HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

trod1234

159 karma · joined November 15, 2024

Illegitimi Non Carborundum
submissionscomments
trod1234··on If we can find information by asking GenAI, who needs the Web?
Imagine AI telling you its safe and proper to water bath can meat for food preservation, and what that actually means when you eat the canned meat following those directions. Same goes for mushrooms, or anything else that might literally kill you.

We've reached a point where AI is not accountable for harms, while being capable of killing people through selective curation of information it provides.

trod1234··on If we can find information by asking GenAI, who needs the Web?
Your wrong. Here's how it might go down.

Web advertising goes away because communications platforms reach the Shannon limit driven by AI generated slop, and deceit. People can no longer communicate with each other, this spawns chaotic hallucinations and delusions that grow into a dragon-king event. Businesses make decisions based on the hallucinatory perceptions that are not sound resulting in losses. Money-printing increases to try to cope with losses by extending debt nationalizing the economy, inflationary pressures cause rapid devaluation of the dollar which in turn puts companies responsible for food production out of business. This culminates in one single company remaining in the food production sector that serves as inputs for other smaller companies, and then they too fail due to chaotic instability and devaluation of the currency, with no further food production thereafter citing regulatory and safety issues confounded by corruption. All the while advertising to everyone that food will be available in the future, but never actually taking the steps to make it happen given the desperate situation that cannot be resolved.

Three days later, most people start getting desperate to feed their families. Rioting breaks out. Some start resorting to cannibalism, looting, and ivolence. The electric grid fails. Production of everything ceases, and the remaining people kill each other using guns/other tools, or detonate nuclear bombs ending it for everyone.

The relation between each step of this is a small domino that by itself wouldn't break a resilient system, it would only break in a predisposed centralized system, a system that has been optimized for chaos to create profit.

You've got the cause and effect reversed that seems based in fallacy. Are you one of those people that would say, "This can't ever happen", sound in that false belief but through your actions then try to make it happen?

Cascade failures lag with time. If you juggle balls up in the air, eventually they will all come down at the same time, where you won't be able to react. This is why these failures are so serious and existential, and shouldn't be ignored by rational people. Those that ignore reality end up dying through their own choices given sufficient time.

trod1234··on If we can find information by asking GenAI, who needs the Web?
The contracts that the founders of the US constitution based the constitution on.

You may want to start with Leviathan, then move on to John Locke, Hobbes and Descartes. No post I make will ever substitute for a reading of those authors.

trod1234··on If we can find information by asking GenAI, who needs the Web?
Not good. Have you considered the second order effects of a breakdown of communications?

Marketing and Advertising is about communicating a product to someone that may be interested in purchasing it.

If Communications is jammed because AI slop has dominated the web, no marketing happens, no hiring happens, no purchases are made because no jobs. In short order (relatively speaking), you get deflationary collapse of all human organization.

Should that collapse, population levels will be forced to make a deep correction in ecological terms. The planet is in ecological overshoot. What happens when 2/3 of people can suddenly no longer feed themselves, and technology allows one person to destroy everyone on the planet. Quite bad.

Also, the money in surveillance capitalism is almost straight from the money-printer. It may be laundered a bit, but overall the reason old marketing/advertising failed is because it was outcompeted by money-printing, and when that fails (as it always does), you have a barren soil where nothing will grow. Corporate business today has a tendency to burn their house down with themselves in it to save a few pennies.

trod1234··on If we can find information by asking GenAI, who needs the Web?
It already has, and it will destroy quite a lot more before all is said and done.

Fundamentally, it breaks the social and generational contracts needed for societal organization to operate. While these structures won't vanish overnight, the consequences are cascading failures that will produce dire outcomes the longer they are allowed to fester.

trod1234··on California resident tests positive for plague, health official say
The article doesn't meet journalistic standards for clarity, transparency, or sources, and this is not unexpected given Nexstar has been funneling Chinese-state skewed propaganda to Americans for years.

The title of the article is quite misleading. Lake Tahoe, which rides the border of Nevada and California, has had a resident diagnosed, and this isn't uncommon in areas where flea's and ticks are. Antibiotics easily treat these.

Importantly, its not newsworthy, and the sole purpose is to fractionate viewers.

trod1234··on AWS CEO says using AI to replace junior staff is 'Dumbest thing I've ever heard'
Up to the first or second chapter, depending on the book being used is more than sufficient to cover the foundational concepts. Sets, and Properties such as closure over given operations, and mathematical relabeling which is a function (f(x), the requirements for it (uniqueness of x, and projection onto) along with the tests for the presence of these, and common mathematic systems properties.

This naturally provides easily understood limitations of math systems which can be tested if there is a question, and allows recognition when they violate the properties that naturally lead to common mistakes, as well as providing a space where they can use numbers/geometry/reasoning at play.

trod1234··on AWS CEO says using AI to replace junior staff is 'Dumbest thing I've ever heard'
The classical system was described, but you can find it in various historic works based on what's commonly referred to today as the Trivium and Quadrivium based curricula.

Off the top of my head, the former includes reasoning under dialectical (priori and later posteriori parts under the quadrivium).

Its a bit much to explain it in detail in a post like this but you should be able to find sound resources with what I've provided.

It largely goes back to how philosophy was taught; all the way back to Socrates/Plato/Aristotle, up through Descartes, Locke (barely, though he's more famous for social contract theory), and more modern scientists/scientific method.

The way math is taught today, you basically get to throw out almost everything you were taught at various stages, and relearn it anew on a different foundation, somehow fitting the fractured pieces back together towards learning the true foundations, which would be much easier at the start and building on top of that instead of the constant interference.

You don't really end up understanding math intuitively nor its deep connections to logic (dialectics, trivium), until you hit Abstract Algebra.

trod1234··on AWS CEO says using AI to replace junior staff is 'Dumbest thing I've ever heard'
Intuitively it fails in making an equivalence to area which is an unrelated dimensional unit, as two lengths multiplied together equaling resistance, as well as the skin-effect related to Intensity/Current which is why insulation/isolation of wires are incredibly important.

The classical approach used charge diffusion iirc, and you can find classical examples of this in Oliver Heaviside's published works (archive.org iirc). He's the one that simplified Maxwell's 20+ equations down to the small number we use today.

trod1234··on AWS CEO says using AI to replace junior staff is 'Dumbest thing I've ever heard'
I included the water pipe analogy for electric theory, that is one specific example.

Also, In Algebra I've seen a flawed version of mathematical operations being taught that breaks down with negative numbers under multiplication (when the correct way is closed over multiplication). The tests were supposedly randomized (but seemed to target low-income demographics). The process is nearly identical, but the answers ultimately not correct. The teachers graded on the work to the exclusion of the correct answer. So long as you showed the correct process expected in Algebra you passed without getting the right answer. Geometry was distinct and unrelated, and by Trigonometry the class required correct process and answer. You don't find out there is a problem until Trigonometry, and the teacher either doesn't know where the person is failing comprehension, or isn't paid to reteach a class they aren't paid for but you can't go back.

I've seen and heard horror stories of students where they'd failed Trig 7+ times at the college level, and wouldn't have progressed if not for a devoted teacher helping them after-hours (basically correcting and reteaching Algebra). These kids literally would break out in a cold PTSD sweat just hearing the associated words related to math.

trod1234··on AWS CEO says using AI to replace junior staff is 'Dumbest thing I've ever heard'
Mathematics pedagogy today is in a pretty sorrowful state due to bad actors and willful blindness at all levels that require public trust.

A dominant majority in public schools starting late 1970s seems to follow the "Lying to Children" approach which is often mistakenly recognized as by-rote teaching but are based in Paulo Freire's works that are in turn based on Mao's torture discoveries from the 1950s.

This approach contrary to classical approaches leverages torturous process which seems to be purposefully built to fracture and weed out the intelligent individual from useful fields, imposing sufficient thresholds of stress to impose PTSD or psychosis, selecting for and filtering in favor of those who can flexibly/willfully blind/corrupt themselves.

Such sequences include Algebra->Geometry->Trigonometry where gimmicks in undisclosed changes to grading cause circular trauma loops with the abandonment of Math-dependent careers thereafter, similar structures are also found in Uni, for Economics, Business, and Physics which utilize similar fail-scenarios burning bridges where you can't go back when the failure lagged from the first sequence, and you passed the second unrelated sequence. No help occurs, inducing confusion and frustration to PTSD levels, before the teacher offers the Alice in Wonderland Technique, "If you aren't able to do these things, perhaps you shouldn't go into a field that uses it". (ref Kubark Report, Declassified CIA Manual)

Have you been able to discern whether these "patterns" as you've called them aren't just the practical reversion to the classical approach (Trivium/Quadrivium)? Also known as the first-principles approach after all the filtering has been done.

To compare: Classical approaches start with nothing but a useful real system and observations which don't entrench false assumptions as truth, which are then reduced to components and relationships to form a model. The model is then checked for accuracy against current data to separate truth from false in those relationships/assertions in an iterative process with the end goal being to predict future events in similar systems accurately. The approach uses both a priori and a posteriori components to reasoning.

Lying to Children reverses and bastardizes this process. It starts with a single useless system which contains equal parts true and false principles (as misleading assumptions) which are tested and must be learned to competency (growing those neurons close together). Upon the next iteration one must unlearn the false parts while relearning the true parts (but we can't really unlearn, we can only strengthen or weaken) which in turn creates inconsistent mental states imposing stress (torture). This is repeated in an ongoing basis often circular in nature (structuring), and leveraging psychological blindspots (clustering), with several purposefully structured failings (elements) to gatekeep math through torturous process which is the basis for science and other risky subject matter. As the student progresses towards mastery (gnosis), the systems become increasingly more useful. One must repeatedly struggle in their sessions to learn, with the basis being if you aren't struggling you aren't learning. This mostly uses a faux a priori reasoning without properties of metaphysical objectivity (tied to objective measure, at least not until the very end).

If you don't recognize this, an example would be the electrical water pipe pressure analogy. Diffusion of charge in-like materials, with Intensity (Current) towards the outermost layer was the first-principled approach pre-1978 (I=V/R). The Water Analogy fails when the naive student tries to relate the behavior to pressure equations that ends up being contradictory at points in the system in a number of places introducing stumbling blocks that must be unlearned.

Torture being the purposefully directed imposition of psychological stress beyond a individuals capacity to cope towards physiological stages of heightened suggestability and mental breakdown (where rational thought is reduced or non-existent in the intelligent).

It is often recognized by its characteristic subgroups of Elements (cognitive dissonance, a lack of agency to remove oneself and coercion/compulsion with real or perceived loss or the threat thereof), Structuring (circular patterns of strictness followed by leniency in a loop, fractionation), and Clustering (psychological blindspots).

trod1234··on Vibe coding creates a bus factor of zero
The author though neglects what a bus factor of 0 means in real terms and how it gets there, aside from the description of the definition upfront where all knowledge lost.

A company acceptable with a bus factor of zero is a company that is not willing to pay the economic advantage to the expertise required to do the work.

The economic demand, of humanity competing with AI is zero because AI does things its good at with an order of magnitude difference in cost, and the deception and lies surrounding the marketing coupled with communications channel jamming lead to predictable outcomes. What happens when that demand and thus economic benefit go to zero? Any investment in the knowledge in the first place has no return. No one goes into it, no one learns, and that's quite dangerous in economies based in money-printing.

So while there may not be a problem right now, there will no doubt be problems in the next proverbial quarter. Career development pipelines are years in the making. They are sequential pipelines. Zero into a sequential pipeline is zero out with the time-lag between the two (which is years).

~2 years without economic incentive is when you lose your best and brightest. From there is a slow march to a 10 year deadline after which catastrophic losses occur.

I had a chance to have a interesting discussion with a local community college Dean. Apparently they have had to lower the number of Computer Science related program sections because of lack of demand. In intro courses, for 18 sections there were 13 people who had declared for the major, most students when asked citing AI concerns and lack of career development pipeline.

What happens when you have no expertise that you can pay at any price to fix the processes involved because you put them all out of business using what amounts to a semi-thinking non-sentient slave.

Without supply, there can be no demand. Where supply becomes infinite because of external parties, there can be no demand. There can be need, but demand is not need.

So this all started in 2022. Best and brightest are re-skilling. There's a glut of lower competency talent too. Bad things happen when you mess with the foundations of economics, and they happen on a time lag, where you can't react fast enough after-the-fact.

What will it take? At some point there will be a crisis where they will have to treat it as triage on the battlefield. The people in charge didn't want to hear about this when it could have made a difference.

trod1234··on Ask HN: Why does the US Visa application website do a port-scan of my network?
Capturing forensic artifacts of the local network allows a building a bridge strategy for identifying fraudulent networks without requiring knowledge of the path taken from destination to recipient. Other local devices do this and send the network map during a phone home, allowing comparison to a source of truth that is tied almost directly to the person, or group of people.

There is also a lot of fingerprintable material within such a port scan from clock skew, TCP ISN, and a few other areas.

You can sieve this quite easily with this available, thanks to Roku's, Phone's, and other things doing this while just sitting locally in a shared collision domain (a digital soldier quartered in every home).

The metadata node graph of devices locally acts as a unique fingerprint once in RFC1918 space, technically not unique but close enough.

trod1234··on Secure Boot, TPM and Anti-Cheat Engines
Sure thing, a surrogate is something that we equate as the same thing but is not the same thing, and it carries negative connotation because the differences causes loss to the owners.

A Hegelian pattern being a circular pattern that abuses the contrast principle (a psychological blindspot), and also includes a long historical context with regards to socialism/communism. For example, I'm sure you've heard of shock doctrine. That's a Hegelian pattern.

For an example of surrogates, your cell phone is a surrogate for the original telephone, also your computer, and any number of other add-on devices. They perform multiple functions, but the primary purpose has been superseded by secondary purposes of control, data collection. A digital soldier quartered in every house, that follows you everywhere you go informing on you to the highest bidder.

A car today is not a car, its a computer which performs the function of transportation, and may be a platform for assassination, but also allows granular tracking of your movements like an animal on a leash.

The fact that most people aren't aware of all the ways their agency has been taken matters little. Industry in cooperation with government, fueled by money-printing have excluded any option through oligopoly, except total compromise/dependency, in furtherance of control. History knows how runaway money-printing ends.

Are you aware your TPMS sensors in your tires passively beacon a unique ID for each tire everywhere you go? That collection of sensors is sufficient to uniquely identify you in conjunction with a few other things in the car remotely, everywhere. Its a weak broadcast, but there are remote sensor networks everywhere, including roaming sensor networks (Tesla's, Public Transpo, etc). All that data collection is mined and added to a secret big-tech dossier you have no control over.

The ODB-II uplink through the telematics unit may even allow a remote control takeover of your car, while you are driving it. Tricking the car into adverse road-condition programming causing an accident.

Bulk data collection of radio-frequency data is either freely available (wigle) or has a very low buyin which allows granular historic tracking for everyone in a geographic region, and there are groups that know about this, and use this towards Zersetzung style gang-stalking (criminal harassment). Just like the lex-luthor sponsored monkey bots on social media. /s

> are you misunderstood often.

I'm not misunderstood by rational people who can reason, avoiding fallacy, and tying their arguments to things that are objective; I'm fine with disagreement, I just can't abide by toxic dissembling and other manipulative tactics the more malign people use.

There are some real existential problems we need to deal with, and when you can't communicate sufficiently so people recognize because of channel jamming, language corruption, and other malign rhetoric, momentum will carry us right to extinction.

A civilization based on total control, is a society that will be extinct in short order.

There are quite a few people online these days, though I dare hesitate to call them actual people because they are delusional, hopelessly complacent, malevolent, or just blind waiting at the chance of being either of the previous 3.

The things I talk about are things people have been conditioned from a young age to believe are impossible, despite objective indicators to the contrary (i.e. lies so big it would rearrange their world), with real science behind it; that has largely been suppressed with the end goal being towards control of the masses.

An indoctrinated willful blindness is a big problem today, I'd say that is probably one of the top things that prevents most people from organizing to make everyone's lives better. The blind are easily manipulated by those with ill intent.

My main goal in bringing attention to things is to hopefully get people to pay attention, and take appropriate action. The ones that aren't paying attention often throw their lot in with the people seeking chaos for profit; survival be damned.

I want an advantaged future for my children. Not the disadvantaged hellscape we see today. To make significant change, you need like-minded people all working towards that direction, and to do that you need to be able to communicate adverse issues in time to act.

With respect to the anti-cheat, once software is on your computer at that privileged level, they can perform an Eclipse attack on you, and you won't be able to know its happening.

MITM is two dimensional involving a single path, Eclipse covers all possible path nodes to such information; and its quite possible to do this without having nation-state backing given the state of IT security at the lowest levels of abstraction.

trod1234··on Secure Boot, TPM and Anti-Cheat Engines
There will be people that cheat regardless of what any game company can do. Racing to the edge is not the way to stop this.

If you haven't noticed, these solutions create the platform to both test, and control your digital life without your knowledge following a classic surrogate/hegelian pattern. How much do you trust the credibility of entities behind these game companies. Would you trust them with your life?

This should be carefully considered food for thought for anyone that values their future.

trod1234··on Did California's fast food minimum wage reduce employment?
The neglect I mention occurs because they perpetuate the outcome they seek to avoid, largely without knowledge of the true factors that lead to wealth as a group/nation in the first place which are codified in some older books.

You make the same assumptive leaps, which are based in fallacy, that cause this route to be a giant circle without agency/choice.

Your, "Tragedy of the commons" implies there's nothing you can do to change the world unless you are at the top of government, and that is both wrong, and the perspective of a demoralized hopeless person.

Actions matter, and you can do quite a lot at the local level by building strong community, and community is not government.

trod1234··on Who does your assistant serve?
I think the main point people should focus on and take away should be that the people that know the truth about psychology and psychotherapy know that its a very vulnerable state where the participant isn't in control, has no ability to discern, and is highly malleable in such states.

If the guide is benevolent, you may move towards better actions, but the opposite is equally true. The more isolated you are the more powerful the effect in either direction.

People have psychological blindspots, some with no real mitigations possible aside from reducing exposure. Distorted reflected appraisal is one such blindspot which has been used by Cults for decades.

The people behind the Oracle are incentivized to make you dependent, malleable, cede agency/control, and be in a state of complete compromise. A state of being where you have no future because you gave it away in exchange for glass beads.

The dangers are quite clear, and I would imagine there will eventually be strict exposure limits, just like there are safe handling for chemicals. Its not a leap to understand there would be harsh penalties within communities of like-minded intelligent people who have hope for a future.

You either choose towards choices for a better future, or you are just waiting to die, or moving towards such outcomes where you impose that on everyone.

trod1234··on Why LLMs can't really build software
Respectfully, I sound like a Computer Engineer because I've worked alongside quite a number of them, and the ones I've worked with had this opinion too.

> A cursory look at a nix system would show ... <three things concattenated together>

This doesn't negate or refute the pigeonhole principle. In following pigeonhole there is some likelihood that a collision will exist, and that probability trends to 1 given sufficient iterations (time).

The only argument you have is a measure of likelihood and probability, which is a streetlight effect cognitive bias or intelligence trap. There's a video which discusses these type of traps on youtube, TED from an ex-CIA officer.

Likelihood and probability are heavily influenced by the priors they measure, and without perfect knowledge (which no one has today) those priors may deviate significantly, or be indeterminable.

Imagine for a second that a general method for rapidly predicting collisions, regardless of algorithm, is discovered and released; which may not be far off given current advances with quantum computing.

All the time and money cumulatively spent towards Nix, as cost becomes wasted, and you are left in a position of complete compromise suddenly and without a sound pivot for comparable cost (previously).

With respect, if you can't differentiate basic a priori reasoned logic from AI, I would question your perceptual skills and whether they are degrading. There is a growing body of evidence that exposure to AI may cause such degradation as seems to be starting to be seen with regards to doctors and their use and diagnostics after use in various studies (1).

1: https://time.com/7309274/ai-lancet-study-artificial-intellig...

trod1234··on Why LLMs can't really build software
The problem with Nix is that its often claimed to be reproducible, but the proof isn't really there because of the existence of collisions. The definition of reproducible is taken in such an isolated context as to be almost absurd.

While a collision hasn't yet been found for a SHA256 package on Nix, by the pigeonhole principle they exist, and the computer will not be able to decide between the two packages in such a collision leading to system level failure, with errors that have no link to cause (due to the properties involved, and longstanding CS problems in computation).

These things generally speaking contain properties of mathematical chaos which is a state that is inherently unknowable/unpredictable that no admin would ever approach or touch because its unmaintainable. The normally tightly coupled error handling code is no longer tightly coupled because it requires matching a determinable state (CS computation problems, halting/decidability).

Non-deterministic failure domains are the most costly problems to solve because troubleshooting which leverages properties of determinism, won't work.

This leaves you only a strategy of guess and check; which requires intimate knowledge of the entire system stack without abstractions present.

trod1234··on Why LLMs can't really build software
Isn't the 401 for LLMs the same single undecidable token? Doesn't this basically go to the undecidable nature of math in CS?

Put another way, you have an excel roster corresponding to people with accounts where some need to have their account shutdown but you only have their first and last names as identifiers, and the pool is sufficiently large that there are more than one person per a given set of names.

You can't shut down all accounts with a given name, and there is no unique identifier. How do you solve this?

You have to ask and be given that unique identifier that differentiates between the undecidable. Without that, even the person can't do the task.

The person can make guesses, but those guesses are just hallucinations with a significant n probability towards a bad repeat outcome.

At a core level I don't think these type of issues are going to be solved. Quite a lot of people would be unable to solve this and struggle with this example (when not given the answer, or hinted at the solution in the framing of the task; ie when they just have a list of names and are told to do an impossible task).

trod1234··on Why LLMs can't really build software
I think most people trying to touch on this topic don't consider this byline with other similar bylines like, "Why LLMs can't recognize themselves looping", or "Why LLMs can't express intent", or "Why LLMs can't recognize truth/falsity, or confidence levels of what they know vs don't know", these other bylines basically with a little thought equate to Computer Science halting problems, or the undecidability nature of mathematics.

Taken to a next step, recognizing this makes the investment in such a moonshot pipedream (overcoming these inherent problems in a deterministic way), recklessly negligent.

trod1234··on Why deterministic output from LLMs is nearly impossible
> but it needs an edit pass - for politeness/assumption of positive regard.

We will have to disagree.

I have appreciated that, though the post isn't repetitive, each point has a fine and different nuance its meant to convey, and a single tie-in back to the overarching point/theme at the end signaling the completion of the idea; this is a very common writing style/structure when conveying information.

The problem with doing as you mention is that any further reduction would introduce ambiguity, and fragmentary thought, through improper generalization/isolation. These would then be latched upon towards subtle harassment attacks, like nullification, which have become all too popular on all platforms today.

You'll notice the people I responded to don't provide reflected appraisal, as someone earnest would, and that is needed to write or tailor responses towards a common audience level, or bridge the comprehensive gap. This is a failing on their part, not mine.

They are in all likelihood either bots seeking to remove useful information, or are doing so purposefully following a critical theory mindset which are a particularly destructive engrammed set of trauma loops, though a rare few manage to crawl and pull themselves out of it towards actual reasoning when the mistakes in reasoning are brought to light.

Politeness and positive regard aren't what you seem to think. Washington wrote about politeness, and aside from the dated material, it still holds up today.

You will find much in his 110 Rules of Civility which constitute politeness which are present in my writings.

The 'disarmed politeness' you seem to want is based in an impossibility when you strip all the indirection and contradiction away. The brevity you seem to want ignores the fine nuance/comprehensiveness needed to be polite, and the resulting outcome of doing either naturally leads to "lies to children", and the imposition of harassment for volunteering useful information, something I won't do disarmed. An impasse.

Charity is provided and given solely on the terms of the giver, and not at the barrel of a gun, blackmail, or inherent threat thereof and volunteers stop giving when it costs them more than they were willing to give, and its an individual decision.

I'll have to remember Mathew 7:6 when next I consider providing such charity, though I'm glad and appreciate you letting me know you found the substance useful. So few people do this and it is appreciated.

trod1234··on Why deterministic output from LLMs is nearly impossible
You should honestly re-evaluate and re-calibrate your measure of tone in moderation and relation to everything else.

Terse is not harsh or rude, its condensed, which carries a fine distinction.

Most business people and professionals speak this way; especially when it comes down to the objective facts which are not in question.

The facts and the effort towards minimization of cost for all parties in a communication conveys a overall respect, its extra effort I didn't have to provide which gets towards a specific goal as a whole for everyone involved in the communication's benefit.

If there is a mistake made on either parties part, its not harsh or rude to point out the mistake in such unambiguous format, or where that's not possible due to a deficit to point out why generally (such as a dependency not met).

Elaborating in great detail repeated or otherwise would be condescending, on the opposite side personal haranguing would be coercive imposition of cost. Lying by omission or commission would be the worst.

You'll note I did neither of these things, which is the socially acceptable way to handle it, and does not merit actions that were done. I pointed out the errors in comprehension, in the most minimal unambiguous way possible.

The only generally understood acceptable middle-ground in those two extremes is terse and to the point, and when you eliminate both sides and the middle ground, you classify all communication as harsh and rude which is an absurdity.

People cannot read other people's minds, and the point of communication is to convey meaning in a way the parties involved can use it towards their own ends beneficially if they choose, without unnecessary third-party interference.

The reflected appraisal is beneficial to all people involved.

trod1234··on Why deterministic output from LLMs is nearly impossible
If that is the case, then you didn't read or comprehend what was actually said, and no one can tailor a response to people who can't read and comprehend.

There are important distinctions, its beyond the scope for me to try and guess at where that failure of comprehension might be for an individual such as yourself.

Basic reading comprehension would note: Properties are not individual inputs, they apply to the whole system as a relationship between input and output, individual inputs cannot define properties.

"Chaos" has a very rigorous definition (changes in small inputs lead to large changes in outputs).

"Injection of non-determinism" is only correct if it included a reference that determinism is built-in to all computation which is not a common understanding. Without that reference, the context improperly includes an indeterminable indirection resulting in fallacy.

The two are unrelated and independent to the context of the conversation or determinism, and so defining such understanding in those terms would result in fallacy (by improper isolation), delusion, or hallucination.

These are fundamental errors in reasoning and by extension understanding.

The correct, on firm foundations understanding, was provided. It is on the individual without knowledge to come into a conversation with the bare minimum requirements for comprehension based in rational thought and practice.

Edit: No amount of down-voting will change the truth of this, though I understand why someone would want useful knowledge to be hidden.

trod1234··on Is Universal Basic Income Effective? Not Really
They are doing more than hope.

The Central bankers only see credits, and liabilities. They've done all they can on the credit side with money-printing over the past decade and a half, so for the past several years policy has been based in lowering life expectancy.

The broader liabilities associated with an individual disappear when those people die. Its callous to think this way, but this is how they think, and they do so and act indirectly because the average Joe won't notice, gradually nice and slow, just like a frog boiling.

trod1234··on Goodbye, Six-Figure Tech Jobs. Young Coders Seek Work at Fast-Food Joints
Its pretty clear there will be a crisis in these skills from just a structural point of view. Career development is a sequential pipeline that sieves people.

If you've as an industry blocked the pipeline saying we don't need these people, time passes and those people who had to invest to get to that point abandon the bad investments, and you get no new people coming in. People leave such industry because of burnout, and aging/retirement/death. The dynamics created are one of a deflationary sieve where the front-loaded cost savings becomes a back-ended cost sink. Tthe demand and related cost of the professionals is recognized at a point where there is great need but they can't be found at any cost. In system's engineering we call this Hysteresis whipsaws, Mises might call this the first early stages of the Economic Calculation Problem.

trod1234··on Did California's fast food minimum wage reduce employment?
That owner neglects that the latter fuels the former, and gets to a point where no business can occur at all (given sufficient time horizons).
trod1234··on Giving Pledge after 15 years: Only 9 billionaires gave away half their wealth
If you look at the economics that are connected with a wealthy nation, and not fake wealth (debt), then you wouldn't have to ask the question because both Adam Smith, and Mises cover these things, and more specifically how the promoted approach fails (every time, given sufficient time).
trod1234··on Giving Pledge after 15 years: Only 9 billionaires gave away half their wealth
Many of those billionaires became so through their government contacts/contracts.

The Fed has a massive problem, and that probleem snowballs down to us, and the reason we have a massive overspending problem is because the Fed has chosen winners and losers to create captive government.

Currency for the past 5 years has been devalued on average across all 5 years, about 25% in aggregate according to government numbers. If you revert to more accurate calculation numbers (ShadowStats), then its almost 40%.

Taxing the rich won't fix this, it comes down to a selection process that only selects for candidates that will make this problem worse through mathematical capture of first-passed-the-post voting. If you have two groups that each exceed 33% of the vote in aggregate, no other group can win.

trod1234··on Tor: How a military project became a lifeline for privacy
The major attack of concern described in the paper is the transparent early terminated encryption attack, and root trust signing that fall under effectively the same centralized hands at the AS level.

Where an AS level entity MITMs all outbound connections from a region in automated fashion for collection, before that traffic ever makes it to TOR or its destination.

It works for TOR, TLS, pretty much any protocol out there where key exchange or trust occurs; so long as the protocol is known and has distinct classifiable characteristics allowing computation to automatically do this.

There have been instances where public certs issued by a CA with the same domain names, but are issued from a root CA that is other than the legitimate site's root CA which are used for attacks. CT logs don't stop this either.

There is a lot of ephemeral content, and private information that can be both collected, and injected on a targeted basis if one has access to such junctions which the industry (Telecom) has proven time and again that they can't secure following basic practice; largely because mandates to backwards compatibility at the regulatory level.

Social credit, where invisible factors people don't control force those same people into poverty through targeted denial of service (communications for job hunting/social contacts), zersetzung, etc; that all would be a breeze to set up without any external indicator, or remedy using that attack.

What the target sees vs what everyone else sees would be quite different, and of course there would be people that gaslight and torture on top of it all (as a natural psychological defense mechanism of denial).

Compromised communications under such type of attacks are madness inducing.

← PreviousPage 4 of 25Next →