HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unionpivo

1,557 karma · joined December 17, 2012

union.pivo@gmail.com
submissionscomments
unionpivo··on Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threatening
> It was never the point of Firefox to offer them. Firefox originally started to be the slim alternative to the fat Mozilla suite.

Not OP, and unlike him still use Firefox but:

I lost a lot of functionality/workflow that I depended on. It worked one day until Mozilla deliberately made it not work.

It pisses me even more because it made that decision to be more like Chrome. If I wanted to Chrome I would just use Chrome.

If you don't see why people like me are upset when thing like this happen, we will just have to agree to disagree.

unionpivo··on Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threatening
> The replacement, declarativeNetRequest, does not require the user to give any permissions, so the days of granting ad blocking extensions full access to every page are gone.

Great, but I want to give my add blocker access to every web page. That's kind of it's purpose.

Sure it could be abused, but not if you used one of the community recommended blockers.

> If you think Google is doing this for their own gain, I guess you can simply ask if declarativeNetRequest will be able to block all Google ads, or if you really need a turing complete language for that.

I am not sure if it will be able to block all google ads. Pretty sure it wont be able to remove their ads from search results, since you wont be able to remove/hide parts of the site. Also it wont be able to remove annoying pop up adds (sure it might remove the content of the ad, but popup will remain - well depending how its implemented.)

Also it is only limited to 30k max urls in a blocker. Nowdays my blocker has 80k+ urls. So i guess I would have to pick an choose (If i continued to use chrome).

unionpivo··on Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threatening
The only extensin I use (and a lot of people i know) is uBlockOrigin.

After manifest v3 it will be worse off.

Ublock origin provides a lot of privacy benefits, so people like me are 100% worse off.

Well I switched to Firefox, only really use chrome for testing nowdays.

unionpivo··on Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market dominance
At the end of day power is power. Once a corporation has enough of it compared to local governments it might as well be "government like entity" themselves, or like in case of defense contractors (not just USA, look at Airbuss in EU, Ariane in France, NSO and others in Israel) where it's hard to draw a line where corporations end and government start.

There are plenty of places with week governments in the world, where global multinationals are above the law (look at Africa, some south America).

If corporations get big enough, this might start happening in more developed world as well.

I perhaps notice it more because I live in small country (Slovenia) whose entire national budget is lower than any one of the FANG's. This is one of the reason I support EU despite it's many shortcomings.

unionpivo··on Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market dominance
Slovenia, pretty sure Austria as well, might be others.

You don't need to be vaccinated, you could also preform regular test (test are free), or if you all ready had Covid 19 and recovered.

unionpivo··on Italy fines Amazon record $1.3B for abuse of market dominance
My analysis:

People often get cough up in definitions of what is or isn't monopoly or what free market is, on HN. And its even often argued in USA politics. In EU its far less. What is important is the perceived result (Apple, Google, Facebook have enormous power over daily lives of people) and how people feel (weather something is fair of not). And many inside EU myself included think that

> Google, Apple, Facebook or Amazon

are abusing their market position, that they are doing shady stuff to limit competition, starting to use more and more dark patterns, avoiding taxes (taxes are higher in EU so people are more pissed if somebody is "getting away with it") and generally don't trust them.

So politicians (that want to score points with people) are doing what people want.

Another thing is, that some of this companies are starting to become so powerful that they are starting to worry politicians themselves. So politicians are "defending their turf", by smacking the upstarts when they can. (This is happening in USA as well )

unionpivo··on Renault Zoe NCAP crash rating: zero stars [pdf]
Nobody wants too keep stock. Everybody just builds the smallest warehouse that can get away with, and some places don't even have that.

That's part of the reason for all the supply issues right now.

unionpivo··on Rust support in the Linux kernel
C is simple is a myth.

Sure it's simple in a sense there are not many keywords or features. And you can learn it over a weekend and start programming in it. But when you factor in undefined behavior, straight up user hostile choices done by common compilers in the name of performance, common patterns/library functions (that are all over books and stackowerflows) to avoid etc. C is not that simple anymore.

When you throw in concurrency, programming in C is quite hard.

I write this because I used to be an embedded C programmer, but that was over 10 years ago. I can still read code, sometimes even add simple patches (not to kernel ), so you could say I know the language. But it would take me several months of focused training before I would even dare to touch something as linux kernel.

Not saying that Rust is simple, just saying C isn't as simple as some people make it.

unionpivo··on Amazon packages pile up after AWS outage spawns delivery havoc
Most services and applications can occasionally have unplanned downtime. Many have also planed downtimes sometimes measured in half a day or more.

Services that truly need 100% uptime (and by that I don't mean what management say they WANT, but they are prepared to PAY) are a tiny minority, to the point that I imagine most software developers never work on one.

Even setups that i have seen to handle such cases, usually had some single point of failure somewhere.

And lest face it. Even if you do multi region on AWS, that won't protect you next time someone screws up BGP/switches/DNS or whatever and every region goes down for a while. In that case you better have failover to some other cloud vendor. Even planes or other safety critical equipment is not 100% failure proof.

unionpivo··on Protected Content, Delete by Date, Device Management and more
But here is the thing, its highly unlikely that open source app will have polish compared to Startup with all the funding in the world.

There are very few open source application (desktop or mobile) that are as polished as commercial applications.

This is unlikely to change, but I still think it's worth trying to get as many users to use open source apps, because more users an app has - higher chance of more developers - better app. Not to mention no ads or spying and other crap that commercial apps are riddled with (General opinion not just chat apps)

unionpivo··on Protected Content, Delete by Date, Device Management and more
Sure, apps with lots of paid developers have better gui, and flows than open source.

I still prefer open source. Managed to convince a portion of friends as well.

unionpivo··on Common Jobs in a Medieval City
Paper was expensive before modern industry. Don't have reference at hand, but I remember it because I read it from few different sources.
unionpivo··on A submarine's weakness: its software?
> - It is driven entirely by formal requirements and specifications Can you explain why this is a bad thing? I've found that formal requirements and specifications are almost always good unless they're just vague (in which case: they're not really formal)

I have been in various projects for government and enterprises (non military, mostly medical and banking fields) with formal requirements and some without. I can say that those without always had better GUI and people using them liked it better. I think that one major reason is that most people can't really imagine application without actually using it. Only once they are using it they can give you useful feedback (as in this is important, this isn't, make that action default etc.)

Another reason is that people that are not using it are writing requirements. For instance in a lot of medical applications, people who will write specs and requirements are Business managers or doctors (or both), but not radiology technicians and nurses that will actually use the software. So they have no idea of day to day workflow - just desired outcome. So software will suck 100% if based only on their requirements (in my personal experience).

unionpivo··on AWS us-east-1 outage
If it's brand new RiscV CPU that was just relesed 5 min ago, and nobody really tested then yes.

If its standard CPU that everybody else uses, and its not known to be bad then no.

Same for software. Is it ok to have dependency on AWS services ? Their history shows yes. Dependency on brand new SaaS product ? Nothing mission critical.

Or npm/crates/pip packages. Packages that have been around and seedily maintained for few years, have active users, are worth checking out. Some random project from single developer ? Consider vendoring (and owning if necessary ) it.

unionpivo··on Ubiquiti developer charged with extortion, causing 2020 “breach”
You assume anyone except the hacker knew anything about AWS.

Our firm subcontracts to other firms. I am among other thing resident Sysadmin which means I get to do everything related to AWS.

Out of 6 contracts we had, where firm had their project on aws I got root credentials in 4 cases. out of 4 i only managed to convince 2 to take their account security more seriously and lock things down.

What I am trying to say is that what happened at Ubiquiti is far more comon than people realize.

Because when all is said and done you still need someone who thinks like sysadmin.

unionpivo··on Google 20% time volunteers have been rewriting the ITA Matrix flight search app
We wrote Application (medical) with GWT in 2010, and we still maintain it, occasionally adding new features.

Once you figure out build step and magic incitation to make debugger work (and docment it), It's really not bad,

and maintaining is easier then most other "older" codebases I come across. Old rubby/php/javascrip(jQuery/whatever) project is usually pain because they all use tons of external packages/libs that you have to update find new ones etc every time you take project off the shelf. With GWT and Java it just works, because we didn't use that many other libraries and Java libraries generally put a lot more effort in backwards compatibility.

So no I would not start new projects in GWT anymore, but I think that current react projects will be a lot harder to maintain in 10 years, than GWT is.

unionpivo··on FTC sues to block Nvidia-Arm merger
You do realize that neither Nvidia nor Arm, have their own foundries and have shown no signs of wanting to build one ?

TSMC and Nvidia are not in the same business.

unionpivo··on Chrome phasing out Manifest v2 support from Jan 2022
You have put into words, what I have been feeling.

Thank you

unionpivo··on Chrome phasing out Manifest v2 support from Jan 2022
Best solution i found is to have normal firefox + Firefox Developer Edition

They use separated profiles (you could sync them to same if you wanted)

https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/developer/

unionpivo··on How to Save a Ski Town
There are a lot of people from balkans working there for a few years or decades before returning home.
unionpivo··on The IPv4 Cleanup Project
Android devices are not optional in some parts of world with low iPhone adaption.

In my previous company of 250+ people only 2 had iphones.

unionpivo··on Backdooring Rust crates for fun and profit
Problem isn't creating namespaces.

Problem is what happens when someone claims google, amazon, and then stars doing shady stuff with it.

And maybe that somebody, was working for such organization and then left on bad terms and doesnt want to give login code or whatever.

It's not that easy problem to solve, and you need to have people on standby to resolve such issues, some of which might include layers.

Implementing namespaces in code are not even 10% of effort for this to work.

unionpivo··on Chrome may start restricting requests to private networks
> Use IPv6 and stop with the NAT. It makes all the split-horizon DNS pain go away.

\s

Sure. Just give me a week or two(or several months) to shut down whole network and reconfigure all the servers, devices, and services.

Also all our business partners and vendors who integrate with our services, will be glad to switch to our new setup, exactly when we need them to.

\s

If you are building new site/network ipv6 is way to go. Migrating existing ones is next to impossible due to all of the dependencies out of your control

unionpivo··on Person Furious That Someone Right Click Saved Their Precious NFT
This sounds funny now, until somebody tries to sue someone or even pass laws that would make it illegal.
unionpivo··on How learned helplessness happens in engineering teams
> healthcare

most of healthcare software (that i have worked with) is really, really bad.

The fact that it mostly has no tests, or if it has tests they mainly test just the happy route.

They usually have lots of documentation, but it's not comprehensive and mostly just describes the happy paths, so when thing break you are out of luck. Also can't google anything since this are all closed source enterprise type software, so you are at the mercy of their support, that often also sucks.

And if you have to integrate with it, you often can't get the documentation, or tools to do it unless you are working for one of their VARs. And the VAR's are often even worse.

If you pick random 10 high school kids, get them into some code academy for a 6 months, and then have them develop an application, the ones that finish will probably be better than majority of health care software out there (for simple reason that they won't know enough to really screw up as bad.).

The only saving grace is, that its often written in Java so you can find workarounds in runtime (or inject stuff) if you really need to.

unionpivo··on Sci-Fi Icon Neal Stephenson Finally Takes on Global Warming
Funny Anathem is still my favorite book from him.

Read it 4 times by now, which is quite rare for me.

Seveneves I didn't particular like and sometimes skipped pages at a time. Just goes to show how peoples taste is different.

unionpivo··on I couldn't debug the code because of my name
I disagree. We are in this mess because nobody took it serious enough for long time.

Now that serious money is on the table, it might actually get solved and fixed once and for all.

We/us in tech had 30 years to fix our shit on our own. We didn't, that's the result.

unionpivo··on Airbnb removes 80% of advertisements in Amsterdam after registration obligation
> I suspect tourists are just an easy scapegoat to deflect blame from policy failure.

There was a policy failure, in allowing Airbnb to run huge unlicensed hotel business.

This policy is addressing that. They didn't stop Airbnb from operating, they just made sure that they operate more in line like other hotels.

This will in turn enable them to make sure that the tourist flow is sustainable, by raising or lowering tourist taxes on such rentals.

unionpivo··on Airbnb removes 80% of advertisements in Amsterdam after registration obligation
Expect if I did it I would have huge penalties and real possibility of jail time for repeat offences

But because its USA megacorp it takes years before it gets slap on a wrist.

unionpivo··on Lab-grown meat may never be cost-competitive enough to displace traditional meat
silicon (the interesting part) inside plastic that you see is quite small and thin. You would need hundreds/thousands of them to approach the size/weight ratio to single steak.

And silicone that needs that high level of cleanliness is not cheap. Most chips are fabricated on larger/older processes that do not require that high level of cleanliness

← PreviousPage 7 of 21Next →