HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unsui

533 karma · joined November 4, 2013

submissionscomments
unsui··on Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future
That's not quite true.

WFH was instituted as an emergency response to COVID-19, thus it can't really be stated that employers forced WFH upon employees capriciously.

Enlightened employers can and have seen the value of hybrid policies that take employee preferences into account: those who prefer at-office can choose to come in, and those who prefer remote can choose WFH.

The disagreement is when an employer is unwilling to work with the employee to reach an understanding that benefits both mutually.

Taken from the other perspective, were a company to become entirely remote, then it could be seen to ruin the relationship for employees who had wanted to come into the office.

That is the case here: what is ruined is that no attempt has been made to reach a middle ground, whereby those who wish to remain at the office can do so, and those who prefer WFH can do so.

It is this reluctance to appreciate the learnings from our collective covid experience: that WFH is a significant boon to a large percentage of employees, and indeed is a competitive advantage, that has ruined an otherwise wonderful working relationship with an employer.

And thus, the only response is to look for employers who appreciate WFH as the competitive advantage it is.

unsui··on Consciousness is supported by near-critical slow cortical electrodynamics
This is laughably false.

Materialism, aka "physicalism", simply posits that all phenomena have an underlying physical basis, i.e., no "spooky" or magic stuff.

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/physicalism/

Quantum mechanics follows from physicalism by demonstrating that the physical nature of reality is incredibly complex and counterintuitive, particularly at quantum scales.

But that in no way implies that quantum mechanics leads to non-materialism or opens the door for materialism to be false. It simply becomes subsumed into materialism itself:

materialism requires that all phenomena be ultimately explainable via physical explanations, and those explanations must account for quantum-mechanical phenomena.

unsui··on Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future
The reality for many is logging in to MS Teams or Zoom to have virtual meetings even within the office. That is what a significant number of my professional colleagues did even while at the office: many of them would just dial in from their offices, even when the meeting room was right down the hall.

A significant portion of companies already accommodate hybrid work environments, whereby some meeting attendees are remote. This would be no different.

There may be legitimate cases where physical proximity is a key advantage for a specific team, but the current WFH situation has demonstrated that those cases have likely been exaggerated, as people are demonstrably productive (in the case of my company, results in record profits) while completely remote.

unsui··on Big tech makes a big bet: Offices are still the future
> Nobody is ruining anything for anybody.

yes they are.

I quite like my employer, but their return-to-office policy is non-negotiable, so I am going to start looking for a new employer.

This literally ruins an otherwise wonderful working relationship and likely will result in years of tribal knowledge lost (as the senior engineer on my team).

And yes, I have reached out to my manager, and this policy is non-negotiable (as it is company-wide), so the writing is on the wall.

unsui··on Consciousness is supported by near-critical slow cortical electrodynamics
agreed.

brain-as-a-radio-antenna is a common trope amongst those who would believe that meatspace isn't capable of generating consciousness alone (always looking for some sort of elan vital, to equate with another pursuit for the magic stuff of life).

From a purposely scientific perspective, we have to begin with the working assumption that materialism is true, until such point that it is conclusively proven false.

There is no evidence that the brain works in any way like an antenna, at least insofar as any electromagnetic waves or other such messaging systems supported by the physics of our current world as we know it.

Thus, the brain-as-antenna thinking necessarily pre-supposes an other-worldly explanation; it assumes what it's trying to prove.

Even if it were true (HIGHLY unlikely), we can't begin with that as the starting point in our search for understanding it. Otherwise, our brains are incredibly adept at shaping our thoughts and concepts to fit those prescribed notions of animacy and otherworldliness.

It's no wonder that many pseudoscientific principles BEGIN with the presupposition that you have to be willing to believe in order for the effect to become apparent.

unsui··on Meta shares drop 20% on Q4 earnings miss, weak outlook
The vitriol is well-deserved.

While there is no such thing as a perfectly-ethical company within a Capitalist framework, there are degrees of ethical behavior that rightly influence a company's reputation.

Would I choose to work or support a company that clubs baby seals?

Less hyperbolic, would I choose to support a company that continually seeks to profit from promoting extremism in dialogue, creating self-perpetuating echo-chambers which have real-world consequences (re: the very real danger to American democratic processes), in addition to brainwashing people's parents into believing in utter hogwash and tearing families apart?

Yes, they are making bank. But at what cost? And should that cost influence your interaction with said company?

unsui··on Geometry from Another Universe
I'm genuinely curious why this dream pattern seems to be quite distributed across many people.

I still regularly have the dream where I realized after graduation that I had missed an entire college class or test (often varies depending on the specific dream), but this then nullifies my graduation and all my subsequent work.

Also over 20 years ago, but still a regular visitor to my dreamscape.

Taking very liberal inspiration from the idea of something like Jungian archetypes, more along the lines of there being attractors in the informational dream-space that create narrative clusters linked to common emotions (such as anxiety), I can imagine of set of emotion-to-dream-narrative mappings that would lead to some of the regularities often seen in distributed recurring dreams:

- losing one's teeth - riding naked in the subway - being late to a class or missing a class/test entirely etc.

Just wondering if there has been any research on this that doesn't try to fall on the old standbys of Jungian archetypes, collective unconscious, and other similar handwaving

unsui··on Lawsuit aiming to break up Facebook group Meta can go ahead, US court rules
scrolled down too far to find this.

yes, google/visa/xxxx probably deserve their own discussion on the merits of breakup or regulation.

But that shouldn't be a primary reason why this specific discussion regarding Meta shouldn't take place.

(there may be other reasons why the meta breakup should/shouldn't happen, but handle those on their own merits)

unsui··on NASA says Webb’s excess fuel likely to extend its lifetime expectations
agreed.

This was, and continues to be, a momentous accomplishment.

The fact that it happened at all is a herculean task in constraints management, not only on the engineering side, but also on the political and zeitgeist-management side (e.g., managing different adminstrations with often antithetical perspectives on the value of science, etc).

A lot of folks on HN only see this from their own perspective, of "how-can-I-disrupt-X", or "I would have done it so much better", without a real appreciation of the overwhelming complexities in pulling off a task with so many moving parts (literally and figuratively).

Sure, you could have done it better. Then do it. But don't diminish the value of a truly monumental accomplishment when it happens; they don't come often enough, and more often than not, projects with this level of ambition fail far before they ever get to the point they can be critiqued by arm-chair geniuses.

unsui··on Language is The Scaffold of The Mind (2019)
Those are simply incidents where the scaffold foothold temporarily slips.

A true counterexample is pure interaction without words, akin to what dogs and other animals do (excepting things like recognizing their name), or meditative state where the conscious mind is no longer driving.

Words provide an information-space regularity mapping to similar constructs in other minds, a shared "game" with shared (crowdsourced) rules.

This, in turns, allows the cognitive chunking of words/ideas mappings so that they can in turn be used as constructs within larger intentional chunks, largely automated by your brain machinery, so that you don't even have to be aware of the syntax, only the semantics.

A world without words would be like navigating in an ocean without lighthouses and stars: anything is possible, but you never really know where you are and where anything else is (including others' minds)

unsui··on Patagonia Is Boycotting Facebook, Urges Other Companies to Do the Same
This is actually a much better reason for boycotting than taking on some quixotic initiative based solely on principle (however honorable that may be):

the market has decided that FB is now the poster child for bad business behavior.

That is, it makes financial sense for (some) companies to disengage from the FB brand.

For a company whose business models rely on leveraging social network dynamics to sell more ads, it seems welcomingly ironic that FB should be labeled the social pariah, if even for a short moment in time.

(let's hope it sticks)

unsui··on A Maze of Murderscapes: Metroid II (2015)
2, if not 3, of the examples you provided are generally considered amongst the most difficult NES games, and in fact led to the trope of "Nintendo Hard"

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/NintendoHard

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nintendo_hard

Much of it had to do with the technical limitations of the systems, which often led to requiring pixel-perfect accuracy to avoid hitboxes.

However, it also stems from the arcade legacy, where game plays were challenging and short, with very little handholding from the game design (i.e., throwing you in the deep end)

Replaying games like Megaman II and Ninga Gaiden on emulators, I now get a visceral distaste for the overwhelming difficult; however, back when I played them as a kid, it was just the way games were, and I would routinely finish these games in the 2-day rental period allotted.

(I assume some people have exactly the opposite reaction, pining for the days when games were merciless)

Basically, our gaming sensibilities have evolved (or devolved) as the medium has grown over time.

unsui··on Gov Parson pushes to prosecute reporter who found security flaw in state site
> This divisive rhetoric is what got us here in the first place

What you're doing is called "pearl clutching", and is not adding in any constructive way to the conversation.

The way we got here is intentionally by using divisive rhetoric to ellicit "engagement". Traditionally, this has been used politically by identifying wedge issues with the explicit intention to divide people along belief borders.

This has been accelerated and amplified n-fold via social media. Engagement is a proxy for divisive rhetoric, as that is what algorithmically produces the most engagement, thereby triggering the reward function(s).

The cat's out of the bag. Its too late to go back and say "but what about the kids?" etc, (especially since there is so much overwhelming evidence that these themselves are simply rhetorical devices to push a particular argumnent or point of view).

We know these arguments are not in good faith, so why should we give them that due process and respect?

Cut the BS.

unsui··on Theranos devices ran “null protocol” to skip actual demo for investors
Fun fact:

Steve Jobs' demo for the original macintosh was actually done with a bit of cheating:

"Once we integrated all the pieces together, the demo didn't come close to be able to run on a standard Macintosh. Fortunately, we had a prototype of a 512K Mac in the lab, so we decided to cheat a little (there were only two in existence at the time) and use that for the demo, which made things fit."

https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&stor...

unsui··on Speed Matters
they exist, although I imagine they are becoming rarer as typing skills are becoming part of the standard elementary/middle-school curriculum.

My dad was a hunt-n-peck programmer all of his life. Electrical Engineer PhD, often programming in fortran or c (although all his c code was actually just fortran too). Two-finger typer all of his life.

His son: 140-160 wpm on Kinesis Advantage 2, thanks to typing classes in middle school.

unsui··on Oculess – Removes account requirements and telemetry from Oculus Quest devices
yet. That's the whole point of getting in early (to the mass-consumer-market), to make it the standard. It's not a necessity yet, but neither were smartphones (now just called "phones").

FB is banking heavily that VR will become a necessity, to one extent or another. I sincerely hope FB fails, but my suspicion is that it would fail not because FB failed, but rather because VR itself failed (e.g. Google Glass for consumers). Still to be seen.

unsui··on Every search bar looks like a URL bar to users
You're thinking like a HN reader, rather than the intended audience for the chrome omnibar (i.e., non-specialists)

They don't want the abstraction punctured to see the inner workings...

Anything less than that creates a Norman Door conflict, whereby their inner mental models conflict with the intended interaction, where they want to pull the door, when the door only works by pushing (yet the door handle basically beckons to be pulled)...

Whether it's a good thing or not is besides the point. It's how people work, if you want to reach them at scale.

unsui··on Every search bar looks like a URL bar to users
> believe that people should have a basic knowledge of the tools they are using

The whole point of intuitive design is to realize that you shouldn't make your users "think", insofar as making effortful cognition (i.e., Kahneman's "Type 2" thinking).

Good design should leverage built-in assumptions of how the world, per users' intuitive mental models, to create affordances that guide users to the desired interaction and behavior.

If a design promotes incoherent behavior, it's not the user that's wrong; getting users to change intuitive behavior requires training and cognitive effort.

Sadly, why vim and emacs are still difficult for newbies to pick up. Yes, the learning curve is (arguably) minimal; that's not the point. It's that there is a learning curve at all.

unsui··on Facebook Whistleblower Leaks Thousands of Pages of Incriminating Internal Docs
whataboutism...

those deserve their own attention on their own merits.

But not directly relevant to this discussion, particularly if it defers or interferes with the FB discussion specifically.

unsui··on Facebook Whistleblower Leaks Thousands of Pages of Incriminating Internal Docs
This is textbook ad hominem:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem

> attacks the character, motive, or some other attribute of the person making an argument rather than attacking the substance of the argument itself

Question her motives or qualifications, rather than the claims themselves.

unsui··on YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking all anti-vaccine content
I don't think we're going to agree here, and that's fine.

There is one interesting outcome of this discussion, though:

Given our discussion, one of us has to bite the bullet on a particular point:

Artifact A: > Those "tremendous wealth of externalities"? That's called living in a society. There's no getting around it.

Artifact B: >These sorts of things are generally challenged because in practice, it's a de facto mandate/ban/whatever. "You're free to choose size of the whip,"...

I will bite the bullet, and accept that unvaccinated people are not directly causing me harm (unless, for example, one punches me in the face). I will wave my hands and accept the externalities as simply "living in society", (even though, as societal beings, unvaccinated folks do have a significant detrimental effect...)

Accepting, for the sake of argument, that personal responsibility ends at what the individual does (rather than any 2nd to n-order effects, i.e., "externalities"), then it also means that the argument "in practice, it's a de facto mandate/ban/whatever." doesn't hold, since no one individual is holding a syringe up to you and forcing you to take it.

again, can't have it both ways.

Thus, if we accept that we are societal beings, and externalities matter (e.g., 2nd to n-order effects), then my right to swing my fist ends at your face, and vice versa, directly and to a tolerable n-th degree.

Just as an employer can choose not to hire you for toxic behavior or any numerous reasons (particularly at at-will states), the only thing they cannot use as a factor is anything that makes you a protected class.

You are effectively proposing that the choice to be unvaccinated should be a protected class.

That is what I disagree with. There is no justification to make it a protected class.

unsui··on YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking all anti-vaccine content
replying to this comment, even though actually applies to multiple replies to my parent comment.

> This is categorically false. The unvaxxed aren't the ones preventing you from doing anything. They don't have the power to do so!

That itself is categorically false. unvaxxed folks provide a tremendous wealth of externalities, such as undue burden on the healthcare system, behavioral and legal changes that require masking due to lack of critical mass in vaccinations, etc.

But, to get to the crux of your arguments:

you do have the personal liberty to not vaccinate. That is not being taken away from you.

However, you do not have the privilege of making it a protected class (which is really what you are talking about).

If you choose not to be vaccinated, you can: - home school your children - self-employ and self-insure - self-medicate and avoid the healthcare system entirely etc..

Now, none of this is practical in reality, but never at any point is your choice to remain unvaccinated impinged upon.

You simply don't have as many career or social options as you would like, equivalent to being unvaccinated as a protected class.

And that is a horrendous idea (i.e., being a protected class). You can't have it both way... personal liberty often comes as great personal cost. If you truly walk the walk, then be prepared to pay the cost.

unsui··on YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking all anti-vaccine content
yet we force our children to be vaccinated in school in order to be part of society.

we also force other things that impinge on personal liberty, such as wearing seatbelts, getting car (and medical) insurance, etc.

I can see the argument that this is a slippery slope, such as "well, the common good dictates that I get this neuro implant to ward off the 2157 neurovirus", and unfortunately, the short answer is "it depends on the context".

Right now, vaccine holdouts are really screwing things up for us who want to return to some form of normality.

as with war measures or other emergency measures, personal liberty has historically been set aside for the common good. I don't see this going away, nor should it.

The conversation should be how to draw the right balance, so that, when the emergency is over, we return to some modicum of personal liberty, while still preserving the common good.

In some cases, it means that the mandate becomes the accepted practice (e.g., child vaccinations). In others, we would hope, personal liberty returns (e.g., habeas corpus).

TL;DR: it is contextual, rather than dogmatic and a-priori

unsui··on A mathematician's guided tour through higher dimensions
This video on how the game Miegakure is being developed helps to break down what is actually happening when a slice of a 4d space is being seen.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vZp0ETdD37E

Same dev who also created 4D Toys toolbox: https://4dtoys.com/

unsui··on TSMC hikes chip prices up to 20% amid supply shortage
the whataboutism is strong with this one...
unsui··on Open-sourcing a more precise time appliance
The question I'm interested in a corrollary of the above question:

What's the use case for microsecond-precise timekeeping, that is of interest to (i.e., benefits) FB?

unsui··on Why can't software engineers work from home most of the time? (2016)
agreed. The virtues of pair/team programming really took a hold for my team when WFH forced us to do screen-sharing rather than just sitting next to each other.

Now, we regularly do screen-sharing for development and demos, with the process of screen-sharing being as normal a part of our development cycle as pull-requests.

unsui··on Video Gaming the System
transcript, since the meat of the article is the podcast (not the article text itself):

https://www.npr.org/transcripts/1018915121

unsui··on The unreasonable effectiveness of just showing up everyday
OP's comment is a vast simplification of what's happening underneath, but nonetheless still tremendously valid as a useful heuristic.

Valuable work, like many things in the real world, is not normally distributed, but skewed or following alternate distributions, such as power-law. This is likely what occurs within "torrents" of work: work that is has significantly more leverage than other work.

Nonetheless, the implicit bedrock of the just-showing-up heuristic is that the valuable work cannot get done without the consistency of simply showing up; indeed, expert performance is often a function of deliberate practice plus persistence (time); one without the other rarely nets positive results.

unsui··on Facebook extends its work-at-home policy to most employees
I've found the opposite.

As a developer, WFH actually facilitates things like pair programming and peer review. Especially for introverts like myself, it is much easier to do a screenshare of your IDE and review code in a group than try to sit next to each other or review code on a big screen in a meeting room. This has become a thing for us now (let's jump on a zoom and i'll show you quickly), for anything that's too complex to slack.

The ability to easily screen share and record sessions as needed means I can get the big picture in the initial live session and review the details later via recording as needed (especially those nitpicky code details nobody remembers the first time around).

I will miss this when we have to go back to the office.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →