HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tritium

395 karma · joined May 14, 2014

submissionscomments
tritium··on Net Neutrality: Time to Use Mesh Networks to Build Your Own Internet?
The difference between random corporate people and random people is slim, and usually little more than the incentive of the paycheck as a token to turn a blind eye, and focus on a limited abstract task that lacks a value greater than the total potential paycheck offered, when the fruits of the task are taken in isolation.

Depending on the organization, a business may or may not adhere to this sort of practice. And yes, it’s still people mystery meat, behind the veil of nearly any business.

tritium··on Net Neutrality: Time to Use Mesh Networks to Build Your Own Internet?
I see that you have your own opinions, and that you’re emotionally invested in them.

The basic premise of your argument is that this is the best we can do for now, so that should be acceptable. Not unlike claiming “If you can’t create a painting better than The Mona Lisa yourself, you just have to admit that it’s your favorite painting.”

My mind hasn’t been changed, especially by mere flak that lacks constructive arguments. People may disagree with me freely, but that doesn’t fix the holes I’ve pointed out in existing technology that mesh networks still leave open.

tritium··on UK Cops Want to Use AI to Spot Child Abuse But It Mistakes Desert Pics for Nudes
Oh, ha! Awesome! I was killing time on my phone, without full debug options, and from the looks of the site, I figured maybe they were being extra cute.
tritium··on UK Cops Want to Use AI to Spot Child Abuse But It Mistakes Desert Pics for Nudes
But... I... I just want to know the answers. That reset quiz button... It’s... Why?
tritium··on Net Neutrality: Time to Use Mesh Networks to Build Your Own Internet?
Before I start trusting random people running mesh nodes to provide me with internet service, I’ll need to see a clear demonstration of some kind of defensive posture for trusting traffic in such a situation.

After all, I think some lessons have been taught by free, open wi-fi offered by cafes.

Is SSL/TLS enough? Probably not for less technical people who can be socially engineered into trusting a malicious root CA because they just want internet.

Is TOR worth anything? Oh, I still feel like it’s pretty laughable that exit nodes operate on an honor system of not snooping on plain-text traffic. From where does one summon the mental gymnastics necessary to go along with that?

I’m not sure why I should just feel comfortable about letting any peer’s node handle my traffic. Feels like a handy-wavey “Brad & Chad” brogrammer move.

tritium··on A Key Lesson from the 1918 Flu Pandemic? 'Tell the Truth,' One Historian Says
The 2014 ebola outbreak is, I think, really, the closest we’ve come to this kind of true fear (since 1918) of a fast-acting deadly illness, capable of killing within days, and frighteningly accidentally infectious.

I can’t speak to much of anything happening outside the U.S. prior to 1970, but if I’ve ever experienced anything that seems like a reasonable pairing with the 1918 pandemic, that’s the only thing that comes to mind.

I remember the news of it emerging in just a few weeks, and hearing level-headed people commenting that this thing seemed to be turning into “quite a thing” and when reasonable people raise an eyebrow, it really magnifies the gravity of an anxiety that just immerses you in this sort of fatiguing alertness, to say the least.

You’re excited, but at a time when there’s no urgency to act, and you wonder if that might be your last error: failing to recognize what that all-important warning sign was to be, or was supposed to have been. Is it time to panic yet? How will I know if it is?

The flu is just this typical sort of seasonal thing, for as long as I’ve been alive. But I imagine what the ebola outbreak felt like, is a stone’s throw from what the 1918 pandemic really became in the sense of a social atmosphere worthy of the fear it produced.

tritium··on The Death of Flash and Rewriting 1.4M Lines of Code
True. However, depending on the manner of licensing applicable to a given project, one might be forced comply with aspects of the protection a given license affords.

So then the choice leaves one working with intellectual property controlled by people who might ignore offers to improve their project, but in the same breath, demand attribution for the burden they inflict.

Why bother playing the sycophant to an emperor with no clothes?

tritium··on I Know What You Download on BitTorrent
This intimidation tactic fails to intimidate.

Many of the subjective “us” remain recalcitrant.

tritium··on Faster Progress Bars: Manipulating Perceived Duration with Augmentations (2010)
Is there any reason you’d advocate writing “typical” software?
tritium··on The Death of Flash and Rewriting 1.4M Lines of Code
The problem with “contributing” to a project that belongs to someone else, is that your contributions might be handily ignored, no matter how incredible and wonderful they may be.

And so, often, the only recourse to such an outcome is to roll your own from scratch.

tritium··on Faster Progress Bars: Manipulating Perceived Duration with Augmentations (2010)
No thanks. I'm not interested in the manipulation of perception.

I'd like a progress bar to actually report on progress. If you can't do that, don't feed me bullshit blinking lights, and pat yourself on the back. Just tell which part is hanging up, so I can either clear the bottleneck, route around it or throw everything in the trash.

I'm torn at this point, about which non-progress bars I hate more these days, Apple's or Microsoft's. Windows used to have the most useless progress bars:

https://www.xkcd.com/612/

But Apple system updates for OS X are possibly much, much worse. Reporting 20 minutes and taking 90, opaque, inching along pixel by pixel, and not telling you anything about what's slow, or whether there are parts to the process. Just one stupid line, and if it fails in the middle, start over. Is it unzipping, checking the integrity of file hashes, connecting to the internet, not connecting and waiting for a time-out, compiling open-source packages for this particular chip set?

One thing's for sure, I've been promised so many minutes, and instead lost hours.

tritium··on A New Form of Matter, Excitonium
Depends, what does ELI5 mean?

  When an electron, seated at the edge of a 
  crowded-with-electrons valence band in a 
  semiconductor, gets excited and jumps over 
  the energy gap to the otherwise empty 
  conduction band, it leaves behind a “hole” 
  in the valence band. That hole behaves as 
  though it were a particle with positive 
  charge, and it attracts the escaped 
  electron. When the escaped electron with 
  its negative charge, pairs up with the hole, 
  the two remarkably form a composite particle, 
  a boson.
So, it is something else entirely, after this whole process completes. It is transformed from being an electron, and is no longer an electron.

Electrons are Leptons, not Bosons.

The electron is transformed into a different thing, after it jumps out of its hole, only to land back in the hole it jumped out of.

When they made an electron jump out of it's valence shell, and then permitted it to bounce back into the void it left behind, landing back in the slot changes it enough that it's no longer an electron.

Apparently the orbit it resumes is different enough to be detected with instrumentation, which actually is pretty interesting, and probably matters in terms of optimizing materials for solid-state applications.

I can't tell if it's just that these are temporary ripples in the valence field that eventually resolve themselves, and that it's just a mild technicality, to be able to notice that the jumping electrons don't immediately meld back into their cloud, and that on paper, and due to mathematical descriptions, this "qualifies" the rebounded electron as "no-longer-an-electron" until it resumes a normal harmonious "orbit" with the atom's general electron cloud? (AKA: "decays back into an electron" in technical terms)

How does this kind of boson transition back to an ordinary electron? How long does that take? How often does this happen in nature? What does this mean in the grand scheme of things? Is the entire world, nay, universe, slowly and irrevocably transforming all electrons into these things forever? How come the all the world's electrons haven't completely decayed into these sorts of bosons by now? Is this really very significant, or is it just a tidbit of technical trivia that persists for less than a few units of planck time?

The article does not answer such questions.

tritium··on Lightning makes new isotopes
Hacker News downvotes are to be ignored as pedantry at best. Imagine the level of discomfort inflicted by my comment, and that should correlate well with the amount of discomfort the HN frowny face is truly worth. Maybe it's taste is closest to something like licking a nine volt battery.

They are mostly unproductive, and express an opinion more akin to noise than anything else.

Don't try to predict when downvotes will occur. Only predict that aligning your comment perfectly with the general sentiment of HN's echochamber and the capricious views of some of its moderators, will likely result in a general trend of upvotes.

If you ardently pine for someone else's approval, conform to their every whim.

tritium··on Lightning makes new isotopes
If only they would have simply written "gamma ray" instead of γ-ray, but I suppose there are the bandwidth savings to consider...
tritium··on iMac Pro Appears to Include A10 Fusion Chip for Always-On ‘Hey Siri’
And that's just it, isn't it. Siri is just a name. A cartoon.

The reality is that at a minimum, it's an organization of profit motivated people trying to listen to you. Maybe Apple is controlled by nice people today, but how many other companies will justify their own actions by pointing to Apple's practices.

And when those companies are bought and sold, or go out of business after a period of desperation, what happens in those moments?

Justify this with Apple, and ten more organizations follow in those footsteps.

tritium··on Studies suggest that many inventors do their best work at later stages
Let's dispense with the facade. Younger employees typically do more for less, and are sought for their energy, flexibility and/or willingness to entertain new ideas, and not necessarily because they invent the new ideas.

It used to be that fast food chains hired teenagers because they could pay them less, and in exchange the kids got to feel like adults usually for the first time, even if the environment was dubious.

Startups are running a similar game, only the skills needed are rare enough that the price tag is sky high compared to ordinary jobs, and only because there really have been a few unicorns and the calculated risk of investment in these sorts of salaries is potentially worth the gamble.

tritium··on The best laptop ever made

  Hardly anyone uses wired ethernet...
Au contraire! Anyone familiar with wi-fi security knows better than to trust the flimsy authentication protocols, and even flimsier application layer implemntation of the user interfaces that control and behave as lock and key for the (more difficult to crack) actual encryption that protects the traffic itself.

Wireless communication is often attacked at the joints, by targeting the login handshakes that relay the password-oriented auth tokens back and forth, when confirming access. These side channel attacks on encryption are more likely to succeed than trying to capture a terabyte of traffic, in order to crack the encryption itself.

Anyone tasked with the technical aspects of handling millions of dollars securely, is likely to be avoidant of wi-fi for some select activities, where convenience is not the priority. If you know you're a spear phishing target, there are certain things you don't do over wi-fi.

tritium··on Germany bans children's smartwatches
The ban puts manufacturers on notice, but in reality, devices are becoming so ambiguously advanced from a technical perspective, that "smart" is not an adequate adjective to describe all that myriad use-cases and features that represent a hazard to any naive user (whether they are children or not).

Such a premise is also inadequate to address the reality that an adult parent or guardian might let their child handle sufficiently advanced devices, unwittingly harming their children and themselves by failing to understand the product they employ. What about placing a child in a "smart" car? How do you anticipate protecting the safety and privacy of anyone under such circumstances?

tritium··on The best laptop ever made
DongleGate™ arguably started (and was likely internally fomented) with this edition of the MacBook Pro.

This was the first MacBook Pro to exclude an ethernet port, and when Desktop Support at my company handed it to me, I looked at it and asked them what the fuck was I supposed to do about it? They shrugged, threw up their hands and left (I was the prima donna that asked for the Mac, figure it out asshole), and so I limped along on guest wi-fi for a week, until figuring out that I had to buy a dongle if I wanted to use wired ethernet. Eventually snagged some from desktop IT services too, but initially, they were callous and indifferent to my plight.

If anything seeing the statistics for the successful sales of this model and related essential dongle accessories, despite knee-capping ethernet, and forcing dongle adoption to replace an old, standard, widely reliable and convenient data bus standard, could only have inspired and emboldened choices like the headphone jack debacle and USB-C minimalism which still plague us even today.

tritium··on The Story of a New Brain
Well, in an extremely primitive and minimal sense, the (appropriately named, especially in this case) Brainfuck language is Turing complete, providing an adequate window into hypothetically any programming tasks a programmer might wish to accomplish, even if the act of doing so would be rendered completely tedious, very abstract and highly repetitive.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brainfuck

Eight instructions to eventually accomplish all tasks involving information. In some circles, eight whopping options might be considered luxurious.

tritium··on China is catching up to the USA, while Japan is being left behind

  "catching up" and "falling behind"
Within the context of this article, the thing gained or lost is capacity for Scientific Research, and the article suggests renaming an NSF report.

It is not a statement about "things in general" around the world.

tritium··on Long-Term Coffee Consumption and Risk of Cardiovascular Disease (2013)
And to clarify further: Normal activity with no coffee (or caffeine?) represents the common risk factor “1.0” as the control group. People who claim to totally avoid this psychoactive stimulant (but naming brewed coffee specifically), and are otherwise typical, have this risk level.

The study links improved health and coffee, with its statistics. People drinking a handful of 8 oz. cups of coffee (black? light and sweet?) seem to do better, having somewhat healthier hearts with less disease, than the control group of consumers of exclusively non-caffeinated substances (naming brewed coffee specifically). Coffee drinkers do best when consuming 24 to 40 fluid ounces of brewed coffee, distributed throughout waking hours, with the range of optimum quantities likely varying based on body weight.

According to this research, excessive drinking of coffee at 80 ounces (or more?) is as bad (or worse?) than drinking none at all. The research examines 1,279,804 participants and 36,352 heart disease cases.

tritium··on Thinking the Way Animals Do (2015)
So I notice that her brain has been scanned and a careful analysis has been performed to detect differences relating to the areas she exhibits strengths in, and also the biological roots for some of her struggles.

It sounds like it was part of an elaborate project, but what was it, and how did the organzers arrive at the decision to approach and invite her to the study? Or did she hear about it, and ask to participate as a matter of curiosity?

tritium··on GPS signal disturbed at altitudes above 2000-3000 feet over Norway [pdf]
So, what your saying is that you're okay with it dropping bombs at all, as long as it's over there, but not on Europe, because Europe is special. (if not for this imagined hazard, would everything suddenly be okay?)

Meanwhile, political undertones aside, I think your idea is a little contrived, considering the realities of fuel capacity and range, nevermind time to travel, lack of stealth capabilities, and the fact that drones are piloted and engage weaponry mostly by a video feed (and using visual flight rules [0]) which would provide major clues that the GPS information has become unreliable.

tl;dr Drones aren't artificially intelligent solar-powered killbots, flying unsupervised missions. (yet)

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_flight_rules

tritium··on When did the golden age of The Simpsons end?
Not that questioning this premise should expect to surface an answer to any of these questions but...

Would such a joke's lineage be perceptible or readily recognizable?

Would anyone notice or remember who made the last/next iteration of the joke, to continue the tradition?

Who defines the canonical serial sequence for this chain of jokes?

How many generations is a joke like this worth?

Would the continuation of such a joke actually be funny in the first place?

Was it ever truly funny at all?

tritium··on When did the golden age of The Simpsons end?
There were a couple of violations in that episode that I remember instinctively grasping when I originally watched it as a new episode when it first aired.

I had been eagerly anticipating the episode, based on station promo spots that had teasers about the episode, and I really thought it was going to be a really good episode.

It was obvious that some extra effort was put into the animation, I had anticipated solid writing to match. It looked like it was going to be on par with a good Treehouse of Horror episode.

Instead, it turned out to be fluff. Only the trippy animation got attention, and the entire episode is built around the trippy shots. The episode lines up what might be considered the first “jerk ass” Homer incident, such that Homer eats this MacGuffin chili pepper, apropos of nothing, and why? There is no reason. It doesn’t build his character. It doesn’t reveal or change anything about Homer. And he’s the centerpiece of the whole episode, the other characters don’t figure into the plot very much, other than as sentimental plush toys. He just does it. Why is he at the chili cook off? No real reason.

So the answer is: because they (the staff) wanted to do a trippy vision quest desert sequence. And that’s it. No other alignment with the Simpsons universe. It’s just Homer trips out in the desert. Everything else is window dressing. Any tugs on the heartstrings, and appearances by the rest of the cast. The spirit animal becomes nothing, and is never seen again, in any other episode that mattered.

And so, then we have the principal violation of Homer doing drugs, and the ancillary violation of Homer “doing drugs” without actually doing drugs. The pepper is a stand-in for hallucinogenic drugs, obviously. And here we have homer trying the pepper, but for dishonest reasons. He didn’t set out to trip balls in the desert, and his character is unaware of this outcome a priori, conserving a moralistic aspect of Homer, the family man, even though, we, beyond the fourth wall, know better.

So they do this episode once, and without any explanation, or impact on continuity, and the jokes aren’t even that great. The episode isn’t very quotable, and has nothing else going for it, aside from the animation, which everyone does remember.

So, at the time, everyone said they loved this episode, but really the episode sucked, and rewatchng it decades later, it still sucks. But people remember the animation, and The Simpsons is animated, so surely this must be a “good” Simpsons episode. But it’s not.

At the time, I remember a subliminal inkling that if this episode passed muster, then more bad episodes were on the way, and I was right. The Poochie episode aired soon after, and I remember watching it at the time, and thinking to myself: “message received, this show isn’t going to be good anymore, don’t expect much else going forward... “ and it seems that was interpretted correctly.

tritium··on When did the golden age of The Simpsons end?
The Guatemalan Insanity Pepper episode was the first “bad” episode to signal decline in quality, after which good episodes were absent, if not extremely rare.
tritium··on The Spread of Feynman Diagrams in the USA, Japan, and the USSR (2004) [pdf]
I think knowledge transfer is hard, because teaching requires time for neurons to reorganize or maybe fix themselves in place, in order to properly cement a retainable fact. It’s just a quirk of the human condition that amounts of memory persist at limited speeds.
tritium··on Why Cryonics Makes Sense (2016)
Given that most of the chemical processes of neurology are halted by rendering the usual liquid soup of metabolism completely inert, any rememberance of dreaming or sensation is going to occur in the transient periods of going under or coming out of storage.

To borrow from the array of Inception memes, your sense of time in the dream world is distorted, which is why dreams can feel like days-long ordeals even though you’ve probably never had a dream last even 2 hours, let alone 8. So if you do come out of it with trippy dream-like memories or weird emotional feelings as residue from nightmares, what will they amount to? I guess it could be unpleasant, but if you’re going to get on living, you’ll have to figure out a way to get over it and move on.

I mean, whatever baggage you wind up with is going to be stacked next to what amounts to an (almost assuredly unsettling) near death experience, and waking up alone anyway, with (very likely) no friends or loved ones to offer support after you wake back up, so you’ll have that to cope with as well. No one promised that living forever would be easy.

tritium··on Why You Can Focus in a Coffee Shop but Not in Your Open Office
The power differential implicit in the voice of managers.

The competitive aspect of operating alongside co-workers.

The fairness of slacking off, letting one's mind wander, contemplating a hard problem while staring off into space and refraining from typing at a keyboard, maybe running late in the mornings, versus doing "real" work, ass in chair, on time, contributing ideas in meetings and phone calls, producing visible progress...

Whether or not people (who can affect your ability to put a roof over your head) ARE NOTICING YOUR EVERY MOVE.

This is what an open office is does to me. The anxiety induced by others, and their potential for influencing where the rubber meets the road.

← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →