HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tpeo

924 karma · joined April 17, 2014

submissionscomments
tpeo··on Google relaunches Glass for businesses
That was my reaction... about 3 to 4 years ago when I saw the Epson Moverio BT-100 engine maintenance training demonstration (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eVV5tUmky6c). It's not as sleek as Glass, but it's in the same spirit.

Point being that Google isn't quite breaking new ground by selling augmented reality to businesses. Rather, it seems that they're trying to make the most out their Glass product now that it tanked as a consumer product.

tpeo··on Show HN: Thoughtwriter – a digital whiteboard for your thoughts
Well, I'd make them more specific to the task I'm trying to solve. For instance, if I had to write what was the results of some paper and what is it's contribution to my field in 1000 characters or less, I'd make that my writing prompt.

Other than that, if I'm not trying to actually tackle something important I'd probably try to use them in goofy ways, such as writing ones with "are you done yet?" or "memento mori".

That, or use them as post-it notes.

tpeo··on Trying Soylent didn’t go well
I'm not keen on Soylent either, but I think you're forgetting about the micro nutrients. Macro nutrients are rather easy to get on the cheap, but micro nutrients can be somewhat of a hassle.
tpeo··on Show HN: Thoughtwriter – a digital whiteboard for your thoughts
Is the stuff in the dashboard(e.g "5w+h") supposed to be writing prompts?

If so, rather neat. Have you considered making them modifiable?

tpeo··on Death of a Pig (1948)
Even if it wasn't erysipelas, they didn't know what it was. Eating the pig could've been fine if they at least were able to tell what is it that it had and whether it was infectious or not.

Eating animals whose cause of death is unknown is usually not a sound decision.

tpeo··on AI Is Inventing Languages Humans Can’t Understand. Should We Stop It?
Somehow this doesn't seem like a desirable property in a language. One of the purposes of (human? inter-sentient?) languages is the reliable transmission of information. Verbosity and repetition in language have a purpose similar to that of redundancy in engineering: they ensure that if someone misses out a part of the message, the whole message isn't ruined.

If your message being get across is predicated on successfully transmitting an arbitrarily large sequence of symbols where every one of them might be crucial (supposing that word frequency is inversely proportional to meaningfulness, which is rather reasonable), this "talking" thing would get hard pretty fast.

tpeo··on How economics became a religion
There are observations. Just go to http://data.worldbank.org if you want some. My point was that people in deparments aren't the ones making them.
tpeo··on How economics became a religion
Why would they talk about data?

Data collection in economics is often very much outside the scope of economics departments. Not only because it's beyond the budgets of individual departments to maintain the necessary personnel, but because it's hard to get people to disclose that sort of information. That task falls mostly on the lap of government and international organizations, who have the sort of legitimacy to pull that off. Besides that, there's experimental data, surveys sent out to private organizations and private (closed) databases. But the majority of the data used in econ deparments was produced elsewhere.

If what you wanted to hear someone talk about "measuring the flow of money", you'd probably be better off in some Federal Reserve bank.

tpeo··on Quirks of the arXiv
I'm on the opposite camp. Nothing makes me groan so deeply as dialogues. And I know I'm not alone either: plenty of people are bored out of Plato because of the dialogic writing, specially because every other line amounts to nothing more than "Why, indeed Socrates...".

Don't get me wrong. I like Plato (quite a bit). But dialogues seem as approachable to me as poetry. They might be approachable in the sense that, since they simulate a conversation between two people who might not know eachother, they necessarily lead to a much clearer exposition of whatever is the topic at hand. It's indeed as if you were reading two people try to make their ideas across when they're complete strangers eachother. But it takes completely different kind of "reading" from the one a person might use when reading prose or when reading a pure exposition.

Two cents.

tpeo··on My Father’s Weakness for Beer Never Lessened His Strengths
Yeah, I don't think you're an alcoholic.

It might be because I come from a wet culture. Which is to say one where having a beer over lunch isn't (or wasn't) frowned upon. But 4 beers a day is completely manageable.

Doctors have been trying to tally up how many beers it takes until someone is an "alcoholic", but IMHO they're far off the mark. Because as it is, it's quite easy to tally up enough standard drinks to become a medically defined "alcoholic", or to enter some similar classification ("heavy drinker"?), without ever experiencing any clear behavioral or physiological issues (e.g. not diverting money from needs to drink, not being a nuisance to yourself or others, absence of seizures upon cessation of intake).

Even the idea of a "standard drink" is rather lousy: 4 shots of vodka doesn't equal 4 beers. The amount of alcohol per volume matters, and the higher the relative volume of alcohol, the faster it hits you and the more easily one might develop dependence.

In short, you're more or less fine. Unless you're downing a fifth of vodka every day, in which case you might want to cut down a bit.

tpeo··on “You filthy-minded little pervert” error when registering obscene .to domains
Not quite so. Farmers don't have to reassure their cows that they care about them. Plus they do care, even if for completely selfish reasons.
tpeo··on What libraries lost when they threw out the card catalog
What do you mean by "in the long run"? Because a library being rendered unusable for a definite length of time wouldn't be a problem in the long run unless we're talking about a system with path dependence. And even if there is some path dependence, it's not quite obvious whether or not that's a major problem. For example, not being able to lend a book during a few hours could be only thing preventing some terminally-ill genius from solving some elusive mathematical problem before he dies, while everyone else can just try to check their books some other day when the power is back on. But so long as the problem can be solved, the solution might be found out later on by someone else.

On the other hand, if libraries are rendered unusable for an indefinite amount of time, or if they become so unreliable that they aren't even worth the effort, those would always be an issue regardless of whether there's path-dependence.

But it sounds somewhat far-fetched to create system to ensure the reliability of libraries in the event of say, a massive solar flare. Plus, it misses the point: in the event of something able to take out something crucial to the entire US library system for any appreciable length of time, the librarians themselves would most likely have far more pressing concerns in their hands. And that would be our new single point of failure.

I pretty much agree with scottLobster. Unless we're talking about developing countries, where electric power is not so much intermitent as unreliable - whereas it might take a hurricane to cause power outages in other countries, a gush of wind here will do - it makes sense to have a system like this in place.

tpeo··on What libraries lost when they threw out the card catalog
Redundancy is actually a good argument for maintaining a library card system along with a digital system. Don't know why the author let that one fly by.
tpeo··on The Lost Art of Manually Calculating Square Roots
Why would he do that, though? I do think it's neat, but I think most people would just memorize an algorithm instead.

Were any memory tricks involved (e.g. pegs, palaces) or did he just go through a table of square roots every morning?

tpeo··on The 1863 edition of the “Dictionnaire Infernal” is the stuff of nightmares
I don't know how much of the stuff associated with ceremonial magic can be called "christian mythology", since most of it was only attested pretty late, between the 15th and 17th centuries, at a time when Christianity was already pretty well established in Europe. Plus, it didn't enjoy widespread currency. Partially because it implied unlawful practices under both Church and local laws. But either way, it's much too restricted to be called a "mythology".

"Christian mythology" would be more along the lines of folk tales concerning the Virgin Mary and the saints, the Tetramorph, the hierarchies of angels and the Great Chain of Being.

tpeo··on Math education: It’s not about numbers, it’s about learning how to think
The issue is that being able to see that little path of logical steps is a skill on it's own, and most students don't know even how to begin approaching a new mathematical problem.
tpeo··on In the Memory Ward: The Warburg is Britain’s most eccentric and original library
I'm torn between whether this is cool or just massively irresponsible. Couldn't they just stock the shelves with fac similes and keep original editions for archival purposes?
tpeo··on Exercise should be kept to a healthy minimum
Depends on what kind of programming or reading. Writing out boilerplate code or just skimming text don't seem to require much brain power. Neither does a task which one is so used to that it becomes "effortless".
tpeo··on A reality check for virtual headsets
Sounds like you might have some stories to tell.
tpeo··on Amazon engineer will let strangers manage his $50,000 stock portfolio 'forever'
I don't see why they'd bother.
tpeo··on A reality check for virtual headsets
Well, I didn't say they were comparable. I just sort of pointed out they existed.

Current generation video game consoles are also incomparable to Pong. But hey, that's the difference between 1st and 8th generation consoles.

tpeo··on A reality check for virtual headsets
These aren't 1st generation products. There has already been a VR craze, back in the 1990s.
tpeo··on This Is How People Make Money Out of Thin Air Thanks to the Internet
Yea, I don't think novelty is quite the exploitable niche though. The uncertainty regarding whether or not something might become some sort of fad is way larger than whether or not some app with a clear use and target demographic might become at least ramen profitable, if not successful.

Plus, there's no clear inference from successful novelty goods or services to what other possible novelty stuff. Someone might make a better text editor than the ones currently out there. But can anyone improve on the Pet Rock?

It's a quite hard problem.

tpeo··on The third thumb
That argument only makes sense if your utility function were either monotonic and non-decreasing over arms or if it were monotonic and non-decreasing over a combination of arms and other things (e.g. legs?). Are you sure you'd always prefer having more arms?

I mean, I don't know about you, but I think most people would stop short of becoming a hecatoncheir. At best those extra arms would be useless, but in the worst case scenario you could be punished by the gods for your hubris. Either that, or be banished to Tartarus by Zeus.

tpeo··on There is a huge 'monolith' on Phobos, one of Mars's moons
This is a huge wake-up call for everyone here on Earth: if you still haven't either watched Kubrick's Odyssey or read the books, you're missing out.
tpeo··on Impossibly Hungry Judges
Maybe they're trying to minimize the number of hours needed to go through the cases yet to be decided. So whenever some free time comes up, they're able to go through that backlog easily.

It could also be that, just as in medicine, harder cases are more relevant than easier cases. If the amount of effort each side puts into their case has any positive relationship with the value with what is at stake, solving harder cases first would free up whatever is at stake and make it available to society again.

tpeo··on The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else
Aren't you overshooting what you mean by linking to that paper? Treating some physical processes as computational processes might lead to some intractable problems, but it also might lead so some insights. Aaronson's section on space seems like an example of this.

Neither is an issue that some way of thinking might raise more questions than it answers. Actually, if any of those questions is both interesting and solvable, that is a virtue.

tpeo··on The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else
Computing a heuristic is doing computation, though.
tpeo··on The Brain as Computer: Bad at Math, Good at Everything Else
Would that be really an issue, though?

At least in so far as living macroscopic beings are concerned, they're all doing computation of some sort by processing environmental information and using the results to produce behavior. They're about as good at math as any other computer programmed to reproduce those algorithms.

So long as "processing" information isn't the same as actually producing that behavior, as in the case of crystal growth, they're doing something besides what they're doing.

Though I'd prefer to think that crystals are actually doing math too, but they're so good they don't even need to think about it.

_______________________________________________________

>Therefore the sage goes about doing nothing, teaching no-talking.

>The ten thousand things rise and fall without cease,

>Creating, yet not possessing.

>Working, yet not taking credit.

>Work is done, then forgotten.

>Therefore it lasts forever.

tpeo··on Popular stomach acid blockers linked to higher death rates
Only if the choice between PPI and H2 blockers is random. If there's some self-selection going on, there isn't much to say about PPI's impact on patient health given what we know about H2.
← PreviousPage 7 of 14Next →