HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unholiness

1,306 karma · joined August 20, 2013

submissionscomments
unholiness··on Facebook disabling messaging in its mobile web app to push people to Messenger
More likely it's about getting more immediate attention from push notifications.

If you only ever use chat in the browser, you only see messages when you actively check it. With the app installed, you get a giant bubble that you can't ignore for every message. FB wants to be the messenger that people respond to immediately.

For me, I actually like the messenger bubble UI, and love that it's not built as a gateway to the massive time sink of the rest of Facebook. But I think it's clear that omnipresence is the goal here, and we have no reason to believe that it won't become a funnel to the rest of Facebook in the future.

unholiness··on Startup Reading List
My interpretation of n72's comment: These books aren't worth reading because they make you focus your time and mental energy on activities that make a good startup, rather than activities that make a good product.

There's a temptation, when you're an early-stage startup with little direction, to start "playing house"[0]: Trying make your startup look and feel like all these other successful startups you've seen, and, by reading more books, getting positive feedback for doing those things.

There's obviously value in wisdom gained from those who've walked down this road before. But it's not worth obsessing over how to make the perfect startup. It is worth obsessing over how you can be delivering more value to your customers.

[0] PG's term http://paulgraham.com/before.html

unholiness··on Show HN: Flexbox Defense – learn CSS flexbox by playing a tower defense game
Okay, but this validation happens instead of opening the help dialog. Whatever event triggers there eats the button click.

When typing an incorrect input, the first place a user will go to fix it is the help. It's a bit of a catch-22 when the help button will only help you after you fix your typos.

unholiness··on Undersea Cable System Cuts in Singapore
It's so startling to see failures so...unabstract. We depend so much on the layers of the internet fulfilling their protocols perfectly, that seeing a vulnerability like this is just bizarre.

Of course xkcd is relevant as always: https://xkcd.com/697/

unholiness··on -2000 Lines of Code
Serious question: Why is asking your salary any less relevant then asking for your previous place of employment? If I say I did X on project Y at Google, that's a pretty incomplete picture of how valuable my coworkers and bosses found my work on project Y. Thus, it seems like a salary is another potentially helpful data point indicating how valuable I've been to previous companies.

Obviously in a better world it would be possible to glean this information from an interview alone, but the bottom line is that interviews generally suck at informing how useful a candidate is going to be. A candidate who claims they've done valuable work is potentially exaggerating, and it's difficult to tell by how much. That's (part of) why we have resumes, and (most of) why an employer wants to know your previous salary.

Note that I'm asking this unironically. I know that "never tell anyone your salary" is a popular point of discussion here, but I have trouble seeing why it's any different from, say, a grad school asking for your GPA.

unholiness··on WordSafety – Check a name for unwanted meanings in foreign languages
"Colgate" similarly passed. In Spanish, it's the imperative command "Hang yourself".
unholiness··on Is the average sinuosity of the world's rivers equal to pi?
Yes.

With a coastline, the closer you measure, the more length-increasing features you observe, causing the measured length to diverge.

Rivers have a finite width, so once the distance between your measurements is smaller than the width of the river, the measured length will converge to the true length.

unholiness··on Things Rust shipped without
A function call is nothing more than putting your return address and parameters on the stack and jumping to the address of the function. By referring directly to the function's address, there's no "additional pointer chase", since calling the function already does exactly that.

If you were to inline all of the perform functions in the GOTO version vs putting a macro at the end of each function, you're right that there's some function overhead, but I think it's as small as a single instruction to put the return address on the stack. Maybe that would be optimized away, maybe not.

To your point: My argument isn't that you can't do the GOTO version. With optimizations, it's essentially identical. My point is, that is a lot more hard-to-grok code to maintain for something that can be achieved in a simpler way.

unholiness··on Things Rust shipped without
Okay, but a much more readable and maintainable way to achieve this same optimization is with function pointers.

In your example:

  void (*[10])() function_table = {
      &perform_addition, 
      &perform_multiplication,
      ...
  }
  
  while(1) {
      ins = fetch_next_inst();
      *(function_table[ins])();  
  }
Edit: Seeing it written like this now, it's clear you could save yet another jump by defining a macro for what's in the while loop and putting it at the end of every function call.
unholiness··on The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iPhones and iPads
I posted this on an earlier thread about the morality of AdBlock, but it seem relevant to the discussion:

There is a huge irony in that fact that AdBlock's function of keeping ads away from our content will eventually do the opposite. The alternative to ads alongside my content is ads inside my content.

Let's face it: paywalls don't work. The alternative on the horizon is native advertising. Buzzfeed is now famously refusing to host ads. Instead they sustain themselves by publishing content that subtly supports the agenda of any company with deep enough pockets to pay for it. A viewer's ability to distinguish between native ads and regular articles is small and quickly vanishing. If separate ads stop reaching people, the path to monetization remaining is to change your content to reflect someone else's agenda.

I keep AdBlock off by default because I prefer a world where creators can make a meaningful articles and a useful apps without caring about who they are supporting, and can, as the price tag, separately attach an ad.

I do see it as a moral issue. There are good people making content that's being sustained by ads. I am never going to remember to give them my modicum of support if I don't consider them innocent until proven guilty. It's worth the small annoyance. It's worth the 2 seconds it takes to turn it on for the problematic pages. Hell, you can even map it to a shortcut[1]. It sucks, but the alternative is positively bleak.

.

TL;DR: The bathroom may be dirty, but at least no one's taking a shit in my kitchen.

[1] https://adblockplus.org/en/faq_customization#shortcuts

unholiness··on Show HN: Mockups fixed by making collaboration effortless, built with React
It's just as fast to draw a browser window, button, or text box in Balsalmiq as it is to draw a rectangle in Precursor, but the former makes it unambiguous what I'm talking about.

The point of low-fidelity mockups is to make the conversation about the the overall design without focusing on detail. If "low-fidelity" means moving from basic web elements to basic geometry, it seems to me like that hinders the conversation more than it helps.

unholiness··on Do Men Really Earn More Than Women? (Infographic)
Not at all. The oft-cited 77-cents-on-the-dollar statistic never referred to people in the same positions, or even the same fields. It simply claimed that the average woman's salary is 77% of the average man's. The article refutes something totally different, but this is where the goalposts have always been.
unholiness··on Do Men Really Earn More Than Women? (Infographic)
Equal pay for equal work, at the end of the day, is an incredibly low bar to set for gender equality. I would get equal pay for equal work at a sweatshop in China, but a sweatshop worker by no means has the same income opportunities as I do.

Gender income inequality is a matter of opportunities. It happens at the education level, where women are less likely to be encouraged to go into higher paying fields, at the hiring level, where equally qualified women are less likely to be hired for the same job as men, and at the promotion level, where women are less likely to ask for, and be taken seriously when asking for, increased position. Looking at salary differences after all these effects takes the real issue of opportunity differences, and replaces it with a non-issue of salary differences within the same position.

unholiness··on Going “Write-Only”
That's a pretty ridiculous stance to take. By posting here, he clearly thinks his thoughts are worth our time to read, but by going "write-only", he clearly thinks other peoples' thoughts aren't worth his time to read.

The whole exercise seems very conceited.

unholiness··on Going “Write-Only”
I think his point is that we have no idea how long people will enjoy any of the music created today, nor can we really say how much people will be listening to classical music 100 years from now. Music from the 14th century is certainly more battle-tested, but there's nothing objectively "least ephemeral" about it that means it can't, or shouldn't, be bested.
unholiness··on I Quit: What really goes on at Apple
I assume that was the intended reading.
unholiness··on A note on the argument about the 'morality' of adblockers
> That's not a serious discussion.

You're right. Let's discuss paid content.

There is absolutely a place for paid content on the internet. But I don't think paying for content is a replacement for the majority of things currently funded by ads. The internet is inherently open. Paid content is inherently exclusionary. If we're talking about a genuine substitute for ads, that right there is a non-starter. Whether I'm paying for it out of pocket or through my company, the fact is that there are loads of people out there who are not getting access to that content.

A lot of what sucks about paywalls is the friction, and the trust needed of the host (that the content will be worthwhile). But even in a world that's solved these problems, there's still the fundamental problem that the majority of the world won't have access that content because they don't have the money to throw around.

unholiness··on A note on the argument about the 'morality' of adblockers
There is a huge irony in that fact that AdBlock's function of keeping ads away from our content will eventually do the opposite. The alternative to ads alongside my content is ads inside my content.

Let's face it: paywalls don't work. The alternative on the horizon is native advertising. Buzzfeed is now famously refusing to host ads. Instead they sustain themselves by publishing content that subtly supports the agenda of any company with deep enough pockets to pay for it. A viewer's ability to distinguish between native ads and regular articles is small and quickly vanishing. If separate ads stop reaching people, the path to monetization remaining is to change your content to reflect someone else's agenda.

I keep AdBlock off by default because I prefer a world where creators can make a meaningful articles and a useful apps without caring about who they are supporting, and can, as the price tag, separately attach an ad.

I do see it as a moral issue. There are good people making content that's being sustained by ads. I am never going to remember to give them my modicum of support if I don't consider them innocent until proven guilty. It's worth the small annoyance. It's worth the 2 seconds it takes to turn it on for the problematic pages. Hell, you can even map it to a shortcut[1]. It sucks, but the alternative is positively bleak.

.

TL;DR: The bathroom may be dirty, but at least no one's taking a shit in my kitchen.

[1] https://adblockplus.org/en/faq_customization#shortcuts

unholiness··on “Today we moved into our new Facebook building”
I've seen the phrase "all the research" thrown around quite a lot in this thread. Would you mind linking to a few studies you refer to?

Mainly, I'm curious about how they define productivity. An office full of people performing completely independent tasks is almost certainly less productive than having separate offices; the advantage of open offices comes when everyone's work is interrelated. In an open environment, whenever I need to make a decision on implementation, I can easily ask someone intimately familiar with the area my code effects, and vice versa. The result is that people are more likely to make the better choices for the long-term future of the code base.

I'm also curious if there are any longitudinal studies that address moral. I wouldn't be surprised if people in open offices feel less like a cog in the system. I could also imagine it's a lot harder to develop a hatred of your coworkers and your boss if they're working right in front of you.

unholiness··on Tell Sam Altman: I will take your bet
The whole point of the particular three propositions is that they're highly correlated. Each condition involves an aggregate of many companies. If any of the conditions is true it says more about the general tech climate than it does about the luck of any particular company.

Personally, I might put the odds of each at 60%, 70%, and 90%, respectively. Independently, that gives me a mere 37.8% chance of losing. However, I also think that condition 1 succeeding is highly indicative that the others will succeed too. So, if it were really $100,000 at stake, I wouldn't take the bet.

The real conundrum is that stakes of winning aren't $100,000. The loser's money goes to charity, and the winner's takings are the publicity gained from being right. No doubt both participants feel that the publicity is worth more than $100,000. They don't need to have even 50% confidence to take the bet.

unholiness··on Why Singapore banned chewing gum
Given the number of smokers I knew when I was in Singapore, and that I never saw anyone smoking in the street, I always assumed public smoking was banned. When I heard there was no such ban, I asked a smoker about it. He said he doesn't smoke in public out of consideration for others, and a lack of public ashtrays (but that the latter was likely a bigger factor).
unholiness··on Be My Eyes – Lend your eyes to the blind
The 12% figure refers to legally blind children, the majority (90%) of whom are partially sighted.

For someone who is able to read text at close distances with significant optical assistance, it is far more beneficial for them to learn a written language than to learn braille characters. Until recently, many legally blind US children (and their parents) had the choice to either learn braille or written English. Those who learned braille ended up severely disadvantaged because of the utter lack of braille information produced in our society, and the difficulty of using any screen-based technology.

unholiness··on New, more powerful Google Translate app
Unfortunately, all of their text-recognition is still done on the cloud. So If you're traveling, you most likely won't have a data plan in the country you're visiting, and word lens won't work. This seems like a huge missing piece to me.

It's strange because they let you download language packs so that all the translation (and voice recognition) can be done locally. I have no knowledge in this area, but honestly: is there something fundamental about text recognition that it can't be done client-side?

unholiness··on BLOKK – A font for clients who don't understand lorem ipsum
This slightly improved version[1] is licensed under the SIL Open Font License.

[1] https://github.com/christiannaths/Redacted-Font

unholiness··on A Magician’s Best Trick: Revealing a Basic Human Bias
I love Darren Brown, but that particular con doesn't really exemplify confirmation bias. Confirmation bias is a selective willingness believe new information only when it conforms to your previous beliefs. The system is a good example of how a limited perspective can introduce those false beliefs in the first place - namely, when every horse you bet on wins, you start to think there's a system. But a the key part of confirmation bias isn't acceptance of information which fits your beliefs, it's the rejection of information that doesn't.

For a good example of confirmation bias by Darren Brown, in his videos on psychic readings [1], he throws a multitude of information out, and people latch on to information which confirms his psychic abilities, and ignore the rest, making his abilities completely unfalsifiable.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6_3L9lB1Qtg&t=2m18s

unholiness··on Show HN: Skimmable Videos
Love it. Something like this catching on would really address the bulk of my hatred of video tutorials.

A few minor tweaks:

1. Your home page is missing a concise description of what this actually is: videos with links to their subsections.

2. It takes a few clicks to see an example, and when I get there, the interaction isn't transparent: why would I click on what just looks like paragraph text?

3. In multivideo skims, starting a subsection of a new video should pause the previously playing video -- when I flip to a new page in a book, I don't want the old page still yelling at me.

Overall, great stuff, and I hope to see it expanded further!

unholiness··on The world is not falling apart: The trend lines
To clarify (since Simpson's paradox really only applies when tracking the average of a single variable, not its "inequality", or standard devation):

The local increases in income inequality don't contradict global decreases because populations are mixing between countries. If an average American moves to Zambia and an average Zambian moves to America, the result is that the income gap of both nations increases, while the worldwide income gap remains the same.

unholiness··on Why movies look weird at 48fps, and games are better at 60fps
Actually, these are two completely distinct phenomena.

Dithering exists in both the visual and the audio realms, as corysama pointed out in their linked article [1]. The term's use is identical in both realms, but neither is really related to stochastic resonance.

Dithering is a technique of adding noise to disguise sampling boundaries. It hides unrealistic artifacts from digital downsampling of analog signals, but it does not add more realistic detail. Critically, it does not increase the signal-to-noise ratio.

The phenomenon being described here occurs on a biological level. As described above, the additional noise improves your visual acuity. That is, you can extract /additional/ details with the noise added which could not be resolved before. This is due to a nonlinear change invoked in the system receiving the signal, not from the change to the signal itself. So, while adding the noise initially decreased the signal-to-noise ratio, the overall effect on the entire system is a increase in signal-to-noise ratio.

Here the mechanism, explained in the Henrig paper, appears to be purely biological, but stochastic resonance is not strictly a biological phenomenon; it can also be seen in the electrical domain [2].

[1] http://loopit.dk/banding_in_games.pdf [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stochastic_resonance

unholiness··on The Reddit Front Page Is Not a Meritocracy
It appears the normalized_hot is only used for the first two pages. The rankings after that are subreddit-agnostic.
unholiness··on Homemade Speakers
Agreed. I think there's a lot to be learned from building a driver, if only for the powerful experience of realizing that there's nothing magical about it. Just a magnet and a coil of wire. It's the equivalent a CS guy designing a rudimentary processor: it won't be necessary be good enough to beat out commercial stuff, but it sure does convince you that the thing you take for granted really can be done with just transistors/magnets and wire.

I for one would have loved to do this kind of activity as a kid: it's a pretty simple concept that puts a whole lot of power in your hands and exposes interesting questions. It looks like Bose is doing something in this space at kids science camps [0]. If you can acquire/make an amp and a strobe light to replace their "blue box", there's a whole host of kid-friendly activities on the site to do with kids centered around making hand-made, origami paper drivers.

[0] http://build.bose.com/

← PreviousPage 10 of 11Next →