HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unabst

1,480 karma · joined June 2, 2015

I am dead.
submissionscomments
unabst··on Have we just stumbled on the biggest productivity increase of the century?
It's absurd to think "we've stumbled on the biggest productivity increase" by changing the math to include commute. If you work 10 hours and are productive for 10 hours, nothing changes regarding workd done whether you commuted 1 hour or not. It's only when you swap 11 hours for 10 that there is a difference. Nothing agaist saving time, but to say that's the biggest productivity increase is stretching it I think.
unabst··on The User Always Loses
We also live in a "consumer always loses" economy as well. It could just be "consumer" supercedes "user".

I was listening to Richard Wolff describing to Patrick Bet-David how capitalism creates monopolies and in the end the consumers always lose [1]. As companies get bigger, they become worse actors. I can't think of a counter example.

Patrick thinks everything has gotten cheaper and the consumer is winning, at least today (since history only backs the thesis). Richard couldn't come up with immediate counter examples regarding how Amazon is abusing their monopoly priviledges but FBA pricing and seller fees came to mind. Someone in the comments mentioned prescription drugs.

[1] Heated Debate On Capitalism with America’s Most Prominent Marxist Economist - Richard Wolff https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wj-zFgxCUnY

unabst··on FB Executive Supported India’s Modi, Disparaged Opp. In Internal Messages
I just stated facts which I also find are incredibly important and relevant.

Downvoting without replying is another perfect example of not pushing past the issues with meaningful discourse and instead resorting to censorship.

unabst··on Why Privacy Matters
The implications were not that bad until companies were able to obtain enough information to change our minds and change our votes. Cambridge Analytica weaponized information. Russia weaponized information. Bots and fake accounts are rampant. Facebook is a warzone, in the most literal sense of the word. Their current implementation is a national security threat and a threat to democracy. And Mark Zuckerberg is that CEO that let it happen.

It doesn't matter what information you share. Facebook buys information from everywhere. They aleady know if your relationship status even if you leave it blank. That's the trap. Then their paying customers are given access to you, based on who they want to convince.

unabst··on FB Executive Supported India’s Modi, Disparaged Opp. In Internal Messages
Thoughts can't be removed or undone. They need to be pushed forward passed the issues. That is why free speech is so important. We need to keep talking in an educational forward-thinking manner.

The reason facebook is fucked is they are touting free speech while claiming they will control bad speech by popular demand. Except, any manipulation is censorship. There is no such thing as conditional free speech.

unabst··on Who to ignore – bullshit filters
Hey, I was reading your comments. Had to check out the guy with the huge balls. Kudos to you sir. I sum up George Carlin's life's work and applied it to bullshit detection and get nothing. I wonder if there are better places to hang out.
unabst··on The Language of Science
Two issues.

First, no math problem or physics problem or chemistry problem or science problem involves politics or ethics. Give great scientists a great problem, and they will solve it. It's always up to the administrators and managers and executives to tell them when to stop, often by cutting funding or firing. These are not the scientists, though they may be made to represent them.

Ethics and politics is a completely separate discipline from logic and science. But often those doing the logic and science aren't given a say. They are just placed in their labs and made comfortable.

Second, most scientists know when they are right. You can check your work. You know how you did it. You are aware of what you understand. And being right is mostly enough in a purely scientific context.

But in the real world, you have the Donald and an endless army of careerists who don't mind serving for a naked king that get to decide what is right.

For the most part I don't believe scientists have much of a communication problem. They trade information and are happy to make progress. That's about it.

unabst··on Who to ignore – bullshit filters
Writing on HN is like walking on eggshells. Everyone writes so carefully. Such a shame, since there are so many great minds here.
unabst··on The Language of Science
The truth is not enough. It needs promoting and needs to be fought for. But the best paid promoters and fighters can win regardless of how true anything is, allowing those with the power and money to select the truth that suits them. And rarely are scientists good fighters.
unabst··on The Language of Science
In my words, because I agree: We are all entangled and entrenched in our self-interests and group interests, and cannot undermine the profit motive or the need to win. Scientists are just players in a vast field of this entrenchment who do not always get the last word, nor win, nor able to always stick strictly to the science to begin with.
unabst··on Who to ignore – bullshit filters
If you cut the bullshit, you cut most of society out. Institutions, the government, the media, the left, the right, corporations... And bullshit is the glue that keeps it all together.

So, I would add one more rule. The George Carlin rule:

-- Are they part of any group?

That actually covers the first and second rule of the author.

But to hate the government is suicide because we are the government. Same with society, and same with groups.

My logical conclusion with regards to speech: Learn to observe, think, form your own opinions, always speak your mind, and be no part of group think or group speech. Which is exactly what George Carlin did.

In an ideal world, no one would be part of any group. But since we all are, here is the Carlin rule revised:

-- Are they openly critical of their groups?

But again, most groups do not tolerate external or internal criticism. They're the disloyal traitors and whistle-blowers. So most of us have to chalk this up as doing our job, so we can all have one. Not everyone get's paid to speak like George.

But wherever and whenever we can, we should promote and protect the groups that embrace and advocate free speech against themselves. They are the only groups sustaining free speech.

unabst··on USPS Files Patent for a Blockchain-Based Voting System
And couldn't you just have one flat log file as an append-only ledger of all the votes? Maybe add a time stamp and location stamp to each prime recorded for context.

Found this gem. https://primes.utm.edu/lists/small/millions/

1 million primes is about 2mb zipped. Even with additional information, a national election result of 130 million votes could fit on a CD.

The beauty of this is we have a completely transparent record that requires no unique software to view or test. No black boxes, and no magic beyond the magic of primes.

unabst··on Toshiba formally and finally exits laptop business
Except sudden pivots and breakthroughs are what made Sony and Toyota and Nintendo and what still drive them. Mario, the Walkman, the Corolla. More recently, the Switch, PlayStation, and Prius. All breakthroughs with exciting beginnings resulting in massively popular and lucrative products.

Nintendo trusts the innovators who insist on innovation. I would love to believe this is the winning formula, and maybe many Japanese companies do, but the problem with that is when the innovators are wrong. How often does a researcher invent exactly what the market needs? So in between hits, the hierarchies must figure ways to feed themselves. And some self destruct through corruption (Toshiba) and internal conflict (Nissan). Some get bailed out (Sharp, JAL). Sony's gaming division has been bailing out their other businesses.

In the case of Xperia, the innovation and product is there, but Sony miserably failed at marketing and being competitive in the US core market. Sony marketing is legendary in Japan, but they have never successfully translated that magic to the US. In Japan, the Xperia is killing it.

https://onlineshop.smt.docomo.ne.jp/ranking/index.html?color...

unabst··on Toshiba formally and finally exits laptop business
Innovation happens at the individual level, and to that end, the Japanese are incredibly innovative. The person must then fight the hierarchies which farms the innovations from individuals who are undercompensated for their miraculous work. Same with the incredible craftsmen and artists. But if the hierarchy is bad, everyone loses.

The engineer would often then defect and seek a meritocracy where they are valued by their work and not seniority.

A quick lookup for the Flash inventor backs this. Fujio Masuoka is now CTO of a company in Singapore.

Shuji Nakamura, the inventory of the blue LED is the other primary example. He is now professor of Materials at the University of California, Santa Barbara, with 208 US patents and a Nobel prize. He was in the news a lot, and stirred up much needed debate in Japan regarding who owns the work of an employee.

But one counter example is Nintendo. Shigeru Miyamoto is the genius behind Super Mario, and him and his small team are responsible for so much of their hierarchy's success. Nintendo stands tall to this day.

Sony is a mixed bag, but their gaming division is still winning.

Korea is actually known to be incredibly similar to Japan, and according to one theory the only reason why Korea outpaced Japan is because the Japanese were too busy addicted to Pachinko. That may sound absurd, but not if you've seen how ubiquitous Pachinko is, and it's pure gambling with all the dangers of addiction and lives in shambles. Ironically, 80% of the parlors are owned by Japanese Koreans.

unabst··on Alcohol as a social technology to check the trustworthiness of others (2014)
OP is saying nomikais are about trust. P is saying they are about team, and that they help bring the boss down and lift the workers up.

Nomikais are both. If anything it's just an excuse to drink, and each company or team would decide how they drank. It starts in college with bukatsu nomikais. And there are good ones, and the ones where the ring leader is arrested for serial rape. That happened at Todai, and is definitely not normal, but unless you're the leader (there is always a leader) how are you to know until you show up and everyone starts drinking? Much like frat recruiting in the States. My year, someone died (1997 I think it was).

unabst··on Science and scientific expertise are more important than ever
I said more.

I posit it's susceptible to both, and that it is susceptible to any manipulation. Not just overt or malicious. Even in good faith. And even the article is a form of manipulation. And I am saying the "manipulated" and the "educated" are often one in the same especially in hindsight when wrong becomes clear.

unabst··on Science and scientific expertise are more important than ever
The 98% are never split equally. And some percentage of 100% is always swayed by propaganda. That's why it's propaganda that pushes the vote over the top. And in today's democracy, its done under the guise of "education". That's why the self-declared "engaged and well-informed" are often the most targeted, readily swayed, and eager to back the wrong movement.

The anti-vaccine movement is one example of the engaged being swayed to total conviction, and it's easy to question whether they truly care about their children, but love is their motivation. Similarly, many "wrong" movements are for the love of democracy of the country etc.

And looking at the bullet points at the end of the article, those are what even the "wrong" are doing, extremely proactively. And it all starts with the "educator" claiming to be the "reliable information source", which happens to be what Scientific American is also doing here.

unabst··on Bayes Theorem: A Framework for Critical Thinking
I agree with the first part. We get by fine for the most part by our own intuitions driven by fear and risk aversion. We are constantly triggered into action, not persuaded -- not by ourselves or anyone. But I think the blog here is a call to be more rational. I would consider Bayes another tool out of many. Unfortunately that doesn't change how we are though. We're still hungry and trigger driven at the end of the day.

Which is why I disagree with the other thing you said. People are pretty stupid. To think you know anything without prior research is stupid. Priors need to be deliberately created (act of learning and understanding and internalizing) for a guess to be educated. Anything without we default to stupid, so most of us are stupid with most things.

But just getting by is an incredibly low bar. We have been tested however with the covid situation. But take covid. Mask wearing isn't a "priors" issue. It's the understanding of what a mask does and how it influences risk that is important. You don't need authority to understand the benefits of a mask, though once understood, it would definitely fall under "staying on the safe side with large margins".

At least that is my take.

unabst··on The Art of Not Thinking
Fear also works. That's why cramming for exams is so easy. Not the act, but getting yourself to do it.

You can also barter with yourself. Have a list of harmless splurges to reward yourself with. Kyoto cold brew, a Sapporo black beer, or a few hours of gaming are on my list.

I recon the most professional approach is to clear your schedule, remove all distractions, and simply give yourself enough time or even unlimited time to do it. I often find they get done faster than expected, since most of these tasks aren't particularly difficult. Like taxes. The problem isn't that they're hard or challenging. They disgust me :/

unabst··on Elite Disillusionment
The "Auckland kid" is the entrepreneur here. And no, I don't believe Harvard would ruin an entrepreneur that would have succeeded otherwise. And they would have attractive alternatives.

Everyone changes, especially in college. Regardless of the school, one can easily assess them the blame, but some of it has to be on you, especially at an age when you should stop making excuses.

With that said, the work load can be absurd, some peers are arrogant and elitist, some teachers are total assholes, and not everything is fair or makes sense. Although, that's true at varying degrees at any school.

unabst··on Elite Disillusionment
But wouldn't you think an "Auckland kid" would fair better as a "Harvard kid" given the same ambitions with better opportunities and greater access?

Ivy League affiliates enjoy the privileges of being branded Ivy League all their lives. And the schools are pretty great to boot.

To me the original article was asking the following questions:

Did I have to come to Harvard to do what I want?

Why don't more people make use of their Ivy League privileges?

Why isn't Harvard doing more good for society?

Which does sound a bit whiny, I would think, especially to an Auckland Kid. The takeaway for me, was that there should be more Auckland Kids at Harvard, and that OP here is more of an Auckland Kid. He's saying there is little to complain about if this is what you came for, and that it should have been.

On the other hand, the author of the article presents valid criticism about Harvard Kids and Harvard, but appears also to be closer to the Harvard Kid than the Auckland Kids she seems to admire. Sometimes it takes one to know the others and where you are at.

But at least there are some Auckland Kids in the Ivy Leagues. And I would bet you there are some Harvard Kids in Auckland too that never made it to Harvard.

unabst··on Philosophers on GPT-3
So your point is most cookie cutter rap is good writing?

If engagement is the new measure of good writing, then we are lost. Click bait is engagement. Tabloid material is engagement. Fox vs CNN and political trigger pieces are all engagement. None of it should be considered good writing.

unabst··on Spotify CEO: musicians can no longer release music only “once every 3-4 years”
Also, didn't the hip hop crowd just give away their music for free and make all their money touring? Until signed anyway. And mix tapes were more than a single. So to that end, music definitely was their marketing. To put it another way, they let the music market itself. That's all they needed, and was all they got. I would put influence under marketing though, unless we can settle that music and influence are both both.
unabst··on Spotify CEO: musicians can no longer release music only “once every 3-4 years”
As Spotify CEO, we should think he isn't speaking to musicians, but to all the bigger labels on how to make the most money. Musicians should feel they can do whatever they want, and should, and probably would, but I reckon they would eventually hear it from their manager once the instructions trickle down the chain of command. That is, any musician signed and making money. To everyone else, the industry itself is largely irrelevant to their craft or their income.
unabst··on Philosophers on GPT-3
How do you engage your audience without giving them anything? With just word play? And are we all forgetting the context of GPT-3 and the post I was replying to?

Also Jay-Z isn't every rapper. I'm pretty sure even Jay-Z would agree most rap is not very substantive or saying anything new. It's cookie cutter.

unabst··on Philosophers on GPT-3
A good poet has something to say, and wastes no words saying it.
unabst··on Philosophers on GPT-3
Yes. But they are also good writers, no? After the premise that good writers have something to say, it should be clear I am referring to the "just rapper" rapper.
unabst··on Study finds learning music won’t make children smart
If you test a population, regardless of the test, certain people will always do better on average. So IQ is real. Out of all the studies done in the social sciences, IQ is by far the most conclusive.

But the other half of the story is the myth of the genius. The idea that intelligence provides all the answers. It does not. Terence Tao, a child prodigy with an IQ of 230 (apparently), would know. [1]

Talking faster is like running faster. If you're a stand-up comedian or chasing a purse snatcher, you'll have an advantage. But neither would make life any easier unless you deliberately reinforce your talents with hard work and pursue paths where you maintain an advantage.

The world seems to be built around normal folk. Being average isn't that bad. Of course, now we must define average. No one is truly average. We're all over the place.

[1] https://terrytao.wordpress.com/career-advice/does-one-have-t...

unabst··on Philosophers on GPT-3
Can GPT-3 make a valid point?

Good writers have something to say, and they don't waste words saying it.

Someone just good with language is an editor. Or a babbler. Or a rapper.

unabst··on Philosophers on GPT-3
> what's written is mostly bullshit. This is very upsetting to some.

But not George Carlin or Ludwig Wittgenstein.

> "How-to" material [...] It lacks adequate ties to the real world.

And so did we. How-to is science. Until we figured out how to align statements with external evidence, we lacked ties to the real world. Once we began aligning statements and then translating those statements into mathematics, we made it to the moon and in quite a short time.

> The shape of that space is a big unsolved problem in AI.

GTP-3 isn't a scientist. It doesn't make observations that it can axiomatize as new true premises for further processing.

Anecdotally, neither do most of us!

← PreviousPage 4 of 20Next →