HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

trutannus

1,118 karma · joined February 24, 2021

submissionscomments
trutannus··on Ask HN: What is the best privacy-focused video doorbell?
I was going to suggest the same thing. If you build out the device yourself, the privacy is as close to perfect as you can get. Take it up a step by having a dedicated hidden and non-internet connected WiFi network for your doorbell/security systems. A few disks connected to the Pi and one of their cameras should be sufficient. I'm sure there's pre-built cases and button enclosures you could pick up.

Bonus: You can build the device to your local privacy regulation. Where I am, doorbells in shared living spaces can't have audio recording, but good luck finding a decent doorbell that does not also record audio.

trutannus··on Can helium be mixed with hydrogen to form a non-explosive mix? (2003)
You've given me a good laugh here. It's clear to pretty much anyone what I mean about industrial uses, so you're just responding to what you mistake as pedantry with pedantry. Anyway, I won't spend any more time here. Have fun, you've picked a strange hill to die on.
trutannus··on Can helium be mixed with hydrogen to form a non-explosive mix? (2003)
You didn't make the points here, you made them elsewhere.

> Burning hydrogen moves upward the same as non-burning hydrogen. Gas in contact with flame does not magically become non-buoyant.

Correct, it burns. Like it did in the Hindenburg. I have no idea what your point is.

> We are not, in fact, discussing "hydrogen cars", so whatever "sealed environment" you picture in them is wholly irrelevant.

This is a counter-argument for your previous points that leaks are irrelevant. My point is simple: No, they're not. You're trying to side-step this point by saying "well, I'm not talking about that" when you did right here:

> H2 under pressure moves outward, and in a containment breach tends to, instead, increase the H2 fraction above the 75% that can sustain a flame until most of the gas has escaped and leapt skyward.

Which is complete nonsense if you look into what's around a containment system. Which is my point -- containment is never not in a confined environment. You talk about some positive airflow system, sure, that's fine. What if the failure affects that? Well now you have to consider the risks all over again.

> involved no exploding hydrogen

This is a pedantic nitpick. In day to day usage, people say explosion to mean "rapid, uncontrolled fire". That does not negate my point -- that was one of the largest hydrogen fires in history.

You sound like you have tunnel vision on the advantages of hydrogen for industrial uses. There's a reason we don't use it. It's dangerous, and engineering solutions to mitigate the danger are prone to failure. If you want more: https://www.airships.net/hydrogen-airship-accidents/

trutannus··on Can helium be mixed with hydrogen to form a non-explosive mix? (2003)
> H2 explosions are a concern in enclosed, unventilated spaces

Well, ignoring one of the largest hydrogen explosions in History which occurred in the open air under the exact circumstances you say are impossible: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindenburg_disaster. You mention earlier that this is not the hydrogen, and instead just the fabric. That's been debunked repeatedly: https://www.airships.net/hindenburg/disaster/myths/#hydrogen...

You also mention nobody died in the fire as a result of the hydrogen, which is also debunked: https://www.airships.net/hindenburg/disaster/myths/#hydrogen

"This is probably the most absurd myth about the Hindenburg disaster, yet it is frequently promoted by hydrogen fuel advocates."

In addition, hydrogen tanks are not just sitting there in a vacuum. In order for the hydrogen to "leap skyward", you have to have it, again like I said earlier, not come in contact with anything that will induce combustion. Also, you need a perfectly open environment. Your point about the mixture being above 75% just shows a somewhat naïve understanding of the physical chemistry at play here. All it takes is for an area near the fuel supply to hit the right fuel-air mixture ratio, which leads to combustion, as in common elementary school science experiments (the hydrogen 'pop' demo). This event leads to a pulling in of the air and fuel around it, sustaining the exposition.

Hydrogen cars have the tanks contained within a sealed environment towards the rear of the car: https://afdc.energy.gov/files/vehicles/hydrogen-high-res.jpg

trutannus··on Can helium be mixed with hydrogen to form a non-explosive mix? (2003)
Your comments are filled with misinformation:

The gas-bag and paint theory is debunked: https://www.airships.net/hindenburg-paint/

The "nobody died from the hydrogen" line is debunked: https://www.airships.net/hindenburg/disaster/myths/#advocate...

That the craft is made out of flammable material is debunked: https://www.airships.net/hindenburg/disaster/myths/#flammabl...

trutannus··on Hackers are stealing data today so quantum computers can crack it in a decade
Suggested pronunciation: Queue-FUD?
trutannus··on Can helium be mixed with hydrogen to form a non-explosive mix? (2003)
> In a collision, gas released goes up and out of trouble

Except for the cases when there's an open flame nearby or sufficient heat, as is the case in a non-insignificant number of collisions. What if a hydrogen engine collides with a standard petrol engine? Or if the gas becomes exposed to hot surfaces during the oxygen mixing? The gas expansion is also a major cause of explosion. You essentially pull oxygen into the fuel, and rapid fuel-air mixing is a known cause of detonation.

trutannus··on Can helium be mixed with hydrogen to form a non-explosive mix? (2003)
It's not random detonation that is the problem, the issue is containment failures, or anything that causes one. A collision, or stress fracture for example will allow oxygen into the tank. In an atmosphere with enough oxygen in it like ours, that's always a risk.
trutannus··on Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will investigate
Even worse/better!
trutannus··on Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will investigate
Sue a billion dollar company? I'm not sure that's a solution for the vast majority of people. Fighting discovery is generally step one in the process of dealing with this sort of lawsuit. Something like this could/will take years, and hundreds of thousands of dollars to deal with.

It would be likely cheaper to buy a whole new car every year for five years than to take Tesla to court.

trutannus··on An Architecture for Life
George is an interesting guy. There's a YouTube channel that mirrors all his live-streams. Sometimes his opinions/he can be a bit off-putting (he yells at the stream viewers calling them "stupid noobs" at some point as an example), but it's clear he's a complete wunderkid when it comes to what he does. His Lex Friedman interviews are interesting too.

Definitely worth a watch if you're able to keep an open mind: https://www.youtube.com/c/georgehotzarchive

trutannus··on Where have all the insects gone?
And where in my derision and mockery of the idea of democide, and folks who support it, as glib and thoughtless do you see me praise it? Looks like you've misread, or misconstrued, my comment as the exact opposite of what I had written.

With respect to changing what I read, I like being exposed to opinions I disagree with, even ones I find abhorrent like this. It's useful to survey the opinions out there, even the nonsense ones.

trutannus··on Photoshop will get a ‘prepare as NFT’ option soon
> I get that it's an image (maybe any digital media?) and it is associated with an entry on a blockchain somewhere but then I get confused.

Not entirely correct. The NFT confers ownership of the NFT, not the asset it "represents" unless otherwise specified in a regular old contract or terms of sale. Often times the copywrite of the NFT's asset isn't even transferred correctly to the NFT owner.

trutannus··on Where have all the insects gone?
This reply is oddly presumptuous for no good reason.
trutannus··on Which jobs most often pair together among married couples
Might be the horoscope effect, but I found that a lot of people in professions that marry school teachers in this chart, did in fact marry school teachers in my life.
trutannus··on Where have all the insects gone?
This won't be popular, but remember just 10 years ago when people were talking about the environmental advantages of a mass die-off of humans? It was trendy for a bit to spitball about how much better off the environment would be with an x% decrease in human population as a result of a global death event. In fact, "we need a new plague" was a running joke on online environmentalist forms for a while. Funny how an actual pandemic made those same people glibly taking up the advantages pull a 180 when it was their grandmother who was in the x% who were going to die.
trutannus··on Edward Snowden Slams Sam Altman's Worldcoin: 'Don't Catalogue Eyeballs'
Time for "This retina does not exist"?
trutannus··on Why did Dostoyevsky write Crime and Punishment?
Another excellent book that injects you into an unstable protagonist is Fyodor Dostoevsky's Notes from Underground. Can be read in a day. Highly recommend. This was my first intro to Russian lit.
trutannus··on Bullets: Sizes, Calibers, and Types (2020)
> After all software engineers are almost exclusively depicted as engaging in unethical and outright criminal activity in pop culture

Right, I agree for sure. I think the reason why we don't consider this a reflection on software engineers is that no politician has thought using freedom to engineer software as a wedge issue in a campaign. It's absolutely unfair and a little odd. But, after all, I've yet to see a political wedge issue arise that isn't unfair, and viewed as a little odd by other cultures.

trutannus··on Bullets: Sizes, Calibers, and Types (2020)
Former gun owner myself as well back when I lived in the sticks. Would carry on walks in my "yard" because of injured, hungry, or otherwise dangerous wildlife.

> Movie frames featuring sainted action heroes, gun out-thrust.

This is the sort of thing that gives firearm owners a bad rap. Especially those who advocate for self-defense rights. Everyone already thinks firearm owners are gung-ho cowboys with itchy trigger fingers. The majority are not.

trutannus··on Trump's new platform and the Affero General Public License of Mastodon
> But those would then be immigrants, right?

No?! Why on earth would that be the logical conclusion? This is almost funny in how Americentric these threads become. You can outsource your project elsewhere. It's very common. America isn't the only country in the world that has software engineers who are competent.

trutannus··on Trump's new platform and the Affero General Public License of Mastodon
Contractors from a country that does not give a fig about American politics? So plenty of options are on the table.
trutannus··on Jack Dorsey mocks Mark Zuckerberg's metaverse plan, saying it's dystopian
Politically expedient as well.
trutannus··on Mastodon: AGPLv3 FOSS social network server
No, McCarthyism was an anti-communist panic in the USA. They're referring to USSR propaganda. I assure you, resentment over a better quality of life was not driving McCarthyism. Quality of life was far lower in the USSR, in addition to the fact that the Union and SSRs had more mass killings and abuses of citizens than United States by orders of magnitude:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_massacres_in_the_Sovie...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_transfer_in_the_Sov...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_deportations_from_Eston...

A place with high quality of life wouldn't have three entire nations jump at the first sign of instability to declare independence:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baltic_Way

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singing_Revolution

"I have seen the future, and it works!" is nothing more than demonstrably false propaganda. See here the anarcho-communist Emma Goldman say it themselves:

http://libcom.org/files/Emma%20Goldman-%20My%20Disillusionme...

trutannus··on Mastodon: AGPLv3 FOSS social network server
I assure you nobody outside America would really care, or know, what that company was.
trutannus··on Mastodon: AGPLv3 FOSS social network server
> USSR was built on that kind of manipulation and now it's coming here

Can you link to where I could read up on that? Propaganda tactics are fascinating, and this one is one I never knew about.

trutannus··on Mastodon: AGPLv3 FOSS social network server
Found that odd too. Jumping to conclusions, and moralizing based on that. Not sure what the purpose was. It lead to other users digging into the other commenter, which is somewhat creepy.
trutannus··on Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair
Gifted students, this wasn't supposed to have anything to do with wealth distribution.
trutannus··on Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair
Crabs in a bucket effect, Harrison Bergeron, Ressentiment -- different names, same thing. Its always been there, but when we give into it and allow the sentiment to guide legislation, we go nowhere good.
trutannus··on Eliminating gifted programs won’t make education fair
Equality of outcome is easier to enforce by punishing the top percentile, rather than bringing the bottom percentiles up to par. By definition, there's less in the upper percentile, so less work is needed. From my understanding of education in America, the path of least resistance is the one taken.
← PreviousPage 5 of 14Next →