1,670 karma · joined March 13, 2012
we do statistical market research. mostly survey-based experiments. for everyone from small startups to the worlds biggest brands to NGOs and political campaigns.
A good explanation is here: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/05/02/liquidity-prefer...
[edit: wording]
I would agree with your larger point that there are other (non-financial) sources of return to these investments.
So, good for Google. It makes a lot of sense for them to do this and I'm glad to see it happening.
NB this does not apply in equal degrees across all industries, and your horses -> cars example doesn't qualify.
In addition, note that I was agreeing with you that the transition, on the whole, is definitely desirable. I'm only arguing that there may be moral consequences in not upholding society's end of the trade I describe above.
Although I do agree that a world where these types of "collaborative consumption" services (like AirBNB) are essentially unregulated (or at least more open to competition) is much better, it is true that a number of industries are regulated, and incumbents that have been "playing by the rules" were promised a protected business environment. And it's not like they didn't have to give anything up in that trade - a taxi medallion in NYC is worth a lot of money - they have been exchanged for over a million dollars.
So the question is: how do we transition to the better world without being unfair to the "stranded capital"?
At any rate, you seem well-versed in this area, so let me ask you a question: what is the difference the website's behavior between a "null" and a "track me, please" value in the header?
My statement that there has to be a default in "one direction or the other" is clearly wrong, as you've indicated. I would still argue that a null value is arbitrary and does not map to the user's wishes. My opinion is that having it 'on' is no more or less arbitrary than having no wishes expressed.
That, and many users will use IE10 knowing that it ships with DNT pre-enabled. To ignore this is totally immoral and unethical. This is totally shameful.
[1] Not necessarily a good indication, as this may be a last ditch effort convert _some_ value out of their app development efforts, and who knows to how many buyers the seller has sold this data.
[1] I'm using "pay" loosely here. I have no idea what they had to give up or produce in order to get the data, but presumably FB received something of value.