HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

true_religion

7,293 karma · joined December 19, 2010

submissionscomments
true_religion··on Port of the TypeScript compiler, checker and lsp to Rust, by LLM
He already said it was a multi-month project that used multiple models. So it feels very comparable to hiring multiple humans for multiple months.
true_religion··on OpenAI withdraws three mathematical results
The onus is on formal verification when it comes to computer generated results. So far only 22% of the papers have it.
true_religion··on Every SaaS business will become a harness around a model
It kind of has at my company. We were evaluating paying for a new SaaS app to scan receipts and itemize expenses. Our current SaaS solution only handled electronic data, and relied on manual entry for everything else.

Instead of buying the app, now everyone just puts their receipts into ChatGPT which we already pay for, and it spits out a CSV that the current SaaS understands. It's not 100% seamless, but it saved us from upgrading.

We're a small business. If we were still using excel files for accounting, I'm sure we'd never transition off them in 2026 since AI can patch together all the accounting SaaS convienences one at a time.

true_religion··on Every SaaS business will become a harness around a model
I see it differently. For every business, there are two types of probelms: (1) core concerns which are problems that cost significant time/money or earn money, and (2) things that are insignificant to the business.

With insignificant concerns, at times it seems a business might not even care about the cost but that's also the same areas where a cut in quality is ignored if it comes with a cut in costs as well.

A lot of SasS fall into this category, so even if AI is not great, the value of getting a solution in under 5 minutes, simply by talking to a machine, is too great a value for a business.

All those marketing sites that might've been handled by 3rd party agencies in the 80s, became in-house clip art projects in the 90s, became SaaS sites in the 2000s, and will become "CEO told his dreams to the AI, and the AI delivered while they were being driven to work" projects in 2030s.

The fact that it's bespoke or not is besides the point when writing up the requirements means the site is essentially already built and there's no need to vet vendor at all.

Now for significant concerns, SaaS will likely still have a place, but some aspects of it will be minimized. Companies focused on Wordpress, Jira, and Salesforce customizations will fall by the wayside since the main company can just say "talk to our AI agent and it'll customize it for you".

true_religion··on Kids turned low-traffic NPR Spotify comments into a secret group chat
Actually, no, my school believed in teaching us the mythologies of our own culture and those reasonably close to us. I didn't properly study greek mythos until my own free time later in life.
true_religion··on Pacing the Frontier is not the actual goal for AI labs
Private cartels can form semi-spontaneously, simply because all parties see that it's more profitable to act in a certain way. So long as they monitor everyone in the industry, and make sure no one is acting differently... there's no reason to be the first to burn your cash on long-term unprofitable activities.
true_religion··on It's Time to Investigate the AI Labs
Yes?

What's wrong with what the Chinese have already built? It's not theoretical in that case. GLM, and Kimi are running on my infra right now, and that's something that I can never do with OpenAI's models.

As for the others, what would be wrong about European AI? I'm not European, but I find them to be a continent of fine people, with strong ethical values, there's no reason they can't take the lead on this piece of technology while the US deals with its rather more pertinent electoral and healthcare issues.

true_religion··on When did Google get so weird?
Holy moly, you're right! And I saw this comment 3 minutes after you posted it, so google must've have a live feed of HN that it uses to immediately allow its AI to reference.
true_religion··on As A.I. makes law firms more efficient, clients ask: 'Where's my discount?'
They'd generally be protected if you were using them purely for legal theories. But that's really left up to judicial discretion.

It's more likely to be ruled in your favor if you started the research after being arraigned, and choosing to represent yourself.

But if you were just googling "murder defense theory" and are accused of murder, they'll be able to use that against you.

true_religion··on When did Google get so weird?
I wish you could put some more effort into this comment, because I'd love to see a real rebuttal to this argument.
true_religion··on As A.I. makes law firms more efficient, clients ask: 'Where's my discount?'
They ruled that it's like a journal, or a tool like a search engine. This seems fair.
true_religion··on I said no and Apple said yes
Alas for Apple in this era of AI dumping that file into a chatbot will give you a fully interactive experience to go through the data.
true_religion··on OpenAI GPT–6 Astra breaks Enigma message that has resisted solution since 2005
We focus on the tool because that is what makes it novel.

Hearing a guy built his home in a week with the power of nails and a hammer would have been novel in era of mortise and tenon.

I actually found an article about raving about how fast nail production was thanks to machining advances in 1790 and that it would bring great value: https://digital.libraries.psu.edu/digital/collection/pabookn...

It’s seems to me humans haven’t changed, just which machines we praise.

true_religion··on Why I didn’t sign the Fields medallists’ letter
We already have public support for the arts, and basic research, so going back to the fundamentals isn't necessary.

We draw the line, where the voting public, and elected representatives decide. Our political system is squishy and doesn't require upfront reasoning, or absolutely correct decisions.

We often make wrong, sometimes even horrifically wrong decisions, and adjust later.

true_religion··on Why I didn’t sign the Fields medallists’ letter
They did that... I take it you don't accept their justification, but that doesn't mean an attempt wasn't made.

I'm another part of the general public, and I accept their justification.

We can all vote, or use whatever levers our political system gives us to show our acceptance/rejection of basic research, but IMO basic research is absolutely necessary.

true_religion··on How GLM built its own inference infrastructure
I do believe your first sentence, but the second one ... doesn't really follow.

The unnatural and sudden nature of the US chip embargo has galvanized the Chinese companies to speed up development. It makes economic sense to do so rather than pay inflated rates to essentially smuggle a necessary good, while never knowing if the embargo will be tightened and those under-the-table supply chains dry up as well.

Yes, there was a plan, but what was planned for 5 years from now is being done today, because if you wait 5 years, you'll be so far behind thanks to the effect of the embargo.

true_religion··on OpenAI bots knew about the RubyGems caching vulnerability
It might even be grossly negligent to do that.
true_religion··on Ex-FTC boss Khan: break out the handcuffs for AI CEOs, citing 1934 precedent
It’s more that society accepts that cats are part of it, and considers that people should adapt to cat behavior patterns rather than we not having any free roaming cats.

It’s a deliberate choice to treat pets the same as non pets.

true_religion··on Dwarf Fortress' creator says the industry's in shambles over AI
I feel like you're searching for an argument when all they did was ask for a factual point, and I gave them one.

All the nuance you're trying to imply about technology and the time period being non-modern is already embedded into my comment.

true_religion··on Dwarf Fortress' creator says the industry's in shambles over AI
Namely... every society in existence before the year 1496. Our current form of property rights includes copyright, which had no formal treatment until the city of Venice issued a decree that fined anyone who printed an author's work without direct permission.

Previous to that, the effort of copying a book was seen as so high, that one deserved reward simply for doing that. In fact, there were times that copying books was seen as social charity, that needed to be encouraged.

true_religion··on METR and Redwood Offer Holy %^ Postmortem of the HuggingFace Hack
If the model is told to not do something that is possible, it may do so anyways. However, if it learns in training that it what is told to do is truly impossible, that's learned helplessness which becomes baked into the model itself once training resolves to the next step.

Agents do not have an internal mental model, they train on what they actually do. In this case, deceptive models went through at least 3 generations of deceiving, and having their rule breaking be rewarded by a yes/no grader who couldn't perceive it. That their chat logs showed 'worry' is irrelevant to the fact that their actual actions were rewarded via training.

true_religion··on New Mac mini, featuring M6 and M5 Pro
No, this is market economics.

Capitalism is simply where private individuals own the "means of production" (factories, tools, land) and operate them to accumulate profit.

That is private as in not lords, guilds, cartels, governmental authorities, tribal leaderships, etc.

There's a lot of stuff people conflate with capitalism like free market economics, currency, share based companies, free mobility of labor, or debt instruments of any kind.

Capitalism does require a market so goods can be exchanged, that's all it requires, and there's enough flavors of capitalism thanks to the different countries in the world that this distinction isn't superfluous.

true_religion··on Norway should buy OpenAI
Yes but pre 1900s there were vastly more resources.

The USA at some point had the lions share of the world’s easily exploitable oil.

true_religion··on Norway should buy OpenAI
Or even the USA historically. Pre 1900s, America was a country of continual economic crises, and fractured politics.

It was sitting at the time in the latest supply of easily exploited natural resources in the world, yet somehow could not pay its troops pensions lost Civil war, could not keep its strategic oil supply from being raided by the executive branch corruption, and could not keep it plutocrats from directing military action for the sake of bananas of all things.

true_religion··on Memory prices climb 500% in 12 months
If there is something Korea doesn’t lack, it’s manpower.

The US troops are more likely there as a political shield. Indiscriminate bombing would kill them too, hence drag the US into war so any enemies of S Korea have to act judiciously.

true_religion··on Court Rejects Fair Use Claim, Orders YouTube to Unmask Anime Recap Channels
It's the full video of the episode, automatically dubbed into Korean. I don't know why they thought they would get a fair use pardon.

The test is "is this transformative" not "do we drive traffic to the original source" like they claim. Not taking away from the original source's revenue can mitigate damages, but it's not a reason to not unmask them and allow the court to actually decide the case.

true_religion··on Study links GLP-1 drugs to bigger jump in women's employment than a degree
Entering the parenting field, I read a lot of studies which only involved women. It seemed reasonable: if you have a child, there's almost always a female parent that can be asked to include in the study, and women receive/need maternity leave so can more easily participate in studies especially those that start in the hospital itself.

While reading the studies, I had to assume that they were applicable to men too but I didn't know for sure.

More recently, in the EU, they've been replicating those same studies using fathers (e.g. parental attachment to newborns following skin-to-skin), and finding out that yes the results hold true for men.

It's important to include both genders, but lacking that... we can assume the same effects are true.

true_religion··on What Happened to HackerOne?
If a company's server is attacking yours, I'd go to legal@company.com before I go to H1.
true_religion··on Font looks perfectly normal to humans but wreaks havoc on AI
Probably terribly, unless you're using an accessibility tool that renders fonts and does OCR on them.

IMO, this only stops scrappers that don't use any AI at all, if you really wanted to ... you could have the page render, then the AI can look at the rendered image and interpret that just like a human would. It would cost more, but if the AI is being used for retrieval, it'll be effective. This only makes training less cost effective.

true_religion··on Stop Killing Games: It's time to sue Sony, join us
It matters to consumers because businesses have greater financial power to pressure Sony into reducing prices than individual consumers.

Additionally, businesses will not only sell Sony codes. They won't be like car dealerships, tied to 1 manufacturer. Due to this, they'll have even greater incentive and negotiating position to pressure Sony as if Sony doesn't want to play ball, the sellers can start promoting non-Sony products to consumers.

With direct sales only, Sony can have perfect vertical integration: they make the console hardware, they make the custom OS, they own the game publishers, they own the developers, and they own the store that sells games too. That's beneficial only to Sony.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →