HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

trukterious

203 karma · joined July 31, 2018

submissionscomments
trukterious··on Let’s bring back the Sabbath as an act against ‘total work’
>stopping all usage of it only one day a week is maybe 90% as unhealthy.

No, a recovery period can make a bigger difference. By the same token the recent advice on alcohol is to avoid it at least 2 days out of 7.

trukterious··on How to Be Better at Parties
Isn't that assuming that people can't be genuinely unconscious/robotic? Can't we allow them to be so?
trukterious··on How to Be Better at Parties
>interact with others in a programatic way.

Yes, there's something demonic about intentionally rule-based behaviour.

>It's this kind of attitude that there is a "right" way to be social that contributes to social anxiety. Fucking stop it!

Here's the problem. You're claiming both that it's wrong to interact like this and that there's no right or wrong in social interaction.

trukterious··on The Algernon Argument (2010)
Yes, most smart people invest their creativity into 'fitting in' better and enacting social memes more faithfully that the norm. Whereas the (rare) creative genius is disagreeable and thus usually ignored.
trukterious··on The Algernon Argument (2010)
There are some things that we talk about everyday and even attempt to measure without having an explanation of what they are. For instance, we say a person is 'happy'. Or 'we feel that...' ('feel'? 'we'?)

Intelligence seems to me like one of those qualities. It's real, but it isn't what we think it is. To me it seems like it ought to be, and often is, subject specific. Yet IQ tests are apparently predictive of career salary.

Some people seem incredibly smart but they don't create anything new. So their impact on the world in limited to 'more of the same'.

Then there's the fact that intelligence isn't additive. A person can make massive contributions to an academic department simply by being genuinely motivated and thereby boosting the morale of his more intelligent colleagues. Whereas a bad genius can retard an entire field (or was is merely that he was mistaken?)

trukterious··on Forgotten Greats of Science Fiction
>Need magic

Yet 'every sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic'. This presumably applies to fictional tech also.

trukterious··on Forgotten Greats of Science Fiction
What gets me are the psychic powers -- Sci-Fi's weird obsession with mumbo-jumbo parapsychology such as ESP which ran I think roughly from 1955 to 1980. In the Foundation series it manifests as the mental powers of the Second Foundationers (their ability to directly seize control of other people's minds, above and beyond their mathematical skill and knowledge of 'psychohistory').
trukterious··on YouTube's tendency to push everyday users toward politically extreme content
Yes. 'Extreme' refers really to the emotional temperature rather than the content. 'Moderate' views, compromises, etc, don't make much sense and are therefore ultimately boring. This doesn't imply moderation or the battle for centre ground in politics is bad. After all we know more than we can tell, so we can't always explain our decisions and policies. It's merely that there's less to understand and/or criticise.
trukterious··on 'Mindful people' feel less pain
My experience is that stopping and paying attention to a stubbed toe makes it more bearable than yelling and hopping around the room.
trukterious··on We know music is pleasurable, the question is why?
>Suicide usually has a cultural basis

Yes -- hence copycat suicides. But cultural, not genetic. Ideas, not genes.

trukterious··on We know music is pleasurable, the question is why?
>We are servants to our genes

If so then how do you explain phenomena like suicide and celibacy?

trukterious··on Eight bird species are first confirmed avian extinctions this decade
Life is good. But technology is morally neutral: it can be used for good or ill.

It's a simple fact that only technology could possibly prevent the next big meteor strike, the next ice age, the next local supernova, etc.

If people feel greedy or jaded or wretched or guilty (or think that all their fellow humans are) I think this is a sign that they need to choose a genuinely important problem to work on. And to have fun working on it -- perhaps with the occasional mango/beach holiday thrown in!

trukterious··on Eight bird species are first confirmed avian extinctions this decade
>stone-age technology can be a solution

What about the next big meteor strike?

trukterious··on Eight bird species are first confirmed avian extinctions this decade
Snikeris is snickety, but correct.

In the long run, only technology and creativity could create better substitutes for burning wood and dung. For making furniture and other structures out of rainforest hardwood.

Only technology will avert the next big meteor strike and the next super-volcano eruption (both otherwise inevitable, and both capable of wiping out a multitude of species, as has happened previously).

Reversion to a primitive way of life could make matters worse, environmentally speaking. The attraction is based on guilt. It's a response to the alienation and nihilism we associate with modernity; a response to philosophical and spiritual problems rather than to environmental ones.

So our duty remains not to prophecy doom but to work for a better world -- for all life.

trukterious··on Loneliness is pervasive and rising, particularly among the young
My take on Friends gets more reactionary the older I get. I now see it as very much a part of the Sexual Revolution: the drive to normalise dating and casual sex. On the one hand the friends treat sex as no big deal, plenty of humour, no judgement, etc. Just occasionally rationalising it as part of a necessary quest to find a husband or wife. On the other hand you notice from a distance that their whole lives revolve around sex. So it is a big deal, de facto, and of course in real life loneliness can be a very real penalty for messing it up.
trukterious··on What Do Happy Teens Do?
They sing while they're playing and/or working at the computer.
trukterious··on AI Can Transform Anyone Into a Professional Dancer
Indeed. It's still in the uncanny valley, but then evil is uncanny valley too. Goodness has always been linked in our minds with beauty and grace, including grace of movement.
trukterious··on Programming My Child
>I guess you can call that a "meme" if you want, but that doesn't make it "not education".

The kind of memes I'm referring to transmit spontaneously, though no doubt intentional cultivation is beneficial in some cases. There's a technical term due to Daniel Dennett: synanthropic memes. These are extremely sticky behaviours/ideas that thrive autonomously in the presence of humans, just as some biological species do, e.g. pigeons, rats, barn swallows. Some are bad. For example, swearing, bullying and perhaps even certain motor tics are memetic and these are considered bad by many.

Our ideas about education are pretty messed up and thus we ultimately have some disturbing realities to face, quite apart from the mounting student debt :-/ Hopefully there will be a clearing up if and when we develop AGI and thus gain a better understanding of how the mind works.

trukterious··on Programming My Child
>As with children, we don’t debug these networks; we educate them

Mostly we aren't educating young children. Rather, they are the recipients of memes (e.g. words, waving). These are ways of behaving in context. The transmission is mostly unintentional and unavoidable.

It has been speculated that if we tried to educate children how to walk and how to talk then they wouldn't succeed at either! Yet they succeed and improve these skills indefinitely. By contrast, arithmetic is intentionally and exhaustively taught, yet most adults cannot perform it.

>But you cannot reset a human being.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DMKcO-T5Y4o

Sure you can. See Tom Scott's face around 3:30. It's a slightly unpleasant facial sequence that I'd only ever witnessed in babies previously; a sort of soft reset.

Another form of reset is evident when addicts are administered with ibogaine.

trukterious··on Air pollution causes ‘huge’ reduction in intelligence: study
There's a list of some of these plants here:

https://learn.allergyandair.com/houseplants-indoor-air-quali...

One minor trick I use when walking down the street is to rapidly exhale if I've breathed in a particularly bad volume of exhaust pollution, like concentrated diesel fumes, walking on a few paces before re-inhaling. I expect it takes ~1s to detect the bubble of bad air and the surrounding air is polluted too. So just mitigation.

trukterious··on The Origins of Hatred for Pigeons (2016)
An interesting word I learnt from listening to Daniel Dennett: synanthrope. Such creatures include pigeons, rats, barnswallows, bed bugs. They benefit from living around humans without providing much in the way of return service.

There does seem to be a trend for embracing and celebrating animals which formerly have been considered ugly or pestilent. For example my son was recently introduced to a tarantula named Miss Fuzzyboots. In parody we have Hagrid of the Harry Potter films trotting out dangerous and/or repulsive beasts for class appreciation ("They're seriously misunderstood creatures...")

Is this a sort of moral/aesthetic inversion or are we genuinely expanding our 'circle of empathy'?

http://adami.natsci.msu.edu/blog/2013/04/the-evolution-of-ci...

trukterious··on Skim reading is the new normal. The effect on society is profound
Sure we do. Most reading is really a form of search and then we re-read the stuff that seems important. (At least I do.)

If one cannot enjoy reading a book over and over again, there is no use in reading it at all.

― Oscar Wilde

trukterious··on The Paradox of Karl Popper
There were exceptions. For instance, David Hume is reputed to have been an affable fellow.

But we nearly all of us underestimate how much creativity and energy is expended in trying to be normal (or to appear normal, which is much the same thing).

trukterious··on The case for abolishing private schools
Though he used it for comedic purposes, my point is that the author knew of the impulse in other people, over 2000 years ago!
trukterious··on The Paradox of Karl Popper
Popper sounds like a dude. We shouldn't confuse this apparent irascibility with dogmatism. He was passionate about his ideas: he published them and read criticism of them. He changed his mind about the testability of evolution, and other things.

Intellectual humility is not the same quality as personal meekness and geniuses have always had difficult personalities. Philosophers doubly so. How could it be otherwise? How can one create new stuff if one is too agreeable and too susceptible to groupthink?

Btw, the reason falsifiability doesn't have to be falsifiable (by experiment) is that it isn't a scientific idea; it's a philosophical one. It is potentially 'falsifiable' by criticism, however.

The best modern Popper proponent is David Deutsch. See his books The Fabric of Reality and The Beginning of Infinity. They're both packed with interesting ideas and arguments. He says that Popper did indeed solve the problem of induction. And here's a recent paper of his on the logic of experimental testing: https://arxiv.org/abs/1508.02048

trukterious··on The case for abolishing private schools
>I consider it driven by a nasty, Platonic impulse

I wouldn't say it's necessarily nasty. There's always been a wish (possibly romantic) for children to be raised in common.

e.g. "It takes a village to raise a child".

e.g. from Assemblywomen by Aristophanes, as summarised in Wikipedia:

>She proposes banning all ownership of private wealth and establishing equal pay for all and a unified standard of living. She further explains that people will no longer have a need for personal wealth as all basic needs will be met by the common fund. She further adds that men and women will be free to sleep with anyone they want, so long as they first sleep with the uglier members of the opposite sex. Parental responsibilities will be shared by the community as children will no longer know their fathers

There's also the fact that we made it through the Stone Age and other prehistoric times in small roving bands with presumably no formal education. Yet the scraps of knowledge of how to hunt and survive were passed down effectively.

People lived more intuitively then and in some sense there was more equality.

Yet that isn't the alternative that's being proposed. What is being proposed is a top-down bureaucratically-controlled system applied to all children regardless of their or their families' wishes. It would inevitably be the most expensive option quite apart from being a giant zombie factory and propaganda machine for the future powers-that-be.

trukterious··on The case for abolishing private schools
>IMO the parents attitude and nurturing at home is 2x as important

Agreed. And since education is inseparable from a child's well-being and general development, it remains the responsibility of parents. They must choose according to their children's interests, wishes and aptitudes, and according to the family situation. Try to take that away and you're putting the State in loco parentis -- a role beyond its bureaucratic capacity to manage.

trukterious··on Coffee delivery drone patented by IBM
Yes. I'm ignorant of intellectual property law, but wouldn't requiring an intent to actually produce the relevant technology prevent some of the abuses of the patent system?
trukterious··on Coffee delivery drone patented by IBM
>is it ok if they deliver paper supplies or food

On the subject of paper, aren't the papers on my desk going to be blown around as a result of drones delivering compulsory coffee?

trukterious··on What does genius look like in math? Where does it come? Dandelin spheres [video]
'Reside of experience'. Yes, more especially the residue of imaginative experience.

Daydreaming can be dysfunctional & defensive, as in:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5962718/

Yet some people are free in their thoughts at least some of the time and thus are able to daydream productively.

(One difference I think is that they are obsessed with problems).

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →