HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tpeo

924 karma · joined April 17, 2014

submissionscomments
tpeo··on The Kolmogorov option
Putting Damore's stuff aside for a while (I haven't even read it yet), reasonably discussing anything and having some sort of "Bohm dialogue" is one of the hardest things in the world. Not only it takes quite a bit of mental effort, but it's also easily disrupted.

The loudest and most obnoxious people in the room can very well misrepresent or ignore whatever you said, take a few bits of it and use it to build their own straw-man to bash. It's as if they weren't satisfied enough to just talk/shout past you, but also feel the need to climb over you and make you their soapbox. And it takes a bit of rhetorical smarts to defuse or avoid this sort of stuff, whereas the people who are in favor of actual discussion tend to be a bit naïve when it comes to rhetoric.

Academics, for instance, are often in danger of being eaten alive by the public if their research is even a little bit controversial. In my opinion, all because of this.

tpeo··on The Kolmogorov option
Indeed, it probably doesn't. Thanks for the link, by the way.
tpeo··on The Kolmogorov option
As I said, I also believe it's much more common. I meant "odd" in the sense that it might lead to unintuitive situations if we only consider the preferences of the people involved. For instance, there might be situations where not a single person in the room might be in favor of the status quo, but not a single one of them dares to say it either, all out of fear that one of the others might be.

Of course, it isn't "odd" if we also consider the incentives involved.

tpeo··on The Kolmogorov option
Besides ideological self-righteousness, Aaronson left out one important component of oppressive regimes, which I think is actually far more important: it takes a relatively large amount of people to topple a regime, while small groups as well as individuals do nothing but expose themselves by rebelling. So no individual with any regard for his own personal safety has any incentive to rebel, and will instead go along with the flow for as long as it's tolerable to him.

But this, on the other hand, would create an odd situation where actually the vast majority of people might actually wish for rebellion, but none of them actually acts out on that wish. Which I also think is actually much more likelier than what he's putting forward. True crusaders are rare, most of people are "just following orders".

tpeo··on ‘My sister says I am an alien’: 9-yr-old applies for planetary protection job
Hey, have a little fun.
tpeo··on When Will the Tech Bubble Burst?
Now I've realized what I thought was so funky. It's a rather semantic issue.

Markets aren't just a pipe or a screen where stuff goes through, at least in economics. The market isn't just the market mechanism, but rather that mechanism plus the collection of all possible buyers and sellers at any given time. If all we have is Sally and Bob talking over the phone with their portfolios in stocks and cash, that's the market.

Now, you're right that no money entered the market when Bob bought that share. But if someone who had no interest in either buying or selling stock handed either Bob or Sally $11, that would be $11 going into the market. If Bob took those $11 as a loan from Chad while Chad himself had no interest whatsoever in what Bob would do with it as long as he paid them back, that would be money going into the market.

Also, I reckon I changed my initial position. But I'm also rather drowsy right now.

tpeo··on When Will the Tech Bubble Burst?
I'm having a hard time understanding why you'd say that the net cash flow is zero. If a person who previously owned no stock buys a share from another person at a price above it's current market price, that's a net cash flow.

Buy bids/orders being matched with sell orders/bids would imply zero net cash flows only if prices were constant.

tpeo··on When Will the Tech Bubble Burst?
I think I've read somewhere that once newspapers report some piece of financial news, it's no longer news.

Anyway, it seems like sound advice.

tpeo··on There Have Always Existed People Who’ve Simply Wanted to Be Alone
I've seen a similar usage of the expression "social creatures" ("social animals") before, and it bothers me. Firstly, because I've known several loners who would take issue with what's being suggested.

But secondly, because the expression originally implied nothing of the sort, and still doesn't in biological jargon (which I believe is where it is/was most commonly used).

It was Aristotle who first used the expression "ζῷον πολιτικόν", and he used it to mean that humans exist in large ordered agglomerations as a matter of fact [0]. He also included bees and ants among the "political animals", but I don't think he ever said anything about any of them wanting company for it's own sake. And, at least in the beginning of his Politics, neither does he suggest that humans want it for it's own sake, either. Biologists, on the other hand, still use that expression with a meaning similar to that of Aristotle (animals who happen to live together), while including other groups [1].

Now, this wouldn't be a problem if in common language these expressions merely meant something else than what they do in biology, or what they mean in Aristotelian exegesis. That would be fine. But instead it seems as if the usage in common language relies on the usage in learned contexts to do a little bit of semantic sleight-of-hand, and suggest something else than what was originally meant e.g. "Humans have an inherent need for company: Biologists say we're 'social animals'".

Otherwise, the statement would have no authority behind it in common language. Instead, it would be just an unfounded assertion. In fact, that there are people who disagree with it already suggests that it is, at least, ill-founded. These are the people saying "No, we don't". But instead, readers are nudged by the usage in learned contexts to take it for granted, without further justification.

Either way, it's a bit like when someone conflates term "observer", as it is used in physics, with the term as it is used in common language to suggest that people can walk through walls if they wish hard enough.

[0] http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_animal

tpeo··on The Economic Lives of Animals
> Even John Maynard Keynes, the father of modern economics, attributed our irrational choices to “animal spirits.”

Yeah, there's an equivocation in this reference. The "animal" in "animal spirits" doesn't refer to non-human lifeforms, rather it means "of or relating to a soul". The expression itself is an obsolete medical term which designated what people from late antiquity to the modern period thought was the cause of bodily movement.

By the early 20th century, it had become a somewhat quaint and tongue-in-cheek expression. To say that someone was "full of animal spirits" was to say that a person was lively, restless, or something like that.

There's without doubt a conflict between rationality and irrationality in Keynes' usage of it. But that conflict isn't alluded to through a reference to "animals", in the contemporary sense.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_spirits_(Keynes)

https://neurophilosophy.wordpress.com/2006/11/16/exorcising-...

tpeo··on Algorithm That Makes Preschoolers Obsessed with YouTube
As much as I agree, notice that it sort of defeats the point of it all if the they have to sit there with their child.

It ain't easy being a parent, a 9 to 5 worker and a household manager within a 24h schedule. If parents leave their children to do some mindless thing while unnatended, it's often because they don't have enough time to give attention to all the stuff which is immediatelly pressing them.

tpeo··on The 'creepy Facebook AI' story that captivated the media
I wouldn't go as far as calling it either terrorism or Luddism. Because, frankly, it doesn't seem like they care.

It's just sensationalism.

tpeo··on Darpa Wants to Build a BS Detector for Science
Do the best we can to dismiss them as irrelevant while simultaneously using them to argue that the project needs additional funding.

As in "The project is fine! We just need to work out this thing".

tpeo··on [dead]
Funding criminal activities comes to mind as an immediate use.
tpeo··on Age of Empires: Definitive Edition Beta
Why do you say so? The original AoE always struck me as kind of clunky, specially because of the atrocious path-finding. But I never actually played it in multiplayer.
tpeo··on The Evolution of Trust
I ran through it. I didn't suggest he didn't cover it. I just used it as a trivial example, because other readers supposedly also ran through it. Some other commenter suggested communication between agents as an extension, I could've used that if I knew what results from it.
tpeo··on The Evolution of Trust
The little animated chums strike me be as a bit too cute.

One has to take care to not anthropomorphize models. Even models ostensibly created to model aspects of human behavior, such game theoretic models.

Anthropomorphism might induce people either to think there's more under the hood than there actually is, and thus lead them to a hold a wrong mental representation of the model, or to naively assume that it's conclusions are robust to specification changes by making the conclusions a bit too familiar, even though even somewhat simple model extensions might significantly change their behavior (e.g. going from single to repeated games, which makes cooperatives strategies viable).

Comparing tit-for-tat strategies with the Golden rule, while mixing in references toe the Christmas truce somehow seems to go in the opposite direction of being cautious regarding model interpretation.

tpeo··on The quitting economy
Frankly, I think that in order for something to "touch on labor markets quite a bit", they'd have to at least dedicate a book to it. In the current day, David Card and Orley Ashenfelter might be said to have touched on labor markets quite a bit.

Hayek and Friedman? Not so much.

tpeo··on It will be much harder to call findings ‘significant’ if a team gets its way
I agree, publication bias is a thing. There's no questioning that.
tpeo··on It will be much harder to call findings ‘significant’ if a team gets its way
Don't be disingenuous. That would require someone to actually read their papers, which would already be a net loss and a massive waste of time for everyone involved. Not to mention the amount of department politics which could be involved in this issue.

Look, not every paper is worth publishing. There are many ways to write noise that can pass for signal given the reader's level of understanding (e.g. crack pottery and "fashionable nonsense"). The usage of p-values implements self-filtering to some degree, and makes everyone better off by increasing the likelihood that at least some papers aren't complete nonsense. And that's good.

The only issue is that it is a much weaker constraint on publishing than it was previously thought.

tpeo··on It will be much harder to call findings ‘significant’ if a team gets its way
What's the point of fitting arbitrary functions to noise? Because that's what high p-values would lead to.

Undue emphasis on p-values is bad, but what you're suggesting is bonkers.

tpeo··on The quitting economy
Would you mind if I told you that you're not even wrong?

First, neither Hayek nor Friedman were well known for contributions to labor market research. Hayek was well known for his critiques of central planning while Friedman was famous for his contributions to monetary theory. But my point is that these guys aren't "labor market economists", so taking an issue with them over labor market issues would be barking up the wrong tree.

Plus, I don't see why "pure theory" should push anyone anywhere: constraints on model-building are actually quite weak. On the other hand, labor market models haven't become more like consumer goods market models over the years. If anything, the opposite has happened: labor markets are unique among other markets because of stuff like human capital, efficiency wages, signalling, gift exchange, searching costs, internal labor markets, non-cognitive abilities, poaching externalities, hedonic benefits of work, etc. This list isn't exhaustive.

There are very fair and well-documented economic reasons why present day firms might want to put more money into their employees than a 19th century landowner hiring day-laborers during harvest would. Firms benefit from having (and keeping!) a skilled and well-motivated labor force, and so they act accordingly. Trying to look "beyond" economics if you haven't heard of any of those is just looking past it.

tpeo··on Agents that imagine and plan
Well, nobody is forced to create models they don't believe in.

But besides some models being useful, as that old adage says, some are also useful-er than others. Adding stuff such as "imagination" functions as a constraint on the number of behavioral patterns that we are willing to consider, and that might lead us to find that one which we're looking for (i.e. "intelligent behavior") faster than a naïve approach.

Besides, it might not be the case that the likelihood of observing "intelligent behavior" increases over the complexity of the behavior generating process.

tpeo··on How Did Anyone Do Math in Roman Numerals?
It really isn't that ambiguous in cursive, though. When writing out "dx" as product in cursive, the "d" and "x" characters are written separately. When writing "dx" as an infinitesimal, the characters are connected. Never had any issue with higher degree derivatives, either.

But I see how it can be confusing with printed characters. I guess Leibniz just took ligatures for granted when he came up with his stuff.

tpeo··on Why Cutting Carbs Is So Tough
I don't think the usage of "rate" here meant the ease of converting sugar from some particular source into blood glucose, but rather how much of blood glucose is used up by the body per unit of time.

The issue wouldn't be so much that a coke has a large amount of sugar compared to expected blood glucose levels, but rather whether that can of coke puts a person in a caloric surplus. At any point in time there might be some glucose either coming in or coming out of our bloodstream. Expected blood glucose levels don't tell us much about that. For instance, two people might have the same blood glucose levels but two completely different energetic requirements due to differing levels of physical activity.

At least, that's what I get from the post you're responding to. Mind you, I don't think that a calorie is a calorie: consuming shitloads of sugar might be bad for anyone for other reasons besides inducing caloric surpluses, so energy sources aren't perfect substitutes for one another. But I don't see what insight is to be gained from the relationship between the amount of sugar in a coke can and average blood glucose levels either.

tpeo··on Plenty, Indoor Farming Startup, Raises $200M
I don't think growing staples within cities will be economically viable within our lifetimes. As a general rule, agricultural land use orders itself around it's markets according to transportation. The more delicate the produce, the closer the producers must be to a city. There's even a (very simple, it's from the 19th century) model for this, which is the Von Thünen's model of land use.

I wish I had some actual data easy at hand to show you, but this is more or less observable from history. Until active refrigeration, spoilage losses associated with the more delicate agricultural products pretty much put them outside of the reach of the majority of urban dwellers. If you wanted any sort of fresh dairy, fresh meat, fresh vegetables or fresh fruit in say, the early 19th century, you'd better live on a farm. So whereas a farmer might have had fresh milk, a city worker would have cheese, and instead of fresh meat, cured meat, and so on.

But anyway, in short of the whole world becoming one huge city, it's unlikely that staples would ever be grown inside them.

tpeo··on NBC News launches a twice-daily Snapchat news broadcast
Don't know, man. Every time part of the establishment (i.e. everything that's already out there and have already made a name for themselves) tries to reach out for the younger crowd it makes itself more démodé, not less so.

I've never used Snapchat, though. So I don't know whether this is cool or uncool by their community's standards.

tpeo··on Google relaunches Glass for businesses
I think he meant that Glass was a dev kit, which is fair enough. But it intended to be eventually released as a consumer product. Somewhere along that path, the idea lost it's charm to the execs at Google.
tpeo··on Google relaunches Glass for businesses
Oh, I see.

To be fair, there might be some more productivity gains lurking around the corner if augmented reality allows a tighter integration of each process in the factory line.

Any time lost involving searching anything in the factory floor could be reduced with augmented reality by peppering the world with "quest markers".

Besides the 10% gain on searching which parts of the engine you're supposed to either screw in or unscrew out, there might be a gain when searching your wrench, when searching Joe, when trying to find out where exactly the new parts are and so on.

tpeo··on Google relaunches Glass for businesses
Low knowledge tasks aren't a bottleneck in contemporary manufacturing though, at least in so far as "low knowledge" correlates with being easily automated.

Tightening a screw or riveting a steel frame for example require little knowledge, but on the other hand they're easily automated. Or rather, more easily automated than reassembling and disassembling an engine.

← PreviousPage 6 of 14Next →