HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

unsui

533 karma · joined November 4, 2013

submissionscomments
unsui··on Employees are quitting instead of giving up working from home
I don't think this is accurate.

Some professionals, notably those whose work culture encourages self-determination, can be allowed to bring in their own hardware or request custom hardware. These are usually the outliers, rather than the norm (and in fact, this is often advertised as a "perk" of being employed at that particular place).

The vast majority of corporate environments are rather locked down and standardized, understandably, with one-size-fits-all or a set menu of tech provisions, depending on role (e.g., designers often get larger screens than accountants).

Even as a developer, I had to fight for larger screens for my team, as IT saw no inherent need for larger screens beyond what they initially provisioned.

Contrast that with my WFH setup, with my 3-monitor setup on a 7-foot standing desk...

unsui··on Beginner’s guide to mechanical keyboards
The kinesis advantage (now Advantage2 LF) has been my mainstay keyboard over the last 20 years, both professionally and personally. I too adhered a trackpad, although mine is an Ergo Mini touchpad: https://ergonomictouchpad.com/ergonomic_touchpad.php

I immediately bypassed the aesthetics side of MK and went straight to functionality; the kinesis has probably been the most reliable piece of hardware I've had over the years (with the exception of a key-repeating known issue that has been resolved with the advantage2)

unsui··on Writing tools I learned from The Economist
In the UK, "Middle Class" is more of a mindset than an economic class (although economic class is definitely a part of it).

You can think of it more as the US middle-upper-class.

This musical number from the UK comedy "Mongrels" more-or-less nails the mindset:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Yr4yEguWrw

unsui··on Why do they still make car alarms? (2015)
I'd say that's a fair assumption for the vast majority of people who drive and have mobile phones, given the ubiquity of mobile phones and the likelihood that most people will carry their phones with them at all times (myself included).

Thus, it would be your behavior which would be considered anomalous. So yes, definitely an assumption, although not an unwarranted one.

unsui··on Facebook Says It Is Removing All Content Mentioning 'Stop the Steal'
That is correct.

Any rationalization is post-hoc, done in support of the pre-existing (and pre-determined) goal.

As such, because it's entirely post-hoc, this leads to moving the goalposts, and any respective adjustments in rationalizations.

The primary question one must ask, in these circumstances:

Is my counterpart arguing in good faith?

If the signs point to bad faith (e.g., telltale language, gaslighting or similar methods employed, etc), then rational argument is not their currency.

unsui··on Down the ergonomic keyboard rabbit hole
On my Kinesis Advantage2, I have added the following mini touchpad (attached via velcro and 3M double-sided tape for the cable): https://www.ergonomictouchpad.com/mini_touchpad.php

The touchpad is in the middle area right above the right-thumb keys, within easy reach of my index finger without having to lift from the home row. Works great.

unsui··on We Need to Talk About TED
Let's play Devil's Advocate here, and possibly suggest that this may be a good thing. Bear with me on this...

The key difference between a traditional academic lecture and a TED talk is the audience. Here, the TED audience functions as a cultural sieve. Yes, a "dumbing down," relatively speaking, but then again, lay audiences are so by definition; academic lectures are attended by self-selected experts in a given field. TED audiences, on the other hand, are usually a collection of diverse specialists and semi-specialists from different fields, and thus may be considered a lay audience for all intents and purposes. Moreover, the internet audience is almost entirely a lay audience.

The benefit of TED is, as others have stated, the "cross-pollination" of ideas that one would likely not have exposure to in other ways. And, unfortunately, that implies a lay audience, with all that it entails.

So, yes, that implies showmanship. It implies humor. It implies oratory skills. Because that's how you reach a lay audience.

Good presentation has much in common with good leadership skills. Per Howard Gardner, there are 3 key points that many good public speakers and leaders possess (http://ecglink.com/library/ps/stories.html):

1. Having a central story 2. Fitting the story to the audience 3. Data is not enough.

This is something that speakers like Gladwell get.

It also means that academic lecturers need to up their game. And this gives them a model for what a lay audience wants.

I once had a lecturer who was very proud to tell his postgrads "real science is boring". Yes, it often is. And for those of us who can stomach boring, it's a paradise of intellectual nourishment.

But most people aren't like that. Most people need shiny things to guide them.

Is this fundamentally a good thing? Probably not. But we don't have the luxury of pre-screening an audience through self-selection, as is the case with most academic audiences. An academic may be absolutely brilliant, but if he/she can't connect with the lay audience, it does no good for the ideas he/she espouses.

Just view the TED talk by Marvin Minsky to see a good academic flounder in front of a lay audience. http://www.ted.com/talks/marvin_minsky_on_health_and_the_hum...

Take home point: yes, this is a dumbing down. Take it for what it is. Instead of complaining that audiences don't react to dry academic lectures, academics need to study people like Malcolm Gladwell to emulate his delivery and rhetorical style, without sacrificing their academic integrity. Easier said than done, but there are plenty of substantive talks on TED to suggest it is possible. If indeed the medium is the message, then academics lecturing to lay audiences need to get the message.

P.S. For those worried about TED's influence on academia, methinks it will be minimal. Academia is a very conservative endeavor, and whereas sales-pitch talks (like TED) may get sexed up, academic lectures to academic peers will continue in their wonderfully "boring" approach, for many years to come (and thank goodness for that). Why? Because academics will never cease to try to poke holes in others' ideas. Intellectual snark works in academia. It doesn't work with a lay audience. However, narrative does.

← PreviousPage 5 of 5