HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tutanchamun

316 karma · joined June 28, 2016

submissionscomments
tutanchamun··on AMD Radeon VII 16 GB Review
Other reviews:

- (anandtech) https://www.anandtech.com/show/13923/the-amd-radeon-vii-revi...

- (tomshardware) https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/amd-radeon-vii-vega-20-...

- (techpowerup) https://www.techpowerup.com/reviews/AMD/Radeon_VII/

- (arstechnica) https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2019/02/amd-radeon-vii-a-7nm-...

- (gamersnexus) https://www.gamersnexus.net/hwreviews/3437-amd-radeon-vii-re...

- (gizmodo) https://gizmodo.com/amds-radeon-vii-is-a-solid-gaming-card-b...

- (gamespot) https://www.gamespot.com/articles/radeon-vii-review-can-amds...

- (digitaltrends) https://www.digitaltrends.com/computing/amd-radeon-vii-revie...

- (extremetech) https://www.extremetech.com/computing/285286-amd-radeon-vii-...

- (pcper) https://www.pcper.com/reviews/Graphics-Cards/AMD-Radeon-VII-...

- (techspot) https://www.techspot.com/review/1789-amd-radeon-vii/

- (tweaktown) https://www.tweaktown.com/reviews/8894/amd-radeon-vii-review...

- (engadget) https://www.engadget.com/2019/02/07/amd-radeon-vii-review-vi...

- (pcmag) https://www.pcmag.com/review/366382/amd-radeon-vii

- (techradar) https://www.techradar.com/reviews/amd-radeon-vii

- (hothardware) https://hothardware.com/reviews/amd-radeon-vii-review-and-be...

- (kitguru) https://www.kitguru.net/tech-news/zardon/no-custom-radeon-vi...

- (hardwarezone) https://www.hardwarezone.com.sg/review-amd-radeon-vii-review...

- (rockpapershotgun) https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2019/02/07/amd-radeon-7-rev...

- (hexus) https://hexus.net/tech/reviews/graphics/126752-amd-radeon-vi...

- (bit-tech) https://bit-tech.net/reviews/tech/graphics/amd-radeon-vii-re...

- (legitreviews) https://www.legitreviews.com/amd-radeon-vii-16gb-video-card-...

- (overclock3d) https://www.overclock3d.net/reviews/gpu_displays/amd_radeon_...

- (techgage) https://techgage.com/article/amd-radeon-vii-1440p-4k-ultrawi...

- (computerbase - google translate) https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https...

- (pc games hardware - google translate) https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=de&tl=en&u=http%3A...

- (harwareluxx - google translate) https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=de&tl=en&u=https%3...

- (golem - google translate) https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=de&tl=en&u=https%3...

- (hardware.info - google translate) https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=nl&tl=en&u=https%3...

tutanchamun··on AMD Radeon VII, FP64 Not Dialed Back – 6.9TF of FP64 for $699
Other reports [0] contradict anandtechs tweet and say FP64 is limited.

Oh well, on Februrary 7th we will know.

[0] https://techgage.com/news/radeon-vii-caps-fp64-performance/

tutanchamun··on AMD Radeon VII: High-End 7nm Vega Video Card
> There's no guarantee this won't have gimped FP64 [..]

It's not gimped according to Ryan Smith from AnandTech: https://twitter.com/RyanSmithAT/status/1083959608371175424

Which means it destroys it's only real competitor for consumer FP64 - the Titan V - which costs 3000 Dollar.

tutanchamun··on AMD Radeon VII, FP64 Not Dialed Back – 6.9TF of FP64 for $699
For people who require FP64 performance this seems like a really good deal.

The Titan V which also has 6.9 TFlops FP64 costs $2999, has 12 GByte memory compared to the Radeon VII's 16 GByte, and it has only 652.8 GB/s memory bandwidth compared to the Radeon VII's 1 TB/s.

tutanchamun··on AMD Ryzen 3rd Gen 'Matisse' Coming Mid 2019: Eight Core Zen 2 with PCIe 4.0
> “Some people may have noticed on the package some extra room,” she said with a chuckle. “There is some extra room on that package and I think you might expect we will have more than eight cores.”

Taken from: https://www.pcworld.com/article/3332205/amd/amd-ceo-lisa-su-...

tutanchamun··on AMD Ryzen 3rd Gen 'Matisse' Coming Mid 2019: Eight Core Zen 2 with PCIe 4.0
On /r/amd a user posted a different photo [0] taken from the stream which - to a layman like me - looks like there is circuitry (or whatever?) for a second chiplet.

[0] https://i.imgur.com/gzXaoJz.png

tutanchamun··on AMD Ryzen 3rd Gen 'Matisse' Coming Mid 2019: Eight Core Zen 2 with PCIe 4.0
thanks for the insight, I only ever read "games are sensitive to latency" but not exactly in what way.
tutanchamun··on AMD Ryzen 3rd Gen 'Matisse' Coming Mid 2019: Eight Core Zen 2 with PCIe 4.0
Since Rome (their server part) uses 8 chiplets for 64 cores it makes sense.

When Rome was presented last year users also speculated about GPU and FPGA chiplets. Playstation 5 rumors also speculate about chiplets to keep the price to performance ratio as low as possible (though I wonder about latency which games are sensitiv to). So going all in on chiplets and reusing them for everything would make sense for AMD.

tutanchamun··on Type erasure and reification
Why are they very different? They port the language over to another platform and need to interop with it.

For example scala.js can call js libraries through facades (similar to typescript typing files) but can also be called from javascript.

Scala.native can call c libraries (I have no idea about the other way around).

tutanchamun··on A novel way to stop the spread of antibiotic-resistant bacteria
Unfortunately not, I tried to find it yesterday but had no luck. The only documentation I could find was a recent one in german [0] but the one I watched was in english.

In this documentation they also mentioned that there are two different types of phages and only one is usable. They also mentioned that food companies already try to use them to disinfect food by spraying phages on the food.

[0] https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https... (not sure if that can even be viewed outside of germany, it's also not only about phages but multiple alternatives to antibiotics, but it seem similar -> people travel to georgia for treatment; there are two patients, one from germany and one from the netherlands)

tutanchamun··on A novel way to stop the spread of antibiotic-resistant bacteria
Bacteriophages are cool. I watched a documentary two or three years ago about western people travelling to Tbilisi, Georgia (were they use bacteriophages since the 1930s) in hope for tratment of their wounds which were infected with antibiotica resistant bacteria.

First they determined which phages to use and then they injected them into the wounds while also giving the patient a cocktail to drink multiple times of the day that also contained these phages.

At least for the patients shown this was helpful.

tutanchamun··on AMD Discloses Initial Zen 2 Details
Do you mean the comment under the article that mentions HBM? If so I think they refer to these papers by AMD:

https://www.computermachines.org/joe/publications/pdfs/hpca2...

https://seal.ece.ucsb.edu/sites/seal.ece.ucsb.edu/files/publ...

tutanchamun··on AMD Discloses Initial Zen 2 Details
Sorry, I've meant analog circuitry, which I've read again and again about on CPUs - see below as one example. And it was also mentioned in some articles about the IO die on Zen 2.

> Intel’s analog designers are responsible for creating circuits such as PLLs (for clocking) and PCIe (for I/O) that are critical for modern SoCs on a process that isn’t optimized for analog

https://www.realworldtech.com/intel-22ffl-process/

tutanchamun··on AMD Discloses Initial Zen 2 Details
Seperating the analog logic (IO die) from the digital logic (CPU cores). Analog shrinks really bad with smaller nodes wheras digital logic shrinks really good.

New process nodes get more and more expensive - especially if the node is new (bad yields etc.) So you want to get the most out of it as possible, which AMD does with this strategy.

For example Zen 1 8 core chips are 213 mm2 on 14nm. On 7nm these chipse would be > 106 mm2 (because the analog elements don't scale). Zen 2 chiplets should be at most 75 mm2 (while also increasing cache, widen AVX etc.) which is mobile SoC territory which means they are cheaper to produce (better yields etc.). Since Intel uses monolithic dies AMD already had an cost advatage, with Zen 2 it's not even funny.

Especially if the guesses of many people are true and AMD designed the IO chip to be cut down, which means they can reuse it for their desktop CPUs (Ryzen on AM4). Anonther nice advantage of this would be that they can bin the chip even better for EPYC, Threadripper and Ryzen.

AdoredTV does a good job of aggregating all the infos/ideas that are floating around and presenting them:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I6AG-woscDU

tutanchamun··on AMD Announces 7nm Rome CPUs and MI60 GPUs
People who follow the tech press talk about the same thing when talking about nm, and they know TSMC 7nm competes with Intel 10nm not Intel 14nm.

It's been all over the town for months that TSMCs 7nm is estimated to be worse than Intels ‎ambitious failure that is 10nm [0][1][2][3] but quite a bit better than Intel 14nm (with the exception of clocks), and that 7nm+ with EUV for cost savings (which TSCM already taped out last month) is estimated to be equal or even slightly better.

So I'm not really sure what to make of your comment?

> AMD's 7nm might get them close to on par with Intel's current 14++ nm chips, but it's not like AMD has really figured out how to make the entire CPU half the size.

No they didn't, but they don't claim that, do they? From what they say they decided on the IO die exactly because IO doesn't scale as much, and that decision allowed them to double the number of cores. Since 7nm is expected to be much more expensive than previous nodes this seems really clever from a money standpoint as well. The core only Zen 2 chiplets are expected to be around 70 mm² which is mobile SoC territory.

AMD is already close in IPC to Intel even though AMD uses a worse node (GloFos mobile optimized 14nm is more like Intel 22 then Intel 14nm) and wins in multithreaded workloads because their SMT implementation seems to scale better than Intels. They also seem to have better performance/watt when under load. I have not seen numbers for idle wattage for Xeons but Intels desktop CPUs are slightly (5 - 10 watt) better when idle.

So I'm looking forward to them having the better node for the first time ever.

[0] https://www.semiwiki.com/forum/content/7544-7nm-5nm-3nm-logi...

[1] https://www.semiwiki.com/forum/content/6713-14nm-16nm-10nm-7...

[2] https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/10_nm_lithography_process

[3] https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/7_nm_lithography_process

tutanchamun··on Intel announces Cascade Lake Xeons: 48 cores and 12-channel memory per socket
> which is a growing portion of their Xeon business and one AMD has no clear, large-scale answer to AFAICS

Probably depends on the size of the company. AMD has their semi custom department which was responsible for the PS4 and Xbox One, as well as PS4 Pro, Xbox One X (the GPUs are based on Polaris but have features from Vega, which no normal Polaris GPU has) and Subor Z (Zen APU with GDDR5 as main memory like the consoles, but can run Windows).

AMD is probably the better vendor if you want custom SKUs (as the underdog they also have more incentive for custom SKUs).

tutanchamun··on Intel announces Cascade Lake Xeons: 48 cores and 12-channel memory per socket
Especially since AMDs SMT is better.
tutanchamun··on AMD Announces 7nm Rome CPUs and MI60 GPUs
I'm really curious about cache on the IO die. Ian Cutress of Anandtech said Rome is ~ 1000 mm² in total. [0] Based on that and the pictures of the Rome die that were shown some users [1] estimated the size of the IO die to be 387 - 407 mm².

- Zen 1 (8 cores) with IO is 213 mm².

- the Zen 2 core only chiplets are estimated to be around 70 mm².

- if we assume IO scales as well as the rest (which it doesn't) Zen 1 would be ~106 mm² on 7nm.

- let's just say the difference between Zen 2 core only chiplets and the imaginary Zen 1 on 7nm is the size of the IO per Zeppelin die => ~36 mm²

- now double the area again because the IO die is on 14nm => 72 mm²

- now quadruple the size because we have 8 memory channels and 128 PCIe 4.0 lanes => 288 mm²

Going by my flawed layman estimation this would mean we still have a budget of ~100 mm² for additional functionality. Either PCIe 4.0 takes much more space than PCIe 3.0, they have some secret sauce in there, or maybe just a large L4 cache.

If they use EDRAM instead of SRAM like Intel did with some of their Broadwell and Skylake CPUs they could probably fit quite a bit cache in this area. Intel used 128 MB EDRAM fabbed on a 22nm node which required 84mm ² [2]

[0] https://twitter.com/IanCutress/status/1059924863014653958

[1] https://old.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/9uscqu/epyc_and_epyc_2...

[2] https://www.anandtech.com/show/6993/intel-iris-pro-5200-grap...

tutanchamun··on AMD Announces 7nm Rome CPUs and MI60 GPUs
> AMD is still behind per core in both clocks and per clock performance.

Yes, that's true but the per clock performance is close. They are only 5-10% behind in single threaded tasks without AVX (depending on the workload). The IPC increase is expected to be 10-15% (will of course depend on the workload). And their achilles heel, the AVX performance, will also improve with Zen 2 (256 bit instead of 128 bit etc.)

Due to 7nm the clocks (for consumer hardware like Ryzen and Threadripper) will probably also increase (not 5 to 5.2 ghz after overclocking like Intel, but up to 4.7 ghz overclocks could be possible seeing that 4.3 ghz is possible on the current node which is mobile optimized).

Depending on how much the clocks increase I believe they can close the gap. Maybe even pass Intel. The future certainly looks promising for AMD.

I wonder if they will revive their X APUs for the Server. In the past they had Opteron X APUs to increase the compute density of servers. Now with Zen and Vega this could be a nice combo in addition to discrete GPUs.

For example this system: https://i.imgur.com/yt5FasA.jpg?1

Imagine replacing these two 32 core Epyc CPUs made in 14nm with two 32 core Epyc APUs (Zen 2) made in 7nm, which would use the saved space due to 7nm for Compute Units, and you might get an additional 10-16 TFlops per System. Which is basically one additional GPU.

tutanchamun··on Spatial: A High Level Programming Language for FPGAs
So this is a level above Chisel [0] seeing that it can emit Chisel as output?

[0] https://chisel.eecs.berkeley.edu/

tutanchamun··on Today, Europe Lost The Internet. Now, We Fight Back
I'm really curious what the german government will do. As far as I know they (CDU and SPD) have a paragraph about being against upload filters in their coalition agreement.

Interestingly the one who spearheaded article 11 and 13 - Axel Voss - is a german CDU politician. Preach water and drink wine?

tutanchamun··on Requests-Scala: A Scala Port of the Popular Python Requests HTTP Client
Nice, would have been exactly what I wanted last year. Ended up discovering sttp which is also really nice.

btw: since you were one of the early adopters of Scala.js, will/can this be ported to Scala.js

tutanchamun··on MapTiler: Map overlay, cut map tiles for Google Maps, GIS layers and mobile apps
Reminds me especially of computer games in general and some single player Assasins Creed title specifically which had always online copy protection. The copy protection server was DDOSed meaning players that bought the game couldn't play or would always be kicked out of the game once the server went down again.

On the other hand the pirates played the game without problems once they circumvented the proctection (a week?) after the game release.

tutanchamun··on Google Cloud Platform – The Good, Bad, and Ugly
What happens if the free quotas are reached? Will the app terminate until the free quotas are available again, or will the user be billed?
tutanchamun··on Gluon – A static, type-inferred and embeddable language written in Rust
What's the problem of implicit arguments in scala? I can see why implicit conversions can be a problem but aren't implicit arguments required for typeclasses and other nice features?
tutanchamun··on Intel 28-core fantasy vs. AMD 32-core reality
https://i.imgur.com/dpfu5K3.png

Intel is mainly faster because of a significant clock advantage. Clock for clock the advantage is small.

tutanchamun··on Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was Overclocked
The Xeon 28 core part seems to be 698mm² [0] while the AMD Ryzen 1800X is 213mm²

[0] https://www.anandtech.com/show/11839/intel-core-i9-7980xe-an...

tutanchamun··on Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was Overclocked
The guarantee to get a CPU which can run stable 5ghz on all cores within the TDP limit and only requiring a cooling solution which can handle the TDP.

If you need to overclock you don't get this and have to buy more expensive cooling and probably need to de-lit (remove the heatspreader) of your above 2000 dollar CPU (which can permanently damage it) to improve the thermals because Intel - unlike AMD - didn't solder their heatspreader. Even then, you're not guaranteed to get a chip which can run 5 ghz on all cores 24/7. The best 18 core HEDT from Intel I have seen to date was running 4.5ghz on all cores 24/7 with delidding and a custom loop.

The 28 core Xeon which this probably is based upon runs 2.5 ghz stock and can boost to 3.8 ghz on a single core (3 or 3.2 ghz on all cores I believe).

tutanchamun··on AMD Zen 2 Update: 7nm EPYC in Labs Now, Launching in 2019
But isn't it easier for AMD to close the gap due to their multiple dies on a package design instead of a large monolithic design like Intel? If they make the cores larger the cost for the entire CPU doesn't increase as much as Intels.

Even though Zen+ (cache optimization) is probably not as much of a improvement as Zen2 ("improves Zen in multiple dimensions") over Zen will be, the single threaded gap did shrink quite a bit:

https://i.imgur.com/dpfu5K3.png

But I guess some of these improvements come also from the faster memory that is supported. The benchmarks sadly were not made with the same memory.

tutanchamun··on AMD Reveals Threadripper 2: Up to 32 Cores, 250W, X399 Refresh
I remember reading a article here on hn about inverse hyper threading (I don't remember the correct term) where multiple cores would work together to increase single threaded performance (if some cores are idle). I believe some company (not a major player like AMD, Intel or Samsung etc.) claimed they would have solved major problems with previous implementations of this idea or something along those lines.

Sounds interesting but is that even possible?

Seems like it would have been the perfect fit for AMDs Bulldozer back then due to the chips worse single threaded performance and it's unused multi threaded performance in mainstream software.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →