HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

trutannus

1,118 karma · joined February 24, 2021

submissionscomments
trutannus··on The NSA and CIA use ad blockers
Somewhere deep under the ice of Antarctica.
trutannus··on The NSA and CIA use ad blockers
This is how you end up with three layers of VMs for browsing the internet. Some gov organizations go a little into the deep end of security in the security-usability continuum.
trutannus··on The NSA and CIA use ad blockers
You're not alone. I took out my partner's online calendar by mistake with a PiHole. I think I blocked all her productivity SaaS tools too. Found out in under 5 minutes.
trutannus··on Reactive Clojure: A web language
Sadly the running out of steam effect hits the tooling for the community too. It's really hard to find good, stable clojure tools on the level of those available for Java.
trutannus··on Ludwig Wittgenstein: A Mind on Fire
The only sources for the claim are evangelic Christian websites, and this specific thread. This thread is actually one of the top results for the search now. I've spent a lot of time reading Wittgenstein, and reading about Wittgenstein. This was never mentioned in any credible source I've come across.
trutannus··on Show HN: Resume maker with no sign-up or subscription
Sometimes not even an commonly talked about bias like race or gender. It can be as simple as "this person looks annoying".
trutannus··on Startup aims to make piloting a jetpack as easy as flying a drone
How on earth do you escape in a jetpack. You own a jetpack. First, I'm sure the list of jetpack owners is very short, and second, it's not exactly a subtle object to own. Assuming the person has burred it in their garage since...
trutannus··on Reasons to Quit Social Media
Yep, and I can't wake up with out it, nor can I stop using it despite multiple attempts. Dependence is a harm of it's own.
trutannus··on Reasons to Quit Social Media
Nothing is wrong with wanting that. I just don't think it is realistic. I've purged all social media other than HN at this point.
trutannus··on Reasons to Quit Social Media
"I don't want to stop using drugs, I just want drugs that are not going to harm me while I use them"

Unfortunately, social media by its nature is going to be harmful. It was never designed to consider the world we live in now.

trutannus··on The Framework is the most exciting laptop I've used
No, I mean if you're buying a laptop off the shelf and not ripping telemetry components and whatnot (WIFI card/airgap for example). Customizing hardware to foil any out of the box attacks, rather than some sharks-and-lasers config to 'protect it'. Governments do this all the time for even slightly sensitive information.

Commenter above was saying though that the device's anti-tamper tech would save you from state level attacks. I'm just getting at the fact that that's not going to work, since if a proverbial 'they' want to take you out, there's other ways to do so you can't overcome. Just a few examples that came to me about how easy it is to foil anti-tampering measures.

trutannus··on The Framework is the most exciting laptop I've used
> threat model is government secret services

Realistically, if your threat model is government secret services, and you're using unmodified consumer grade electronics, then you're in 'danger' no matter what. You can't effectively mitigate a threat at the state level using resources produced under the watchful eye of the same state. All they have to do is ask the producer to swap out the device they gave you with a device that comes compromised out of the box. And that's assuming the tech is perfect. Most likely they just hire someone to defeat the countermeasures. However many resources Apple has, I assure you even the most janky state has more.

trutannus··on Quran API
> My issue was you saying Islam doesn't consider other religions infidels

I see the disconnect. I agree that they say everyone else are infidels, however there's some infidels who are more acceptable than others. My understanding has always been that the sentiment is a lot closer to "these infidels are so close to the truth!". Or, at least, close enough to allow marriage and coexistence. This point was intended to counter the comment that religions say others unilaterally wrong. In this case, there's some acceptance that the others are 'on the right track'.

trutannus··on Quran API
I don't recall ever saying that my Muslim family were diaspora, or that the diaspora were the common majority. That's an assumption you made just to discredit me dishonestly. One person is now, as of 6 years ago 'diaspora', the rest are not and still live in their Muslim majority home country of over 40 million people. The problems you're talking about don't exist there.

You're also misconstruing my point in the least charitable way, and in the process implying that all Pakistani Muslims are extremists. I'm sure you see the problem with that. The only reason I brought up my family is that you stated very clearly that by being from Islamabad, and being an ex-Muslim you could not learn anything from me about Islam, with the implication being that I'm therefore ignorant since I lack the same experience.

All I have been trying to suggest is that the violence you are seeing is from a violent minority, who do not reflect the values of all. On top of that, I'm suggesting that the majority follow a different view of the issue that the extremists you're talking about. Which is a fact. Your argument is equivalent to saying that the Irish Christian terrorists mean that Christians hate Protestants. This is false, a small and violent minority do. To say it does would be cherry picking. No matter how many Northern Irish folks tell me until they are blue in the face that it is representative of all Christians, it will not make it true.

On top of that, you're veering into flame-war/abusive territory here. I'd suggest you review the HN guidelines, since your comments are getting less constructive each time: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

trutannus··on Quran API
A large portion of my family is Muslim. Many people very close to me are. Your experience does not represent every experience there is. Again, I specifically called attention to how I'm discussing the common majority of Islamic followers. You're discussing a subset which deviates from the average by a large margin. You're also discussing this in a nation known for being a hotbed of extremism. The Taliban were formed in Pakistan, so it's no surprise that there's extremists there.
trutannus··on Quran API
We're not talking about the Quran, we're discussing Islam. You're making pretty common error I see made in the Atheism world, where you're conflating the content of a holy text with the practice of a religion. I'm neither Muslim, nor any religion myself, but there's no sense in taking such a reductive approach.

Yes, you can mine around pretty much any holy book and produce quotes that say anything. If I recall, the bible has some passage about rabbits 'chewing the cud', as well as other absurdities. You'll find no recognized denominational Christian who practices rules derived from this though. In fact, you will notice practice even dictated by the Vatican deviates from the content of the Bible frequently as well.

In Islam, the practice I'm talking about is accepted to the point of being codified in their marriage law: https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext...

Section specifically allows marriage to unbelievers. Islamic scholars have expanded this into practice which allows marriage between People of the Book.

trutannus··on This implanted microchip may one day control your sleep
Well, not entirely. Not all the drugs used to treat sleep disorders are mimics of existing biomolecules. Some inhibit or modify the reception of the signaling molecules. This article talks about directly generating the substance itself.

The pills themselves also tend to be somewhat indiscriminate with where they cause the substance release. When you release a substance that does X into the body via the stomach, or even an injection, you end up with a lot more hitting receptor sites scattered across the body. For example, SSRIs often cause nausea since they affect the serotonin receptors in your GI tract. Just having serotonin released inside the brain would totally side-step this.

That said, my point is more about addiction. A large amount of sleeping pills are also common drugs of abuse, and can be highly addictive. A brain chip would not have nearly the same abuse potential.

trutannus··on Assyrian soldier diving with an inflatable goatskin bag (ca. 865–860 BC)
Given how it's nearly impossible to breathe under water without the air itself being pressurized, I highly doubt option one. If you ever tried breathing out of a tube underwater as a kid, you'll know exactly what I mean.
trutannus··on This implanted microchip may one day control your sleep
Sleeping pills are a real kettle of worms. I don't think most people have an issue with carrying pills, but sleeping pills themselves are fraught with issues from addiction to nasty side effects.
trutannus··on This implanted microchip may one day control your sleep
I like this idea, but hate the idea of needing a third party app. Something like this would have to be open for me to use it. I dislike the idea of a third party writing the code that controls something embedded in my body.

Not even for the typical reasons of 'ads and privacy'. What happens if the business fails? Someone pushes bad code? The organization is sold? Something we can't anticipate now? I'd need the certainty that I can take full control over it if needed.

trutannus··on Quran API
Well, to take the example here of Islam, that's not entirely correct. In Islam, those who are following Judaeo-Christian belief systems are considered 'brothers of the book' (or something to that effect). The worst that some sects believe is that they are 'well meaning, but not aware of the truth of Mohamed'. I'm specifically not talking about radical Jihadist sects, but the more 'middle of the road' Muslims who are closer to the average church going American than an Al-Qaeda member.
trutannus··on Quran API
Wait until you come across an API that uses POST requests as GET requests. Worked on one recently where all search operations were submitted by POSTing the data. And it wasn't even something like a "send a search request to a queue".
trutannus··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
Time really is irrelevant if you lack the resources to deal with issues quickly and effectively.
trutannus··on Freenet is a peer-to-peer platform for censorship-resistant communication
There's another side here. Some don't like companies and governments chipping away at privacy. At the same time, they don't trust Shiny New Privacy Startup 2021 to not expose them to illegal material as a result of being overrun by bad actors. I would personally rather an established organization to respect my privacy, rather than move to a new platform that does not have the resources to protect me from liability.
trutannus··on The reason employees aren't returning to work in America [video]
Fallacy of the Single Cause has become a popular ope-ed trope lately.
trutannus··on Illustrated Glossary of Organic Chemistry
Resources like this back up my idea that we teach organic chemistry wrong. It always escaped me why rote memorization is how the subject is taught, when it's actually much better suited to the 'learn by doing' approach. If you have references like this, actually doing the work of organic chemistry is much more educational!

For example: rather than trying to force people to memorize solvent-reaction combinations, have them actually try the wrong combinations and show them physically what happens. Seeing the reaction fail, then getting into why that is would likely stick more than just seeing a red X mark beside the wrong selection on paper. Always found doing the lab course first made the subject just make sense.

The "you won't always have a reference" argument is nonsense. Am I going to be teleported back in time and have to recreate modern medicine?

trutannus··on Illustrated Glossary of Organic Chemistry
One of my favorite books of all time is Organic Chemistry by Wade et al. Sadly, that book is a monster of a book.
trutannus··on A Go Package for Building Progressive Web Apps
> I built this 22 years ago

You monster!

trutannus··on The Big Escape: How the Ultra-Wealthy Avoid Paying Taxes and How to Fix It [pdf]
If I'm not mistaken, Switzerland the wealth tax hits everyone as well. The starting is something like 200K CHF. That said, the actual percentage is very low, like 0.2%. Having read a few bits of the Swiss tax code, I'd actually prefer to have this wealth tax like that over a cap-gains tax, since it would overall be a lower percentage of my capital asset appreciation than a CGT.
trutannus··on The Big Escape: How the Ultra-Wealthy Avoid Paying Taxes and How to Fix It [pdf]
They have no capital gains tax. Overall the wealth tax is a lower cost to individuals than the style of wealth taxes en-vogue in a lot of places now. Wealth taxes require liquidation of assets to pay, given the nature of wealth. When you liquidate assets, you pay cap gains tax and then have to pay the wealth tax. In Switzerland, you just pay the wealth tax. Basically, you have to be taxed to pay the tax in most places, where in Switzerland you just pay the tax without being 'double taxed'.

Liquidating assets to cover that tax works out to a lower overall tax burden on the individual than capital gains tax. Most nations that are mulling wealth taxes are considering them as an added tax layer, as opposed to the Swiss who use it as an indirect means to tax investments, rather than asking for a per-transaction gain payment. Nations that have done the approach that's opposite to Switzerland tend to reverse their wealth taxes, or see little benefit (France, for instance).

← PreviousPage 8 of 14Next →