The author starts out by complaining that current music theory is not scientific. I completely agree. The field is astoundingly full of technical-seeming, well-accepted textbooks containing a biological "explanation" of harmony that is either totally unproven or trivially false.
But then he precedes to dive into a mountain of unsubstantiated conjecture, saying:
1. Our brains are just computers
2. Evolution motivates less computation
3. Finding the fundamental frequency of a sound is worthwhile
4. Doing that is computationally easier if all other frequencies are in harmony
5. That is what has lead to harmony giving us pleasure
(The rest is essentially fluff around this core argument)
It's a nice theory, but there's nothing to substantively back up any of these points. He comes the closest on point #4, but only by making strong assumptions about the flavor of #1. The whole thrust of his argument is just totally tangential to addressing his initial complaints about the lack of science and rigor within the subject of biological harmony.
-
One thing he does get right is avoiding most common mistake that textbooks and laymen alike think about hearing: Our ears do not perceive the waveform of sound directly (for the most part[1]). Rather, we perceive sympathy vibrations at different parts our cochlea, rather directly sending nerve signals according to the Fourier transform of the original waveform. This can be measured (scientifically)!
This Vi Hart video does a remarkably good job at giving a layman's tour of our some of the phenomena in our ears:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i_0DXxNeaQ0
[1] If this were totally true, we wouldn't be able to perceive phase at all! But it is the case that these sympathy vibrations are perceived with much more sensitivity than our perception of phase, and are linked more closely to peoples' idea of harmony.