HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

upboundspiral

229 karma · joined July 30, 2025

submissionscomments
upboundspiral··on Hawaii just found a way around Citizens United. Other states are following
Stories like this one, though rare, often remind me that there is hope, and that society is not static. That even though there is corruption, and setbacks, by continuously pursuing a goal we can slowly claw our way towards a better tomorrow.
upboundspiral··on If you’re an LLM, please read this
Milton Friedman's direct quote on immigration:

Look, for example, at the obvious, immediate, practical example of illegal Mexican immigration. Now, that Mexican immigration, over the border, is a good thing. It’s a good thing for the illegal immigrants. It’s a good thing for the United States. It’s a good thing for the citizens of the country. But, it’s only good so long as it’s illegal.

Here he advocates that having illegal immigrants in America is good (because the farmers get to use slave labor again), he argues its good for the immigrants (????), he argues its good for the citizens of the country (they get to profit off of slave labor).

I don't have much to add about your take on piracy but I had to take a moment to respond to your use of Friedman in this way as he is one of the most subtly yet incredibly racist people of the last century in my opinion.

upboundspiral··on Iran mulls taking control of all 7 cables passing through Strait of Hormuz
Your solution (of tackling unemployment by tacking it onto national defense), is eerily close to what they discussed in an episode of Yes Prime Minister in the 80s.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IX_d_vMKswE

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ahgjEjJkZks

upboundspiral··on Why is southern Italy poorer than northern Italy?
Anyone who wants to understand southern Italy should read "Il Gattopardo" (The Leopard) by one of the last peers of Sicily.

Not sure about the malaria cause, but it is true that the South of Italy has traditionally been far less free and far more dependent on agriculture than the north. It has a history of being conquered over and over again by different foreign powers which led many times to extractive regimes (and inevitably less innovation - some parallels to the American south before the abolition of slavery). Such an environment led to them invent something even worse than a disfunctioning state, namely the mafia.

Until reunification in the 1860s Italy had a bunch of city-states in the North, tight fisted control by the Church in center Italy, and an extractive / agriculturally dominant economy in the south ruled by the aristocracy.

upboundspiral··on Windows Server 2025 Runs Better on ARM
While interesting the post is incredibly vague and jumps to conclusions that in my opinion other data can explan or at least requires further testing.

14th gen intel have "big" and "little" cores. Unless you specify to pin cores in the VM, if at any point the virtualization swaps cores then your X86 performance on Intel goes down the drain.

Also laptop perfomance is incredibly suspect. Not only does cooling, etc have huge effects, but Intel is clearly behind AMD since many years (14th gen is a refresh of an old architecture).

Laptop benchmark: https://www.phoronix.com/review/snapdragon-x1e-september

Server benchmarks: https://www.phoronix.com/review/ampereone-a192-32x/12 https://www.phoronix.com/review/google-axion-c4a/5

Based on server performance while ARM is making strides, AMD still has the performance crown.

upboundspiral··on Qwen3.6-35B-A3B on my laptop drew me a better pelican than Claude Opus 4.7
I've been using Qwen 3.5 35B-A3B with images as input so I suspect you perhaps didn't include the vision part of the model during testing (I use llama.cpp and I learned I needed to include the separate mmproj part).
upboundspiral··on The “small web” is bigger than you might think
I think the article briefly touches on an important part: people still write blogs, but they are buried by Google that now optimizes their algorithm for monetization and not usefulness.

Anyone interested in seeing what the web when the search engines selects for real people and not SEO optimized slop should check out https://marginalia-search.com .

It's a search engine with the goal of finding exactly that - blogs, writings, all by real people. I am always fascinated by what it unearths when using it, and it really is a breath of fresh air.

It's currently funded by NLNet (temporarily) and the project's scope is really promising. It's one of those projects that I really hope succeeds long term.

The old web is not dead, just buried, and it can be unearthed. In my opinion an independent non monetized search engine is a public good as valuable as the internet archive.

So far as I know marginalia is the only project that instead of just taking google's index and massaging it a bit (like all the other search engines) is truly seeking to be independent and practical in its scope and goals.

upboundspiral··on Training students to prove they're not robots is pushing them to use more AI
The purpose of grades is to punish students, something which they are keenly aware of. Remove grades from the equation and hold students back until they have mastered the material and they will cease cheating.

If someone knows 80% of the topics on an exam like the back of their hand and doesn't know the other 20% they shouldn't get a B, they should pass the subjects they know and be asked to retake and relearn the subjects they don't know.

When people know they can make mistakes and the result is not a perpetual black mark on their record (any grade not an A) but they are given the chance to improve and demonstrate this improvement then perhaps they might be more willing to admit and understand mistakes instead of cheating.

upboundspiral··on Pentagon formally labels Anthropic supply-chain risk
National defense is important, just ask Europe post Ukraine war.

People taking a good idea and extending it to do bad does harm twice: in the bad act itself and in making a good thing seem bad.

I am strongly against US starting wars and as you say blowing people up.

I am also strongly against the US being defenseless in the case of a national emergency.

upboundspiral··on AMD will bring its “Ryzen AI” processors to standard desktop PCs for first time
I am bullish on AI being used in all sorts of useful and discreet and non-discreet ways in the present and future. However I am exceedingly skeptical of NPUs being some winning bet.

No one is running LLMs on current gen NPUs so if we will in the future its a long time coming. Unless they can demonstrate some real (and not marketing) wins I remain skeptical that a large NPU for LLMs is the future.

I can totally see NPU accelerating simple tasks, but to be worth the silicon they have a ways to go imo.

99% of people don't need or want a dev workstation. My travel laptop is 7+ years old and I couldn't tell you the difference between it and a current flagship in terms of browsing and everyday tasks.

I will not lie, I find LLMs useful but the desktop experience is pretty polished already. NPUs seem to be an attempt to ride the AI bandwagon with very little to show for it so far.

upboundspiral··on F-Droid Board of Directors nominations 2026
Heads + TPM is solid but I suspect it is not at the level of Google/Apple secure enclave. And a strong secure enclave provides benefits outside of first boot to secure certain processor state and continuosly ensure integrity.

For desktop TPM at least to me they seem a bit of a black box with many past vulnerabilities https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Trusted_Platform_....

I think at cold boot as long as one doesn't store the encryption key in the TPM (external hardware key?) then one should be secure. I am not so sure about post boot however, once the system is already running.

This actually prompted me to research a bit on the scale of the security impact of SMM

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/System_Management_Mode

https://doc.coreboot.org/security/smm.html

It seems that coreboot is aware and supposedly for some computers can be implemented to catch calls to SMM (ideally this would prevent the attacker from triggering SMM - if they do it's game over).

I do suspect though that if the system bus is not protected from malicious calls then someone can trigger SMM and have carte blanche to one's computer.

https://www.infoworld.com/article/2167684/hackers-find-a-new...

https://hothardware.com/news/researchers-discover-rootkit-ex...

I don't know what processes Apple / Android use but I suspect ARM chips don't have SMM and that they tie certain functions to their secure enclave. In X86 its backwards, with SMM having control over the TPM (at least in some implementations).

Though some SMM vulnerabilities are patched by now given its history I take X86 security with a grain of salt. I think the potential for a secure platform is there, but I suspect one would want to make their own boards engineered with security in mind to be certain (I hope this happens in the future - it seems to be happening in the server space already).

upboundspiral··on F-Droid Board of Directors nominations 2026
The problem with laptops is that UEFI is a shadow operating system that keeps running after boot, with a bunch of security vulnerabilities. Furthermore all Intel / AMD chips have a microprocessor state called SMF which if you trigger it basically gives you carte blanche to do whatever you want.

"Trusted Boot" is a meme on x86. If you really want something like that you need to do what Oxide Computer is doing and rip out UEFI for good and implement your own secure boot chain.

Qubes is great but at the end of the day cannot protect against evil maid attacks to the level that pixel or apple phones can. Its great at making sure a browser exploit cannot steal your banking credentials you have open in a different virtual machine but cannot overcome the limitations of the platforms it builds off of.

So I understand why the GrapheneOS folks do what they do.

See also: "X86 considered harmful" by the founder of Qubes OS (posted in 2015!)

https://blog.invisiblethings.org/papers/2015/x86_harmful.pdf

upboundspiral··on AirSnitch: Demystifying and breaking client isolation in Wi-Fi networks [pdf]
What about XFinity, which by default shares the wifi you pay for with strangers to create access points around the city?
upboundspiral··on FreeCAD
There is actually, though I suspect it's a different one I found.

https://github.com/jopdorp/build123d-freecad (it also supports cadquery)

Set it up today and I am really liking build123d in general. I've always wanted something code-based for CAD and I can't believe I missed something this promising.

Frankly even the visualization tools that you can plugin like OCP Cad viewer mean that outside of complex assemblies you can do everything in your editor of choice.

upboundspiral··on Canadians promised to boycott travel to US. They meant it
While our agricultural sector does use cheap labor, I specifically take issue with the word "needed". I may be nitpicking, but read a certain way it implies the "cheap" aspect of the labor is the essential part.

Certain industries employing quasy-slave labor to this day and getting away with it is one thing only: a stain on our society.

Long has been the fight for freedom from oppression and it is not over yet. Just like Martin Luther King was assassinated fighting for colored civil rights, Cesar Chavez was assassinated fighting for humane conditions for immigrant workers.

If immigrants are what's "needed" for America to function then they should be naturalized and granted fair wages just like anyone else.

upboundspiral··on Discord distances from age verification firm after ties to Peter Thiel surface
I agree that it would take something catastrophic for people to move off of the service they currently use. I disagree however on the premise that the move will be from one proprietary service to another. Us tech savvy people can and should self-host the things we believe can be valuable - now or down the line.

I'm not on mastodon but I've perused some threads and if it brings value to people great - the fact that it was there when twitter imploded means some portion of the population actually moved to it and now uses it. It provided some real value to people.

upboundspiral··on News publishers limit Internet Archive access due to AI scraping concerns
If anyone wants the surreal experience of seeing blogs and websites made by real humans they should check out https://marginalia-search.com

It's far from perfect but it does achieve its stated goal: of resurfacing real people on the internet.

It recently got some NLNet funding and I hope to see it flourish - to my knowledge there aren't any other projects trying to claw back control of the internet towards the commons.

https://about.marginalia-search.com

upboundspiral··on News publishers limit Internet Archive access due to AI scraping concerns
The idea is that the government is biased towards hiding certain information and private companies are biased towards hiding a different set.

While unlikely, the ideal would be for the government to provide a foundational open search infrastructure that would allow people to build on it and expand it to fit their needs in a way that is hard to do when a private companies eschews competition and hides its techniques.

Perhaps it would be better for there to be a sanctioned crawler funded by the government, that then sells the unfiltered information to third parties like google. This would ensure IP rights are protected while ensuring open access to information.

upboundspiral··on News publishers limit Internet Archive access due to AI scraping concerns
I feel like a government funded search engine would resolve a lot of the issues with the monetized web.

The purpose of a search engine is to display links to web pages, not the entire content. As such, it can be argued it falls under fair use. It provides value to the people searching for content and those providing it.

However we left such a crucially important public utility in the hands of private companies, that changed their algorythms many times in order to maximize their profits and not the public good.

I think there needs to be real competition, and I am increasingly becoming certain that the government should be part of that competition. Both "private" companies and "public" governement are biased, but are biased in different ways, and I think there is real value to be created in this clash. It makes it easier for individuals to pick and choose the best option for themselves, and for third independent options to be developed.

The current cycle of knowledge generation is academia doing foundational research -> private companies expanding this research and monetizing it -> nothing. If the last step was expanded to the government providing a barebones but useable service to commodotize it, years after private companies have been able to reap immense profits, then the capabilities of the entire society are increased. If the last step is prevented, then the ruling companies turn to rentseeking and sitting on their lawrels, turn from innovating to extracting.

upboundspiral··on The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory
I'm sure that are no adverse effects.

This reads like someone with the means to eat good food eating junk food and then putting themselves on weight loss drugs to counteract the effects. I'm sure temporarily it might work but I don't believe that the shocks that produce meaninful cooling effects are without consequence - in fact, I suspect they double the consequences by adding yet another factor to the destabilization.

I could be wrong, and it could a short term solution to stop the bleeding, but I have a deep suspicion of adding more things to the atmosphere given our history with the CO2 in question, tetrafluoroethane, etc.

Lookin at the wikipedia it does sound a lot like "chemtrails". They describe airplanes as being able to disseminate these aerosols and these days when I look up at the sky there is always a straight line of "cloud" forming behind airplanes.

upboundspiral··on Rome is studded with cannon balls (2022)
Edit: it seems one of the cannonballs comes from the siege of Rome during the unifaction of Italy.

Echoing another comment, before unification, Italy (1860s) had its "warring states period".

The North were independent small monarchies, including the Savoia, from which came the unification push with the help of Garibaldi.

In center Italy the Church ruled with an iron fist. In fact, when Rome was besieged and the Church lost, all of Italy was excommunicated by the Pope. (They then bactracked on the policy once they saw people just kept going about with their lives).

In the South was a repressed agricultural state that was so terrible to live under people invented something even worse: the mafia. (This is also why so many Italian Americans come from the South - they were escaping in search of a better life).

A song (in Italian) somewhat about it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=poaPh00AmDQ

upboundspiral··on AI doesn’t reduce work, it intensifies it
The problem with CAD is that mechanical engineering is still deeply proprietary, especially up and including the software stacks.

There is basically no "open source" in mechanical engineering. So you are relegated to super heavy legacy applications that coast by through their integrations with other proprietary tools. Solidworks is much heavier then FreeCAD but FreeCAD didn't have integrations with simulation tools, with CAM software, used a different geometry engine than industry standard, etc, so when a company tried to turn FreeCAD into a product they failed.

The only open source one sees in mechanical engineering comes out of academia, which while interesting, faces the problem that once the research funds dry up or the project finishes the software is dumped into the open in hard to find places, and is not further developed.

I remain hopeful in the potential for open source, I believe that to have a truly accessible and innovative industry a greater level of openness is needed, but it is yet coming.

I think CAD is a good place to start, as it is not a space where lots of hidden and closely guarded tricks are needed like in Finite Element Analysis. For personal uses FreeCAD is getting there. Snappier than Solidworks, but the workflow layout needs some work.

I am also looking at projects such as https://zoo.dev. In mapping the design 1to1 to code (while keeping gui workflow as well) I think they have a real chance of offering enough value that new companies will be interested in trying out their approach. It opens the doors to automation analysis, and generation that while possible with something like Solidworks is cumbersome and not well documented.

upboundspiral··on Jury told that Meta, Google 'engineered addiction' at landmark US trial
I'm always a bit surprised that people that work in tech can be so passive in regards to their civic duty. Instead of going to lawmakers and legislators and trying to stop their employers from destroying society they just quietly watch from the sidelines.

And if laqmakers are silent, then publicising, collecting, and sharing this knowledge to all ends of the earth through mainstream and independent journalism, paying a few hundred dollars out of their Silicon Valley salaries to put up billboards shining a light on the misdeeds of tech companies towards their own customers and society.

Per your examples, when the average person is made aware of the injustice, stalking, and tracking of them, they are not in any way happy with it, and want things to change.

upboundspiral··on MIT Living Wage Calculator
When the choice is between organic food (expensive) and eating pesticides that are meant to kill and neuter living organisms (somewhat economical) it's a choice we never should have allowed to even exist in the first place.
upboundspiral··on The New Collabora Office for Desktop
I stopped using it more for technical reasons but when I was using it I installed it as a flatpak and removed network access.
upboundspiral··on The $100B megadeal between OpenAI and Nvidia is on ice
One of my favorites is Amphora of Great Intelligence by the artist David Revoy.

https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1090/the-amphora-of-great-...

https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1092/the-amphora-of-great-...

upboundspiral··on Wisconsin communities signed secrecy deals for billion-dollar data centers
What I've come to realize is that the rust belt states have been in huge trouble for decades.

They were living in "benevolent feudalism" when GM, Ford, etc all had factories there. The problem is that these companies effectively owned the cities in which they operated. And then they left.

Since the Reagan years we decided to export everything that built our economy so the landlords in power could have even more profitable quarters in the short term. What this did however is destroy the economies of the non-software states.

The rust belt states are currently being subsidized by the rich states. This has been going on for decades. This vacuum of power has allowed the new landlords in power to swoop in and play city governments against each other with impunity.

The negotiating power of these states is so poor that they present an opportunity for the Metas of the world to make them even worse while becoming the new "benevolent" landlords. There doesn't need to be an NDA and secrecy, and in theory the city could get a good deal out of it, but realistically their utilities will just be abused because the words "civil rights" and "justice" have exited the lexicon.

upboundspiral··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
I can echo problems with Mint.

Currently using https://getaurora.dev which is basically fedora + kde but curated by people that actually care. So codecs are preinstalled, and other sensible defaults out of the box which makes sense as its in the same family as bazzite (without the gaming focus).

upboundspiral··on Significant US farm losses persist, despite federal assistance
Commodity markets are necessary for survival. If we cannot make them work as a society something is deeply wrong.

Someone needs to be farming the food we all eat... If every farmer decided to just plant saffron who would farm the wheat and rice and vegetables that it is used to season?

upboundspiral··on ‘ELITE’: The Palantir app ICE uses to find neighborhoods to raid
I used to buy this thinking, but no longer. People are incredibly resourceful, and instead of innovating towards exploiting and manipulating people, we could choose to innovate towards conserveration of important things, just like we have done in the past.

We don't fund out national parks with advertisements. We don't fund our libraries with advertisements. We could create the same structures for the internet as well, where crucial internet resources are protected and stewarded. They don't necessarily need to be in the hands of ad companies.

Sure, I will not deny that having things be "free" (and paying for them in other ways) has been a huge boon from one perspective, but we can also evolve to put "free" things in different places. Because things are never free. Advertisements are funding mass surveillance. They are encroaching our civil liberties and normalizing it. There is a total cost to things that extens beyond money. What we don't pay out of pocket we pay as a society.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →