HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tsungxu

363 karma · joined August 3, 2019

https://www.vightaero.com
submissionscomments
tsungxu··on Show HN: I made a 3D printed VTOL drone
Two impressive things about Wing's design are 1) load paths are designed to break the airframe in controlled ways 2) the 4 blade props have alternating shorter and longer blades for quieter aeroacoustics

Adam Savage did a video tour of their factory recently, worth a watch

tsungxu··on Show HN: I made a 3D printed VTOL drone
Thanks, I did crash it again, and that's why it was half assembled on the wall at the end. But yeah foaming PLA is extremely soft, almost feels like tough, thin paper.
tsungxu··on Show HN: I made a 3D printed VTOL drone
Could be right! Really depends because the quad motors on freestyle say have massive throttle upside they can tap but it increases power draw and reduces flight time by multiples.
tsungxu··on Show HN: I made a 3D printed VTOL drone
Appreciate that! It's just a lot more effort making long videos with the voiceover/clips/etc.
tsungxu··on Show HN: I made a 3D printed VTOL drone
Yes I used single wall foaming PLA which is much less impact resistant and more brittle vs any foam, even cheap foamcore and especially EPP or EPO. This has definitely been an issue with crashing and rebuilding.

But my first and only other VTOL build was foamcore Readyboard and that took a 12 ft drop onto asphalt with only a slight compression in the fuselage. Never replaced it.

I would add dovetails or other clips for printed sections if I did another printed build.

Yes avionics and propulsion parts are COTS for speed, the Amprius pack is US manufactured but others are all made in China.

I'm starting to see some more Ardupilot used commercially too but yes the UX is janky and unintuitive.

tsungxu··on Show HN: I made a 3D printed VTOL drone
Not tested! But minimum I would say 70 mph. If designing for speed, I'd be looking at a cruise motor and prop that maximizes the thrust output rather than cruise efficiency

edit: at least 70 mph

tsungxu··on Show HN: I made a 3D printed VTOL drone
Thanks, I've not! But given the battery mass fraction is 53% for this build, rule of thumb is about 30% of a VTOL's weight for battery if you want to include payload. So I could just use a smaller 6S battery.

Or I could probably add another ~0.5 lbs or a little more without issue. The lifting motors hover at 45% ish throttle so there is some headroom for more payload without reducing battery mass fraction.

tsungxu··on Show HN: I made a 3D printed VTOL drone
And also iteration cycles slow down, adds cost to development and qualification if making them in-house for larger prototypes.
tsungxu··on Show HN: I made a 3D printed VTOL drone
And the weight (and drag) penalty is ~5% given the actuators and subassemblies for tilting don't come for free either.

This is also the most the penalty will ever be as electric motors continue increasing in specific power, and quite rapidly this century so far.

tsungxu··on Show HN: I made a 3D printed VTOL drone
It's actually not a terrible inefficiency.

With this config, the cruise motors and prop are optimally sized for cruise - which gives non trivial gains to both eta for propulsive motor efficiency and prop efficiency.

Vs a tiltrotor/wing/body in which the cruise motor has to do double duty as lifting motors. Given it takes anywhere from ~4-7x more power to hover (depending on disc loading) than to cruise, you can see how the motors are not in an optimal throttle/rpm band in this case. Archer's CTO Munoz has actually said this publicly.

tsungxu··on Show HN: I made a 3D printed VTOL drone
Thanks! Yes ~$700 without battery and I scored the Amprius pack on special for $700 but it is currently $1300.
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
I first heard of seeds growing into structures from Drew Endy at Stanford. Fascinating concept. May take several more generations of biomaterials to get there.
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Thanks! Not financial advice but some of the public companies that offer services in the biomanufacturing tech stack. Performance biomaterials companies are not public yet and may take quite a few years to get there.
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Nice. I've heard a little about chitosan and am aware of keratin but not as a biomaterial. The case the article makes is that functional biomaterials with superior properties have not been made at any scale but that it is on the way.
tsungxu··on A New Materials Paradigm Is Overdue
Actually it's not, these are two separate articles.
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Thanks, fixed.
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
I think the shift to centralized production is not necessarily permanent.

Energy generation is decentralizing again. We can make more and more manufacturing feedstocks (metals, H2, CO2, biomolecules) using more modular processes that can also be decentralized.

tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Nuclear is very important. It's just not scaling fast enough.

I don't see a future where next-gen SMR nor fusion gets to cost parity with renewables quickly or easily. They will have to scale up via beachhead markets adjacent to existing electricity demand sources.

Long term, I do think economically viable fusion will supplant renewables, but that's decades away.

tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Agreed! I'm also bullish on more localized manufacturing in which we have more control over the function, aesthetic and shape of the end products.
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
I've not seen that research or finding. It seems we're super early in the potential of 2D materials, especially as you say, as they come down the cost curve.
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Very welcome.
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Thanks for sharing!
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Agreed! It is and will play a big role in current and future innovations in the world of atoms.
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Thanks, that's how I largely felt too. Software is a key part of developing biomaterials too, but deep tech is so much more.
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Not any blogs that I know of specifically on performance biomaterials.

But this podcast with 6 episodes is great: https://open.spotify.com/show/5ldzwDpvUsaaQVVjMLRlLA?si=33fb...

Also SynBioBeta has some great content as well: https://synbiobeta.com/read/

tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Agreed. Still very early in the adoption of these materials, and biomaterials in particular
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Thanks, I'll take a look!
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Thank you!
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Thanks for sharing the thread!
tsungxu··on Biomanufactured materials are coming
Thanks for sharing!
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →