HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ttonkytonk

187 karma · joined April 18, 2017

submissionscomments
ttonkytonk··on Ask HN: What are you doing to fight climate change?
I've seen it suggested to replace them with clover as well.
ttonkytonk··on The Odyssey by Homer, Translated by Samuel Butler
I'm sure there are better, more recent translations, but I've read Plato: Complete Works (John Cooper) and a reasonable bit of Jowett's translations, and in my (layman's) opinion, if newer translations aren't available, Jowett's will do just fine.
ttonkytonk··on The Odyssey by Homer, Translated by Samuel Butler
>But these translations are, generally speaking, poor.

I think that's an unfair characterization - Benjamin Jowett's translations of Plato's dialogues are decent and readable (these are readily available online). I also liked H.G. Dakyn's translations of Xenophon's The Memorabilia and The Symposium:

https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/1177/pg1177-images.html

https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/1181/pg1181-images.html

ttonkytonk··on Epistemological Relativism (2016)
The article's reference to Plato's discussion concerning Protagoras' doctrine that "Man is the measure of all things" (expounded in Protagoras' lost book, Truth) can be found in Plato's Theaetetus, beginning at 152.
ttonkytonk··on Ask HN: Are You Happy?
Not that I'll die, it works, but I had to cut it off after it ran for hours straight and couldn't even hold 90° (its highest setting).

Otherwise, like I told someone else today who asked me this same question, I'm "relatively happy".

ttonkytonk··on Ask HN: Are You Happy?
No, because I'm sitting in a 95°F apartment because, despite complaining many times over the years I've been here, they refuse to replace the AC unit which is old and seems to have a freon leak.

They've had plenty of money to do lots of cosmetic renovations though, and no wonder since the rent has increased over 25% in four years.

ttonkytonk··on Relaxed beliefs under Psychedelics and the Anarchic Brain
Interview:

https://youtu.be/S0NSi7tiQBE

College lecture:

https://youtu.be/QKde3rIVZ14

ttonkytonk··on Relaxed beliefs under Psychedelics and the Anarchic Brain
>"Speaking of Carhart-Harris’ overenthusiasm for psychedelics running a little ahead of the evidence, the paper ends with a weird section comparing the hierarchial structure of the brain to the hierarchical structure of society, and speculating that just as psychedelics cause an “anarchic brain” where the highest-level brain structures fail to “govern” lower-level activity, so they may cause society to dissolve or something:

Two figureheads in psychedelic research and therapy, Stanislav Grof and Roland Griffiths, have highlighted how psychedelics have historically “loosed the Dionysian element” (Pollan, 2018) to the discomfort of the ruling elite, i.e., not just in 1960s America but also centuries earlier when conquistadors suppressed the use of psychedelic plants by indigenous people of the same continent. Former Harvard psychology professor, turned psychedelic evangelist, Timothy Leary, cajoled that LSD could stand for “Let the State Dissolve” (Pollan, 2018). Whatever the interaction between psychedelic use and political perspective, we hope that psychedelic science will be given the best possible opportunity to positively impact on psychology, psychiatry, and society in the coming decades—so that it may achieve its promise of significantly advancing self-understanding and health care."

I wonder how many people are aware that Timothy Leary was a fan of Socrates! He mentions him in an interview as being "his model" (idol?), and "the cause of all the trouble". There's another video made late in his life where he mentions providing material related to Socrates to a group of college students (with not-so-much emphasis on psychedelic drugs to the best of my memory, though Socrates wasn't the main subject matter either).

Socrates, as presented by Xenophon and Plato, considered the state, defined as a group of individuals that cooperate for their mutual benefit, to be a noble thing that he would have no interest in dissolving, merely improving. I think this is likely the intent of the authors as well (notice they say, "... the best possible opportunity to positivity impact..."), and I would wager the late Leary himself if pressed (note that despite everything, in the end American society tolerated him).

ttonkytonk··on Aristotle’s Rules for Living Well
My point is that Ethiopia is mentioned, and therefore there is probably some influence there.
ttonkytonk··on Aristotle’s Rules for Living Well
Christian/Judeo (as well as ancient Greek) thought is probably indebted to the thought of places like Egypt and Ethiopia as well.

Interestingly, I think in both The Illiad and The Odyssey there is a mention of a god making a trip to Ethiopia.

ttonkytonk··on Aristotle’s Rules for Living Well
>Instead i care if i can get enough sleep, enough relaxing, enough studying, enough working to fullfill my life or not.

And that's not a desire to "live well"?

I think your objection is key to understanding Socrates' denial of "weakness of will" (Protagoras 358d), an idea that Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics actually supports (book seven - 1174b-15).

Maybe norms are ultimately guidelines to the good life for groups of people based on past experience, but they can't possibly account for every contingency of any particular existence.

Btw I don't think the idea is to justify any behavior, but to establish that from a rational perspective everybody is making decisions based on what seems right at the moment.

ttonkytonk··on Aristotle’s Rules for Living Well
>Things simply don't work like this on an individual level - you can be the biggest arsehole in the village and still potentially live a happy, meaningful life. Or live in virtue and miserable.

This is pretty much the complaint of Socrates' interlocutors in The Republic.

Socrates (or Plato) might object that "being the biggest arsehole" would entail security concerns that would hinder happiness.

They may also object to such a life being meaningful if it involves indulging one's desires to the detriment of the rest of the villagers. Don't the villagers make their happiness possible? Will their arseholiness help sustain what makes human life meaningful into perpetuity, or set the stage for its destruction?

ttonkytonk··on Counting the Hard Way
In base 12, the multiplication tables are (likely) easier to learn because of the increase in factors (e.g. 3 would be "3,6,9,10,13..." and 4 would be "4,8,10,14..." 8 would be "8,14,20,28..." and 9 would be "9,16,23,30,39...").
ttonkytonk··on Climate Apocalypse Inbound/Emergency – Why Invest Resources on Better AI and Ads
If we can somehow significantly lower travel and power use, since these two are responsible for most of the emissions.

Locating manufacturing as close as possible to the consumption source might help immensely. Heating and cooling are major culprits - 78/68° farenheit are traditional thermostat-conservation goals, but I would encourage healthy people to try 85/60°f (from personal experimentation due to necessity - i.e. a tight budget. Maybe even 90/55 is doable as an upper/lower limit, but be careful with the upper limit).

A main driver also seems to be rents, whether tenant rents or property taxes. Is there a way to reduce the need for people/governments/society to do/have/need so much?

Supporting the infrastructure of affluent lifestyles is also an important factor (this is not a judgement, just an observation).

But perhaps the biggest problems are existential or philosophical. I almost get the feeling that there's so much mutual disgust with humanity that there's a tacit agreement to "commit suicide", in a sense, which in this case requires no special effort. So maybe a little existential reassurance is in order, along the lines of, 'Humanity's been through a lot, a lot of change, and especially a crisis of meaning with the compromise in authority of the traditional sources' (an evolving and unresolved issue).

Also, addressing global warming should not be a miserable endeavor. For example, less travel and more relaxed lifestyles can be happier ones, and while "bringing manufacturing home" may result in more expensive things, it would probably help the unemployment issues in America (which are greater than appreciated) significantly.

Then there's existential/philosophical "intangible benefits" that should be considered, e.g. how much better people might feel knowing their products come from people they know are making fair wages, and knowing they're working to provide a future for their descendants that they can be proud of.

ttonkytonk··on Video Chess disassembled and commented
This is off topic (I owned an Atari 2600, and loved Atari, but never owned Video Chess), but I've come up with a chess variant I call "Transposition Chess" (not to be confused with Transcendental Chess).

The rules are the same with three major differences.

I) Black has the option of transposing any two pieces on their back rank before play begins. If they do they must transpose the parallel pieces on their other side to make their setup symmetrical (unless they transpose the king and queen). White must adjust their setup to mirror Black's, and then play can commence.

This creates 11 possible setups:

1)b>RNBQKBNR w>RNBQKBNR

2)b>RNBKQBNR w>RNBKQBNR

3)b>RBNQKNBR w>RBNQKNBR

4)b>BNRQKRNB w>BNRQKRNB

5)b>NRBQKBRN w>NRBQKBRN

6)b>RNQBBKNR w>RNQBBKNR

7)b>RNKBBQNR w>RNKBBQNR

8)b>RQBNNBKR w>RQBNNBKR

9)b>RKBNNBQR w>RKBNNBQR

10)b>QNBRRBNK w>QNBRRBNK

11)b>KNBRRBNQ w>KNBRRBNQ

Castleling is only possible in the first five set-ups, and will always be with the piece that occupies the Rook's original square.

II) Pieces can be demoted by moving them to an original pawn square (on one's own side of the board) and declaring a demotion. However, there must be at least one of their pawns captured that they can "exchange" it for. Note that the new pawn could deliver checkmate/stalemate.

III) Pawns can only be promoted to pieces currently captured. If no pieces are currently captured, the pawn may not move to the promotion rank (as if a piece was blocking it). Note that it may still deliver checkmate/stalemate in this position, as normal.

The thinking behind the first rule is to make book opening memorization less of an issue (without making things too complicated or unusual) as well as giving Black compensation for moving second. The thinking behind demotions is to make games that would normally be draws due to lack of material (or skill) winning. The thinking behind the last rule is to make over-the-board play easier (e.g. no confusion about whether a piece is a pawn or queen), though it also potentially makes "two for one" exchanges more attractive for the person capturing two pieces (I recently saw somewhere that there's some evidence that when the queen is exchanged for two rooks or the rook for two minor pieces, the person losing two pieces typically does better, though nominally they have less in material value).

ttonkytonk··on The Decade of Sock Hops, Poodle Skirts, and Climate Change Awareness
@cpncrunch - for some reason it's not letting me respond directly to your comment.

The link you have provided seems to show a decrease in total fires but some increase in actual area burned.

It's natural for media to exaggerate somewhat.

There's been many reports of an increase of the wildfire season in California, though it's not necessarily all driven by global warming.

ttonkytonk··on The Decade of Sock Hops, Poodle Skirts, and Climate Change Awareness
This is why in The Republic (the dramatic setting being a chance, informal discussion about justice), the ruling class was not allowed to have private property - because it warps their judgement. What's interesting is that despite this prohibition, Socrates refuses to concede that they would not be happy, the implication being that their jobs as rulers would be sufficient.

Notice how many games involve power and control. How much happier might people be, if they had some real power in decision-making in their communities!

ttonkytonk··on The Decade of Sock Hops, Poodle Skirts, and Climate Change Awareness
...and yet you're cherry picking information from the article, the main point being that global warming was a well known phenomena in the 1950's!

I just don't get it - this is an existential threat, and people are still in denial.

ttonkytonk··on A mysterious bright green flash on Jupiter was just captured by NASA
The article says, "The green flash on Jupiter was captured during Juno’s 31st close flyby of the planet on December 30, 2020."
ttonkytonk··on Dietrich Bonhoeffer on stupidity (1943)
> Alternative interpretation: If someone has managed to be around for 1,000 years and you think they are stupid, then maybe your definition of "stupidity" is the wrong one.

I'd be surprised if they were.

ttonkytonk··on Dietrich Bonhoeffer on stupidity (1943)
This reminds me of a passage in Plato's Theaetetus (143e-144b):

Socrates:... So if you have come across anyone worth mentioning, I should be glad to hear.

Theodorus: Well Socrates, I think you ought to be told... about a remarkable boy I have met here... Along with a quickness beyond the capacity of most people, he has an unusually gentle temper...I never thought a combination could exist; I don't see it arising elsewhere. People as acute and keen and retentive as he is are apt to be very unbalanced. They get swept up in a rush, like ships without ballast; what stands for courage in their makeup is a kind of mad excitement; while, on the other hand, the steadier sort of people are apt to come to their studies with minds that are sluggish, somehow - freighted with a bad memory. But this boy approaches his studies in a smooth, sure, effective way, and with great good temper; it reminds one of the quiet flow of a stream of oil.(...)

ttonkytonk··on Dietrich Bonhoeffer on stupidity (1943)
"If we want to know how to get the better of stupidity, we must seek to understand its nature."

The philosophical attitude should be trying to understand. The way I think about it, if someone has been around for 1,000 years and yet is indulgently stupid then maybe I have some right to be angry with them, otherwise I should consider that they haven't been around that long and are understandably susceptible to the double ignorance of thinking they know what they don't.

"Here we must come to terms with the fact that in most cases a genuine internal liberation becomes possible only when external liberation has preceded it."

This statement reflects a general observation present in Socratic (or Platonic and Xenophonic) philosophy that those with the most power and authority are basically by definition most responsible for changing things for the better. Without organization and attention people act on an individual level, and their apparent unreasonableness may be a concession to their limited circumstances.

"The word of the Bible that the fear of God is the beginning of wisdom declares that the internal liberation of human beings to live the responsible life before God is the only genuine way to overcome stupidity."

"God" could be replaced with "Nature" for those of a modern, skeptical bent, but nevertheless can combine a humility resulting from an awareness of the limits of human knowledge with a confidence in greater meaning in virtue of the existence of humanity and the ordered cosmos itself.

ttonkytonk··on Homeless Numbers Rise in U.S. Cities
The original post said nothing about being anti-feminist.
ttonkytonk··on Socrates
The article states:

Socrates's theory of virtue states that all virtues are essentially one, since they are a form of knowledge. For Socrates, the reason a person is not good is because they lack knowledge. Since knowledge is united, virtues are united as well. Another famous dictum—"no one errs willingly"—also derives from this theory. In Protagoras, Socrates argues for the unity of virtues using the example of courage: if someone knows what the relevant danger is, they can undertake a risk. Aristotle comments: " ... Socrates the elder thought that the end of life was knowledge of virtue, and he used to seek for the definition of justice, courage, and each of the parts of virtue, and this was a reasonable approach, since he thought that all virtues were sciences, and that as soon as one knew [for example] justice, he would be just..."

Socrates' ethics implied a unity of experience. One's person's loss is not another person's gain - the material benefit one person gets at the expense of another does material harm to the latter, and psychic (or spiritual) harm to the former - if nothing else, their character is harmed.

ttonkytonk··on Daniel Ellsberg Is Dying. and He Has Some Final Things to Say
While I think your first sentence is true, I think this is a consequence of being human - i.e. it's hard to be an objective observer.

Remember, all these countries were Warsaw Pact countries. And from my limited knowledge of the situation I recall that Russia's attempt to join NATO was basically responded with, "You have to wait your turn" as if they were just another country, not the country that the alliance was formed because of to begin with.

It's kind of like the story of the prodigal son, only instead of a joyous welcome the father tells him to "wait his turn".

It's also occurred to me that things like not allowing Russian athletes to fly their flag at the Olympics must be profoundly humiliating.

I remember happening to see a speech a neo-con made where they called the idea of thinking of countries in terms of international citizens (and therefore the U.S. should behave like a good citizen) "crazy", but the question is, "how else should we act?" It's kind of like thinking of various universities in terms of their sports rivalries, instead of institutions of higher learning working for a common cause.

In conclusion, the observation that critics think in terms of moral polarities applies equally to the criticized, and should be cold comfort.

ttonkytonk··on California spent $17B on homelessness – it’s not working
Exactly. The logistics may not be simple (i.e. actually getting the federal government's support) but the logic should be obvious: piecemeal support results in the ones that are doing the most to help get "penalized" with more people seeking help.
ttonkytonk··on Head-Trapped – Descartes, Dawkins, Hobbes, Marx, Mill, Darwin
I believe the author's point is not that you can't have thoughts (how can you not?), but that they're not identical with identity, and that awareness is more fundamental to identity, a great insight of Eastern philosophy.

I have wondered if Socrates had this insight. Judging from Plato and Xenophon's writings about him he may have not had such a clear view of it, but he does speak of his bodily feelings as being separate from himself (e.g. in Plato's Phaedo, while sitting in prison he remarks that if it was up to his legs he would be in earnest flight from Athens.)

I think the author is pretty close to the truth of things; however, things like anger and "addiction to thinking" are not so easily overcome (at least in my experience), but awareness of them seems like a necessary first step.

ttonkytonk··on Nirvana fallacy
The linked article "Appeal to consequences" is also interesting.
ttonkytonk··on A temperature rise of 2 degrees Celsius impacts billions
I don't know, what you said is pretty confusing.

Either the temperatures are increasing or they're not. Either CO2 is retaining heat and increasing temperatures or it's not.

But ocean surface temperatures are 0.9°C warmer whereas temperatures over land are 1.9°C warmer.

And the Arctic is warming at least three times faster than the globe as a whole since the mid-1990s primarily due to the "ice-albedo feedback" where the melting of sun-reflecting ice results in more heat absorption.

(per "The Climate Book" {Greta Thunberg} pp 78 and 62)

ttonkytonk··on A temperature rise of 2 degrees Celsius impacts billions
Would you prefer denial of the denial? I only know what I learn from the media, so as far as I know, you could be right.

But is there not a consensus from the scientists, the people in the best position to know? Does CO2 not come from combusting fossil fuels, remain in the atmosphere for long periods, and retain heat?

But this is an issue - whether in denial or in reasonable doubt, many are unconvinced.

← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →