HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

truth_

885 karma · joined April 15, 2021

submissionscomments
truth_··on Ask HN: What Are You Learning?
I am going through SICP. I have just begun.

I am learning more about Transformers architecture and modern NLP using the Hugging Face API.

Building a computer from scratch using nand2tetris on Sundays.

Learning to meditate following a detailed meditation guide. This has been working better than I expected.

Going on and off with learning classical music online (with a piano).

Learning German.

I am primarily focused on learning deploying AI to embedded devices right now. Working with the TinyML book and the course on edX.

As someone who does Computer Vision for a living, and always loved Electronics in college (no microcontrollers experience), I am finding it right at home with this. I wish I had started earlier. Really liking the experience.

truth_··on House committee approves bill that could break up Amazon, Apple, and Google
Not true.

Very high quality AI research regularly come from Facebool, Google, Microsoft, and Amazon.

Yann LeCun at FAIR is pioneering Self-Supervised Learning which is likely to be a gamechanger in AI.

truth_··on Microsoft’s own Windows 11 livestream runs into technical difficulties
I too, could not watch from the Microsoft website. I had to switch to Twitter.
truth_··on Brave Search beta
> Over the past few years, I have made several attempts to replace Google Search with DuckDuckGo

I have been using Startpage for a while. It's results are same as Google, but with zero tracking. But it puts (non-personalized) ads in results.

truth_··on A CCTV Company Is Paying Remote Workers in India to Yell at Armed Robbers
> This is the ultimate human-in-the-loop based AI you can ever have.

Where do you see AI in the article?

truth_··on Haruki Murakami and the Scarcity of Serious Thought
I have read 1Q84, and yours is the only response so far that mentions this book. It was a fascinating book.

While "Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki" is more anime-like, I found "Hard Boiled Wonderland" very full of (unpronounced) deep and profound thoughts.

I found "Sputnik Sweetheart" to be the most original work of art by him.

I am yet to read "Kafka on the Shore", "Wind Up Bird Chronicle", and some of the others.

truth_··on Haruki Murakami and the Scarcity of Serious Thought
> Second, Asian literature often seems to follow a "Life continues with or without you" path and the characters may not learn anything and may have been completely bound to their (generally doomed) trajectory from the very start and just resign themselves to their fate.

Some call that deep and meaningful--I call it crap.

You don't know anything about Asian literature or literature in general.

I am a Bengali, and there are so much deep and profoundly interesting works in Bengali literature alone- I am afraid I am going to have to die before reading all the good stuff.

Although Bengali is 1200 years old, the modern Bengali literature only started about 200 years ago, and due to invasions and political unrest during 1200-1757, there are mot much volume of work of note.

Japan has had political unrest in its history, but it is a more continued (for the lack of a better word) culture. There must be 3x-10x more works in Japanese than Bengali.

And I have left out modern and medieval Urdu literature, and whole of China out of this comment.

The fact that you are putting all of the works- literally tens of thousands if not hundreds of thousands pieces of literary art into "Asian literature" bucket and trying to generalize them foolishly shows your utter and complete ignorance in these matters.

truth_··on New Machine Learning Gems for Ruby
What do you think about Elixir in this context? Is it not "creativity-enhancing" enough?
truth_··on When Graphs Are a Matter of Life and Death
Duplicate of- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27528285
truth_··on 1931: Kurt Gödel shows limits of math, logic, computing, AI
You mention in another comment that it skipped some part of the proof and that you were disappointed. Do you still recommend the book?
truth_··on Brave, the false sensation of privacy
I found a list [0] on HN awhile ago of "free, open source and privacy respecting services and alternatives to privative services".

I have been using many of the items before I came across the list, and started using some after going through it.

Many items on the list are viable and practical alternatives to proprietary products commonly used.

[0]: https://github.com/pluja/awesome-privacy

truth_··on 1931: Kurt Gödel shows limits of math, logic, computing, AI
There are already better interpretation.

And "know that history as well as he does" approach is not suited for knowledge fields. The notion that you need to know as much as a creator to critic their works is childish and immature.

I might not know as much as him about the field, but I am sufficiently well versed about the topics discussed in this article to point out his biases and fallacies.

I am a fan of people like LeCun and Schmidhuber, but I don't worship them.

I have read many articles and listened to many talks by JS, and the kind of biases present in this article is nothing new.

truth_··on 1931: Kurt Gödel shows limits of math, logic, computing, AI
Yes, I can propose a concrete correction. Just not in the mood.

And, moreover, I don't need to. It is already "out there".

truth_··on 1931: Kurt Gödel shows limits of math, logic, computing, AI
> According to the text, however, this practical part really started with Konrad Zuse's patent application of 1936

"According to the text"

I don't agree with the text, that is the point.

truth_··on 1931: Kurt Gödel shows limits of math, logic, computing, AI
I agree with much of what he says, I just pointed out things I don't agree with.

And what's up with the wall of quote? I read the article in full.

On top of what I already said, I add that crediting Lambda Calculus as only the basis of a high-level programming language does not do it justice.

He is giving Turing and Post credit in one paragraph, and taking it away in another. As if like he cannot decide.

More importantly, Turing's approach is completely reduced to adopting "a traditional, reductionist, minimalist, binary view of computing—just like Konrad Zuse". It is not giving even close to the credit deserved. Many of the child parents to my main address to that.

truth_··on In Argentina, cheap government-issued netbooks sparked a musical Renaissance
This story, for me, proves to me again- significant things are possible if people have more liberal access to a computer and internet, and better resources in general.

The fact that many potential great artists, scientists, developers, musicians are lost to poverty, and for not having access to tools is mind-numbing.

truth_··on In Argentina, cheap government-issued netbooks sparked a musical Renaissance
You have to work with what you have.

And while I am unaware of the music scene of YT, you can get access to world-class tutorials in CS topics- from MIT, Stanford, etc. They are as good as any.

And, yes, critical feedback is very important, but while you cannot properly substitute the feedback you get at unis, you can learn to live with and benefit from internet forums, groups, subreddits, etc.

truth_··on Why I Support the Haskell Foundation
Much like novels and poetry, math and programming have sincerely contributed to my happiness.

It is not that I can't socialize or don't have friends, it's just that I don't like what most people do (like watching sports, and talking about uninteresting things, etc.) And save some specific people, I feel burned out after spending time with other people. I am known to many as an extremely sociable, and friendly person. I just don't like it.

On top of that, being heretically progressive (truly progressive, e.g. criticizing and disliking all religions and all patriarchy- Christian, Islamic, and Hindu- not toeing the modern woke liberal agenda), I cannot freely express myself except in front of my parents, SO, and about two friends.

In such a life, programming brings immense bliss. I profoundly enjoy poetry, and novels, but they are something you are consuming. I love to create things, modify and change things.

Programming, whether in microcontrollers for hobby, or solving business problems with innovative solutions, or solving project Euler problems, I feel immense joy. If programming did not exist, my life would have been significantly worse.

truth_··on 1931: Kurt Gödel shows limits of math, logic, computing, AI
I appeciate how Schmidhuber puts focus on non-US-centric history of Deep Learning and modern AI.

He sometimes overdoes these. Even when something is not related to Deep Learning and modern AI. He tries to push very narrow and one-sided views without much room for nuance.

For example- "Turing used his (quite inefficient) model only to rephrase the results of Gödel and Church on the limits of computability."

He is trying to say that Turing did nothing new, his work is a mere extension of Godel's (!), and he only accounted for practical computational reality. That is not true.

He goes on further by saying, "Later, however, the simplicity of these machines made them a convenient tool for theoretical studies of complexity." Like, Turing and Church's work was only good for that. I digress. I believe that Turing's work is more seminal and paved the way for modern general computers.

Another bit here says "The formal models of Gödel (1931-34), Church (1935), Turing (1936), and Post (1936) were theoretical pen & paper constructs that cannot directly serve as a foundation for practical computers."

It is putting the works of Turing, Post, Church, and Godel all together. Like they are the same. I see the logic as they are all impractical, but they are different levels of impractical. Putting them all under one bracket like that makes no sense.

I respect Schmidhuber a lot, but some of his behaviour is borderline childish which are more pronounced in his claims about AI history. You should be skeptical about what he says (and what anyone says).

Despite all this, I did not know many things written in this article. I learned a lot and had fun reading it.

I first read about Zuse in Isaacson's Innovators book. Did not know that he used a high-level language for a chess program. Fascinating. He is very underrated.

truth_··on 1931: Kurt Gödel shows limits of math, logic, computing, AI
If you want to learn thoroughly about Godel's Incompleteness Theorem, and all its implications, nothing is better than Godel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid by Hofstadter.

This book is quite outdated in both approaches and ideas about computers, and computer-aided approaches to Artificial Intelligence, this book still has to offer a lot. It is one of the most impactful books I have read.

truth_··on How Indian Zoroastrians helped shape modern Iran
Indian Parsis are the "model minority" of India.

They are rich, educated, charitable, and polite. Extremely low to non-existent crime rates.

They serve in the armed forces, active in academia and commerce. They are also quite highly involved in Bollywood.

truth_··on Ask HN: Can you think deeply in real time?
I can completely relate to this. Taking time to think about something really opens up many perspectives that are not accessible at the moment.

I first noticed this when I wanted to buy something but had to save money to comfortably afford it. In many cases, by the time I had saved the money, I did not want the item any more. So, I created a rule for myself, whenever I wanted to spend on something that would take more than 500, I would take 30 days to buy it. If I still wanted to buy that thing, I went for it.

This rule is still in place. I don't think about it actively, but some kind of subconscious analysis goes on from time to time.

I have saved a ton of money that I otherwise would have spent on things that I did not need or want.

Then I incorporated some variant of the rule on other avenues of my life. It translates well to other areas as well.

truth_··on Silicon Valley thought India was its future, now things have changed
Most people fail to realize this. The culture that had Ashoka as an Emperor, hosted Buddha in its soil, made breakthroughs in Mathematics and astronomy is long gone and disrupted. The condition of ower caste people were always horrible, and women were always oppressed.

But that society was also open to sex, gender identities, open, free-flowing debate, LGBTQ, alcohol, etc. that are now carnal sins in modern Hindu narrative.

What is gone is gone.

truth_··on Try APL
I recently listened to this podcast episode titled CORECURSIVE #065 From Competitive Programming to APL With Conor Hoekstra[0]. I learned a lot things there. I highly recommend it.

[0]: https://corecursive.com/065-competitive-coding-with-conor-ho...

truth_··on I saw millions compromise their Facebook accounts to fuel fake engagement
> tragedy of the commons

No tragedy of scale is only limited to one socio-economic sect. There's a proverb in Bengali- "When the village burns, can the temple be safe?"

truth_··on Apple M1 support for TensorFlow 2.5 pluggable device API
PyTorch currently provides RoCM support. Has anyone tried that?
truth_··on Ask HN: Books for Effective Communication
I don't think these can be learned through books.

What you need is practice. Years of practice in performing arts has made me good in public speaking, and my stage-fear in non-existent.

And, since my childhood, I was always encouraged by teachers to write my own amswers to literary subjects as opposed to reading answers written in companion books and teachers' notes. Years of practice made me better. You would think that the skill of literary answer writing in middle school does not translate well into writing technical blogs, or project/grant proposal. You would be wrong. Many skills are general to writing.

What I suggest is that you begin reading non-fiction books in the areas that interest you. Start blogging. It could be about anything. Then improve your writing quality through iteration. Iteration is the only way to improve your writing. Generally read more. Read _anything_.

Same goes for speaking. Join a book club. Or any Clubhouse room with a topic of your interest where things are well organized. Prepare speeches. Talk. Seek brutal feedback.

Take any opportunity to speak and write.

I must warn you that these things take time. You will not be magically better after one month. You can see progress after, say, six-seven months. And if you are in the correct path, you will feel world-encompassing cringe in your writing and speeches from six months back. This is the way.

Think of a timeframe of five/six years. Be focused. Your speaking and writing will be completely transformed.

Pro tip: many people speak and write to woo an audience, project themselves as something they are not, impress peers, etc. Their effect is limited to only a small (and often insignificant) portion of people out there. The only important goal of writing and speaking is communicating your thoughts, feelings, knowledge, intuition, and so on. Everything else comes later.

truth_··on Ask HN: Those who read “The 48 Laws of Power”
I haven't read the book, but definitely talked to at least two people who read it and felt that they have fallen victims to some of the methods described in the book.
truth_··on Google removes its head of diversity after 2007 blog post surfaces
90% of what is touted as "Palestine" was always empty.
truth_··on The Development of Erlang (1997)
What are the best resources to learn Elixir for a programmer? And what are you using?
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →