HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unfocussed_mike

2,222 karma · joined January 25, 2022

submissionscomments
unfocussed_mike··on Apple’s risky, yearslong effort to design its own silicon is paying off
Well. I think x86 is dead and Intel just doesn't know it yet. Might take a decade for them to realise.

Intel as a business? Maybe as a design house they will struggle to catch up. As a foundry? If they do not catch up with the amount of government support they are going to be able to claim, then there is something very wrong.

Most chip designers have at least one way forward, which is to produce chips that run WASM well on Linux or a BSD. This is actually a good time for minority architectures, because a truly portable architecture is on the horizon, and everyone has an incentive to see it work; that incentive being not losing all their business to Apple, Samsung and a few Chinese firms whose names we don't recognise yet!

unfocussed_mike··on Apple’s risky, yearslong effort to design its own silicon is paying off
AMD does ARM stuff and has had plenty of time to get it right.

Intel has had, what, three, four bites of the RISC cherry? They've owned big chunks of the ecosystem Apple now exists in. Evidently one of their pitches involves RISC-V and specifically SiFive.

I think it's a mistake to see the future as Apple vs Intel or AMD; that is the battle of the first -- nearly over -- quarter of this century.

The future is Apple vs Samsung and some Chinese megacorps we don't necessarily recognise. Because the battle is now moving on from large-scale off-the-shelf products and chips for motherboards to SoCs and large-scale bespoke design.

It will be the speed and performance of native apps on Apple and Samsung ARM silicon vs the freedom of choice and universal portability of WASM on RISC-V and the-long-tail-of-every-other-architecture.

unfocussed_mike··on Ask HN: Has anyone successfully renegotiated an AWS non-compete?
> They won't act on it for your regular employees because it costs them money to do so and developers _routinely_ jump ship, though they want you to know that they technically have the power to because you signed that contract.

This kind of thinking is exactly why these clauses get worse and worse and worse over time, I'm afraid.

People should be prepared to argue the toss over every single line of an employment contract, and seek advice for every single line.

unfocussed_mike··on They Thought They Were Free: The Germans, 1933-45
I agree. I mean, more than four years earlier than Jan 6th 2021, David Frum wrote that when Republican voters understand they can no longer win by democratic means (that is, once they become a clear minority), they wouldn't reject the Republican Party, they'd reject democracy.

So this was really a long-observed trajectory.

Personally I think it is not over, because I'm not convinced the GOP is ready to accept it is destined for minority status, and because since that day an enormous amount of groundwork has been done to practically guarantee the next election is undermined.

unfocussed_mike··on They Thought They Were Free: The Germans, 1933-45
Right.

Trump didn't think the 6th insurgents would succeed. He had clearly been advised that the reaction to it might allow him to institute marshal law, and there was a draft executive order floating around that would have seen him use that situation to try to delay things further.

I think a lot of people fail to understand how many different ways there are to make order out of chaos, and how in extreme chaos a lot of people will accept any kind of order.

unfocussed_mike··on They Thought They Were Free: The Germans, 1933-45
> When January 6 happened, it was a shock.

A shock in the sense of a systemic shock, sure.

In the sense of a surprise to observers, no. Not really. Certainly should not have been a shock at all to anyone paying any sort of attention from around the 20th of December.

unfocussed_mike··on Employee’s unwanted birthday party nets him $450k after lawsuit
What it sounds like is a company that screwed up, offended someone who was easily upset, made that person panic, confronted him, made it worse, and then used company policies that are only necessary in the USA to stop him returning in case he returned to do harm.

It's not theatre but it sure sounds theatrical, when they could have apologised, given him some time to regroup his emotions and then left it at that.

When I was much younger I had a nervous breakdown at work during a period of extreme personal stress -- I really absolutely and totally lost the plot. Quite probably upset a lot of people, many of whom did not see me the same afterwards. Though more fallout for me personally; it was difficult to be there and my reaction undermined me.

I was treated with enormous -- and I must say on reflection completely unearned -- respect and at no point did the company feel they had to do this. Because I'm not in the USA.

It's worth considering that many places in the USA seem to think the problem in their culture with violent crime is not guns but the fact that mentally ill people can get guns and weaponry of all sorts.

What follows from that is company policy that seriously upset people must necessarily be treated as a threat.

And this sort of "bar him from the building because he panicked" outcome is the logical conclusion of this attitude.

unfocussed_mike··on Elon Musk makes $43B unsolicited bid to take Twitter private
Salt?

I've fully grasped that he is rich. Though he is not, actually, $43bn liquid rich, at all; he's going to need to sell chunks of his other businesses to do this. That potentially means handing over significant influence over SpaceX or Tesla, so he can buy the cause of his hurt feelings in his spat with the SEC.

I don't give a damn whether he is the richest man in the world now (he is not -- Putin is) or continues to be.

I don't think Twitter want to be compared to someone buying a pleasure boat. That really does underscore my point about it being a narcissism purchase though, with the added frisson of white male mid-life crisis, so I'll stipulate if you will!

The strategy I outlined in a single sentence for twitter to stay true to its roots means not having to worry about shareholder value or decline. There are several viable, thriving market utilities run on this basis (e.g. in currency trading markets). They do not decline and they are beholden to their shareholders only in continuing to provide the utility.

There is no way that Twitter owned by a random rich narcissist won't decline as it tilts at windmills.

Twitter owned by a set of media companies that have come to depend on it as a means to exist -- as a utility that supports the media market through enlightened self-interest -- is viable.

unfocussed_mike··on Elon Musk makes $43B unsolicited bid to take Twitter private
"Elon Musk's raging narcissism launches all-out $43B assault on his credibility and fortune"

Without any understanding that the his right-wing narcissistic suppliers who rage in public about being prevented from raging in public are not the sort of people who become good paying customers for a free platform.

This is like the universe seeing Elon Musk and issuing a course correction.

For the avoidance of doubt: this is dreadful for Twitter's longevity. Twitter's only sustainable future while staying true to its roots, is as a market utility co-owned by media companies.

A billionaire pouring money into a money-pit is fine only for as long as it holds his interest as a plaything (which might be a long time, considering his narcissism)

unfocussed_mike··on My Life as a Mentalist
> "You ran 15km before breakfast? You bloody mentalist" "You carried on drinking even after I left? Mentalist"

Well some of this I include under high-risk social behaviour I suppose.

But it's a good observation. I can't think of a time recently I've heard it used positively.

unfocussed_mike··on My Life as a Mentalist
Side note: the word "mentalist" is widely-used London (maybe South-East London) slang for nutter/weirdo/unhinged person; the kind of person who is unpredictably or disproportionately angry, violent or prone to high-risk social behaviour that is best avoided. Usually a man: "bloke's a mentalist!"

It is basically never a compliment (whereas "mental" occasionally has a positive/fun connotation now).

It makes reading about Americans talking about "mentalists", including some of the comments on this page, very funny indeed.

unfocussed_mike··on My Life as a Mentalist
Not always.

One part of Derren Brown's act involves getting people to say things that aren't true at all -- playing with suggestibility in groups and cohesiveness.

Like, he'll do a quickfire guessing thing, going through audience members, guessing, "did I guess right?" thing, ramping up the speed, and he knows for sure people will say yes when they want to say no.

He's maniacally clever.

unfocussed_mike··on You’re muted – or are you? Videoconferencing apps may listen when mic is off
> Bob Woodward has gotten PLENTY of high level politicians to talk to him candidly even though he's publishing what they are saying often in an unflattering light.

Woodward is absolutely one of the few exceptions, if not the only one.

He publishes on a long timescale with dozens of sources, not a short timescale with one or two.

So everyone knows the story will come out but not immediately, and everyone knows everyone talks to Bob.

But like it or not, most (not all) of the people he talks to have less to lose, because they are at or close to the apex of power in DC; there will always be jobs for them elsewhere in the USA, in a thinktank or on a board somewhere.

(It's also worth noting that Woodward's most famous source was anonymous for essentially his entire life)

In the real world outside seats of government, talking to a journalist on the record about stuff you should not often means you are the single source -- the only person who made the unflattering or damaging story possible, in a story that maybe won't wait even a week to be published.

It puts you out there on your own, gets you fired, makes it difficult to get immediately re-hired, and I suspect for an American with a family in an at-will state makes telling the truth on the record a luxury they can't afford.

unfocussed_mike··on Don’t Cook Yourself with RF Energy
All of western movie history would have us believe that there's the official limit on paper, and then there's the real limit in practice that Grigori, the underfed, overtired engineer-who-probably-shouldn't-be-smoking-around-all-that-stuff, actually has to work with.

The current situation makes that stereotype seem more and more plausible by the day.

unfocussed_mike··on Why I quit this battle
This is simultaneously funny and also somehow deep-down true.

No idea if it happened in this case because this is the first I've read about it, but it has always struck me that the websites of campaigners get progressively worse as the battle gets more and more difficult, and fellow campaigners drop out, leaving the diehards with both the campaign and maintaining the overly-ambitious campaign website that someone earnestly set up. There always comes a point where someone just hacks the HTML by hand.

Either way, I wish the guy peace of mind and hope someone can help him with his medical bills.

unfocussed_mike··on Mgmt – Next generation distributed, event-driven, parallel config management
Controls your stuff.

Take only what you need from it.

(do-do-do-do do-de-do-do, dooo-dooo)

Sorry, silly music/lyrics joke. But it seems to be a scripting-focussed alternative to Puppet and Ansible, at least from what I can see.

So, remote deployment of packages, timed/scheduled configuration changes etc., I think.

unfocussed_mike··on Web3: A VC-funded gig economy of securities fraud
> Some HN thought leaders declared Bitcoin a tulip bubble when the price was 1000x smaller than it is now.

I don't know that I understand the point you're making. The fundamentals of Bitcoin haven't changed, and it is worse than a tulip bubble.

unfocussed_mike··on Web3: A VC-funded gig economy of securities fraud
> The community.

100% this. A basket of deplorables.

unfocussed_mike··on Web3: A VC-funded gig economy of securities fraud
I really hope David is absolutely certain of everything he says.

I have learned not to be surprised about anything to do with web3, but if there's the slightest error in here they will rip him apart in the British courts.

(Though that might produce enough heat to bring about an investigation, at least.)

unfocussed_mike··on Are film critics losing sync with audiences?
It intrigues me that as time goes on, Jim Carrey will become better known for arty seriousness than for the box-office smash gurning that got him to the screen from late night talk show comic slots.

Like the opposite of Leslie Nielsen: a man now really only recognised for comedy, when he got his start in comedy by satirising his own serious roles in mainstream potboilers.

I only wish for the same for Adam Sandler, who made one film (Punch Drunk Love) that so completely changed who he could be that it might one day, maybe, perhaps, just possibly, correct the damage he did to western culture with Little Nicky. ;-)

unfocussed_mike··on Are film critics losing sync with audiences?
Mm, but Ebert is now decades into the past, isn't he. I think critics are generally aligning better with audience understanding.

It's ironic that Ebert misunderstood a film like Fast Times, considering he co-wrote a film with bloomin' Russ Meyer isn't it!

I will have to look up those reviews (as a Brit I was not routinely exposed to Ebert; for us it was Barry Norman).

I don't expect film critics to like every movie, and I do expect them to engage in criticism of films they like, for example of weak parts of dialogue, of spoiled shots, etc.

Unpopular opinion: Blue Velvet is a bad film.

unfocussed_mike··on Are film critics losing sync with audiences?
> Is that a good criteria for whether a film is good or not.

I don't rewatch films as a rule but I do sometimes rewatch films with people who have not seen that film.

There are films like Dancer In The Dark, Grave Of The Fireflies, or Dogville that I simply cannot watch a second time because of the precise, agonising emotional turmoil they create. I will recommend this experience to everyone, and they too will watch it only once and recommend it to others.

Then there are films like Taken that I would never watch because they are dreadful, hateful trash.

I would consider the former list to be beautiful, painful exceptions to the idea that a film that can be watched endlessly is a great work. And even then I might be persuaded to watch them with someone I really loved. Perhaps. Though I'd have to love someone a lot to willingly watch through the end of Dancer again.

I would not be so enthusiastic about spending time with anyone who joyfully rewatches Taken.

unfocussed_mike··on Are film critics losing sync with audiences?
> For instance, Taken gets 59% with critics on Rotten Tomatoes. It was a hugely important and impactful film. It basically spawned/revived a whole subgenre of action film.

A fair number of critics looked down on that film because it is casually chauvinistic, nasty and bigoted. (I absolutely loathe it. Want to see how that film could have been? Watch Man On Fire.)

I don't know whether you can support your "politically desirable" assertion with meaningful data -- not to say that you might not be right, but more to say that I don't know what shape that data would have.

But I'd be interested to hear a couple of examples anyway.

unfocussed_mike··on How is the free firmware for the Raspberry progressing?
Thank you for this.

Part of the problem with the cynical view of charities that you're responding to is that if it goes unchallenged, it actually becomes practically impossible to help charities improve their charitable efficiency.

If people think all charities are BS, they stop donating, and it becomes meaningless to say charity X is doing a better job on a structural level than charity Y, which is for sure important information for donors.

I've worked on some stuff for a social organisation that is now a registered charity, and it is amazing how deep the tendrils of the regulations actually go -- the extent to which things have to be structured to avoid conveying benefits that aren't the objectives of the charity.

(I also applaud you for doing what you do)

unfocussed_mike··on How is the free firmware for the Raspberry progressing?
> Though it adds another small question: aren’t/weren’t most public schools severely Anglican?

Yes -- implicitly.

(sidebar: I am not sure that, when public schools really first sprang up, it was even possible to educate people of Jewish descent; the situation for Jews in england in particular was deeply complicated by their unique relationship to the state as established by the Magna Carta. Either way, they were not landowners by law and therefore probably not that interesting to the church.)

But at any rate as Wikipedia says, the first public schools appear to have been generalised and detached versions of grammar schools, which were the schools run for wealthy families that were attached to churches and monasteries.

Those schools started off teaching young people the skills needed to function in church life, but eventually they seem to have become so generalised for various other trades that they separated themselves in an administrative sense.

They'd have had lots of clergy doing the teaching nonetheless, I imagine, simply because really only clergy had access to education at that point.

I am not sure how "technical" the school I went to ever was in its earliest form (we did have technical schools in the UK for a while as a precursor to the comprehensive system).

I get the impression it was commercial in the sense that it taught reading and writing necessary for conducting a business, maths necessary for bookkeeping and engineering, and some science.

(The livery company that founded it still owns half of it -- the outside half, literally)

unfocussed_mike··on How is the free firmware for the Raspberry progressing?
There is no "jack shit" about the Raspberry Pi Foundation's charitable status.

It's really not in question.

They've even relatively recently split the business in two (Foundation and Trading Company) to further protect the charitable aims of the Foundation and avoid the ugly Ikea situation.

There is also (in the UK and in the USA as I understand it) a distinction between not-for-profit and charitable status.

In the USA AFAIK most self-declared non-profit organisations follow or are advised to model themselves on the Georgia Nonprofit Corporation code. But not all non-profits are charities (all charities are non-profits, but as you say, it does not mean they don't _make_ profits from time to time; they just don't return them to shareholders).

In the UK we have slightly different non-profit codes like the CIC (Community Interest Company). They are very distinct from charities.

unfocussed_mike··on How is the free firmware for the Raspberry progressing?
Run by -- and for -- the public not by/for the church.

The state did not run schools when these were established. It's much older than that as a term.

unfocussed_mike··on How is the free firmware for the Raspberry progressing?
Yes -- but also all "Public" schools were not "Church" schools.

Basically there is a time when education was almost exclusively monastic; those who were not taught privately were taught by religious institutions.

The public schools were free of that influence to a greater extent.

There is one more tier of school you don't mention which sits somewhere below "public": the "commercial school". There were some of these owned by the livery companies, and were a tier of schools that were created along the lines of the public schools but before the school system was fully established. Most of them were not fee-paying but were funded by donations or livery company charitable funds. They taught largely vocational skills (but professional ones rather than technical ones); parents sent their kids to commercial schools to bring back the knowledge to professionalise the family business or to set them up in a trade.

(I went to a school that was originally founded this way, but was a part-state-owned grammar school by the time I got there a century later)

unfocussed_mike··on Are film critics losing sync with audiences?
I tend to mischievously misapply the word "Challenging" to movies I think shouldn't have been made because they expose the bigotry of their audience.

Like all the Taken movies, or A Boy And His Dog, or anything Steven Seagal made after he discovered Russian money.

unfocussed_mike··on Are film critics losing sync with audiences?
> Keep in mind that most of the foreign films that you can find with subtitles tend to be among the best films the country has ever produced, or the ones that fit their cultural climate the best.

This is really not true from what I can see. European films are routinely subtitled for other languages. (They used to be dubbed instead).

And even cheap and cheerful Bollywood and Chinese movies find a distributor and a bad translation.

Perhaps this is more of a problem on US streaming services. You do have to want to find these things, to some extent. But almost all cinema is produced with a global audience in mind.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →