HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unanswered

116 karma · joined January 4, 2021

submissionscomments
unanswered··on Only 28 Percent of Young Black New Yorkers Are Vaccinated
I don't find it contradictory at all; in fact I would be surprised if it were any other way. There is a single unbroken thread of policy positions linking white paternalistic slave owners[0], to white paternalistic parts of the abolitionist movement, to white paternalistic policies of today. You can argue that this is outrageous and unbelievable, and look, I wouldn't disagree except that when you look at the world through this lens you will no longer be surprised by the policy and behavior of this group, only saddened.

"Diversity and inclusion" is, shall we say, the happy side of that movement; the part of that movement which is prominent throughout the intervening years in between abolition and whatever the fuck is happening this century. While diversity holds its memetic ground, I have not heard "inclusion" used in reference to a policy position in many years.

[0] quite possibly a minority of historical US slave owners; I really don't have quantitative details, just synthesis from historical facts

unanswered··on Major study of Ivermectin finds 'no effect whatsoever'
> Without a randomized controlled trial, they have nothing but speculation as to what is effective or not.

Like this one? https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.05.31.21258081v... Or you can go find one of the 21 others FLCCC cites (excluding Elgazzar's).

I hope you didn't bury those goalposts too deep as you'll need to move them again.

Meanwhile the meta-review you cite is the one that managed to "find" only 18 trials and those somehow just happened to be the ones showing neutral results; no one has yet figured out how they somehow accidentally missed all the studies with positive findings cited by the FLCCC. Maybe in a few years there will be a peer-reviewed RCT explaining this apparent selective blindness, which is the most alarming epidemic happening right now.

Look, I don't know what to make of all the conflicting evidence. But I sure as hell know what to make of all the people lying about the evidence.

unanswered··on Major study of Ivermectin finds 'no effect whatsoever'
The flccc unequivocally states that ivermectin given alone is not known to be effective. That's why their protocols are not "give ivermectin alone", in any dose. Even the protocols they recommend that people can follow at home are not "take ivermectin".

Moreover, as to the claim that the flccc is recommending ivermectin with no proof it works; they have 60+ peer-reviewed studies showing that it works, a couple un-reviewed studies by avowed skeptics which show that it does nothing, and zero studies ever in the history of the drug showing it to be harmful. That is better than can be said for any other purported treatment for COVID.

unanswered··on Major study of Ivermectin finds 'no effect whatsoever'
This study is

(A) not published (B) not peer reviewed (C) not science (see a and b) (D) not actually studying the treatment protocols recommended by the flccc

This is not so much a study as it is tracking the outcomes of someone taking their pets' heartworm medicine without any advice from their doctor. It's farcical.

unanswered··on Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles under a fake name
You're still linking the retconned article. In the original it is as I said.

This new article is also extremely disingenuous. It argues "there's no evidence Wuhan isolated RaTG13". Well no shit, since the best evidence is that RaTG13 is completely made up, never existed in reality, and never existed on paper until early 2020. For snopes to take that evidence and turn it around and say it's evidence for the Wuhan Institute being totally reliable and trustworthy is perverse.

unanswered··on Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles under a fake name
That was not the original lab leak article. The original article called it definitely false and racist.
unanswered··on There Is a Tennis Ball Shortage Too Now
As opposed to all of those dollars flowing into extremely republican-leaning cities... Oh wait.
unanswered··on There Is a Tennis Ball Shortage Too Now
Never forget that this was done to us intentionally. The virus was unexpected; but the reaction was deliberate.
unanswered··on YouTube suspends Rand Paul over a video disputing the effectiveness of masks
This is a pointless and politically motivated distinction though. The moderators manually protect controversial articles with the correct political slant. Failing to act is entirely equivalent in this case.
unanswered··on 2020 U.S. Migration Map
No, they want to move to flourishing red states, but they don't want to change their own politics.
unanswered··on Red Cross Nurse Injects 8,600 with Saline Instead of Covid Vaccine
The vaccine is so effective that tests are unable to determine who has received it.
unanswered··on A wind-powered vehicle that can travel twice as fast as the wind itself
Ah, but not so fast. It actually depends on your frame of reference.

Suppose the vehicle is facing the +x direction. Suppose the wind is travelling at +10m/s relative to the ground. Suppose the (experimentally determined) maximum velocity of the vehicle under these conditions is +12m/s. Now consider an inertial reference frame which, compared to the ground's reference frame, is moving at +11m/s. (I.e., pick the frame in which the ground moves at -11m/s.) Now let the vehicle run. There will come an instant when the vehicle is stationary in this reference frame (when the vehicle has accelerated to +11m/s relative to the ground, not yet having reached its maximum velocity).

Consider the instantaneous change in kinetic energy at this instant. The air about to be pushed by the propeller has velocity -1m/s and will accelerate in the -x direction. The vehicle has velocity 0m/s and will accelerate in the +x direction. In both cases, the kinetic energy is actually increasing! So in this frame, where does the increasing kinetic energy of the air-vehicle system come from?!

The answer is the ground. It has velocity -11m/s. When it pushes against the contact point of the wheels, it is therefore pushing the contact point in the -x direction. But this means the contact point is pushing against the ground in the +x direction. And therefore the ground is undergoing a minuscule +x acceleration. That acceleration is therefore decreasing the kinetic energy of the ground — by a lot, because of the mass factor.

And this is why we say the energy is derived from the difference in velocity between the ground and the wind — because depending on your inertial reference frame, the kinetic energy might be coming from one or the other. In the frame of reference of the vehicle, it starts out coming from both, but when the (relative) direction of the wind shifts (so that relative to the ground the vehicle is travelling faster than the wind), the kinetic energy starts coming from the ground only, and the vehicle is forced to transmit some of it to the air to keep moving. But this might actually be the nicest explanation of how the vehicle outpaces the wind: in the faster-than-the-wind regime, the vehicle is transmitting energy from the ground into the air — which is exactly what you would expect to happen, given the mechanical linkage between the wheels and the propeller! — but some of this energy bleeds off into increasing the velocity of the vehicle itself, because it's on wheels and that's what happens when wheeled vehicles push against something behind them, no matter what the ground happens to be doing (such as moving backwards like a treadmill, in this frame of reference).

Disclaimer: I did not do well in college-level Mechanics. But I think I have convinced myself of the above explanation, just barely.

unanswered··on Summer 2021 has changed our understanding of extreme weather
Do you have evidence this is worse than allowing the greenhouse effect to rule in the interior, than having to run the vehicle with the windows down and/or run the A/C harder and/or idle before leaving to cool off surfaces like steering wheel and shifter? Or is it just frustration at a lack of performative emissions reductions?
unanswered··on A wind-powered vehicle that can travel twice as fast as the wind itself
Where the power comes from is easy: the wind gets slowed down. Of course the nature of wind is such that you could never measure this, but the point is that when the propellor pushes against the air, that air's velocity relative to the ground is decreased while the vehicle's is increased. The vehicle leaves behind it an imperceptible region of less-energetic air and takes that energy with it.
unanswered··on Fairer Chess: A Reversal of Two Opening Moves in Chess Creates Balance
I think a better way to state this would be: player A makes white's first move, then player B decides whether to play white or black. Play proceeds as normal with black to move.

But tbh it seems a bit silly; at least TFA realizes there at least naively seems to be more at stake in moves 2 and ..2.

unanswered··on Longitudinal analysis shows durable immune memory after SARS-CoV-2 infection
Real facts that people won't like to hear: anyone who thought differently probably needs to retake a high school biology class.
unanswered··on 94% of English adults have Covid antibodies, ONS data shows
"People in the hospital" and "Covid-19 hospitalizations".

These are not the same thing.

unanswered··on Officials put the wrong man in a mental facility for two years
> The judge, the doctors, and everyone else that failed to do even the most basic searches or confirmations of anyone’s identity should be put in jail in this case.

No, they should be put in mental institutions under the name Castleberry with strict instructions to the medical staff that they are delusional and misstating their own identity.

unanswered··on Amazon union election should be run again, labor board official says
> They created their own ballot boxes and "processed" them behind closed doors

Do you have any evidence of this? Seems libellous to me and it directly contradicts all of the reliable media reports I've heard on the subject, which state that ballots were deposited in the mail including an official USPS box on-site.

unanswered··on Are “Buy Now, Pay Later” Retail Loans a Rip-Off?
Yes, in the same way that credit card companies convince people to buy things they cannot afford, as well as mortgage companies, car financers, etc. Anyone enjoying these services but attacking BNPL is really attacking poor people: "those poors can't handle credit like I can!"

And that ultimately comes down to enforcing class norms. "Poors", the thinking goes, "shouldn't be allowed to purchase middle-class things on credit because then what is the middle-class?"

unanswered··on Controversial crime app Citizen launches $20/month Protect service
> where criminal organizations make places unsafe

This already happens we just use different, more familiar words for the phenomenon.

unanswered··on Are “Buy Now, Pay Later” Retail Loans a Rip-Off?
The only doubleplusungood thing being alleged about these BNPL scenes is that they are — checks notes — offering lines of credit. Shocking.
unanswered··on Amazon union election should be run again, labor board official says
The whole point of a union is to prevent anyone from being able to compete with them, so allowing non-dues-paying coworkers would defeat the purpose of the nlrb.
unanswered··on CDC document cites delta variant’s ability to spread among the vaccinated
> vaccination is now about personal protection — protecting oneself against severe disease. Herd immunity is not relevant

So there is no real reason to force people to vaccinate now, if they don't want to? Leave them to their chosen fate.

unanswered··on Facebook is now claiming official CDC.gov links are “False Information”
> If that’s true, then, how can we be sure that flu hasn’t been misdiagnosed?

Because I haven't seen anything on Facebook, or self-censoring HN for that matter, validating those claims. So they must be but only false but really out-there wacky conspiracy theories.

unanswered··on Grand jury indicts Trevor Milton, Nikola founder, on three counts of fraud
I wouldn't recommend it. Many of us have known for months and months that the company is 100% fraud but the market stays irrational.
unanswered··on Science is needed to find how sars-cov2 reached humans
> Do you care to elaborate?

Not really because my viewpoint is not permitted on HN. Further discussion will likely draw moderator attention.

unanswered··on Google delays workers’ return to office, mandates vaccines
I feel like this exchange may have been a manufactured strawman, because the flaw in the shower argument is obvious: no one is mandating showers, and there are no widespread objections to showers.

Even insofar as minimal personal hygiene is implicitly required, it's left entirely up to an individual's conscience how to achieve it. A fair comparison would be mandating "either a vaccine or avoiding crowds in indoor spaces or any similar measure", since both of those are known to significantly reduce (but not eliminate) the risk. (How effectively they do so is beside the point of the inapplicability of the shower analogy.)

unanswered··on Science is needed to find how sars-cov2 reached humans
Science is not an appropriate epistemic tool to answer an historical question.
unanswered··on Texas Children's Confirms It Has Some Covid Kids on Ventilators
> Currently, roughly 10 percent of those children who test positive do require hospitalization

Does that mean "require hospitalization because of covid" or "require hospitalization and happen to have covid"?

← PreviousPage 5 of 13Next →