This is a really good bug and nobody should downplay it.
426,829 karma · joined November 1, 2007
Helu! I'm Thomas.
thomas@sockpuppet.org
t@tk.inc
(Don't apologize for contacting me! I'm happy to meet you.)
Daily follow list: 'jcranmer, 'rgovostes, 'pvg, 'rgovostes, 'lisper, 'kentonv, 'DannyBee, 'JumpCrisscross, 'kasey_junk, 'tzs, 'dctoedt, 'idlewords, 'carbocation (many others who don't post often enough to call out like this).
All comments Copyright © 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2015, 2018, 2023, 2031 Thomas H. Ptacek, All Rights Reserved.
This is a really good bug and nobody should downplay it.
The only interesting thing I can tell you about interfacing with law enforcement is that it's pretty funny to authenticate law enforcement people (they can't just give you a phone number to call them at).
I have no idea what this is about. Sorry, you're not going to get any tea from me on it!
A thing I wish more people would do: ask prospective cloud hosting companies "is there a mode of this offering where my workloads might share a kernel with other tenants I don't trust, as would be the case with Docker?", and if the answer to that question is ever "yes", disqualify the provider.
Firecracker doesn't require bare metal, but (1) you want it for performance and efficiency at scale and (2) you take a security hit for nesting.
Generally, the less your OS can do, apart from strictly hypervising guest operating systems, the safer you probably are. Hence why people do things like seL4.
I'm certainly not telling you to use Xen. I wouldn't use Xen for anything untrusted.
I think "hardware" vs. "software" is the wrong way to frame this. The big difference is between shared-kernel multitenant and guest kernels. gVisor (in some configurations) is like an 80% solution; a partially emulated guest kernel. I think the verdict is in on shared-kernel vs. not: don't share kernels between tenants.
The hardware isolation itself --- AMD-V, VT-X, &c --- has held up for almost 2 decades now. You never know, of course, but if you were going to place a bet it probably wouldn't be on hardware isolation failing before software did.
And then, of course, L4s live in millions and millions of shipped products, which is a reason to consider L4 instead of something novel, but I'm not saying you should or shouldn't.
Crucially, this happens in the middle of packet processing, so the kernel code is forced to work with two different ideas of how long the IPv4 header is. All hell predictably breaks loose.
The reason more companies don't use IQ tests is that they don't work well for candidate qualification. Also, candidates hate them.