HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ttonkytonk

187 karma · joined April 18, 2017

submissionscomments
ttonkytonk··on Bill Gates Should Stop Telling Africans What Kind of Agriculture Africans Need
The article was originally published in 2021.
ttonkytonk··on Are humans a cancer on the planet? A physician argues that civilization truly is
I'm with the people who hope that humanity will go extinct.

The "virtueization" of excess and deception creates a psychic nightmare for many, many whose voices are ignored and eventually muted.

It's untenable to take power and forgo responsibility. It's untenable to ignore the existential issues facing individuals, or pretend they don't exist. And it's especially untenable (in my opinion) to employ deception and willful ignorance as the rule.

ttonkytonk··on Italy shocks banks with 40 percent windfall tax for 2023
But we don't want the sharks to turn on us - it should be demonstrated that 1) they're not being cheated (or robbed) and 2) that their welfare is not being seriously compromised.
ttonkytonk··on Italy shocks banks with 40 percent windfall tax for 2023
If liberty can be sacrificed through conscription, why not property through taxes?
ttonkytonk··on There Is No Housing Crisis
May also find this article interesting (even if you don't necessarily agree with the identity politics): https://hoodcommunist.org/2022/04/21/the-jackson-kush-plan-t...
ttonkytonk··on The world nears feared global warming 'tipping points': 5 disastrous scenarios
Basing taxes on income and/or expenditures as opposed to property, and supplying a universal basic level of support for necessities?

As things are now, many or most are defacto forced to work(and consume - I believe the two are correlated {e.g. "I'm working like hell but will make up for it with a big vacation"}).

I believe universal guarantees of the necessities are justified in virtue of most or all resources being privitized and opportunities regulated. Besides, it appears many or most don't have an appetite to watch their fellow citizens starve or go completely without.

Please note that many or most people don't really want to "do nothing", they just want acceptable circumstances. It's hard for acceptable circumstances to exist in an environment that values extreme wealth. (For example, intellectually it may not seem like a big deal to compensate for increasing expenses by "working a little harder", but at some point that becomes "a lot harder".)

ttonkytonk··on Climate Change Hasn’t Set the World on Fire
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2022/06/220630095714.h...

"Key findings from the analyses include:

    The length of the annual fire weather season has increased by 14 days per year (27%) during 1979-2019 on average globally and the frequency of days with extreme fire weather has increased by 10 days per year (54%) during 1979-2019 on average globally.
    Fire weather has risen significantly in most world regions since the 1980s. Increases have been particularly pronounced in western North America, Amazonia and the Mediterranean. Fire weather has already emerged beyond its natural variability in the Mediterranean and Amazonia due to historical warming.
    At 2°C this will also be the case in the boreal forests of Siberia, Canada and Alaska and the temperate forests of the western US. At 3°C, virtually all world regions will experience unprecedented fire weather.
    Globally, the area burned by fires has decreased by around one-quarter -- or 1.1 million km2 -- during 2001-2019. Much of the decrease -- 590,000 km2 -- has been in African savannahs, where 60-70% of the area burned by fire occurs annually. Local/regional human impacts have reduced the area burned by fire in tropical savannahs, in combination with lower grassland productivity during (increasingly drier) wet seasons.
    Large increases in burned area have been observed elsewhere, and especially in temperate and boreal forests. For example, the area burned by fire has increased by 21,400 km2 (93%) in east Siberian forests and by 3,400 km2 (54%) in the forests of western North America (Pacific Canada and US combined).***"
ttonkytonk··on Do something, so we can change it
The Wikipedia page on it looks pretty good: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sociocracy

Sociocratisch Centrum co-founder Reijmer has summarized the difference as follows: "By consensus, I must convince you that I'm right; by consent, you ask whether you can live with the decision".

ttonkytonk··on Ask HN: How do I get started in philosophy
Okay, thanks for the link and the insight!
ttonkytonk··on Ask HN: How do I get started in philosophy
If you learn by reading, read primary sources: Protagoras, Plato, Aristotle, Descartes, Hume, Kant, Hegel (the Science of Logic in particular), in that order, are basically what you need to get caught up to modernity in philosophy.

What would be a primary source for Protagoras? It appears none of his works are extant.

ttonkytonk··on Ask HN: How do I get started in philosophy
A "Philosophy for Dummies" - type book would probably serve as an adequate introduction, as well as the online resources already mentioned.

I'm a big fan of Socratic philosophy, and there's two main sources for this, Xenophon and Plato.

Xenophon's main Socratic work is traditionally titled The Memorabilia and there are two older translations available online, The Memorable Thoughts of Socrates (Henry Morley) and The Memorabilia (H.G. Dakyns). The latter has footnotes and is probably the better translation but the former might be a little easier to read, but they're both pretty old. A good modern option is Conversations of Socrates (Hugh Tredennick/ Robin Waterfield) which includes all of Xenophon's Socratic works (and useful footnotes). My advice is to try and not take the somewhat moralistic tone of Xenophon too seriously.

All of Plato's dialogues that are generally agreed to be authentic are available for free online, per the old but very readable translations of Benjamin Jowett. Everything attributed to Plato is contained in Plato Complete Works (John M. Cooper). Plato Collected Dialogues (Edith Hamilton and Huntington Cairns) has all of the authentic dialogues plus a few others. The Last Days of Socrates (Hugh Tredennick, I think revised by Robin Waterfield) has the four relevant Platonic dialogues (including Apology {"Socrates' Defense"} which might be the best record of things Socrates actually said.)

The Republic is available on the Perseus Tufts website with lots of good footnotes. I happened to have read Allan Bloom's translation and it has lots of good footnotes and interesting observations too, though I think his opinions may have been somewhat outside those of mainstream scholarship.

Also the third century AD/CE Lives and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers (Diogenes Laertius) is interesting and quite readable (though I haven't read all of it) and could serve as a (dated) introduction to ancient Greek philosophy itself.

ttonkytonk··on Greed and Excess Drive the Climate Crisis, So Why Aren’t They Being Questioned?
"...if the top 10% of global emitters were to cut their carbon footprint to that of the typical EU citizen... that alone would cut global emissions by around one third." - p.208 The Climate Book (Greta Thunberg)
ttonkytonk··on The key to understanding complex systems is patience
I still have considerable difficulty with interpersonal patience, but I feel I've learned something about the sort of personal patience the article is talking about.

Basically when I feel myself becoming inpatient (it's a feeling in my chest, kind of an anxious feeling) I will stop and take a little breath, and give myself a chance to "reframe" mentally a little bit.

I tend to be obsessive about thoroughness as well, and while I still struggle with this, I've learned to "8-bit" things, kind of mentally "zoom out", so to speak.

I've also learned to be okay with not taking the time for something if I don't feel like it (the rule of thumb is to push through minor pain, but to respect serious resistance).

ttonkytonk··on Don’t Forget Intuition: The art of doing science
A review of In a Flight of Starlings: The Wonders of Complex Systems by Giorgio Parisi
ttonkytonk··on St Francis of Assisi
Absolutely.

I was impressed to hear that he even started addressing flames of fire as "brother flames" (iirc).

ttonkytonk··on We bailed out the banks but we’re not prepared to bail out the planet
*sympathize somewhat

The (crude) analogy that comes to mind is something akin to the "checks and balances" of U.S. government, with the head of one checking the ass of the other, but instead everybody's head is under everybody else's ass.

ttonkytonk··on We bailed out the banks but we’re not prepared to bail out the planet
My opinion is speculative and not well-informed, but if I had to guess I would say 1) our governments are more or less defacto oligarchies (or at least the politicians are generally on the upper end of the economic spectrum), and 2) because of many social factors this seems to be a real uphill climb, so I can actually sympathize with politicians who on one hand have maybe a vague sense that they won't suffer the worst effects of climate change and on the other don't necessarily have a clear or great path to produce the needed changes.
ttonkytonk··on Ask HN: Who is your favourite living philosopher?
She understands that to know the good is to do the good, the criterion established by Socrates, the only philosopher worth his salt in a sea of bigoted pedants.
ttonkytonk··on Ask HN: Who is your favourite living philosopher?
Who is your favorite living philosopher? Which living philosopher has changed the world the most? Which of the living philosophers is the most truthful, at least in theory?

Greta Thunberg: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zlTBi5nkBT4

ttonkytonk··on Our culture war is not a distraction
"Rather than a reflection of antipathies between Right and Left, today’s culture war is a continuation of the age-old conflict between liberty and authoritarianism."

Is private ownership of most or all the land, without compensation, compatible with liberty? You shouldn't have to be a Marxist to understand why this should be a central question. I'm not sure what the answer is, but as long as this question is ignored, the conversation isn't a serious one, in my opinion.

I agree that the culture war is "not a distraction" however, and I have some strong feelings about it, though I think they're ultimately peculiar to my circumstances.

But I've noticed works of Plato and copies of Don Quixote removed from my local library. Now I'm not sure they're victims of the culture war (there's a move towards "e-books", and not all of the books by this author/under this title have been removed), but I have my suspicions.

In chapter 29 of Part One of Don Quixote, there's this episode where Sancho Panza is troubled in thought while contemplating rule of the kingdom of Micomicon (an invented name that suggests the words mico {"monkey"} and comico {"comical"}) of Ethiopia that all his subjects will be black, but reassures himself with the thought that he can sell them into slavery.

Now I'm sure this is shockingly racist for modern ears, but are contemporary psyches so fragile that they can't handle the blunt prejudice of a silly, fictional seventeenth century Spanish peasant?

My guess is that the subject of slavery is also why Plato could be considered "problematic". My understanding of his thinking is that authority of those with knowledge over those without is natural, or at least ideal (think of our relationship with young children and animals, which in the latter Plato included humans), and this line of thought would have undergirded his acceptance of slavery. This is different from approving of the exploitation of humans (or potentially any animal for that matter) based on race, and/or without regard for their welfare (the implied onus is not to be less, but more concerned about the welfare of those under one's authority). Also, the most important kind of liberty for Plato is liberty of the soul or psyche, which is hindered by the appetites and desires of the body.

(Note- minor edits throughout)

ttonkytonk··on Monopoly: the capitalist board game’s leftwing origins
Interesting article, but lots of ads - when a video ad started auto-playing, I stopped reading it.
ttonkytonk··on What is happening in the Atlantic Ocean to the AMOC?
"Conclusion

Timing of the critical AMOC transition is still highly uncertain, but increasingly the evidence points to the risk being far greater than 10 % during this century – even rather worrying for the next few decades. The conservative IPCC estimate, based on climate models which are too stable and don’t get the full freshwater forcing, is in my view outdated now. I side with the recent Climate Tipping Points report by the OECD, which advised:

'Yet, the current scientific evidence unequivocally supports unprecedented, urgent and ambitious climate action to tackle the risks of climate system tipping points.'"

ttonkytonk··on It’s Time to Bring Back Asylums
I wonder how things might be different if President Reagan hadn't repealed most of the Mental Health Systems Act:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mental_Health_Systems_Act_of_1...

ttonkytonk··on Exxon bets carbon will be the new oil
Asking Exxon to take action to prevent global warming is like asking the foxes to guard the hen house:

https://tz.linkedin.com/posts/alisheridan_assessing-exxonmob...

ttonkytonk··on The past is not true
History is true, but the history anyone knows is selective, a mental model, often guessed or interpreted, and usually secondhand information.
ttonkytonk··on Why can't we stop homelessness? why there's no end in sight
I am implying that the real problem (or close to it) is the unlimited acquisition of wealth - I mean individuals who can afford thousands of homes.

But speaking of reason - it certainly has its limits. If reason is ignored, it may well eventually succumb to anger.

ttonkytonk··on Why can't we stop homelessness? why there's no end in sight
To clarify, in the Republic the spirited part of the soul that is dominated by the appetitive part is compared to an ape or monkey (perhaps in allusion to a sort of buffoon). Similarly I was comparing the spirited part of Marx's (or Marxism's) soul to a manticore.
ttonkytonk··on Why can't we stop homelessness? why there's no end in sight
You sure do seem anxious to make "hard decisions" for people used to them.

How about some "hard decisions" for people who aren't, e.g. people who can, all by themselves, afford thousands of private homes forever?

ttonkytonk··on Why can't we stop homelessness? why there's no end in sight
But again, the overriding problem, they say, is the dire lack of places low-income people can afford to live.

"There's really no way to solve homelessness without seriously addressing this," says Kushel, the UCSF researcher. "Otherwise, we're going to be compelled to continue to spend huge amounts of money managing an increasingly out of control crisis."

Judging from the comments so far, there seems to be a lot of emotion involved in them. I haven't read the first work by Marx, but my sense is his work had a thread of anger running through it.

In Plato's Republic, the tripartite soul(Greek "psyche") consists of the appetitive part (compared to a multi-headed beast), a spirited, honor-loving part associated with the emotion of anger (compared to a lion), and the rational part (compared to a human being). It depicts the soul dominated by the appetitive part being like an ape or monkey. To use the same line of thought, I think Marx's soul may have been dominated by the spirited part, which could be compared to a manticore (a beast with the body of a lion and the face of a human). Capitalism, on the other hand, is dominated by the appetitive part.

Also it's pointed out in the Republic that unlimited acquisition of wealth results in wars (due to needing more land/resources) and health problems (due to overindulgence).

I could say more, and I know my comment is somewhat unfocused, but if you keep ignoring the foundations of these issues, you're not going to be able to fix the problem.

Remember in A Christmas Carol (yes, I know Charles Dickens didn't "walk on water"), how the Spirit of Christmas Present showed Scrooge the two children, Want and Ignorance? I see a generation of un- or under-educated children coming up that has been given a bill they never could have or would have agreed to. How do you think they must feel? What should they do?

ttonkytonk··on Why can't we stop homelessness? why there's no end in sight
Please name a relevant board that takes as little data, and I'm there!
← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →