, and social and familial ties could become strong enough that even the thought of suicide would seem offensive, as if one were abandoning friends and family to their own luck. And when you have people running around shouting orders, bullets flying and bombs falling there's simply not enough time to think about anything else.

What people seem to dread being is left to themselves, not their conditions. Which is why only reason why war has ever had any defenders, aside from bureaucrats: it gives "purpose" to men.

Recently enough, Ars ran an article on a study (10.1126/science.1250830), which I'm not sure how appropriate is to the discussion of suicide, but sums up this point quite well:

In 11 studies, we found that participants typically did not enjoy spending 6 to 15 minutes in a room by themselves with nothing to do but think, that they enjoyed doing mundane external activities much more, and that many preferred to administer electric shocks to themselves instead of being left alone with their thoughts. Most people seem to prefer to be doing something rather than nothing, even if that something is negative.

tpeo··on An Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments
The "argument from fallacy" is sadly missing.
tpeo··on The Indie Bubble Is Popping
"the cold, hard-hearted hand of Adam Smith"

Adam Smith was a lovely fellow and a gentleman, you must be thinking of Thomas Malthus.

← PreviousPage 14 of 14